By Cathleen A. Mann, Ph.D., 2003
I attended the APA (American Psychological Association) annual conference recently in Toronto, Ontario, Canada. The convention had its share of problems before it even convened the week of August 6, 2003. One item of interest to me was the willingness of the APA Board to allow Dr. Lois Holzman and her various underlings to speak 4 times this year at the convention. Last year in Chicago, the APA only allowed Dr. Holzman and crew to speak once.
a
Dr. Holzman is affiliated with Fred Newman, and inhabits various incarnations, such as Social Therapy, All Stars Project, Inc., East Side Institute for Social Therapy (in New York City), Castillo Cultural Project, New Alliance Party, and sometimes, just plain International Workers Party (IWP). Many past members, including professional counselors/therapists and former patients, report abuses, deceit, and manipulation at the hands of Social Therapy and its various offshoots. There have been allegations of psychotherapeutic manipulation, lack of ethical integrity, boundary violations from professionals to students to staff to clients, financial improprieties, and various other problematic behaviors.
Many ex-members of Social Therapy say they've been subject to a mind control cult operating under the guise of a legitimate psychological movement. Individuals formerly involved with Social Therapy emphatically claim that they were deceived into a pseudo-postmodernistic social influence political movement. One useful model to assist in understanding how a destructive cult operates is Hassan’s BITE model (Hassan, 1988, 1998). Using social psychological principles, a destructive cult deliberately and deceitfully wrestles control of an individual’s behavior (B), information (I), thought (T), and emotions (E) through subtle processes (see http://www.freedomofmind.com/resourcecenter/articles/BITE.htm). Many other psychologists have also discussed the cult phenomena, including Drs. Margaret Singer, Phil Zimbardo, Stephen Kent, Steve Dubrow, and Michael Langone, just to name a few.
When word got around to concerned individuals that the APA had rewarded Social Therapy and Dr. Lois Holzman with four separate presentations this year at the APA conference, a small email campaign was launched with complaints about Social Therapy’s presence at the APA, and their seemingly transparent pretensions to science.
When word reached Dr. L. Michael Honaker, COO/Deputy CEO of the American Psychological Association that all was not bliss with Social Therapy’s presence at the convention, he responded:
“Thank you for your recent email concerning the participation of Drs. Lois Holzman and Fred Newman in our upcoming conference in Toronto. The APA Convention is a large 4-day meeting with over 4,000 presenters. It provides a forum for a wide variety of speakers and presentations. Dr. Holzman will participate in four convention sessions. She was invited to participate in those sessions after a review of her program proposals by peer committees that deemed the presentation appropriate for an APA convention.
Furthermore, Dr. Holzman has participated in APA conventions in the past and we have not received any complaints about the content of those presentations. However, the issues you raise are serious. We will monitor those sessions in which Dr. Holzman participates to hear what is said. We are also confident that if Dr. Holzman or anyone else were to express views that were prejudiced or potentially harmful to psychotherapy patients their APA colleagues would challenge those views. (emphasis added). Dr. Newman will not be participating in the meeting. Thank you again for bringing your concerns to our attention.”
L. Michael Holanker, Ph.D.
Chief Operating Officer/Deputy CEO
American Psychological Association
Executive Office
Email: mhonaker@apa.org
It should be noted that by the time the email campaign was initiated, Social Therapy was already on the APA convention program. It may have been difficult for the APA to completely remove them the program; thus, the presentations were allowed to go forward.
I personally attended Dr. Holzman’s first presentation on Saturday morning, August 9, 2003 (session #3079), entitled “Symposium: Impact of Participatory Youth Programs on Youth and Communities.” In addition to Dr. Holzman, in attendance were Barbara Silverman, who spoke on the broad subject of crises in education; Diann Eley, who spoke on the use of sports to aid “disaffected young people,” and Gloria Strickland, who spoke on the All Stars Project in New Jersey, wherein she uses theatre and the performing arts to “aid hundreds of inner city young people.” There were no APA staff or board members in attendance at this presentation.
The presence of APA board members at this session would have done a great deal to see the subtle nature of Social Therapy in action. Much of the presentation was geared toward mutual admiration of the panel’s “contributions to society,” with little opportunity for scholarly interaction with psychologists and others in the audience. An APA board member should have been there to document the one-sided nature of the presentation, and the impression that Dr. Holzman and company were merely pushing an agenda.
Arriving just as the presentation was to begin was Columbia University professor, Dr. Edmund Gordon, who quickly and adroitly turned the discussion into a left-right political debate complete with comments on the “social causes” of racism and poverty. Dr. Gordon was ostensibly inducted to be the discussant of the presentation.
However, Dr. Holzman spoke first with some interesting opening comments. She acknowledged that she had “been recently informed that complaints have been made about this presentation.” She asked if any “complainers” were in the audience, which may seem an odd question as there were a range of 12 to 16 people in the audience at various times in the presentation. Dr. Holzman nobly stated, “I encourage challenges and debates. I want to create together our psychology. I am from a passionate group of individuals with new approaches to community development.” She also stated that she had been presenting at APA conferences for “over 20 years” and “had heard no complaints before.”
This is not a true statement, or Dr. Holzman and the APA have an exceedingly short memory. At the APA conference in Chicago last year, I also attended one of Dr. Holzman’s presentations on the legacy of Fred Newman, among other topics. When she asked for questions of the audience, I asked her, “There have been newspaper reports and ex-member accounts that you operate a psychotherapeutic cult. Could you please respond to this allegation including your definition of what a cult is and what it is not?” Dr. Holzman refused to answer the question, and either would not or could not tell me what a cult was, but she was certain her group was not one. She refused to address the issue of ex-member complaints, and sat silently as I asked her the same question three times. I did bring this to the attention of then-APA president, Dr. Philip Zimbardo, but I don’t know if any action was ever initiated.
After 70 minutes of a 90-minute presentation, Dr. Holzman acknowledged my raised hand in pursuit of a question. I asked her a simple question; a question that every member of APA, and certainly every presenter at an APA conference, should be able and willing to answer. I asked Dr. Holzman, “As an APA member, do you ascribe to and uphold the APA Ethical Principles for Psychologists at your East Side Institute for Social Therapy?” Dr. Holzman replied, “That is not relevant to this discussion here.” I responded back. “You are speaking at a professional conference. You represent several organizations. You show yourself as the representative of these organizations in order to obtain permission to speak here today. Again, I ask you, do you ascribe to and uphold the APA Ethical Principles for Psychologists at your East Side Institute for Social Therapy?” Dr. Holzman again replied, “The question is not relevant.” I replied, “Do you refuse to answer?” Dr. Holzman replied, “The question is not relevant.”
Then, quick as a flash, Dr. Gordon jumped to Dr. Holzman’s rescue. He stated that the controversy with Social Therapy came from the “old Freudian thinking at APA” and from the “political right.” I responded by informing him that he knew nothing of the extent of the lie and the extent of the controversy. I asked permission from Dr. Gordon to leave a flyer so members of the audience could consider another side of Social Therapy (see http://www.ex-iwp.org ). While Dr. Holzman sat silent, Dr. Gordon provided permission for me to leave the flyer. Presenting alternative views is the essence of critical thinking (at least that’s what they taught us in graduate school). Dr. Holzman’s refusal is not keeping with the best pursuits of science. I and some of my colleagues have been concerned that some destructive cults may use professional and scientific platforms to gain credibility and respectability. I don’t want to see this happen to the APA.
It is appalling that Dr. Holzman cannot identify herself and her organizations as subscribing to the APA Ethical Standards for Psychologists regardless of her designated “agenda” and “topic.” I think the APA should take note of this refusal, and place it in context of the desire of psychology to have open debate, not refusal at an APA annual conference. If the APA is concerned about these questions, perhaps a deeper investigation should be made before Social Therapy and its various offshoots are again allowed to present at another APA conference. It is vital that the premier organization of psychology, the APA, look more closely at this matters in order to assure its membership that convention presenters have committed themselves to the highest standards of science, scholarship, openness, and respectful dialogue with other professionals.
Showing posts with label Lois Holzman. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Lois Holzman. Show all posts
Tuesday, August 9, 2011
Letter to the U.S. Department of Justice (1989)
November 3, l989
BY TELECOPIER
Mr. Barry Weinberg
Acting Chief
Voting Section
Civil Rights Division
U.S. Department of Justice
320 1st Street, NW Washington, DC 20001
Dear Mr. Weinberg,
We are writing to request that the Justice Department monitor the election to be held on November 7, l989 for City Council in the 11th District, Bronx, New York under the Federal Observer Program as per the Voting Rights Act of 1965. Allegations of irregularities in the 1982 and 1985 elections for Member of the City Council in the 11th District of New York City have been brought to our attention. They indicate that it would be appropriate to send federal observers from your office. We urge you to honor this request. Our concern is that the voters of the 11th Council District can participate in a fair and democratic election free from harassment, intimidation and fraud.
Very truly yours,
Lenora B. Fulani, National Chairperson, New Alliance Party
Alvaader Frazier, Esq., International People's Law Institution
Dr. Lois Holtzman, Association of Progressive Helping Professionals
Dr. Mohammad T. Mehdi, American Arab Relations Committee
Rafael Mendez, Candidate for City Council President, New York City
Puerto Rican Legal Defense and Education Fund
Reverend Al Sharpton
Barbara Taylor, Principal and Founder Barbara Taylor School, and Candidate for Manhattan Borough President, New York City.
BY TELECOPIER
Mr. Barry Weinberg
Acting Chief
Voting Section
Civil Rights Division
U.S. Department of Justice
320 1st Street, NW Washington, DC 20001
Dear Mr. Weinberg,
We are writing to request that the Justice Department monitor the election to be held on November 7, l989 for City Council in the 11th District, Bronx, New York under the Federal Observer Program as per the Voting Rights Act of 1965. Allegations of irregularities in the 1982 and 1985 elections for Member of the City Council in the 11th District of New York City have been brought to our attention. They indicate that it would be appropriate to send federal observers from your office. We urge you to honor this request. Our concern is that the voters of the 11th Council District can participate in a fair and democratic election free from harassment, intimidation and fraud.
Very truly yours,
Lenora B. Fulani, National Chairperson, New Alliance Party
Alvaader Frazier, Esq., International People's Law Institution
Dr. Lois Holtzman, Association of Progressive Helping Professionals
Dr. Mohammad T. Mehdi, American Arab Relations Committee
Rafael Mendez, Candidate for City Council President, New York City
Puerto Rican Legal Defense and Education Fund
Reverend Al Sharpton
Barbara Taylor, Principal and Founder Barbara Taylor School, and Candidate for Manhattan Borough President, New York City.
Crisis Normalization And Depression: A New Approach To A Growing Epidemic (1987)
By Fred Newman
The following is based on a talk by Dr. Newman sponsored by the East Side Institute for Short Term Psychotherapy, on October 23, 1987 (later published in Practice: The Journal of Politics, Economics, Psychology, Sociology & Culture, 1987, Vol. 1 No. 3).
I do not wish to add my name to the long list of definition mongers. I believe that the search for definition is methodologically problematic. What 1 want to try to develop here is what it means to evolve an approach to depression which doesn't have, amongst its presuppositions, the need to offer a definition of what depression is. I want to talk about why definitional approaches are less curative, less useful; less helpful-in fact, function negatively-relative to the treatment received by people we see in the "non-definitional" short term, social therapeutic approach.
A curious feature of our language (noted by many) is the humor sometimes obtainable by flipping subjects and objects in phrases or sentences. More often than not, such a flip produces both humor and insight. I'll give you an example of what I mean. A much more precise title for Coyne's Essential Papers on Depression would be Depressing Papers on Essentialism. These are indeed very depressing papers on essentialism! They all attempt to give not only a definition of depression hut an essentialistic characterization of the human being as a precondition for then discussing depression. "Depression must he understood as the common cold of psychopathology," we are told. Exactly right. After all, depression, in one form or another, strikes not just handfuls of people, hut millions of people. The estimates given center around I out of 5 people. That figure is likely an underestimation, referring only to people who have received some kind of treatment. The number is surely higher since there is a continuum of depression. Indeed, it is often debated whether depression, qua clinical category, is actually an extension of depression as we know it in ordinary life. It is hard to do therapy for more than ten minutes without treating people who suffer from depression. And many of us here, I am sure, have gone through severe bouts of depression ourselves. Being depressed, then, seems almost an element of the definition of being human.
The DSM-Ill criteria for major depressive episodes further this question. Here is the definition (officially of depression, unofficially a partial definition of human being): "Loss of interest or pleasure in all or almost all usual activities and pastimes, characterized by symptoms such as the following: sad, depressed, blue, hopeless, down in the dumps; irritable-must be persistent but not necessarily the dominant symptom. At least four of the following symptoms must have been present nearly every day for a period of nearly two weeks (in children under six at least three of the first four): (1) Poor appetite or significant weight loss, when not dieting, or increased appetite or significant weight gain (in children under six, consider failure to make expected weight gains); (2) insomnia or hypersomnia:; (3) Psychomotor agitation or retardation, not merely subjective feelings of restlessness or being slowed down (in children under six, hyperactivity); (4) Loss of interest or pleasure in usual activities or decrease in sexual drive not limited to a period when delusional or hallucinating (in children under six, signs of apathy); (5) Loss of energy, fatigue; (6) Feelings of worthlessness, self-reproach, or excessive or inappropriate guilt. either may be delusional; (7) Complaints or evidence of diminished ability to think or concentrate, such as slowed thinking or indecisiveness not associated with marked loosening of associations or incoherence; (8) Recurrent thoughts of death, suicidal deviation, wishes to be dead or suicide attempt." It goes on. So must we. Let's try to move beyond definitional approaches.
Some experts suggest that loss is primarily emotive, some that loss is more cognitive than emotive; others say that loss is more interpersonal than either cognitive or emotive, and still others actually say that loss is chemical. The idea which comes across in these varying approaches to depression is that there are some kinds of loss which provoke or induce an inability to cope, and that this inability to cope is not specifically a sadness nor a feeling blue. Rather, the feeling state identified with depression is more appropriately identified as the lack of a feeling state. What cuts across many of these statements and points of view is that the essence of the depressive state is the experience of helplessness, to some extent a non-feeling, i.e., a seeming inability to any longer be responsive.
As I understand Becker, what is common to both the experience of depression and the approaches to the experience is this loss of the capacity to cognitively, emotively, psychologically, culturally, politically "keep the whole damn thing together." There has essentially been a breakdown of framework and meaning. With this breakdown, one becomes weighted down with a sense of helplessness ("learned helplessness") because the life experiences which previously may have been nourishing, developmental, meaningful, and significant, no longer have that impact. The depressed experience is compounded by the fact that one is now going through life epistemologically aware of doing the same things one had always done (and. in the past, derived nourishment and pleasure from) but now these experiences give no pleasure. The depression, then, deepens due to what is effectively a kind of "learned helplessness." In place of the ability to take experiences and fit them into an overall framework which is growthful, productive, and makes you feel human, cared for, capable, and alive, increasingly these same kinds of experiences now contribute nothing to your sense of self-identity. You become dead in life. You go through the motions. You might perform well-many, many depressed people perform very well. In some cases people don't even know that they are depressed. They say "Oh that's how I thought life was! I didn't know that was a sickness! I didn't know that could be cured." In the midst of a rather severe depression many years ago, I could see that my life experience for some 15-20 years before was not all that dramatically different. I came to see that depression (almost as severe as what I was then experiencing) was what I had thought of as the normal state of life.
Once again let us change the initial premise of our investigation from searching for a cure for a disease, to searching for a cure for a normal state. This of course has serious socio-economic implications. For example, if you put up a shingle which says. "Only Normal People Come Here," no one would know whether to come or not! People might come in and say. "I'm terribly ill," and you'd reply. "Well, to tell you the truth, I don't treat illness." I do not treat illness-because much of what has been conceptually and socially defined as illness makes it, in my opinion, fundamentally incurable. A lot of people fail to appreciate the perniciousness of definition and categorization, fail to appreciate the perniciousness of language, and fail to appreciate the extent to which we have all been socialized by language and categories, including the categories of emotion, cognition and disease, such that if we persist in functioning within these categories, it is questionable whether we can ever make it out of them.
Starting from our quite different assumption, our anti-paradigm, if you will, how do we relate to folks who come to see us and lay out all of the symptoms described in the literature on depression! People tell us. "I feel sad, disempowered, listless-helpless. I don't know what to do with my life. I'm thinking about committing suicide." Those are very real things said by very real people, and they should not he denied or doubted. Millions of people feel this way, and some few come to us seeking help, and one cannot make fun of the people who are suffering, who are in pain. What do we do then, when people come to us depressed!
American culture, more than any other, has profoundly and dramatically lost a sense of history. Far from being a radical statement, this is the standard analysis of many people across the political, social and cultural spectrum. Over and over again it has been pointed out that the American sensibility runs roughly from the six o'clock news to the ten o'clock news. "What happened?" "What is historical?" "What is really going on?" The answer is what is momentary; it is whatever is presented in the media, largely on television. Our sensibility, such as it is, is mediated by an incredible barrage of words and images carefully shaped in such a way as to not simply create a certain picture, hut to explicitly create a certain sense of alienation from the sources and objects of that picture. That is, to destroy our sense of history. There is ample evidence to suggest that as a people, we have not simply been alienated from the process of work and production hut we have been alienated from the historical process of our own historical development. We have been denied the possibility of history as well as the actuality of history. People like Richard Sennett and others have noted the narcissism of American society. But the "Me Generation" is more than generational. The "me-ness" of American culture goes well beyond any single generation.
