By Christopher Hitchens
Vanity Fair, May 2004
Democrats are furious that Ralph Nader, whose last presidential bid helped put George W. Bush in office, is running again. Equally dismaying, the author finds, is Nader’s backing from a crackpot group with ties to Pat Buchanan, Lyndon LaRouche, and Louis Farrakhan
For me, it was all over as soon as it began. The day after he announced himself as a candidate for president on Meet the Press, Ralph Nader held a press conference at which he said, “I think this may be the only candidacy in our memory that is opposed overwhelmingly by people who agree with us on the issues.”
Hold it right there, Ralph. First, don’t you realize that politicians who start to refer to themselves in the plural, as in the royal “we,” are often manifesting an alarming symptom? (Mrs. Margaret Thatcher started to employ this distressing locution shortly before the members of her own Cabinet began to stir nervously and finally decided to call for the men in white coats.) Second, if by “we” and “us” you really meant to say yourself and your allies in this enterprise, then you should not complain if it’s pointed out who those allies actually turn out to be. Third, by stating that your campaign is “opposed overwhelmingly by people who agree with us on the issues,” do you mean to imply the corollary, which is that you will appeal to those who don’t agree with you on the issues?
Nader’s answer to that third question, astonishingly enough, does appear to be in the affirmative, since he had told Tim Russert just the day before that he expected to reap votes from “conservatives who are furious with Bush over the deficit,” as well as “liberal Republicans who see their party taken away from them.” The job of reconciling these opposed factions of the G.O.P will be hard enough for Bush himself. But the idea that either group would rally to a Nader banner, this year or any other, is a non sequitur of hallucinatory proportions.
The psychedelic effect is only intensified when one examines the forces that might allow Nader to speak in the plural. A short while before announcing his candidacy, he had been the featured attraction at a conference of third-party “independents” in Bedford, New Hampshire. The word “independent” can conceal more than it reveals, as anyone with any savvy in American “alternative” politics can tell you, but in this case it only barely masked the influence of Fred Newman, Lenora Fulani, and the former New Alliance Party (NAP), whose latest front organized the New Hampshire hootenanny.
Not to mince words, the Newman-Fulani group is a fascistic zombie cult outfit, based on the eternal principle that it is a finer and nobler thing for the members to transfer their liquid assets to the leadership. It’s where you would turn when you had exhausted all the possibilities of a better life with Lyndon LaRouche, or Jim Jones, or any of the other alliterative crackpot or quasi-redemptive formations (K.K.K., A.A.…).
The Newman-Fulani faction is protean and sinister in one way, and pathetically obvious and transparent in another. In New York City, for example, it sometimes calls itself the Independence Party, which also controlled the rump and letterhead of the Reform Party—Ross Perot’s gift to American pluralism. Indeed, Lenora Fulani, a black woman who, like her mentor Fred Newman, professes to be a shrink of some sort, was a prominent co-chair of Pat Buchanan’s Reform Party candidacy in 2000. That must have made a soothing change from being a Louis Farrakhan fan in her two presidential election bids.
“Try anything once” would seem to be the motto here. And now she’s endorsing Ralph Nader. “I think it’s pretty cool,” she breathes. “I think Nader is a distinguished independent and he needs to be supported.” A fabulous detail about Fulani, incidentally, is the hold that she seems to exert on the cast of The Sopranos. Dominic Chianese, who plays Uncle Junior, is a regular at the All Stars Project, co-founded by Fulani and Newman, which puts on Newman’s unwatchable dramas, and has taken along other members of the team, including James Gandolfini, for photo ops. Analyze that, if you dare.
Am I asserting guilt by association here? After all, a candidate needn’t necessarily be judged by his disciples. And at “third party” events in previous campaigns there was certainly a fair sprinkling of people with propeller beanies, the fillings in their teeth wired for instant Martian dial up access. (You get these people at mainstream gatherings, also; be in no doubt of it.) No, the difference in this case is that the Newman-Fulani cult more or less is the Nader campaign. Through its network of shell organizations and front groups, and given its batteries of living dead petition drive robot artists, it has arrived at the point where it can at least guarantee ballot access in many, many states. All you have to do is agree to run on its ballot line.
Even Michael Bloomberg, princeling of opportunists, was willing to take out this Newman-Fulani insurance in his campaign for mayor. This, you may say, is partly the fault of restrictive ballot access laws, riveted into place by the Democratic-Republican duopoly in many jurisdictions—an offense to the spirit and letter of the United States Constitution.
But Nader kept people guessing, in a rather irritating way, about whether he would run at all or whether he might deign again to accept the Green Party nomination (which he has suddenly decided he won’t anymore). So, having come down from his Sinai, he finds it’s the loonies or nothing. Is this politics? And if it is, is it clean politics? Does it “empower” the average voter, who is so often taken for a ride by the party machines, or does it empower clusters of well financed, marginal nut bags with whom, behind closed doors, the party machines can and do frequently make deals?
Nothing is more difficult to write than a “more in sorrow than in anger” letter. Sentimentality swirls around your feet like a swamp, tempting you to become even more moist and runny yourself. But if this were an open letter to Ralph Nader, it would begin by being genuinely soft.
We don’t have enough heroes. (We have replaced them with “role models” and don’t even know what we have lost.) We do not have many candidates of whom it could be said that, if they were caught on video seeming to accept a bribe or kickback, we would automatically assume that the video had been faked. Washington, as a community, and Washington, as a federal city, would be a very much worse place without Ralph Nader.
He stood up against the rotten bureaucracy and mayoralty of the town itself, while unsettling the folks who live on Capitol Hill. Some of the story is known by everyone, including people who have never heard Nader’s name, the exploding car that the manufacturers lied about; the lead in the water; the non-regulation of the meat and mining industries.