All over the world, people are astounded by the historical deprivation that is characteristic of our culture. We read in the European press of Europe's fears of the Reagan administration. To be sure, part of that has to do with his programmatics. But it also has to do with the fact that Europeans quite correctly are fearful of a major power to whom they are beholden in a life and death sense, being run by someone whose paradigm of reality is the grade B movie or six o'clock news. Many people are concerned about a population, a president and a culture which over-identifies war, for example, as something that appears on television, which identifies profound social problems as images in a movie. We have, in many ways and for many reasons, evolved as a culture so thoroughly alienated from history as to make us profoundly vulnerable, in a momentary situation, to deep-rooted depression.
I am not suggesting that the more traditional elements discussed in classical papers and research on depression are irrelevant, however, I am urging that none of what is said makes a whole lot of sense unless we locate these analyses in some socio-psychological understanding of our particular culture, specifically our deprivation of history. In the absence of a historical sense we are enormously vulnerable to profound depression. Does this happen to individuals? Yes. Does it happen to masses of people? Yes. Is it of great concern?-certainly.
The study of how that occurs at the mass level is much more informative of how it happens at the individual level than the other way around. The study of mass psychology is much more informative of individual psychology than individual psychology is of mass psychology. Freud, and even his radical follower, Reich, did not fully appreciate this. They effectively believed that mass psychology is best modeled by an examination of the individual psyche. But it is clear, at least to me, that it goes the other way around.
How did this mass social transformation called Nazism occur? Reich gives a complex, characterological answer which I can only summarize here. He argues that there are three levels to people's characterological make-up. One element is fascistic, implying that there is the capacity for fascism in all of us. I do not accept that model. What I believe, and what we've come to see in our social therapeutic work, is that our normal social interaction is so profoundly alienated and lacking of a sense of historical connectedness that relatively minor changes in the actual process by which information is communicated and disseminated can create total transformation overnight. The absence of a sense of history leaves us extremely vulnerable. And this was very much the situation with German culture and German society in the 1920s.
This process, while in varying degrees cognitive, emotive and social, is not characterizable as any of these processes. Rather, it is a process of investigating if there is another sense of identity aside from the over- determined societal sense of identity. This societal sense of identity, in my opinion, is the ultimate source of the depressed state. This is not the same thing as saying that depression has social origins. To be sure, it does. The point is that the whole mode of our emotional organization, both its normalcy and its abnormalcy, is effectively organized by the categories, life interactions, and social roles of one super-ahistorical culture and society.
If we take depression as a normal as opposed to an abnormal state, then looking for the source of depression in its particularity means looking for the historical origins of the total social experience which leaves us vulnerable, in the face of particular historical stimuli, to an unraveling best described as losing our sense of identity because of having lost our sense of location in society.
In Anti-Oedipus (a very good book which I completely disagree with) the French psychoanalysts and philosophers, Guattari and Deleuze, say that, in the final analysis (pardon the pun), Freud's greatest contribution was that he gave the madman social validity, a societal location: that what Freud did for the insane was to offer them a social contract, and say. We have a place for you. You're not a devil, you're not a demon, you're not extra-societal-you're merely insane. And we shall enter ("we" meaning the psychoanalyst and the patient) into a social contract which gives you a relationship to society. Having that relationship, you are now able to function in a more stable fashion whether or not anything else of any significance happens in these interactions, be they five or six or seven days a week. What is fundamentally curative, Guattari and Deleuze argue, is that contract. I believe this is by and large correct. I think that this contract with the maladjusted is of profound importance. R.D. Laing once said that the good news about psychoanalysis is that most people who practice it do nothing resembling what is contained in its theories for, if they did, they would do terrible damage to people. It is the contract that does the good work.
Now, if we want to move beyond therapy whose effectiveness is totally contained in its liberal contract, then we have to change the depressive person's relationship not within or to society but within and to history. The distinction I am making here is the distinction between adaptation to society through a reorganization of one's relationship to society and adaptation to history through a reorganization of one's relationship (or a group's relationship or a nation's relationship) to history. History cures depression.
What does that mean? My colleague Lois Holzman and I have been doing research on these matters for the better part of a decade. In an article we wrote about three years ago, we pointed out that in our culture both thought and history have been profoundly over-determined by language. Others have observed that. Some people, including distinguished social scientists (e.g., the communicationist school in Palo Alto, California) go so far as to say that in point of fact, we should talk only about language usage because language usage is the closest approximation we have to both thought and history. They mention that any attempt to reach thought or history directly is ill-fated, that the study of human existence, of interpersonal behavior, of subjectivity, of life, is best accomplished by the study of communication.
The attempt to reach history, then, is inseparable from the attempt to understand the ideological limitations of a linguistically over-determined socio-pathology. The questions, "What is language?" and "What is language usage?" are not abstract, but questions about a social process which involves the very rich and complex phenomena of making sounds, making inscriptions, making marks, putting them together in certain ways, forming them verbally, etc. What is this extraordinary social process? And to what extent has this process emerged in such a way as to become identifiable with life itself and with history itself? In many respects, the process of reaching history is best understood as the process of self-consciously creating a new language-actually, an anti- language. Many people say that this is part of the Freudian tradition. Isn't there, after all, a sense in which a new language is created in the process of psychoanalysis? Yes, but it is designed specifically to translate from one societally-bound language into another societally-bound language. What we are talking about here is the creation of a language (anti-language) whose specific function is to reach the historicalness of our social being.
We are, of course, in history right now, you know. Being in history, if you'll permit me this word, is our "natural" state. The unnatural state, the pathological state, the abnormal state, is being in the limited location that is society. In the case of our particular society and its particular developmental route, this fundamental abnormality translates into a depressive population. There will be no cure for depression in the absence of breaking down all the ideological connectors to society.
A person comes into my office and says, "I feel blue, depressed; suicidal." "Why?" "I have suffered a great loss." "How do you know?" "How do I know I have suffered a great loss? I have lost a loved one. She's dead. She's gone. She's left. That's a great loss. What do you mean how do I know?" "I appreciate all of that pain. I appreciate that experience. I appreciate your feelings. I empathize, I sympathize. But why do you persist in identifying it as a loss?" "To me it's a loss!" "How did it get to be a loss?" "To me it is a loss. It is my personal loss." "It may he your personal loss, but it is after all not your personal conception of loss." Does this deny the validity of the emotional response?-Not at all. Rather, it speaks to the organization of emotionality, which is specific to the societal definition of who we are. And it raises-going back to the issue of definition-why it is that we have to accept these definitional, categorical locations at all, and how fundamental this question is to what we call depression.
This historical approach is most powerful when a person is in crisis, whether or not you wish to categorize that as depression. There more than anywhere must we challenge the societally over-determined affective- cognitive self-understandings. In its crudest form, Crisis Normalization Short Term Therapy looks like this: A person comes in and says. "Everything just fell apart. The stock market, my family, the world, it all fell apart." And in the loudest possible voice, one has to work up the gumption to say "How do you know? What makes you believe that? Where did that happen? What gave you that idea? What the hell are you talking about?" As a social therapist, one takes the risk of having the patient think that you are out of your mind. But the question is a profoundly important question. "How do you know that? How do you know you're in crisis? How do you know you're incapable? How do you know that you can't cope?" That is not said in the form of a pat-on-the-back-"You can really do it, kid." Maybe you can't do it; in fact, the presumption of being in crisis therapy is that you can't do it. But the question is: "How do you know that?" "Why do you think that way?" "Why are those your emotive responses?" You must as a social therapist directly question the organization of emotionality when someone is in crisis because if you don't, you will be leaving her or him in the situation of potentially being permanently locked into no longer having the capacity to cope, no longer having any sense of meaning, i.e., in what we have identified as the experience of societal identity being totally demolished. And the cure for that is not to help someone relocate or adapt, but to find a new place. History is the name of that place.
I hope you are not shocked. From the vantage point of attempting to define depression, they were the least pretentious. That is, the authors (in Coyne's anthology) at least had the decency to say that what they were doing was simply discovering what they took to be techniques for dealing with symptoms. One might not like them; I myself have some very serious questions about them. They at least admit that we should not confuse our capacity to help people with having identified the source or the cause of a problem. In one particularly insightful paper (in Coyne's collection), it was pointed out that the effectiveness of aspirin for the simple headache should in no way be taken to imply that aspirin deficiency is the cause of headaches. I think that is an important insight not only for biomedical approaches but for all approaches. All that I have said tonight should not suggest that we have the correct definition, causal analysis, ideological location, or understanding of depression. Do not make of me a definition-monger. In fact, what I am saying is that holding to a definitional paradigm is problematic. We are not suggesting that the "aspirin of history," if you will, is giving a causal accounting of depression. What we are contending is that we have discovered a very effective aspirin-in history-which we call the Short Term Crisis Normalization approach. Thank you.
Well. I'd do precisely as I described. So it must be that you're saying that that's not a proper approach for the immediacy of this crisis. All the different approaches can and need be taken. The question is not which approaches you take, it's rather what you take these approaches to be. This has a profound impact on the direct relationship in the real world. We are trained in such a way as to call the real world the world which exists simply at the object level of direct response to the immediate presentations. But this is the illusory, not the real, world. The real world includes the historicalness which is the process by which these objectified responses are but the immediate presentation. That's the point I'm speaking to. So yes, of course, I have met such people and I treat such patients. They come to see me and those are exactly their responses. What I am insisting upon is that whatever one's object-level approach, without the inclusion of historicalness one is effectively leaving something of enormous significance out of the treatment.
Now what does that look like? It looks like coming to terms with the historicalness of whatever immediate approach it is that you are taking. I personally believe that the approaches should be as varied as what is helpful for a human being in pain. But I don't think that, in the name of pragmatism, we should buy in on the institutional categories so as to leave the person permanently locked in that position. I've worked with many people who have gone through a process where development is rekindled by virtue of a connection to this historical process. In my opinion:, if we cannot re-stimulate growth, then we are truly limited to aspirins. So I don't want to leave anybody with the impression that what I'm here describing is an abstraction, because it does deal with the immediacy of a situation. One must. The issue is whether you're completely organized by the immediacy of the situation. Everything that we're taught and trained to do socializes us to be thus organized. What I am urging is breaking out of that kind of training, not by way of giving up what is most valuable about it, but rather by using what is most valuable about it. The search for definition is an invalid search. The search for historical location is a valid search. What techniques are used along the road?-All and any that are helpful. But not just treatment relative to finding some place for the person you're relating to. No, not just giving someone a drug so we can find a spot for them. Not the activity of putting a label on somebody and putting them somewhere. No, not that.
Going beyond diagnosis to treatment, wouldn't you say that the application of Social Therapy is to become involved actively in understanding and working on the social problems that contribute to depression and anger?
Strangely enough, I think the answer is no. In July, I gave a talk to the Congress of the Interamerican Society of Psychology in Cuba where I developed the conception of relating to the patient as a revolutionary. This means relating to someone as a human being capable of transforming her or his social environment. Whether one chooses to do so is another issue. In fact, it seems to me that it is most important to relate to someone as a revolutionary when the patient is not one. To put it candidly, I'm willing to run the risk that, if one empowers people, they will do progressive things. I have seen that when people are free from the constraints of societal definition, they do very positive, nourishing, and progressive kinds of things. Therefore, our concern is primarily to help people to become empowered and to allow their social activities to flow, as it were, from themselves. I am a very strong critic of so-called radical therapy. I think it failed: on scientific, social and cultural levels, to simply take the risk of empowerment and go from there. We have come to see that empowerment need not establish an end, because people will establish ends that are consistent with the continuation of empowerment. Empowerment feels good. Depression feels lousy. I'm ready to bank on that. People, as they are currently locked up and classified in society, are in serious trouble. They have to be helped from their state of depression into an empowered historical state. And from there, people need to be allowed to, as it were, roam free. I'll take my chance on people in history.
I think that the natural state of the human being is powerful, not in chains. The work, then, is to help people not simply find another set of chains, or an accommodation to being in chains, or a way of painting the chains so we can pretend that they're bracelets, but rather to come to terms with the social-historical origins of those chains. This is specific to different individuals, since we all have different histories and are imprisoned in various ways to varying degrees. These histories are critical for us to take control of. Taking control of our history has, as a precondition, not simply having a cognitive awareness of it, but restructuring or reorganizing of it. We only come to know our history by participating actively in its creation. Creating a new relationship or a new community-one that is qualitatively different, is part of creating a new history. It would be qualitatively different by being self-consciously determined, developed, built, and organized by those who participate in the process, which includes, necessarily, a constant engagement of the limiting circumstances of our current societal location. Now that's an altogether different paradigm than adapting to a societal situation. It's not adaptive to society-it s adaptive to history. I am not anti-adaptive. Let's adapt to history-not to society.
Take a social problem like illiteracy. It is still the case that some people live right next door to each other and one person learns and the other person doesn't. One could approach the issue of illiteracy, therefore, in a way which overly focuses on that kind of issue. Or one could approach the issue of illiteracy from the vantage point of the conditions which establish the mass phenomenon of illiteracy. This is what we must do vis-Ã -vis the issue of depression if we take depression not to be abnormal but a normal state. What I am urging here is a mass psychological approach, which has a profound influence on every individual who participates in the transformation of the conditions which produce depression, as opposed to an approach which seeks to identify the definitional causes of a particular individual's depression.
Social Therapy purports to be a theory of human life which counts on the activity of human beings, not on the passivity of human beings. Isn't the premise that human beings are nothing more than products of our environment antithetical to the conception of the human being as active? How is this contradiction resolved?
Let me try to answer that by talking more about depression. One of the ways we can approach depression is to try to eliminate loss. If we can do away with loss, then even by the criteria that the traditionalists have laid down, we probably can do something about depression. But most of the people who research and write about depression take both the phenomenological experience of it and the actual socio-historical phenomenon of loss as something which goes without saying. The issue then becomes figuring out what to do about how people respond to loss. But, what if we get rid of loss? What if we no longer have losses? Wouldn't that be a breakthrough in the treatment of depression? I actually think we have a better chance of eliminating losses than we have of eliminating depression if we hold onto losses. I think that if we hold onto losses, depression simply follows.
Scientifically speaking, then, our best shot is to go after loss and forget about depression. I don't think this has to be seen in merely grandiose terms only. Loss is something we can learn to transform in the collective activity of changing the relatively mundane totalities of our daily lives. People tend to treat losses as somehow primordial: "Losses simply happen to us!" But they don't simply happen: the concept and phenomenon of loss is particularized to a specific societal organization of human life. Can we do something about that? What would it take to change the whole societal arrangement? It probably falls outside the scope of the Social Therapy group! But it doesn't follow that you can not make those kinds of changes within the limited environments of totalities that we relate to in our everyday lives. So it's important that you don't take what I'm saying as "we have to change the whole world and then people won't he depressed anymore." What I'm saying is that there is a methodology for the transformation of environmental and social totalities of a very mundane variety.
Why do you have to lose something? When you say it's natural, are you suggesting that in all cultures-past, present, and future-people have the same reaction to, for example, the ending of a relationship? Is that what "natural" implies?
As a matter of fact, the ways in which people respond to relationships ending vary enormously from culture to culture.
There are cultures where people relate to endings of relationships as relatively natural parts of the life process. Some peoples relate to death, for example, very differently than we do. There are differences within our own culture, although to be sure, there is much overlap. But I'm trying to engage the issue of your insistence that it is a natural phenomenon rather than a socially determined one. It is not an integral part of the human being that we have to have the particular experience that you are identifying as loss. It is not natural at all. On the other hand, I'm not saying that it is unnatural, meaning that there is something wrong with it. We are, after all, products of the social conditioning of our culture, so we do, in fact, have these kinds of experience. They are deeply ingrained and profoundly reinforced, so much so that it is quite understandable that you would react to how I'm talking about loss by saying. "This is crazy! The feeling of loss is natural!" But if we pursue this a bit, we begin to see that it is not so much natural as it is, in a complex way, social. There are conditions which lead us to organize our environments in certain ways. So certainly the experience of deprivation is going to be one kind of experience in a society which is undersupplied and a different kind of experience in a society which is not undersupplied. Deprivation means very different things for different people in our culture, people of different classes, different ethnicities, etc. But again, I must add that I'm not even talking about broad socio-cultural changes to eliminate loss I actually think that people can learn to have a different experience of loss within the relatively narrow set of environments that we engage on a day to day basis. But to do so involves learning how to transform totalities. That is, the key activity that is the activity that we are free to do as human beings.
But to give a truly adequate answer to your question involves spelling out a whole new social therapeutic approach to depression. Since we don't have time and I don't have it totally clear, I can just begin to lay out some of the initial thinking. Why do I say that losses are bound to society more than to history? It is because I think that the social experience of life in history is not the experience of the alienated object which is subjective loss, but of the social process of which the object is but a description of one of its stages. Part of what it means to be in history is to experience the chair not as a commodified object, a product totally isolated from the social-productive process which led to it, but rather to experience the social-productive process. The name that we give to this relatively stable moment of its existence is CHAIR. But it is possible that there are cultures, not just futuristic cultures but past cultures, where the immediacy of the productive process leads to a totally different view of the world such that what is viewed is not alienated and separated-out objects, products or commodities rather, the viewed experience is social process. When the ontology of perception, i.e., what you view and experience, is social process, then the concept of loss is altogether different. In fact, it is not at all clear to me that under those circumstances loss has any meaning. Because what you actually wind up viewing is the transformation of the complex interweave of social process.
The notion of loss is very much tied to the development of commodified societies. Loss is fundamentally, in my opinion, an economic term. Does it have emotive meaning? Of course it does, because terms which are fundamentally economic come to have meaning in all areas of life. But this concept of loss is basically the elimination, destruction, obliteration of what is already the alienated product of the social process of development, production. Our world is filled with these alienated objects called commodities. Commodities behave in strange ways. For example, they can disappear. They can go out of existence in a way that social processes can't. Social processes continue. Commodities go out of existence (which is rather convenient for those who produce them). Part of what we do in the Short Term Crisis Normalization model is, as it were, to get people out of their role-determined location in society and move them (modestly, to be sure) into history so as to elongate their sense of social process so they are not overwhelmed by the wrenching of the gestalt of their life, this gigantic element, this loss. This rupture is profound when your view of the world is of a framed object-you rip that out and it is exceedingly difficult to see the world. We attempt to deal not merely with the missing object-e.g., by trying to replace it (even though it is irreplaceable) or pretending that what happened didn't happen-but with the frame of the picture. The primary focus is to break down that frame, because until you bust open that frame, the experience of deprivation will be so overwhelming, the sense of loss so great, that people can remain paralyzed in crisis. This positive process of opening up-rather than staying confined within-that frame, is an example of dealing with totalities rather than dealing with elements.
The following is based on a talk by Dr. Newman sponsored by the East Side Institute for Short Term Psychotherapy, on October 23, 1987 (later published in Practice: The Journal of Politics, Economics, Psychology, Sociology & Culture, 1987, Vol. 1 No. 3).
I do not wish to add my name to the long list of definition mongers. I believe that the search for definition is methodologically problematic. What 1 want to try to develop here is what it means to evolve an approach to depression which doesn't have, amongst its presuppositions, the need to offer a definition of what depression is. I want to talk about why definitional approaches are less curative, less useful; less helpful-in fact, function negatively-relative to the treatment received by people we see in the "non-definitional" short term, social therapeutic approach.
A curious feature of our language (noted by many) is the humor sometimes obtainable by flipping subjects and objects in phrases or sentences. More often than not, such a flip produces both humor and insight. I'll give you an example of what I mean. A much more precise title for Coyne's Essential Papers on Depression would be Depressing Papers on Essentialism. These are indeed very depressing papers on essentialism! They all attempt to give not only a definition of depression hut an essentialistic characterization of the human being as a precondition for then discussing depression. "Depression must he understood as the common cold of psychopathology," we are told. Exactly right. After all, depression, in one form or another, strikes not just handfuls of people, hut millions of people. The estimates given center around I out of 5 people. That figure is likely an underestimation, referring only to people who have received some kind of treatment. The number is surely higher since there is a continuum of depression. Indeed, it is often debated whether depression, qua clinical category, is actually an extension of depression as we know it in ordinary life. It is hard to do therapy for more than ten minutes without treating people who suffer from depression. And many of us here, I am sure, have gone through severe bouts of depression ourselves. Being depressed, then, seems almost an element of the definition of being human.
The DSM-Ill criteria for major depressive episodes further this question. Here is the definition (officially of depression, unofficially a partial definition of human being): "Loss of interest or pleasure in all or almost all usual activities and pastimes, characterized by symptoms such as the following: sad, depressed, blue, hopeless, down in the dumps; irritable-must be persistent but not necessarily the dominant symptom. At least four of the following symptoms must have been present nearly every day for a period of nearly two weeks (in children under six at least three of the first four): (1) Poor appetite or significant weight loss, when not dieting, or increased appetite or significant weight gain (in children under six, consider failure to make expected weight gains); (2) insomnia or hypersomnia:; (3) Psychomotor agitation or retardation, not merely subjective feelings of restlessness or being slowed down (in children under six, hyperactivity); (4) Loss of interest or pleasure in usual activities or decrease in sexual drive not limited to a period when delusional or hallucinating (in children under six, signs of apathy); (5) Loss of energy, fatigue; (6) Feelings of worthlessness, self-reproach, or excessive or inappropriate guilt. either may be delusional; (7) Complaints or evidence of diminished ability to think or concentrate, such as slowed thinking or indecisiveness not associated with marked loosening of associations or incoherence; (8) Recurrent thoughts of death, suicidal deviation, wishes to be dead or suicide attempt." It goes on. So must we. Let's try to move beyond definitional approaches.
Some experts suggest that loss is primarily emotive, some that loss is more cognitive than emotive; others say that loss is more interpersonal than either cognitive or emotive, and still others actually say that loss is chemical. The idea which comes across in these varying approaches to depression is that there are some kinds of loss which provoke or induce an inability to cope, and that this inability to cope is not specifically a sadness nor a feeling blue. Rather, the feeling state identified with depression is more appropriately identified as the lack of a feeling state. What cuts across many of these statements and points of view is that the essence of the depressive state is the experience of helplessness, to some extent a non-feeling, i.e., a seeming inability to any longer be responsive.
As I understand Becker, what is common to both the experience of depression and the approaches to the experience is this loss of the capacity to cognitively, emotively, psychologically, culturally, politically "keep the whole damn thing together." There has essentially been a breakdown of framework and meaning. With this breakdown, one becomes weighted down with a sense of helplessness ("learned helplessness") because the life experiences which previously may have been nourishing, developmental, meaningful, and significant, no longer have that impact. The depressed experience is compounded by the fact that one is now going through life epistemologically aware of doing the same things one had always done (and. in the past, derived nourishment and pleasure from) but now these experiences give no pleasure. The depression, then, deepens due to what is effectively a kind of "learned helplessness." In place of the ability to take experiences and fit them into an overall framework which is growthful, productive, and makes you feel human, cared for, capable, and alive, increasingly these same kinds of experiences now contribute nothing to your sense of self-identity. You become dead in life. You go through the motions. You might perform well-many, many depressed people perform very well. In some cases people don't even know that they are depressed. They say "Oh that's how I thought life was! I didn't know that was a sickness! I didn't know that could be cured." In the midst of a rather severe depression many years ago, I could see that my life experience for some 15-20 years before was not all that dramatically different. I came to see that depression (almost as severe as what I was then experiencing) was what I had thought of as the normal state of life.
Once again let us change the initial premise of our investigation from searching for a cure for a disease, to searching for a cure for a normal state. This of course has serious socio-economic implications. For example, if you put up a shingle which says. "Only Normal People Come Here," no one would know whether to come or not! People might come in and say. "I'm terribly ill," and you'd reply. "Well, to tell you the truth, I don't treat illness." I do not treat illness-because much of what has been conceptually and socially defined as illness makes it, in my opinion, fundamentally incurable. A lot of people fail to appreciate the perniciousness of definition and categorization, fail to appreciate the perniciousness of language, and fail to appreciate the extent to which we have all been socialized by language and categories, including the categories of emotion, cognition and disease, such that if we persist in functioning within these categories, it is questionable whether we can ever make it out of them.
Starting from our quite different assumption, our anti-paradigm, if you will, how do we relate to folks who come to see us and lay out all of the symptoms described in the literature on depression! People tell us. "I feel sad, disempowered, listless-helpless. I don't know what to do with my life. I'm thinking about committing suicide." Those are very real things said by very real people, and they should not he denied or doubted. Millions of people feel this way, and some few come to us seeking help, and one cannot make fun of the people who are suffering, who are in pain. What do we do then, when people come to us depressed!
American culture, more than any other, has profoundly and dramatically lost a sense of history. Far from being a radical statement, this is the standard analysis of many people across the political, social and cultural spectrum. Over and over again it has been pointed out that the American sensibility runs roughly from the six o'clock news to the ten o'clock news. "What happened?" "What is historical?" "What is really going on?" The answer is what is momentary; it is whatever is presented in the media, largely on television. Our sensibility, such as it is, is mediated by an incredible barrage of words and images carefully shaped in such a way as to not simply create a certain picture, hut to explicitly create a certain sense of alienation from the sources and objects of that picture. That is, to destroy our sense of history. There is ample evidence to suggest that as a people, we have not simply been alienated from the process of work and production hut we have been alienated from the historical process of our own historical development. We have been denied the possibility of history as well as the actuality of history. People like Richard Sennett and others have noted the narcissism of American society. But the "Me Generation" is more than generational. The "me-ness" of American culture goes well beyond any single generation.
All over the world, people are astounded by the historical deprivation that is characteristic of our culture. We read in the European press of Europe's fears of the Reagan administration. To be sure, part of that has to do with his programmatics. But it also has to do with the fact that Europeans quite correctly are fearful of a major power to whom they are beholden in a life and death sense, being run by someone whose paradigm of reality is the grade B movie or six o'clock news. Many people are concerned about a population, a president and a culture which over-identifies war, for example, as something that appears on television, which identifies profound social problems as images in a movie. We have, in many ways and for many reasons, evolved as a culture so thoroughly alienated from history as to make us profoundly vulnerable, in a momentary situation, to deep-rooted depression.
I am not suggesting that the more traditional elements discussed in classical papers and research on depression are irrelevant, however, I am urging that none of what is said makes a whole lot of sense unless we locate these analyses in some socio-psychological understanding of our particular culture, specifically our deprivation of history. In the absence of a historical sense we are enormously vulnerable to profound depression. Does this happen to individuals? Yes. Does it happen to masses of people? Yes. Is it of great concern?-certainly.
The study of how that occurs at the mass level is much more informative of how it happens at the individual level than the other way around. The study of mass psychology is much more informative of individual psychology than individual psychology is of mass psychology. Freud, and even his radical follower, Reich, did not fully appreciate this. They effectively believed that mass psychology is best modeled by an examination of the individual psyche. But it is clear, at least to me, that it goes the other way around.
How did this mass social transformation called Nazism occur? Reich gives a complex, characterological answer which I can only summarize here. He argues that there are three levels to people's characterological make-up. One element is fascistic, implying that there is the capacity for fascism in all of us. I do not accept that model. What I believe, and what we've come to see in our social therapeutic work, is that our normal social interaction is so profoundly alienated and lacking of a sense of historical connectedness that relatively minor changes in the actual process by which information is communicated and disseminated can create total transformation overnight. The absence of a sense of history leaves us extremely vulnerable. And this was very much the situation with German culture and German society in the 1920s.
This process, while in varying degrees cognitive, emotive and social, is not characterizable as any of these processes. Rather, it is a process of investigating if there is another sense of identity aside from the over- determined societal sense of identity. This societal sense of identity, in my opinion, is the ultimate source of the depressed state. This is not the same thing as saying that depression has social origins. To be sure, it does. The point is that the whole mode of our emotional organization, both its normalcy and its abnormalcy, is effectively organized by the categories, life interactions, and social roles of one super-ahistorical culture and society.
If we take depression as a normal as opposed to an abnormal state, then looking for the source of depression in its particularity means looking for the historical origins of the total social experience which leaves us vulnerable, in the face of particular historical stimuli, to an unraveling best described as losing our sense of identity because of having lost our sense of location in society.
In Anti-Oedipus (a very good book which I completely disagree with) the French psychoanalysts and philosophers, Guattari and Deleuze, say that, in the final analysis (pardon the pun), Freud's greatest contribution was that he gave the madman social validity, a societal location: that what Freud did for the insane was to offer them a social contract, and say. We have a place for you. You're not a devil, you're not a demon, you're not extra-societal-you're merely insane. And we shall enter ("we" meaning the psychoanalyst and the patient) into a social contract which gives you a relationship to society. Having that relationship, you are now able to function in a more stable fashion whether or not anything else of any significance happens in these interactions, be they five or six or seven days a week. What is fundamentally curative, Guattari and Deleuze argue, is that contract. I believe this is by and large correct. I think that this contract with the maladjusted is of profound importance. R.D. Laing once said that the good news about psychoanalysis is that most people who practice it do nothing resembling what is contained in its theories for, if they did, they would do terrible damage to people. It is the contract that does the good work.
Now, if we want to move beyond therapy whose effectiveness is totally contained in its liberal contract, then we have to change the depressive person's relationship not within or to society but within and to history. The distinction I am making here is the distinction between adaptation to society through a reorganization of one's relationship to society and adaptation to history through a reorganization of one's relationship (or a group's relationship or a nation's relationship) to history. History cures depression.
What does that mean? My colleague Lois Holzman and I have been doing research on these matters for the better part of a decade. In an article we wrote about three years ago, we pointed out that in our culture both thought and history have been profoundly over-determined by language. Others have observed that. Some people, including distinguished social scientists (e.g., the communicationist school in Palo Alto, California) go so far as to say that in point of fact, we should talk only about language usage because language usage is the closest approximation we have to both thought and history. They mention that any attempt to reach thought or history directly is ill-fated, that the study of human existence, of interpersonal behavior, of subjectivity, of life, is best accomplished by the study of communication.
The attempt to reach history, then, is inseparable from the attempt to understand the ideological limitations of a linguistically over-determined socio-pathology. The questions, "What is language?" and "What is language usage?" are not abstract, but questions about a social process which involves the very rich and complex phenomena of making sounds, making inscriptions, making marks, putting them together in certain ways, forming them verbally, etc. What is this extraordinary social process? And to what extent has this process emerged in such a way as to become identifiable with life itself and with history itself? In many respects, the process of reaching history is best understood as the process of self-consciously creating a new language-actually, an anti- language. Many people say that this is part of the Freudian tradition. Isn't there, after all, a sense in which a new language is created in the process of psychoanalysis? Yes, but it is designed specifically to translate from one societally-bound language into another societally-bound language. What we are talking about here is the creation of a language (anti-language) whose specific function is to reach the historicalness of our social being.
We are, of course, in history right now, you know. Being in history, if you'll permit me this word, is our "natural" state. The unnatural state, the pathological state, the abnormal state, is being in the limited location that is society. In the case of our particular society and its particular developmental route, this fundamental abnormality translates into a depressive population. There will be no cure for depression in the absence of breaking down all the ideological connectors to society.
A person comes into my office and says, "I feel blue, depressed; suicidal." "Why?" "I have suffered a great loss." "How do you know?" "How do I know I have suffered a great loss? I have lost a loved one. She's dead. She's gone. She's left. That's a great loss. What do you mean how do I know?" "I appreciate all of that pain. I appreciate that experience. I appreciate your feelings. I empathize, I sympathize. But why do you persist in identifying it as a loss?" "To me it's a loss!" "How did it get to be a loss?" "To me it is a loss. It is my personal loss." "It may he your personal loss, but it is after all not your personal conception of loss." Does this deny the validity of the emotional response?-Not at all. Rather, it speaks to the organization of emotionality, which is specific to the societal definition of who we are. And it raises-going back to the issue of definition-why it is that we have to accept these definitional, categorical locations at all, and how fundamental this question is to what we call depression.
This historical approach is most powerful when a person is in crisis, whether or not you wish to categorize that as depression. There more than anywhere must we challenge the societally over-determined affective- cognitive self-understandings. In its crudest form, Crisis Normalization Short Term Therapy looks like this: A person comes in and says. "Everything just fell apart. The stock market, my family, the world, it all fell apart." And in the loudest possible voice, one has to work up the gumption to say "How do you know? What makes you believe that? Where did that happen? What gave you that idea? What the hell are you talking about?" As a social therapist, one takes the risk of having the patient think that you are out of your mind. But the question is a profoundly important question. "How do you know that? How do you know you're in crisis? How do you know you're incapable? How do you know that you can't cope?" That is not said in the form of a pat-on-the-back-"You can really do it, kid." Maybe you can't do it; in fact, the presumption of being in crisis therapy is that you can't do it. But the question is: "How do you know that?" "Why do you think that way?" "Why are those your emotive responses?" You must as a social therapist directly question the organization of emotionality when someone is in crisis because if you don't, you will be leaving her or him in the situation of potentially being permanently locked into no longer having the capacity to cope, no longer having any sense of meaning, i.e., in what we have identified as the experience of societal identity being totally demolished. And the cure for that is not to help someone relocate or adapt, but to find a new place. History is the name of that place.
I hope you are not shocked. From the vantage point of attempting to define depression, they were the least pretentious. That is, the authors (in Coyne's anthology) at least had the decency to say that what they were doing was simply discovering what they took to be techniques for dealing with symptoms. One might not like them; I myself have some very serious questions about them. They at least admit that we should not confuse our capacity to help people with having identified the source or the cause of a problem. In one particularly insightful paper (in Coyne's collection), it was pointed out that the effectiveness of aspirin for the simple headache should in no way be taken to imply that aspirin deficiency is the cause of headaches. I think that is an important insight not only for biomedical approaches but for all approaches. All that I have said tonight should not suggest that we have the correct definition, causal analysis, ideological location, or understanding of depression. Do not make of me a definition-monger. In fact, what I am saying is that holding to a definitional paradigm is problematic. We are not suggesting that the "aspirin of history," if you will, is giving a causal accounting of depression. What we are contending is that we have discovered a very effective aspirin-in history-which we call the Short Term Crisis Normalization approach. Thank you.
Well. I'd do precisely as I described. So it must be that you're saying that that's not a proper approach for the immediacy of this crisis. All the different approaches can and need be taken. The question is not which approaches you take, it's rather what you take these approaches to be. This has a profound impact on the direct relationship in the real world. We are trained in such a way as to call the real world the world which exists simply at the object level of direct response to the immediate presentations. But this is the illusory, not the real, world. The real world includes the historicalness which is the process by which these objectified responses are but the immediate presentation. That's the point I'm speaking to. So yes, of course, I have met such people and I treat such patients. They come to see me and those are exactly their responses. What I am insisting upon is that whatever one's object-level approach, without the inclusion of historicalness one is effectively leaving something of enormous significance out of the treatment.
Now what does that look like? It looks like coming to terms with the historicalness of whatever immediate approach it is that you are taking. I personally believe that the approaches should be as varied as what is helpful for a human being in pain. But I don't think that, in the name of pragmatism, we should buy in on the institutional categories so as to leave the person permanently locked in that position. I've worked with many people who have gone through a process where development is rekindled by virtue of a connection to this historical process. In my opinion:, if we cannot re-stimulate growth, then we are truly limited to aspirins. So I don't want to leave anybody with the impression that what I'm here describing is an abstraction, because it does deal with the immediacy of a situation. One must. The issue is whether you're completely organized by the immediacy of the situation. Everything that we're taught and trained to do socializes us to be thus organized. What I am urging is breaking out of that kind of training, not by way of giving up what is most valuable about it, but rather by using what is most valuable about it. The search for definition is an invalid search. The search for historical location is a valid search. What techniques are used along the road?-All and any that are helpful. But not just treatment relative to finding some place for the person you're relating to. No, not just giving someone a drug so we can find a spot for them. Not the activity of putting a label on somebody and putting them somewhere. No, not that.
Going beyond diagnosis to treatment, wouldn't you say that the application of Social Therapy is to become involved actively in understanding and working on the social problems that contribute to depression and anger?
Strangely enough, I think the answer is no. In July, I gave a talk to the Congress of the Interamerican Society of Psychology in Cuba where I developed the conception of relating to the patient as a revolutionary. This means relating to someone as a human being capable of transforming her or his social environment. Whether one chooses to do so is another issue. In fact, it seems to me that it is most important to relate to someone as a revolutionary when the patient is not one. To put it candidly, I'm willing to run the risk that, if one empowers people, they will do progressive things. I have seen that when people are free from the constraints of societal definition, they do very positive, nourishing, and progressive kinds of things. Therefore, our concern is primarily to help people to become empowered and to allow their social activities to flow, as it were, from themselves. I am a very strong critic of so-called radical therapy. I think it failed: on scientific, social and cultural levels, to simply take the risk of empowerment and go from there. We have come to see that empowerment need not establish an end, because people will establish ends that are consistent with the continuation of empowerment. Empowerment feels good. Depression feels lousy. I'm ready to bank on that. People, as they are currently locked up and classified in society, are in serious trouble. They have to be helped from their state of depression into an empowered historical state. And from there, people need to be allowed to, as it were, roam free. I'll take my chance on people in history.
I think that the natural state of the human being is powerful, not in chains. The work, then, is to help people not simply find another set of chains, or an accommodation to being in chains, or a way of painting the chains so we can pretend that they're bracelets, but rather to come to terms with the social-historical origins of those chains. This is specific to different individuals, since we all have different histories and are imprisoned in various ways to varying degrees. These histories are critical for us to take control of. Taking control of our history has, as a precondition, not simply having a cognitive awareness of it, but restructuring or reorganizing of it. We only come to know our history by participating actively in its creation. Creating a new relationship or a new community-one that is qualitatively different, is part of creating a new history. It would be qualitatively different by being self-consciously determined, developed, built, and organized by those who participate in the process, which includes, necessarily, a constant engagement of the limiting circumstances of our current societal location. Now that's an altogether different paradigm than adapting to a societal situation. It's not adaptive to society-it s adaptive to history. I am not anti-adaptive. Let's adapt to history-not to society.
Take a social problem like illiteracy. It is still the case that some people live right next door to each other and one person learns and the other person doesn't. One could approach the issue of illiteracy, therefore, in a way which overly focuses on that kind of issue. Or one could approach the issue of illiteracy from the vantage point of the conditions which establish the mass phenomenon of illiteracy. This is what we must do vis-Ã -vis the issue of depression if we take depression not to be abnormal but a normal state. What I am urging here is a mass psychological approach, which has a profound influence on every individual who participates in the transformation of the conditions which produce depression, as opposed to an approach which seeks to identify the definitional causes of a particular individual's depression.
Social Therapy purports to be a theory of human life which counts on the activity of human beings, not on the passivity of human beings. Isn't the premise that human beings are nothing more than products of our environment antithetical to the conception of the human being as active? How is this contradiction resolved?
Let me try to answer that by talking more about depression. One of the ways we can approach depression is to try to eliminate loss. If we can do away with loss, then even by the criteria that the traditionalists have laid down, we probably can do something about depression. But most of the people who research and write about depression take both the phenomenological experience of it and the actual socio-historical phenomenon of loss as something which goes without saying. The issue then becomes figuring out what to do about how people respond to loss. But, what if we get rid of loss? What if we no longer have losses? Wouldn't that be a breakthrough in the treatment of depression? I actually think we have a better chance of eliminating losses than we have of eliminating depression if we hold onto losses. I think that if we hold onto losses, depression simply follows.
Scientifically speaking, then, our best shot is to go after loss and forget about depression. I don't think this has to be seen in merely grandiose terms only. Loss is something we can learn to transform in the collective activity of changing the relatively mundane totalities of our daily lives. People tend to treat losses as somehow primordial: "Losses simply happen to us!" But they don't simply happen: the concept and phenomenon of loss is particularized to a specific societal organization of human life. Can we do something about that? What would it take to change the whole societal arrangement? It probably falls outside the scope of the Social Therapy group! But it doesn't follow that you can not make those kinds of changes within the limited environments of totalities that we relate to in our everyday lives. So it's important that you don't take what I'm saying as "we have to change the whole world and then people won't he depressed anymore." What I'm saying is that there is a methodology for the transformation of environmental and social totalities of a very mundane variety.
Why do you have to lose something? When you say it's natural, are you suggesting that in all cultures-past, present, and future-people have the same reaction to, for example, the ending of a relationship? Is that what "natural" implies?
As a matter of fact, the ways in which people respond to relationships ending vary enormously from culture to culture.
There are cultures where people relate to endings of relationships as relatively natural parts of the life process. Some peoples relate to death, for example, very differently than we do. There are differences within our own culture, although to be sure, there is much overlap. But I'm trying to engage the issue of your insistence that it is a natural phenomenon rather than a socially determined one. It is not an integral part of the human being that we have to have the particular experience that you are identifying as loss. It is not natural at all. On the other hand, I'm not saying that it is unnatural, meaning that there is something wrong with it. We are, after all, products of the social conditioning of our culture, so we do, in fact, have these kinds of experience. They are deeply ingrained and profoundly reinforced, so much so that it is quite understandable that you would react to how I'm talking about loss by saying. "This is crazy! The feeling of loss is natural!" But if we pursue this a bit, we begin to see that it is not so much natural as it is, in a complex way, social. There are conditions which lead us to organize our environments in certain ways. So certainly the experience of deprivation is going to be one kind of experience in a society which is undersupplied and a different kind of experience in a society which is not undersupplied. Deprivation means very different things for different people in our culture, people of different classes, different ethnicities, etc. But again, I must add that I'm not even talking about broad socio-cultural changes to eliminate loss I actually think that people can learn to have a different experience of loss within the relatively narrow set of environments that we engage on a day to day basis. But to do so involves learning how to transform totalities. That is, the key activity that is the activity that we are free to do as human beings.
But to give a truly adequate answer to your question involves spelling out a whole new social therapeutic approach to depression. Since we don't have time and I don't have it totally clear, I can just begin to lay out some of the initial thinking. Why do I say that losses are bound to society more than to history? It is because I think that the social experience of life in history is not the experience of the alienated object which is subjective loss, but of the social process of which the object is but a description of one of its stages. Part of what it means to be in history is to experience the chair not as a commodified object, a product totally isolated from the social-productive process which led to it, but rather to experience the social-productive process. The name that we give to this relatively stable moment of its existence is CHAIR. But it is possible that there are cultures, not just futuristic cultures but past cultures, where the immediacy of the productive process leads to a totally different view of the world such that what is viewed is not alienated and separated-out objects, products or commodities rather, the viewed experience is social process. When the ontology of perception, i.e., what you view and experience, is social process, then the concept of loss is altogether different. In fact, it is not at all clear to me that under those circumstances loss has any meaning. Because what you actually wind up viewing is the transformation of the complex interweave of social process.
The notion of loss is very much tied to the development of commodified societies. Loss is fundamentally, in my opinion, an economic term. Does it have emotive meaning? Of course it does, because terms which are fundamentally economic come to have meaning in all areas of life. But this concept of loss is basically the elimination, destruction, obliteration of what is already the alienated product of the social process of development, production. Our world is filled with these alienated objects called commodities. Commodities behave in strange ways. For example, they can disappear. They can go out of existence in a way that social processes can't. Social processes continue. Commodities go out of existence (which is rather convenient for those who produce them). Part of what we do in the Short Term Crisis Normalization model is, as it were, to get people out of their role-determined location in society and move them (modestly, to be sure) into history so as to elongate their sense of social process so they are not overwhelmed by the wrenching of the gestalt of their life, this gigantic element, this loss. This rupture is profound when your view of the world is of a framed object-you rip that out and it is exceedingly difficult to see the world. We attempt to deal not merely with the missing object-e.g., by trying to replace it (even though it is irreplaceable) or pretending that what happened didn't happen-but with the frame of the picture. The primary focus is to break down that frame, because until you bust open that frame, the experience of deprivation will be so overwhelming, the sense of loss so great, that people can remain paralyzed in crisis. This positive process of opening up-rather than staying confined within-that frame, is an example of dealing with totalities rather than dealing with elements.
After the Revolution: A Documentary (1986)
(Originally published in Practice: The Journal of Politics, Economics, Psychology, Sociology & Culture, Fall 1986)
This is a documentary on “After the Revolution,” the tenth annual Marxism and Mental Illness event (MMI) of the Institute for Social Therapy and Research, which took place in New York city on June 28, 1986. It excerpts the keynote talks of Dr. Lenora Fulani, Dr. Lois Holzman, and Dr. Fred Newman of the Institute's Board of directors [and indented] dialogue from the play From Gold to Platinum, which was the centerpiece of the event; and a post-production discussion of the play by the writers, directors, actors, producers, and production staff.
Lois Holzman: This past Thursday the U.S. House of Representatives approved $100 million in military aid to the counter-revolutionary forces working to overthrow the democratically elected, socialist led, progressive government of Nicaragua to murder innocent people. Although I was not surprised, I had many emotions when I heard this news. First, I was furious. I was worried about our brothers and sisters in Nicaragua, who have had to put all their energy, brains, money, and time into defending their revolution, at the expense of rebuilding their country. I was ashamed to be associated with the ugly, arrogant, macho United States. And, I was proud to be a communist.
I am aware that whenever I say the word “communism” people begin to squirm a little. And we must understand why; because a major reason why this anti-human, undemocratic, and vicious contra aid bill passed is how afraid our people are of that word—communism. It's a very loaded term a code word, a symbol—but even more, the word communism functions for the powers that be like a cattle prod—it shocks our people into acquiescence. Why should our intellectual yearnings, our cultural curiosity; our search for humane solutions to the practical problems of our lives end at the U.S. border? Why must they be suspiciously and forcefully checked? Why are we not allowed to learn from the people of Africa, Asia, and Latin America who are using Marxism and communism to eliminate hunger and illiteracy—who are using Marxism and communism to build hospitals, schools, and cultural centers in the towns of their countries?
The bourgeois media in this country work overtime to have us believe that there are worlds of difference between the wants, needs, and desires of Americans and those of our neighbors; that we are more advanced than they are; that we are superior to them; that Marxism and communism are for inferior people. What kind of ideology thwarts our natural inclination to seek out what is common, what is shared, our natural desire for internationalism? What kind of ideology maliciously thwarts as in the case of the blood-thirsty U.S. press coverage of the tragedy of Chernobyl—our natural need, quite simply, to care? It is an ideology of the rich, the powerful, the greedy—not an ideology of the broad masses of our people.
But let's not be fooled by a word; let's look under, behind, in, around, and through the word at what communism really is. Communism is a system of living, of societal organization—of economics, psychology, teaching, learning, working, playing, shopping, eating, sleeping, and loving—that is not based on the exploitation of one person for the benefit of another. This doesn't mean it's perfect, heaven, utopia, or nirvana. Communist and socialist societies are as imperfect as human beings are fallible. But communist society doesn't depend for its very economic existence on exploitation, oppression, profits, or scarcity in the way that U.S. society does. In a communist society, such things are treated as serious problems, not as normal human behavior.
The Institute for Social Therapy and Research has put this tool of working people—the science of Marxism—to work in America's inner cities—practically and actively—to solve the critical problems of illness, madness, poverty, and illiteracy. Is it working? Growing from 20 patients in Social Therapy on Manhattan's Upper West Side in 1978 to 500 patients in Social Therapy all over the country in 1986 says it's working; a 600% growth in gross income over 8 years to a projected annual revenue of $964,717 in 1986 says it's working; 1,475 members of Healthy Clubs in New York, Boston and Philadelphia says it's working; the 6,425 people who have come to the Castillo Center for theater and gallery events and parties says it's working; and the 38 children who attended the newly opened Barbara Taylor School this year and the 2 who just graduated says it's working.
Dan Friedman: As a performer, I know that the audience listened and responded to every line in a way that most audiences never do. People laughed and clapped in a way that showed a real connection with what was going on; they were really paying attention. I'm told that 100 people walked out, which means that 600 stayed, which sounds like a great percentage. The other way I know about how the audience responded was that we talked to them. The night after the performance, I was talking to two women from Jackson, Mississippi, one of whom is middle class, the other a tool and dye maker.
The middle-class woman stayed up the whole night, she was so upset by the violence, and the class polarization. But she wanted to talk about it. What she wanted to talk about was what her role would be in the revolution, if there could be a place for her. I said, “You heard it in the last line of the play—it's not your pedigree that counts, it's your politics!” She was very pleased to hear that again.
The other woman, the white working class woman, was so moved by the play and so enthusiastic, it blew me away. It gave me a sense of how we are actually out organizing, and the class is responding to it, to that play. Other things that happened were among our own organizers. For example: Nancy Hanks, a NAP organizer in Philadelphia, called up and read me a poem about her own life and how it related to MMI. People are talking about how they were moved and agitated and upset and inspired.
Fred Newman: We're talking about a new social vision. In point of fact, it's impossible to do the kinds of things that we do every day of the week in Harlem, in East New York, in East Los Angeles, in Jackson, Mississippi, and all over the country without a social vision. We're not simply about helping our children to be healthy just so this society can make them sick again. We're not about educating our children so they can live in a society that denies them the opportunity to use their learning and creativity. We're not about simply providing services in order to make it easier on the people in City Hall, in Albany, and in Washington, who would like nothing better than to get away without providing any services to poor people. We provide those services because we and you, our children and friends, have a social vision, and we intend to build and service and work every day until that social vision is realized. That's what we're about.
Lois Holzman: Let me share with you a personal experience. In 1980, I spent 3 months living in the Soviet Union. I was an exchange psychologist from Rockefeller University, where I had been doing research in education and psychology.
At the time I went I was not very politically sophisticated. In my naiveté, and in a typical American exceptionalist manner, I felt at first that I was “more political” than a lot of the Soviet citizens I met. I expected that they would speak about politics all the time. What I quickly came to realize was that progressive politics was totally integrated into the lives of the Soviet people; they grew up politically progressive; it came to them naturally. I saw a society that was run very differently from our society—it's a society organized for the benefit of, and from the vantage point of, the working class.
People were very open, and when they spoke about what was wrong with how things worked in their country and they spoke about these matters very passionately—they did it not from the perspective of the individual, but from the perspective of how to get the most for the most people. It was a striking contrast to how our society teaches us to understand and talk about what's wrong here in the United States—to say I can't get a job; I can't get ahead; I don't have what I need to live; I can't make it.
The other Americans who were studying or working in the Soviet Union would insist on making a separation between the personalities of the people they met and the conditions under which they lived. In other words, they loved the Russian people, but hated their society. These brainwashed Americans never asked themselves how the Russian people got to be the way they are; they never seemed to make the connection between the Soviets' caring, their concern for peace, their friendliness, and the society they lived in—the society that they produced and that produced them. They could not see that they had a different understanding of the world and a different approach to solving problems and getting things done.
In the Soviet Union I saw schools that are organized to teach kids as much as they can, because their talents, skills, and productivity are needed to build the country. I saw a system organized with the needs of the total person in mind—with factories that included day care centers, theaters, libraries, and schools. I saw the handicapped trained and treated as productive and contributing members of society. I saw at work a way of approaching life that is profoundly different, so that even the most common experiences are not the same, even something as common and seemingly universal as standing on a line. Shopping lines, movie lines, subway lines, bus lines—they are as long, if not longer, in Moscow as in New York. But is the line the same? Is it the same experience (does it have the same social meaning) to wait in line 15 minutes to buy meat for dinner in New York as it is in Moscow?
In New York the line exists as part of a system to increase profits for the owners. Our frustration and anger as we wait is not just in our heads—it's a real outgrowth of the antagonistic relationship between us—workers and consumers—and them—owners and profiteers. In Moscow, the line exists as part of a system that is designed and committed not to making profit for a few, but to eliminating scarcity and feeding everyone. And that requires the collective participation of every citizen in the effort. The felt experience of waiting on line in Moscow is very different—it may not be pleasant, but it is not antagonistic.
Fred Newman: Several years ago, I gave a talk at that forum called “The Psychology of Communism.” As a result of that talk, I got a phone call from a guy named Bob Lassiter in Tampa, Florida, who has an afternoon radio talk show. He called me up and he said, “I heard about your ‘Psychology of Communism' talk. How would you like to be on the air and answer questions about communism? You be in New York, and I'll call you up and people will call in with questions for a couple of hours. And I'll make you one guarantee—if anybody gets really hostile, I'll shut them up.” So I said, “Don't shut anybody up, I'm down for whatever people want to raise, just let them call—it'll be great!”
On the first two hour show, Lassiter, who's a nice, liberal sort of fellow, gets on the phone and says, “Before we begin, I have a question for you, Dr. Newman. Why do you call yourself a communist? You seem like a bright fellow. Don't you appreciate that people would be less offended if you didn't use that word? Why don't you put out your ideas and not say that you're a communist?” I said, “Well, Bob, I think that's a good question. There are many reasons I call myself a communist, but the first reason is that if I didn't, everyone else would. All you've got to say is you believe that the people of Harlem should come before people getting rich and someone will call you a communist. If you say that people have a right to a job or that they have a right to decent health care, someone will call you a communist. But I'll confess that I also do it for another reason: I do it because I like to shake you up.”
I think it's very important to teach people that we can no longer afford to be brainwashed, to cringe with fear, as Lois was saying, when we hear that word. So we did the show and some people were hostile and some were friendly, and Bob Lassiter kept calling me back month after month to do more shows. In fact, he now speaks of me—I'm on again in 2 weeks—as “the resident communist.” I'm the resident communist of Tampa, Florida—can you believe it? That's mind boggling!
Eva Brenner: I have many things to say, but the overriding experience that I and many other people had from being involved in this event is a feeling that revolution is really possible. A lot of people who were there had never heard of us, but saw the flyer on the street, and my sense was that we created a sense of “maybe this is possible.” If it did that, I think it was very successful. My roommate was talking about her political development and she said, “I really want to come out more as a leader, like Betti from the Bronx [a character in the play].”
It felt like people were treating these folks on the stage like they were comrades, everyday friends. That changed a lot of my perceptions of what characters are. In the avant-garde where I come from, people watch at a great distance and are not really being there with you. It raised a lot of things about identifying with someone, but identifying in a totally different way than the bourgeois way, where you identify with these petty emotions that are very uninteresting and actually detract from a historical view of reality. The play accomplished a lot on that level.
Tom D.: I think, just on a pure feeling level, it was really an enormous success. At the end, the joy of people on and off the stage, the level of energy, was just tremendous. I've experienced that feeling maybe two or three times in my life. People were floating.
SARAH: It's funny. When I was in college we used to go to the demonstrations supporting the revolutions in South Africa and the Congo and Mexico and we used to wonder if it could ever happen here. If we could win one here, we'd be winning for all the other revolutions around the world. If not, it was dear, even back then, that the capitalists would blow the world away. And then we did it. We made a revolution. I still find it hard to let that in.
Lois Holzman: Each year, as we at the Institute apply Marxism to mental illness, stress, cancer, homophobia, racism and ethnic divisions, illiteracy, sexuality, unemployment, drug addiction, and many other crises and problems of everyday living, welcome to a deeper understanding and appreciation of the relevancy of Marxism and the power of this different world view.
Lenora Fulani: In 1986, the Harlem Institute for Social Therapy and Research, located on 125th Street and Seventh Avenue in the landmark Theresa Hotel, serves as a model in its practice of medicine and therapy of how to build among the Black, Latino, Jewish, gay, and oppressed populations of this country a deeply needed, deeply missed, most inclusive, and dramatically empowering sense of community. And this community is not just any old community. The right wing in this country teaches a sense of community based on a thinly veiled message of deep and awesome hatred of the oppressed. Our community is based on the power of and love for the oppressed.
What is taken out as the Harlem Institute in a form that is powerfully and passionately digestible is a sense of community based on our social vision, with a growing recognition that building a sense of community for the liberation of oppressed peoples in this country means going all the way.
This sense of community is not new to people of color. African American historians teach us of African communalism, the collective spirit that dominated the work and lifestyles of our people before the European raping of the African continent; a spirit that has been profoundly visible in the struggles of our people in contemporary Namibia, Zimbabwe, Angola, Mozambique, the Congo, and South Africa as they shape African communalism into a tool of socialism and communism in their fight for liberation and freedom. It is a spirit, a vision, a sense that appeared time and time again in the struggles led by Martin, Malcolm, and the Black Panthers. It is raising its head again in the response of our people—people of color, Jews, gays, progressives in the community of independent institutions of which the Institute for Social Therapy and Research is proud to be a part.
America has deprived its people of a sense of community. A sense of community, like a sense of history, has always been denied to the people of this country by the people who run it. Black folks are denigrated as a people who don't stick together; Blacks and Latinos and Asians as people who can't unite because we come from different cultures; and Jews as people who do stick together, but only for themselves. The truth is that those who rule this country have spent millions of dollars and millions of conniving hours murdering grassroots movements, leaders, and peoples, and doing all they can to destroy our sense of community, solidarity, and history.
Allen Cox: One thing I really enjoyed as a performer was the audience's support. It allowed me to come out more. Not only the people that I know through the political community—but my aunt was there and told me that she took a friend with her and they stayed through the whole show. She said her friend called her up and said, “Oh, you hanging out with the commies, huh?” But they laughed about it and my aunt said she really enjoyed it. She said she took pride in how well I had done, and she enjoyed other folks too. It gave me an opportunity to talk about communism in a way that I haven't been able to even begin talking about it before with her.
Fred Newman: That is, for me, one of the really important things about the whole play. I'm very interested in making it possible for people to even hear the word “communism” and associate it with some of the more ordinary things, like people being conflicted, happy, sad … so at least you can get a foot in the door, you can talk about it. No small part of what's problematic about organizing in this national sector is you can't even get past the word, it has such incredible connotations. One thing I was concerned to do was really break that down. I thought that was powerful. Some people were really polarized around it, because they don't want to hear the word. But in a sense, it makes the word human. Here's a person who's really human—and a communist. That's very heavy, in an American theater and in American life.
Lois Holzman: Look around you. Virtually all of us here tonight have been touched by Marxism—some a lot, some a little, some for a long time, some just recently. Our community is evidence of its usability in contemporary America. Tens of thousands of people experience daily what we've built. Social Therapy is available in clinics from Boston to Denver, from Jackson, Mississippi to Los Angeles. The Harlem Institute has doubled in size this year, as Black people in that community, together with gay people, women, and Latinos, have claimed Social Therapy as their tool for empowerment. Thousands of people have come to the Institute's Castillo Cultural Center's events and thousands more have participated in Musicruises on the Hudson River and talent shows we help to produce. Hundreds have taken classes at the Jackson Luxemburg School and visited our medical clinics.
Lenora Fulani: How do we build this sense of community, based on our progressive social vision, in our day to day practice at the Institute for Social Therapy and Research? One way is in our use of Social Therapy, a drug free, group oriented approach to the treatment of emotional problems that is also steeped in a recognition that our problems—mental illness and the emotional stresses of our lives—are social in their origin.
Social Therapy is an empowerment therapy that we use to create an environment where people can come to know who they actually are. I remember when I first began practicing at the Harlem Institute, I was taken aback that poor people and addicted people in our Medicaid groups would come in with descriptions and misunderstandings of themselves and their problems that were straight out of Reagan's mouth; the Black and Latino professional middle class would come in with understandings from Ozzie and Harriet and the Cosbys and would ask, “Why me?” as if they were not also Black and Latino; and gay people would display no sense of having made a radical move that seriously challenges some oppressive institutions of this society.
The power of Social Therapy is that people—poor, working class people, middle class people, people of color—are pushed to work on their emotional problems as who they are in the world, not as isolated and alienated Freudian ids, egos, and super egos, but as people with histories. It is this process that has led to the growth of our clinics, and this process goes along, long way in creating a sense of community.
BETTI: if we lose this one, we lose the Bronx again. The Bronx was capitalism in sick decay. We were left to rot, to starve—to kill each other. We were left to die by the capitalist motherfuckers. But we didn't die and we didn't kill each other. We organized. And then it was our time to let them die. And we did. So now they want it back. They want to rule over the decay of western civilization. Let them rule over hell.
Lois Holzman: Of all the profound and extraordinary achievements we've seen in this past year of growth, I want to share with you the significance of the Barbara Taylor School, which opened in September of 1985 in Harlem, because this school can be understood as a synthesis of all that the Institute is doing. At the Barbara Taylor School, young people—our future—are treated not as individuals who must compete for knowledge, nor as individuals whose limited store of development and promise will taper off somewhere in their early teens. They are not treated as victims—poor, Black and Latino youngsters who, as “disadvantaged” and “deprived” (to use some other oppressive words of the powers that be), need a supportive environment to “to catch up” to their white, middle-class peers. The students at the Barbara Taylor School, ages 3-13, are into some very serious business. They are participating in a bold experiment in education. They are being trained to be leaders—all of them, not just the best or the brightest—in liberating themselves, their families, and their communities from the racism and classism of this country that keeps them “remedial.” They are participating in learning and developing in the way they must if they are to change the world into a place for them and their communities to grow.
All of the advances of radical and Marxist psychology and pedagogy are being brought to bear on the building of the Barbara Taylor School. Especially useful are the brilliant insights of the Soviet psychologist, Lev Vygotsky. Let me take a minute or two to explain. The way we are taught to understand development and learning in this society is totally individualistic. In the 1960s, progressives tried to address the failure of our schools to teach kids anything. They tackled the form and the content of teaching—peer and team teaching were introduced; the authoritarian teacher/student relationship was critiqued; Black Studies and culturally relevant curricula were introduced.
But none of these approaches challenged the fundamental bias inherent in the schools that all learning depends on development; as a result, we have students and teachers alike believing that you can learn only as far as you've developed. Once you've been labeled with a low I.Q., forget it! Vygotsky challenged this he said it was all wrong, all very individualistic and distorting of how social human beings really are. Learning, he said, can lead to new development. People don't stop developing at age 5, or 16, or 21, or 40, or 90—they can go all through life developing, changing, and growing.
It's our current society—not our human nature—that limits our growth and development. What is empowering about Social Therapy and social learning is that they break down these constraints and limits on our development and on the collective power that human beings have. That is what is empowering about the Barbara Taylor School, too. Its goal is to initiate and re-initiate development by teaching children how to use whatever is available to collectively break out of the roles and constraints that limit them.
Kids learn all kinds of dirty words at an astoundingly early age. But one very clean word that the powers that be consider a dirty word and that kids don't learn is class. They are sensitive to its impact, but cannot name it. When kids tease each other about where they live—for example, in a tenement, a project, or a shelter—or pick as their best friend the best dressed, they are responding to the deep class divisions of this supposedly classless American society. All of us, not just kids, make judgments instantly on meeting someone new, and what class someone represents is part of that judgment, although it's not necessarily conscious. We are allowed other identities—woman, man, Black, Latino, white, Asian, Jewish, gay, straight—but are deprived of our class identity and history.
It's important to see why and how this has evolved in the United States, and how it serves to keep working people and oppressed people impotent and underdeveloped. For once we see that there is such a thing as class, we are open to seeing that there is a class politic. We are open to seeing that the politic of the working and oppressed of the world is the politic of socialism and communism. Denying class denies this politic; it denies the need for the world view and social vision that I have been speaking about and that we have been building with at the Institute for Social Therapy and Research. Our therapy clinics, schools, medical centers, legal services, plays, boat rides, and talent shows are not just services for working people but are fundamentally different methods of treatment—representing a different class interest. They are services based totally on the needs of the working class, of oppressed peoples.
Lenora Fulani: We have been told by the powers that be that nothing good or powerful is to come out of the Harlems of this country. We do not agree. The new leadership of our country is coming from the Harlems, and we are putting our money and labor where our mouth is by building the institutions that make the expression of that leadership possible. The Harlem Institute, since 1983, has grown annually at a rate of 91%. This has led to the recently completed expansion of our therapy offices and medical clinic, and we're still growing! This month, the Community Clinics in New York City did a record breaking 35 intakes.
I can't tell you what it means to me to see Black and Latino sisters and brothers—middle class, working class, and poor—open up secrets that they've kept for years, secrets of incest, affairs, gay relationships, drug and alcohol addiction, dirty thoughts, possessions, obsessions, self hatred, self doubt, inadequacies, humiliations, and failures; to hear adults, who grew up as foster children and who were taught that anything they got was more than they deserved say, “I, too, can have something,” to hear macho men talk about homosexual relationships in their adolescence, and for the first time raise their heads as they recognize that it was the most intimate they've ever been with anyone and is not something to be ashamed of; to hear Caribbean Americans weep for the first time of their mistreatment at the hands of Black Americans; to hear Puerto Rican men and women—in English and Spanish—make demands and stop being invisible; to see the chronically ill get healthier from getting the proper dosages of compassion and ruthlessness, not drugs; to see poor Jews in the Bronx fight back against the vicious anti Semitism that says you can't be Jewish and poor; to see gay people come out, straight people loosen up, women be powerful, men struggle to be intimate, and poor people kick ass!—all from the vantage point of us, our people, our community, being empowered.
CARMEN: The greatest days of my life were when we moved through Orange County. Luis and I worked flame throwers. We torched the mansions; the smug, slick, sunken living room mansions of the California rich, the Anglos who had stolen Aztlan from us a century and a half before, who had walked tall in their cowboy boots, who had forced us into their garment shops, their electronics factories, who had forced us to pick what was now their fruit, in their fields, and huddle in shacks that they provided, who had left us to our zoot suits and low riders and took our young girls into their homes as maids, to clean for the lady of the house and to fuck for the man. Yeah, those were my glory days, Luis' glory days, when we burned them out and blew them away. I saw the ghost of Ronald Reagan slinking around in the ruins, and I laughed at him.
Pam Lewis: When Allen was talking about his aunt, I was remembering that in the very first couple of rehearsals we all tried to be superhuman, militant characters, the image of what we thought a revolutionary was supposed to be. We all tried to say our lines like a Black Panther: “I'M BETTI THE BRONX BOMBER!” Like that. Fred had to really push us to get in touch with the fear and the pain and the craziness, it was a fight in the rehearsals. If we had done it the other way, people would have been so bored. We were trying to prepare our characters so the audience could identify with communism immediately, but we tried to play stereotyped roles of what we understood revolutionaries to be, as opposed to people who were crazy and scared, which is who communists are. I'd like to share that with people, because I don't know if people know that we had that fight. I think that allowed the audience to be more conflicted, and they had to deal with us more, and be more intimate with us.
Fred Newman: There was something I said to a number of people in sharing some of my post-MMI impressions that people had a hard time with, so I want to throw it out again. I think that the way the communists in the play appeared (though obviously in a dramatic and exaggerated form) is how we, as organizers, appear to other people right now. I think that people who organize, who are political, who are progressive at this point in time, in this country, are viewed by others as profoundly crazy.
I think having to look at that raises all kinds of stuff or people—even people who have been progressive organizers or communists for a long time. I think we all have a need to see ourselves as being perceived in a certain way, but I don't think that's the way progressives are perceived, and I think it's a very valuable learning experience to have a hard look at that. I talked to a number of people, and I could see these strange looks on their faces when I raised this. I just want to throw that out.
Dan Friedman: I oversaw the improvs by dozens of groups within the political community, and then I transcribed those improvs into scenes, and then we had a meeting—Fred Newman, William Pleasant, Marian Grossman, and myself—to figure out how to make the distinction between the adventure story (which is the narration) and the dramatic scenes (the learning scenes as we call them). I said, “They should be very stark, all in gray, intensely lit; it should feel like a pressure cooker,” and Fred said, “Yeah, all that good. But the communist characters should all be insane.” I said, “What?” But I found when I went home to write it that I understood the craziness of all those characters. I wrote those scenes in record time.
But acting them was a different matter. I found it was really hard to do my character, Ira, crazy. Like most of the other actors, I was “acting crazy” by acting angry. Then one night in rehearsal, Fred said, “Dan, you know that crazy little laugh you have sometimes…?” That was the key to Ira s craziness. But I had a hard time sustaining it, particularly in the introductory monologue where I say, “I'm from a radical Jewish trade-union family.” I wanted the audience to like that character and to respect him, not to think he was a lunatic.
Finally, between the final dress rehearsal in the afternoon and the performance that evening, I had a discussion with Gloria Strickland, who played Carmen, and what she was saying was how excited she was to be in the show because it was a way she could directly serve the class. When she said that I thought, “That's right. I've got to be crazy for the working class tonight—that's what I have to be.” But I was really fighting against every instinct of mine. The highlight of the night for me was when I said to Betti, “You had a breakdown? What do you think the rest of us are, sane?” And the audience laughed! People saw me afterwards and said, “I was so relieved to find out that you knew it!” That was a real turning point for the audience, in terms of being able to go with us as communists. “Okay—they're crazy, but they know it.”
BETTI: Grace was just comforting me. If I kissed her, it was because I needed to. I needed to calm down. I had gone crazy.
IRA: You had gone crazy? What do you think the rest of us are, sane? In case you haven't noticed, I'm stark raving mad! Have you ever listened to Hanif? He talks about his father as if he were still alive! Carmen sees ghosts. Doesn't that strike you as just a little bit crazy; and what about Eddy B. there? He was a crazy motherfucker! He was the mad dog, remember? Every one of us is a lunatic, Betti. What else could we be? We're destroying the old reality and we haven't built the new one yet. You've got to be crazy to make a revolution. But insane or not, we stay on guard duty!
Pam Lewis: Along those lines—I remember how people told me afterwards that they really wanted me to stop moving around and saying everything twice. It made them nervous. One thing I experienced as a performer on the stage was the conflictedness of the audience. We've talked about how nowhere else would you have these different kinds of people in the audience—Black working class, white working class, Latino working class, Black middle class, white middle class, Latino middle class—all these people in the audience sitting next to each other, and the White Fathers would say things and some people would laugh at them. If a white person laughed, the Black person sitting next to him might say, “What the fuck are you laughing at?” I really experienced the conflictedness of the audience and I could hear people I knew laughing and being conflicted. I could literally hear the laughing going, “HA, HA, HA … ha, ha … ha…” You could really hear that! There was a Black man up front who literally laughed at everything Dorn, the leader of the White Fathers, said. Everything, until he said, “We'll make Blacks want to be slaves.”
Fred Newman: There was a lot of stuff going on in the audience. It sounded like a Yankee/Red Sox game! I think it's a very conflicted experience, watching people being crazy—people who are dedicated, caring, giving things, moving, but also hopelessly idealistic. I think the experience people have, specifically in this national sector, is, “Why would you be doing something that's hopeless?” People associate tremendous commitment to something that is hopeless with insanity. That's almost a working definition of insanity. If you work morning, noon, and night to do something that's hopeless, people say, “You must be crazy!”
I think people are socialized to perceive that. The U.S. government has spent millions and millions of dollars to do studies on how revolutionaries are crazy. They treat revolution as a form of mass insanity. A lot of so called academic leftists get grant money to study the relationship between insanity and revolutionary activity. For me, it was incredibly important to put that right up in front of everybody. In directing, I found it very hard. The rehearsals were really a wipe out.
CARMEN: That dude over there is a man and he's Jewish and I'm Chicana and Beth's Black and you're lesbian, and the White Fathers don't care about the subtle differences one fucking bit. To them we are all red. And you know what, comrade? They're right about that. We're red. That's all that history will record where we stood on this fight. Not your fight with the labor aristocracy, not Hanif's fight with European culture; not nothing but that we did in the fight to save the human race; socialism or barbarism—life or death; that's it.
Fred Newman: I had a great year this year. I learned a lot about culture. My dear friends, my comrades, my colleagues—there're too many to name but they're sitting all around the auditorium—I want to publicly thank all of you for teaching me about culture. I think we tend to regard culture as simply a poem, or a play, or some music, as something that just entertains us. But culture is much more powerful than that. Culture is about teaching us how to see, and if we let the people who control culture in this country teach us how to see, we're going to see how they want us to see instead of seeing what we need to see. Culture is about the reorganization of seeing—how to see, how to look, how to understand, how to actually visualize differently.
Some people say, “Well, how could that be? Don't we just look out and see whatever is there? Isn't seeing a natural kind of thing?” No, it's not. There's nothing natural about it. We are socialized to see what they want us to see—unless we create our own culture so that we can see as we want to see, which is what we're doing at the Otto Rene Castillo Center for Working Class Culture.
Eva Brenner: For me, from Gold to Platinum represents a real advance. It represents a summation of the work that's gone into the Cultural Department in the last 9 months, and in another way, the play itself represents a change. If the people see a popular story that they can get into, they are going to start to demand more of it.
I kept raising over and over again, “How come we're doing it this way, we only have 3 week to put this together!” and Fred said, “The issue isn't doing it right, but doing it.” It's a fight that has been going on in the Cultural Department; a fight between the primacy of aesthetics or the primacy of politics, and I think it has to be brought out more into the open. We did what needed to be done, and we did it together instead of criticizing each other all along the way. Politics won this battle.
Roger Grunwald: In your talk, Fred, you said that culture is a way to make people see better or differently. One of the feelings that I had during the show was that I got a better sense of myself as an artist … I've never had an opportunity to be an artist and an organizer at the same time, and I got a real sense of being part of this organizing tool to help people to see. I don't know what it did to my performance, but I think there was something there. There's something different going on for you as an actor when you're apart of something that's helping to change things. It's a new feeling for me.
Tom Drumgold: As an actor I have a lot of friends from the theater and I told them I was going to be doing this and they said, “It's about what? You're playing a fascist?” The first question for an actor is always, “Are you going to get paid?” Then after you tell them what you almost always tell them—“No, I'm not,”—they say, “Well, what are you doing it for? Are you going to get agents to come to see you?” There is political theater in this city, but not very much of it, and artists don't see much point in doing it. So they do think you're crazy.
Fred Newman: What we are trying to do, and what I think we did successfully, was to openly caricature sanity. The fascists were sane. They were kind of the ultimate, sane Americans. It was like stripping away the veneer of liberalism, even conservatism, and saying, “Here's good old fashioned, American logic.” In one of the scenes, there's an interplay about how fucking people over is the American way.
MASTER GENERAL DORN: You just don't realize who you are. You are a White Father, a founder of the Aryan Nation of North America. Think about it: a pure white America. There'll be nothing to hold us back. All the commies we find we'll murder. Some real white folks [will] have to be sacrificed too—they were red dupes. But Jews, niggers, and spics—watch out. The Jews go with the commies—every mother's son. I mean that, you two. If a man's got one drop of Jew blood then he goes to the gallows. As for the Blacks, we kill all the worthless ones—that's kids and old ones. There are a lot of smart Negroes too, educated ones. We won't need them either. The rest—the bucks and the bitches—we put to work until they drop. They'll wish they were slaves when we get our hands on them. Give this program about 10 years and America will be pure as snow.
TRENK: After that, we can take on the world.
DORN: And our great grand kids will sing about us as the white men who wiped communism off the face of the earth.
WHITWORTH: It's a pretty picture, but I'm worried about right now. What if the Russkies and the rest decide to intervene in the civil war after we get the bombs?
DORN: Then that'll just be the end of the world—just put it like that. High stakes today, white men. You got the balls?
TRENK: What the fuck, huh?
DORN: That's the spirit that made America great!
Fred Newman: The audience really responded to that. “Goddamit, that's right; that s the essence of the American way!” The fascists came off much more rational and sane than the communists. They showed a kind of consistency with the reality of what America is. There was a way in which—and I think we intended for this to happen—a significant element of the audience could relate much more easily to the fascists than to the communists. The communists were really tough to relate to. They were out of their minds! The fascists even seemed to be much closer to each other a sort of buddy buddyness that was vulgar and foul, but did show a certain kind of togetherness that was rather lacking among the communists—until their social practice brought them together. I was thinking about that quote from Marx where he says that the process of working class revolution goes from defeat to defeat to defeat—to ultimate victory. I was very self conscious of that as we were doing the play.
IRA: Never a straight line. History never moves in a straight line. It zig-zags. History moves like a drunkard. It staggers, it lurches, it stands still for a moment, frying to focus. What we're in now is a zig, or maybe a zag. It's no end. This doesn't mean the end. Was Auschwitz the end? Was Leningrad the end? Was Soweto the end? What end? What are we talking about an end for? We're too close to talk about losing. We're so close we can smell it—it smells a little bit like fresh coffee early in the morning. We're so close we can hear it singing. Do you hear it? It's singing out in the woods. We're so close we can feel it breathing next to us at night as we sleep. We're that close. That close to ending the 5,000 year old nightmare. Ending class society. Ending poverty. Ending all the pain. It's as close as Omaha. As close as those gas tanks.
Fred Newman: What people saw on that stage—simply in terms of a grouping of white actors up there and primarily Black actors down here, in a way that was interactive—was a profoundly conflicted aesthetic experience also. Because ordinarily you can see plays that are primarily white with one or two Black actors, but it's obviously a white theater. On the other hand, you can see Black theater, which might sometimes include someone who's white. But the notion of seeing the stage set up as we did as that kind of conflict—I think that raised tremendous issues for people in the audience.
Some people were strongly identified with feminist or nationalist elements of the politics, and were really getting into that and then they suddenly realized that they'd come with this other person who was upset by their reactions: “Wait a minute—when we go out for coffee later, this might be a tough discussion.”
One of the things that was interesting to me was how many people talked about having a hard time with the violence. I found that really striking in view of the fact that there was shockingly little violence in the play. At one level, the first 5 minutes of almost any television show that you see had more violence in it than that entire play. I think that people were actually responding to the conflictedness and calling it violence. Their way of covering that was to identify the conflictedness, in some way, as violence.
Lois Holzman: I recently got a very moving letter from a dear comrade I met on my trip to the Soviet Union. We've kept in touch these past 6 years and he's kept up to date on the growth of our political community. Let me share what my friend and your friend Sasha had to say about the significance of our work: “The growth of the Institute for Social Therapy and Research is the basis for optimism and hope. In spite of Reaganism, neo conservatism, and world pessimism, there are some forces on the planet that are strong and healthy. I think that the nations of the world are sometimes in need of Social Therapy on a global scale.” A simple yet profound recognition of the vitality of Marxism—that here in the belly of the beast, “our lives, our history, our language must shape it.”
Marian Grossman: Ricky Flores and I did the first improv session in the Bronx with the Bronx Healthy Club. I remember feeling very nervous and sort of defensive. On my way there on the train, I was thinking of the worst scenarios—that I was going to read the play and people were going to say, “Oh my God, what is this communist stuff?” What we did was lay out the scenario up to the scene we were going to work on, and it was a wonderful experience to watch the people in the room, who were predominantly working-class Black women in their 40s and 50s, start to smile at the parts about the Army of the Poor taking over. That experience organized me. I realized that the class was ahead of me, that I was much more conservative than these working class women, and that people really wanted this vision of the future. When Pam and I went to Reverend Harvin's church, it was the same thing. We got up there and Pam said she was the Bolshevik Bronx Bomber, and she got a huge round of applause! That was without any lights, sound or costumes. That was just the idea of an American revolution!
Lenora Fulani: We are about communism, class, culture, and community. Over the past several months, we have been discussing these matters at Institute staff meetings. We have been asking each other about the social vision that guides, inspires, and informs us, in our day-to-day work from Harlem to East Los Angeles, from Jackson, Mississippi to Boston, Massachusetts. Because that vision, that class vision, that community vision—yes, that communist vision—that new way of seeing, is no abstraction. It is a moving, vital force everywhere we go. We talked about a future America and how it would come about. I knew I would not be there to see it, but it did not matter because it would be ours.
Bill Pleasant: I thought it would be important to do the play in a way that people could take on their fantasies. When I go to sleep at night, the first dreams I have are revolutionary dreams—striking back at Reagan and things like that. I know that everybody has those dreams, in one way or another. I wanted to take those dreams, that rage—you know, just when you're going to sleep and you're thinking, “I'll get those motherfuckers!” and say, “Okay, now I can see it.” I think that's extremely explosive, because we have the tactic to actually organize it.
Dan Friedman: An important aspect of the play was the collective fantasy aspect. Do you know half the people I meet now call me “Ira?” The day before MMI, of course, I was a nervous wreck and I ran into Ed Costa. He said, “What's the matter?” I said, “Oh, I'm just nervous about tomorrow.” He said, “You shouldn't be thinking about tomorrow, you should be thinking about 3 years from now when you're in Madison Square Garden. You know, Fred is always talking about how the fascists in Europe were able to organize people culturally and give them a vision, and the Left wasn't. It's going to be this very exciting revolutionary vision that the working class is going to be really excited about.” We have all shared this collective fantasy, and so have 600 other people. And I think that gives us a sense of community and makes that social vision all the more real.
Fred Newman: It's very important to not get into thinking that the play represents some kind of homogeneous statement of the broader political community, or even of the whole working class. In fact, what's most exciting about the play is that it continues to live as an element of a very complex and contradictory community experience. That means that people will say, “I can go to the Barbara Taylor School—no problem at all—but I can't touch From Gold to Platinum.” Some people will say, “This is great therapy, I'm getting a lot of help, but that play was very tough.” The play is, in fact, an extension of the poles around which we evolve the contradiction of political community. If you start to look upon the play in an overstated way, as a “consolidation” piece, you actually rob us of what's most significant about the play. That's exactly what it wasn't. It was designed to be provocative, and it was.
If what we wanted to do was consolidate the whole community, we wouldn't present that program. There's a whole other program you can present to do that job. But it is not our concern, culturally, to consolidate—our concern is to be provocative, to provide a certain political pole to intensify and deepen the dynamic of the contradictions. Don't throw that out! That's why the play was so powerful—because it raised so much. I think that some of the people who probably had the most extraordinary experiences were the hundred who left! They walked out into the street saying, “Gee, I really like working with those folks, they're nice people but what the hell was that?”
That's what I think was significant about it, and that's what I think is significant about a great deal of the cultural work that we're doing. It forces the issue. It forces us to extend beyond the very narrow tunnel vision that people want to have relative to some of the things that we're doing across the city and across the country. The political situation in America today is contradictory. On the one hand, people feel the pull to support that which is progressive, but they also feel incredibly cynical. People say: “You're crazy, it's hopeless, a waste of time. I'm sorry you rang my bell today. All you're doing is making me feel guilty—now I'll have to go for three more sessions this week because I feel more guilty than ever, seeing you out there ringing doorbells when I haven't done anything in 10 years. That makes me feel terrible!” That's about where three fourths of the population of this country is at.
Dan Friedman: One middle class woman said to me, “The bottom line is: I don't trust communists. But you people are the best organizers and the best human beings I've ever met. I have to go with that.”
Fred Newman: Right—that's until she doesn't, and you have to remember that. It's a process, a pulsating, social/political process.
Lois Holzman: For those in power, science is a conservative method for discovering such truths as keep them in power. For those of us not in power, we must see that our lives, our children's lives, our neighbors' lives, our friends' lives, the life of our people, the life of our class, depend on a new science for discovering such truths as change the world and place the disempowered in power. When our children are sick, we must ask not how can we make them healthy consistent with keeping Ronald Reagan and his profiteering friends in power. We must rather ask: How do we make our children healthy? We must use all that is available to empower our people. And if the fear of a word—of the word “communism”—keeps us from helping our children to be healthy, then we must overcome that fear. For our class has nothing to fear from communism. Mr. Reagan and his wealthy friends have much to fear. I hope they are frightened to death.
This is a documentary on “After the Revolution,” the tenth annual Marxism and Mental Illness event (MMI) of the Institute for Social Therapy and Research, which took place in New York city on June 28, 1986. It excerpts the keynote talks of Dr. Lenora Fulani, Dr. Lois Holzman, and Dr. Fred Newman of the Institute's Board of directors [and indented] dialogue from the play From Gold to Platinum, which was the centerpiece of the event; and a post-production discussion of the play by the writers, directors, actors, producers, and production staff.
Lois Holzman: This past Thursday the U.S. House of Representatives approved $100 million in military aid to the counter-revolutionary forces working to overthrow the democratically elected, socialist led, progressive government of Nicaragua to murder innocent people. Although I was not surprised, I had many emotions when I heard this news. First, I was furious. I was worried about our brothers and sisters in Nicaragua, who have had to put all their energy, brains, money, and time into defending their revolution, at the expense of rebuilding their country. I was ashamed to be associated with the ugly, arrogant, macho United States. And, I was proud to be a communist.
I am aware that whenever I say the word “communism” people begin to squirm a little. And we must understand why; because a major reason why this anti-human, undemocratic, and vicious contra aid bill passed is how afraid our people are of that word—communism. It's a very loaded term a code word, a symbol—but even more, the word communism functions for the powers that be like a cattle prod—it shocks our people into acquiescence. Why should our intellectual yearnings, our cultural curiosity; our search for humane solutions to the practical problems of our lives end at the U.S. border? Why must they be suspiciously and forcefully checked? Why are we not allowed to learn from the people of Africa, Asia, and Latin America who are using Marxism and communism to eliminate hunger and illiteracy—who are using Marxism and communism to build hospitals, schools, and cultural centers in the towns of their countries?
The bourgeois media in this country work overtime to have us believe that there are worlds of difference between the wants, needs, and desires of Americans and those of our neighbors; that we are more advanced than they are; that we are superior to them; that Marxism and communism are for inferior people. What kind of ideology thwarts our natural inclination to seek out what is common, what is shared, our natural desire for internationalism? What kind of ideology maliciously thwarts as in the case of the blood-thirsty U.S. press coverage of the tragedy of Chernobyl—our natural need, quite simply, to care? It is an ideology of the rich, the powerful, the greedy—not an ideology of the broad masses of our people.
But let's not be fooled by a word; let's look under, behind, in, around, and through the word at what communism really is. Communism is a system of living, of societal organization—of economics, psychology, teaching, learning, working, playing, shopping, eating, sleeping, and loving—that is not based on the exploitation of one person for the benefit of another. This doesn't mean it's perfect, heaven, utopia, or nirvana. Communist and socialist societies are as imperfect as human beings are fallible. But communist society doesn't depend for its very economic existence on exploitation, oppression, profits, or scarcity in the way that U.S. society does. In a communist society, such things are treated as serious problems, not as normal human behavior.
The Institute for Social Therapy and Research has put this tool of working people—the science of Marxism—to work in America's inner cities—practically and actively—to solve the critical problems of illness, madness, poverty, and illiteracy. Is it working? Growing from 20 patients in Social Therapy on Manhattan's Upper West Side in 1978 to 500 patients in Social Therapy all over the country in 1986 says it's working; a 600% growth in gross income over 8 years to a projected annual revenue of $964,717 in 1986 says it's working; 1,475 members of Healthy Clubs in New York, Boston and Philadelphia says it's working; the 6,425 people who have come to the Castillo Center for theater and gallery events and parties says it's working; and the 38 children who attended the newly opened Barbara Taylor School this year and the 2 who just graduated says it's working.
Dan Friedman: As a performer, I know that the audience listened and responded to every line in a way that most audiences never do. People laughed and clapped in a way that showed a real connection with what was going on; they were really paying attention. I'm told that 100 people walked out, which means that 600 stayed, which sounds like a great percentage. The other way I know about how the audience responded was that we talked to them. The night after the performance, I was talking to two women from Jackson, Mississippi, one of whom is middle class, the other a tool and dye maker.
The middle-class woman stayed up the whole night, she was so upset by the violence, and the class polarization. But she wanted to talk about it. What she wanted to talk about was what her role would be in the revolution, if there could be a place for her. I said, “You heard it in the last line of the play—it's not your pedigree that counts, it's your politics!” She was very pleased to hear that again.
The other woman, the white working class woman, was so moved by the play and so enthusiastic, it blew me away. It gave me a sense of how we are actually out organizing, and the class is responding to it, to that play. Other things that happened were among our own organizers. For example: Nancy Hanks, a NAP organizer in Philadelphia, called up and read me a poem about her own life and how it related to MMI. People are talking about how they were moved and agitated and upset and inspired.
Fred Newman: We're talking about a new social vision. In point of fact, it's impossible to do the kinds of things that we do every day of the week in Harlem, in East New York, in East Los Angeles, in Jackson, Mississippi, and all over the country without a social vision. We're not simply about helping our children to be healthy just so this society can make them sick again. We're not about educating our children so they can live in a society that denies them the opportunity to use their learning and creativity. We're not about simply providing services in order to make it easier on the people in City Hall, in Albany, and in Washington, who would like nothing better than to get away without providing any services to poor people. We provide those services because we and you, our children and friends, have a social vision, and we intend to build and service and work every day until that social vision is realized. That's what we're about.
Lois Holzman: Let me share with you a personal experience. In 1980, I spent 3 months living in the Soviet Union. I was an exchange psychologist from Rockefeller University, where I had been doing research in education and psychology.
At the time I went I was not very politically sophisticated. In my naiveté, and in a typical American exceptionalist manner, I felt at first that I was “more political” than a lot of the Soviet citizens I met. I expected that they would speak about politics all the time. What I quickly came to realize was that progressive politics was totally integrated into the lives of the Soviet people; they grew up politically progressive; it came to them naturally. I saw a society that was run very differently from our society—it's a society organized for the benefit of, and from the vantage point of, the working class.
People were very open, and when they spoke about what was wrong with how things worked in their country and they spoke about these matters very passionately—they did it not from the perspective of the individual, but from the perspective of how to get the most for the most people. It was a striking contrast to how our society teaches us to understand and talk about what's wrong here in the United States—to say I can't get a job; I can't get ahead; I don't have what I need to live; I can't make it.
The other Americans who were studying or working in the Soviet Union would insist on making a separation between the personalities of the people they met and the conditions under which they lived. In other words, they loved the Russian people, but hated their society. These brainwashed Americans never asked themselves how the Russian people got to be the way they are; they never seemed to make the connection between the Soviets' caring, their concern for peace, their friendliness, and the society they lived in—the society that they produced and that produced them. They could not see that they had a different understanding of the world and a different approach to solving problems and getting things done.
In the Soviet Union I saw schools that are organized to teach kids as much as they can, because their talents, skills, and productivity are needed to build the country. I saw a system organized with the needs of the total person in mind—with factories that included day care centers, theaters, libraries, and schools. I saw the handicapped trained and treated as productive and contributing members of society. I saw at work a way of approaching life that is profoundly different, so that even the most common experiences are not the same, even something as common and seemingly universal as standing on a line. Shopping lines, movie lines, subway lines, bus lines—they are as long, if not longer, in Moscow as in New York. But is the line the same? Is it the same experience (does it have the same social meaning) to wait in line 15 minutes to buy meat for dinner in New York as it is in Moscow?
In New York the line exists as part of a system to increase profits for the owners. Our frustration and anger as we wait is not just in our heads—it's a real outgrowth of the antagonistic relationship between us—workers and consumers—and them—owners and profiteers. In Moscow, the line exists as part of a system that is designed and committed not to making profit for a few, but to eliminating scarcity and feeding everyone. And that requires the collective participation of every citizen in the effort. The felt experience of waiting on line in Moscow is very different—it may not be pleasant, but it is not antagonistic.
Fred Newman: Several years ago, I gave a talk at that forum called “The Psychology of Communism.” As a result of that talk, I got a phone call from a guy named Bob Lassiter in Tampa, Florida, who has an afternoon radio talk show. He called me up and he said, “I heard about your ‘Psychology of Communism' talk. How would you like to be on the air and answer questions about communism? You be in New York, and I'll call you up and people will call in with questions for a couple of hours. And I'll make you one guarantee—if anybody gets really hostile, I'll shut them up.” So I said, “Don't shut anybody up, I'm down for whatever people want to raise, just let them call—it'll be great!”
On the first two hour show, Lassiter, who's a nice, liberal sort of fellow, gets on the phone and says, “Before we begin, I have a question for you, Dr. Newman. Why do you call yourself a communist? You seem like a bright fellow. Don't you appreciate that people would be less offended if you didn't use that word? Why don't you put out your ideas and not say that you're a communist?” I said, “Well, Bob, I think that's a good question. There are many reasons I call myself a communist, but the first reason is that if I didn't, everyone else would. All you've got to say is you believe that the people of Harlem should come before people getting rich and someone will call you a communist. If you say that people have a right to a job or that they have a right to decent health care, someone will call you a communist. But I'll confess that I also do it for another reason: I do it because I like to shake you up.”
I think it's very important to teach people that we can no longer afford to be brainwashed, to cringe with fear, as Lois was saying, when we hear that word. So we did the show and some people were hostile and some were friendly, and Bob Lassiter kept calling me back month after month to do more shows. In fact, he now speaks of me—I'm on again in 2 weeks—as “the resident communist.” I'm the resident communist of Tampa, Florida—can you believe it? That's mind boggling!
Eva Brenner: I have many things to say, but the overriding experience that I and many other people had from being involved in this event is a feeling that revolution is really possible. A lot of people who were there had never heard of us, but saw the flyer on the street, and my sense was that we created a sense of “maybe this is possible.” If it did that, I think it was very successful. My roommate was talking about her political development and she said, “I really want to come out more as a leader, like Betti from the Bronx [a character in the play].”
It felt like people were treating these folks on the stage like they were comrades, everyday friends. That changed a lot of my perceptions of what characters are. In the avant-garde where I come from, people watch at a great distance and are not really being there with you. It raised a lot of things about identifying with someone, but identifying in a totally different way than the bourgeois way, where you identify with these petty emotions that are very uninteresting and actually detract from a historical view of reality. The play accomplished a lot on that level.
Tom D.: I think, just on a pure feeling level, it was really an enormous success. At the end, the joy of people on and off the stage, the level of energy, was just tremendous. I've experienced that feeling maybe two or three times in my life. People were floating.
SARAH: It's funny. When I was in college we used to go to the demonstrations supporting the revolutions in South Africa and the Congo and Mexico and we used to wonder if it could ever happen here. If we could win one here, we'd be winning for all the other revolutions around the world. If not, it was dear, even back then, that the capitalists would blow the world away. And then we did it. We made a revolution. I still find it hard to let that in.
Lois Holzman: Each year, as we at the Institute apply Marxism to mental illness, stress, cancer, homophobia, racism and ethnic divisions, illiteracy, sexuality, unemployment, drug addiction, and many other crises and problems of everyday living, welcome to a deeper understanding and appreciation of the relevancy of Marxism and the power of this different world view.
Lenora Fulani: In 1986, the Harlem Institute for Social Therapy and Research, located on 125th Street and Seventh Avenue in the landmark Theresa Hotel, serves as a model in its practice of medicine and therapy of how to build among the Black, Latino, Jewish, gay, and oppressed populations of this country a deeply needed, deeply missed, most inclusive, and dramatically empowering sense of community. And this community is not just any old community. The right wing in this country teaches a sense of community based on a thinly veiled message of deep and awesome hatred of the oppressed. Our community is based on the power of and love for the oppressed.
What is taken out as the Harlem Institute in a form that is powerfully and passionately digestible is a sense of community based on our social vision, with a growing recognition that building a sense of community for the liberation of oppressed peoples in this country means going all the way.
This sense of community is not new to people of color. African American historians teach us of African communalism, the collective spirit that dominated the work and lifestyles of our people before the European raping of the African continent; a spirit that has been profoundly visible in the struggles of our people in contemporary Namibia, Zimbabwe, Angola, Mozambique, the Congo, and South Africa as they shape African communalism into a tool of socialism and communism in their fight for liberation and freedom. It is a spirit, a vision, a sense that appeared time and time again in the struggles led by Martin, Malcolm, and the Black Panthers. It is raising its head again in the response of our people—people of color, Jews, gays, progressives in the community of independent institutions of which the Institute for Social Therapy and Research is proud to be a part.
America has deprived its people of a sense of community. A sense of community, like a sense of history, has always been denied to the people of this country by the people who run it. Black folks are denigrated as a people who don't stick together; Blacks and Latinos and Asians as people who can't unite because we come from different cultures; and Jews as people who do stick together, but only for themselves. The truth is that those who rule this country have spent millions of dollars and millions of conniving hours murdering grassroots movements, leaders, and peoples, and doing all they can to destroy our sense of community, solidarity, and history.
Allen Cox: One thing I really enjoyed as a performer was the audience's support. It allowed me to come out more. Not only the people that I know through the political community—but my aunt was there and told me that she took a friend with her and they stayed through the whole show. She said her friend called her up and said, “Oh, you hanging out with the commies, huh?” But they laughed about it and my aunt said she really enjoyed it. She said she took pride in how well I had done, and she enjoyed other folks too. It gave me an opportunity to talk about communism in a way that I haven't been able to even begin talking about it before with her.
Fred Newman: That is, for me, one of the really important things about the whole play. I'm very interested in making it possible for people to even hear the word “communism” and associate it with some of the more ordinary things, like people being conflicted, happy, sad … so at least you can get a foot in the door, you can talk about it. No small part of what's problematic about organizing in this national sector is you can't even get past the word, it has such incredible connotations. One thing I was concerned to do was really break that down. I thought that was powerful. Some people were really polarized around it, because they don't want to hear the word. But in a sense, it makes the word human. Here's a person who's really human—and a communist. That's very heavy, in an American theater and in American life.
Lois Holzman: Look around you. Virtually all of us here tonight have been touched by Marxism—some a lot, some a little, some for a long time, some just recently. Our community is evidence of its usability in contemporary America. Tens of thousands of people experience daily what we've built. Social Therapy is available in clinics from Boston to Denver, from Jackson, Mississippi to Los Angeles. The Harlem Institute has doubled in size this year, as Black people in that community, together with gay people, women, and Latinos, have claimed Social Therapy as their tool for empowerment. Thousands of people have come to the Institute's Castillo Cultural Center's events and thousands more have participated in Musicruises on the Hudson River and talent shows we help to produce. Hundreds have taken classes at the Jackson Luxemburg School and visited our medical clinics.
Lenora Fulani: How do we build this sense of community, based on our progressive social vision, in our day to day practice at the Institute for Social Therapy and Research? One way is in our use of Social Therapy, a drug free, group oriented approach to the treatment of emotional problems that is also steeped in a recognition that our problems—mental illness and the emotional stresses of our lives—are social in their origin.
Social Therapy is an empowerment therapy that we use to create an environment where people can come to know who they actually are. I remember when I first began practicing at the Harlem Institute, I was taken aback that poor people and addicted people in our Medicaid groups would come in with descriptions and misunderstandings of themselves and their problems that were straight out of Reagan's mouth; the Black and Latino professional middle class would come in with understandings from Ozzie and Harriet and the Cosbys and would ask, “Why me?” as if they were not also Black and Latino; and gay people would display no sense of having made a radical move that seriously challenges some oppressive institutions of this society.
The power of Social Therapy is that people—poor, working class people, middle class people, people of color—are pushed to work on their emotional problems as who they are in the world, not as isolated and alienated Freudian ids, egos, and super egos, but as people with histories. It is this process that has led to the growth of our clinics, and this process goes along, long way in creating a sense of community.
BETTI: if we lose this one, we lose the Bronx again. The Bronx was capitalism in sick decay. We were left to rot, to starve—to kill each other. We were left to die by the capitalist motherfuckers. But we didn't die and we didn't kill each other. We organized. And then it was our time to let them die. And we did. So now they want it back. They want to rule over the decay of western civilization. Let them rule over hell.
Lois Holzman: Of all the profound and extraordinary achievements we've seen in this past year of growth, I want to share with you the significance of the Barbara Taylor School, which opened in September of 1985 in Harlem, because this school can be understood as a synthesis of all that the Institute is doing. At the Barbara Taylor School, young people—our future—are treated not as individuals who must compete for knowledge, nor as individuals whose limited store of development and promise will taper off somewhere in their early teens. They are not treated as victims—poor, Black and Latino youngsters who, as “disadvantaged” and “deprived” (to use some other oppressive words of the powers that be), need a supportive environment to “to catch up” to their white, middle-class peers. The students at the Barbara Taylor School, ages 3-13, are into some very serious business. They are participating in a bold experiment in education. They are being trained to be leaders—all of them, not just the best or the brightest—in liberating themselves, their families, and their communities from the racism and classism of this country that keeps them “remedial.” They are participating in learning and developing in the way they must if they are to change the world into a place for them and their communities to grow.
All of the advances of radical and Marxist psychology and pedagogy are being brought to bear on the building of the Barbara Taylor School. Especially useful are the brilliant insights of the Soviet psychologist, Lev Vygotsky. Let me take a minute or two to explain. The way we are taught to understand development and learning in this society is totally individualistic. In the 1960s, progressives tried to address the failure of our schools to teach kids anything. They tackled the form and the content of teaching—peer and team teaching were introduced; the authoritarian teacher/student relationship was critiqued; Black Studies and culturally relevant curricula were introduced.
But none of these approaches challenged the fundamental bias inherent in the schools that all learning depends on development; as a result, we have students and teachers alike believing that you can learn only as far as you've developed. Once you've been labeled with a low I.Q., forget it! Vygotsky challenged this he said it was all wrong, all very individualistic and distorting of how social human beings really are. Learning, he said, can lead to new development. People don't stop developing at age 5, or 16, or 21, or 40, or 90—they can go all through life developing, changing, and growing.
It's our current society—not our human nature—that limits our growth and development. What is empowering about Social Therapy and social learning is that they break down these constraints and limits on our development and on the collective power that human beings have. That is what is empowering about the Barbara Taylor School, too. Its goal is to initiate and re-initiate development by teaching children how to use whatever is available to collectively break out of the roles and constraints that limit them.
Kids learn all kinds of dirty words at an astoundingly early age. But one very clean word that the powers that be consider a dirty word and that kids don't learn is class. They are sensitive to its impact, but cannot name it. When kids tease each other about where they live—for example, in a tenement, a project, or a shelter—or pick as their best friend the best dressed, they are responding to the deep class divisions of this supposedly classless American society. All of us, not just kids, make judgments instantly on meeting someone new, and what class someone represents is part of that judgment, although it's not necessarily conscious. We are allowed other identities—woman, man, Black, Latino, white, Asian, Jewish, gay, straight—but are deprived of our class identity and history.
It's important to see why and how this has evolved in the United States, and how it serves to keep working people and oppressed people impotent and underdeveloped. For once we see that there is such a thing as class, we are open to seeing that there is a class politic. We are open to seeing that the politic of the working and oppressed of the world is the politic of socialism and communism. Denying class denies this politic; it denies the need for the world view and social vision that I have been speaking about and that we have been building with at the Institute for Social Therapy and Research. Our therapy clinics, schools, medical centers, legal services, plays, boat rides, and talent shows are not just services for working people but are fundamentally different methods of treatment—representing a different class interest. They are services based totally on the needs of the working class, of oppressed peoples.
Lenora Fulani: We have been told by the powers that be that nothing good or powerful is to come out of the Harlems of this country. We do not agree. The new leadership of our country is coming from the Harlems, and we are putting our money and labor where our mouth is by building the institutions that make the expression of that leadership possible. The Harlem Institute, since 1983, has grown annually at a rate of 91%. This has led to the recently completed expansion of our therapy offices and medical clinic, and we're still growing! This month, the Community Clinics in New York City did a record breaking 35 intakes.
I can't tell you what it means to me to see Black and Latino sisters and brothers—middle class, working class, and poor—open up secrets that they've kept for years, secrets of incest, affairs, gay relationships, drug and alcohol addiction, dirty thoughts, possessions, obsessions, self hatred, self doubt, inadequacies, humiliations, and failures; to hear adults, who grew up as foster children and who were taught that anything they got was more than they deserved say, “I, too, can have something,” to hear macho men talk about homosexual relationships in their adolescence, and for the first time raise their heads as they recognize that it was the most intimate they've ever been with anyone and is not something to be ashamed of; to hear Caribbean Americans weep for the first time of their mistreatment at the hands of Black Americans; to hear Puerto Rican men and women—in English and Spanish—make demands and stop being invisible; to see the chronically ill get healthier from getting the proper dosages of compassion and ruthlessness, not drugs; to see poor Jews in the Bronx fight back against the vicious anti Semitism that says you can't be Jewish and poor; to see gay people come out, straight people loosen up, women be powerful, men struggle to be intimate, and poor people kick ass!—all from the vantage point of us, our people, our community, being empowered.
CARMEN: The greatest days of my life were when we moved through Orange County. Luis and I worked flame throwers. We torched the mansions; the smug, slick, sunken living room mansions of the California rich, the Anglos who had stolen Aztlan from us a century and a half before, who had walked tall in their cowboy boots, who had forced us into their garment shops, their electronics factories, who had forced us to pick what was now their fruit, in their fields, and huddle in shacks that they provided, who had left us to our zoot suits and low riders and took our young girls into their homes as maids, to clean for the lady of the house and to fuck for the man. Yeah, those were my glory days, Luis' glory days, when we burned them out and blew them away. I saw the ghost of Ronald Reagan slinking around in the ruins, and I laughed at him.
Pam Lewis: When Allen was talking about his aunt, I was remembering that in the very first couple of rehearsals we all tried to be superhuman, militant characters, the image of what we thought a revolutionary was supposed to be. We all tried to say our lines like a Black Panther: “I'M BETTI THE BRONX BOMBER!” Like that. Fred had to really push us to get in touch with the fear and the pain and the craziness, it was a fight in the rehearsals. If we had done it the other way, people would have been so bored. We were trying to prepare our characters so the audience could identify with communism immediately, but we tried to play stereotyped roles of what we understood revolutionaries to be, as opposed to people who were crazy and scared, which is who communists are. I'd like to share that with people, because I don't know if people know that we had that fight. I think that allowed the audience to be more conflicted, and they had to deal with us more, and be more intimate with us.
Fred Newman: There was something I said to a number of people in sharing some of my post-MMI impressions that people had a hard time with, so I want to throw it out again. I think that the way the communists in the play appeared (though obviously in a dramatic and exaggerated form) is how we, as organizers, appear to other people right now. I think that people who organize, who are political, who are progressive at this point in time, in this country, are viewed by others as profoundly crazy.
I think having to look at that raises all kinds of stuff or people—even people who have been progressive organizers or communists for a long time. I think we all have a need to see ourselves as being perceived in a certain way, but I don't think that's the way progressives are perceived, and I think it's a very valuable learning experience to have a hard look at that. I talked to a number of people, and I could see these strange looks on their faces when I raised this. I just want to throw that out.
Dan Friedman: I oversaw the improvs by dozens of groups within the political community, and then I transcribed those improvs into scenes, and then we had a meeting—Fred Newman, William Pleasant, Marian Grossman, and myself—to figure out how to make the distinction between the adventure story (which is the narration) and the dramatic scenes (the learning scenes as we call them). I said, “They should be very stark, all in gray, intensely lit; it should feel like a pressure cooker,” and Fred said, “Yeah, all that good. But the communist characters should all be insane.” I said, “What?” But I found when I went home to write it that I understood the craziness of all those characters. I wrote those scenes in record time.
But acting them was a different matter. I found it was really hard to do my character, Ira, crazy. Like most of the other actors, I was “acting crazy” by acting angry. Then one night in rehearsal, Fred said, “Dan, you know that crazy little laugh you have sometimes…?” That was the key to Ira s craziness. But I had a hard time sustaining it, particularly in the introductory monologue where I say, “I'm from a radical Jewish trade-union family.” I wanted the audience to like that character and to respect him, not to think he was a lunatic.
Finally, between the final dress rehearsal in the afternoon and the performance that evening, I had a discussion with Gloria Strickland, who played Carmen, and what she was saying was how excited she was to be in the show because it was a way she could directly serve the class. When she said that I thought, “That's right. I've got to be crazy for the working class tonight—that's what I have to be.” But I was really fighting against every instinct of mine. The highlight of the night for me was when I said to Betti, “You had a breakdown? What do you think the rest of us are, sane?” And the audience laughed! People saw me afterwards and said, “I was so relieved to find out that you knew it!” That was a real turning point for the audience, in terms of being able to go with us as communists. “Okay—they're crazy, but they know it.”
BETTI: Grace was just comforting me. If I kissed her, it was because I needed to. I needed to calm down. I had gone crazy.
IRA: You had gone crazy? What do you think the rest of us are, sane? In case you haven't noticed, I'm stark raving mad! Have you ever listened to Hanif? He talks about his father as if he were still alive! Carmen sees ghosts. Doesn't that strike you as just a little bit crazy; and what about Eddy B. there? He was a crazy motherfucker! He was the mad dog, remember? Every one of us is a lunatic, Betti. What else could we be? We're destroying the old reality and we haven't built the new one yet. You've got to be crazy to make a revolution. But insane or not, we stay on guard duty!
Pam Lewis: Along those lines—I remember how people told me afterwards that they really wanted me to stop moving around and saying everything twice. It made them nervous. One thing I experienced as a performer on the stage was the conflictedness of the audience. We've talked about how nowhere else would you have these different kinds of people in the audience—Black working class, white working class, Latino working class, Black middle class, white middle class, Latino middle class—all these people in the audience sitting next to each other, and the White Fathers would say things and some people would laugh at them. If a white person laughed, the Black person sitting next to him might say, “What the fuck are you laughing at?” I really experienced the conflictedness of the audience and I could hear people I knew laughing and being conflicted. I could literally hear the laughing going, “HA, HA, HA … ha, ha … ha…” You could really hear that! There was a Black man up front who literally laughed at everything Dorn, the leader of the White Fathers, said. Everything, until he said, “We'll make Blacks want to be slaves.”
Fred Newman: There was a lot of stuff going on in the audience. It sounded like a Yankee/Red Sox game! I think it's a very conflicted experience, watching people being crazy—people who are dedicated, caring, giving things, moving, but also hopelessly idealistic. I think the experience people have, specifically in this national sector, is, “Why would you be doing something that's hopeless?” People associate tremendous commitment to something that is hopeless with insanity. That's almost a working definition of insanity. If you work morning, noon, and night to do something that's hopeless, people say, “You must be crazy!”
I think people are socialized to perceive that. The U.S. government has spent millions and millions of dollars to do studies on how revolutionaries are crazy. They treat revolution as a form of mass insanity. A lot of so called academic leftists get grant money to study the relationship between insanity and revolutionary activity. For me, it was incredibly important to put that right up in front of everybody. In directing, I found it very hard. The rehearsals were really a wipe out.
CARMEN: That dude over there is a man and he's Jewish and I'm Chicana and Beth's Black and you're lesbian, and the White Fathers don't care about the subtle differences one fucking bit. To them we are all red. And you know what, comrade? They're right about that. We're red. That's all that history will record where we stood on this fight. Not your fight with the labor aristocracy, not Hanif's fight with European culture; not nothing but that we did in the fight to save the human race; socialism or barbarism—life or death; that's it.
Fred Newman: I had a great year this year. I learned a lot about culture. My dear friends, my comrades, my colleagues—there're too many to name but they're sitting all around the auditorium—I want to publicly thank all of you for teaching me about culture. I think we tend to regard culture as simply a poem, or a play, or some music, as something that just entertains us. But culture is much more powerful than that. Culture is about teaching us how to see, and if we let the people who control culture in this country teach us how to see, we're going to see how they want us to see instead of seeing what we need to see. Culture is about the reorganization of seeing—how to see, how to look, how to understand, how to actually visualize differently.
Some people say, “Well, how could that be? Don't we just look out and see whatever is there? Isn't seeing a natural kind of thing?” No, it's not. There's nothing natural about it. We are socialized to see what they want us to see—unless we create our own culture so that we can see as we want to see, which is what we're doing at the Otto Rene Castillo Center for Working Class Culture.
Eva Brenner: For me, from Gold to Platinum represents a real advance. It represents a summation of the work that's gone into the Cultural Department in the last 9 months, and in another way, the play itself represents a change. If the people see a popular story that they can get into, they are going to start to demand more of it.
I kept raising over and over again, “How come we're doing it this way, we only have 3 week to put this together!” and Fred said, “The issue isn't doing it right, but doing it.” It's a fight that has been going on in the Cultural Department; a fight between the primacy of aesthetics or the primacy of politics, and I think it has to be brought out more into the open. We did what needed to be done, and we did it together instead of criticizing each other all along the way. Politics won this battle.
Roger Grunwald: In your talk, Fred, you said that culture is a way to make people see better or differently. One of the feelings that I had during the show was that I got a better sense of myself as an artist … I've never had an opportunity to be an artist and an organizer at the same time, and I got a real sense of being part of this organizing tool to help people to see. I don't know what it did to my performance, but I think there was something there. There's something different going on for you as an actor when you're apart of something that's helping to change things. It's a new feeling for me.
Tom Drumgold: As an actor I have a lot of friends from the theater and I told them I was going to be doing this and they said, “It's about what? You're playing a fascist?” The first question for an actor is always, “Are you going to get paid?” Then after you tell them what you almost always tell them—“No, I'm not,”—they say, “Well, what are you doing it for? Are you going to get agents to come to see you?” There is political theater in this city, but not very much of it, and artists don't see much point in doing it. So they do think you're crazy.
Fred Newman: What we are trying to do, and what I think we did successfully, was to openly caricature sanity. The fascists were sane. They were kind of the ultimate, sane Americans. It was like stripping away the veneer of liberalism, even conservatism, and saying, “Here's good old fashioned, American logic.” In one of the scenes, there's an interplay about how fucking people over is the American way.
MASTER GENERAL DORN: You just don't realize who you are. You are a White Father, a founder of the Aryan Nation of North America. Think about it: a pure white America. There'll be nothing to hold us back. All the commies we find we'll murder. Some real white folks [will] have to be sacrificed too—they were red dupes. But Jews, niggers, and spics—watch out. The Jews go with the commies—every mother's son. I mean that, you two. If a man's got one drop of Jew blood then he goes to the gallows. As for the Blacks, we kill all the worthless ones—that's kids and old ones. There are a lot of smart Negroes too, educated ones. We won't need them either. The rest—the bucks and the bitches—we put to work until they drop. They'll wish they were slaves when we get our hands on them. Give this program about 10 years and America will be pure as snow.
TRENK: After that, we can take on the world.
DORN: And our great grand kids will sing about us as the white men who wiped communism off the face of the earth.
WHITWORTH: It's a pretty picture, but I'm worried about right now. What if the Russkies and the rest decide to intervene in the civil war after we get the bombs?
DORN: Then that'll just be the end of the world—just put it like that. High stakes today, white men. You got the balls?
TRENK: What the fuck, huh?
DORN: That's the spirit that made America great!
Fred Newman: The audience really responded to that. “Goddamit, that's right; that s the essence of the American way!” The fascists came off much more rational and sane than the communists. They showed a kind of consistency with the reality of what America is. There was a way in which—and I think we intended for this to happen—a significant element of the audience could relate much more easily to the fascists than to the communists. The communists were really tough to relate to. They were out of their minds! The fascists even seemed to be much closer to each other a sort of buddy buddyness that was vulgar and foul, but did show a certain kind of togetherness that was rather lacking among the communists—until their social practice brought them together. I was thinking about that quote from Marx where he says that the process of working class revolution goes from defeat to defeat to defeat—to ultimate victory. I was very self conscious of that as we were doing the play.
IRA: Never a straight line. History never moves in a straight line. It zig-zags. History moves like a drunkard. It staggers, it lurches, it stands still for a moment, frying to focus. What we're in now is a zig, or maybe a zag. It's no end. This doesn't mean the end. Was Auschwitz the end? Was Leningrad the end? Was Soweto the end? What end? What are we talking about an end for? We're too close to talk about losing. We're so close we can smell it—it smells a little bit like fresh coffee early in the morning. We're so close we can hear it singing. Do you hear it? It's singing out in the woods. We're so close we can feel it breathing next to us at night as we sleep. We're that close. That close to ending the 5,000 year old nightmare. Ending class society. Ending poverty. Ending all the pain. It's as close as Omaha. As close as those gas tanks.
Fred Newman: What people saw on that stage—simply in terms of a grouping of white actors up there and primarily Black actors down here, in a way that was interactive—was a profoundly conflicted aesthetic experience also. Because ordinarily you can see plays that are primarily white with one or two Black actors, but it's obviously a white theater. On the other hand, you can see Black theater, which might sometimes include someone who's white. But the notion of seeing the stage set up as we did as that kind of conflict—I think that raised tremendous issues for people in the audience.
Some people were strongly identified with feminist or nationalist elements of the politics, and were really getting into that and then they suddenly realized that they'd come with this other person who was upset by their reactions: “Wait a minute—when we go out for coffee later, this might be a tough discussion.”
One of the things that was interesting to me was how many people talked about having a hard time with the violence. I found that really striking in view of the fact that there was shockingly little violence in the play. At one level, the first 5 minutes of almost any television show that you see had more violence in it than that entire play. I think that people were actually responding to the conflictedness and calling it violence. Their way of covering that was to identify the conflictedness, in some way, as violence.
Lois Holzman: I recently got a very moving letter from a dear comrade I met on my trip to the Soviet Union. We've kept in touch these past 6 years and he's kept up to date on the growth of our political community. Let me share what my friend and your friend Sasha had to say about the significance of our work: “The growth of the Institute for Social Therapy and Research is the basis for optimism and hope. In spite of Reaganism, neo conservatism, and world pessimism, there are some forces on the planet that are strong and healthy. I think that the nations of the world are sometimes in need of Social Therapy on a global scale.” A simple yet profound recognition of the vitality of Marxism—that here in the belly of the beast, “our lives, our history, our language must shape it.”
Marian Grossman: Ricky Flores and I did the first improv session in the Bronx with the Bronx Healthy Club. I remember feeling very nervous and sort of defensive. On my way there on the train, I was thinking of the worst scenarios—that I was going to read the play and people were going to say, “Oh my God, what is this communist stuff?” What we did was lay out the scenario up to the scene we were going to work on, and it was a wonderful experience to watch the people in the room, who were predominantly working-class Black women in their 40s and 50s, start to smile at the parts about the Army of the Poor taking over. That experience organized me. I realized that the class was ahead of me, that I was much more conservative than these working class women, and that people really wanted this vision of the future. When Pam and I went to Reverend Harvin's church, it was the same thing. We got up there and Pam said she was the Bolshevik Bronx Bomber, and she got a huge round of applause! That was without any lights, sound or costumes. That was just the idea of an American revolution!
Lenora Fulani: We are about communism, class, culture, and community. Over the past several months, we have been discussing these matters at Institute staff meetings. We have been asking each other about the social vision that guides, inspires, and informs us, in our day-to-day work from Harlem to East Los Angeles, from Jackson, Mississippi to Boston, Massachusetts. Because that vision, that class vision, that community vision—yes, that communist vision—that new way of seeing, is no abstraction. It is a moving, vital force everywhere we go. We talked about a future America and how it would come about. I knew I would not be there to see it, but it did not matter because it would be ours.
Bill Pleasant: I thought it would be important to do the play in a way that people could take on their fantasies. When I go to sleep at night, the first dreams I have are revolutionary dreams—striking back at Reagan and things like that. I know that everybody has those dreams, in one way or another. I wanted to take those dreams, that rage—you know, just when you're going to sleep and you're thinking, “I'll get those motherfuckers!” and say, “Okay, now I can see it.” I think that's extremely explosive, because we have the tactic to actually organize it.
Dan Friedman: An important aspect of the play was the collective fantasy aspect. Do you know half the people I meet now call me “Ira?” The day before MMI, of course, I was a nervous wreck and I ran into Ed Costa. He said, “What's the matter?” I said, “Oh, I'm just nervous about tomorrow.” He said, “You shouldn't be thinking about tomorrow, you should be thinking about 3 years from now when you're in Madison Square Garden. You know, Fred is always talking about how the fascists in Europe were able to organize people culturally and give them a vision, and the Left wasn't. It's going to be this very exciting revolutionary vision that the working class is going to be really excited about.” We have all shared this collective fantasy, and so have 600 other people. And I think that gives us a sense of community and makes that social vision all the more real.
Fred Newman: It's very important to not get into thinking that the play represents some kind of homogeneous statement of the broader political community, or even of the whole working class. In fact, what's most exciting about the play is that it continues to live as an element of a very complex and contradictory community experience. That means that people will say, “I can go to the Barbara Taylor School—no problem at all—but I can't touch From Gold to Platinum.” Some people will say, “This is great therapy, I'm getting a lot of help, but that play was very tough.” The play is, in fact, an extension of the poles around which we evolve the contradiction of political community. If you start to look upon the play in an overstated way, as a “consolidation” piece, you actually rob us of what's most significant about the play. That's exactly what it wasn't. It was designed to be provocative, and it was.
If what we wanted to do was consolidate the whole community, we wouldn't present that program. There's a whole other program you can present to do that job. But it is not our concern, culturally, to consolidate—our concern is to be provocative, to provide a certain political pole to intensify and deepen the dynamic of the contradictions. Don't throw that out! That's why the play was so powerful—because it raised so much. I think that some of the people who probably had the most extraordinary experiences were the hundred who left! They walked out into the street saying, “Gee, I really like working with those folks, they're nice people but what the hell was that?”
That's what I think was significant about it, and that's what I think is significant about a great deal of the cultural work that we're doing. It forces the issue. It forces us to extend beyond the very narrow tunnel vision that people want to have relative to some of the things that we're doing across the city and across the country. The political situation in America today is contradictory. On the one hand, people feel the pull to support that which is progressive, but they also feel incredibly cynical. People say: “You're crazy, it's hopeless, a waste of time. I'm sorry you rang my bell today. All you're doing is making me feel guilty—now I'll have to go for three more sessions this week because I feel more guilty than ever, seeing you out there ringing doorbells when I haven't done anything in 10 years. That makes me feel terrible!” That's about where three fourths of the population of this country is at.
Dan Friedman: One middle class woman said to me, “The bottom line is: I don't trust communists. But you people are the best organizers and the best human beings I've ever met. I have to go with that.”
Fred Newman: Right—that's until she doesn't, and you have to remember that. It's a process, a pulsating, social/political process.
Lois Holzman: For those in power, science is a conservative method for discovering such truths as keep them in power. For those of us not in power, we must see that our lives, our children's lives, our neighbors' lives, our friends' lives, the life of our people, the life of our class, depend on a new science for discovering such truths as change the world and place the disempowered in power. When our children are sick, we must ask not how can we make them healthy consistent with keeping Ronald Reagan and his profiteering friends in power. We must rather ask: How do we make our children healthy? We must use all that is available to empower our people. And if the fear of a word—of the word “communism”—keeps us from helping our children to be healthy, then we must overcome that fear. For our class has nothing to fear from communism. Mr. Reagan and his wealthy friends have much to fear. I hope they are frightened to death.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)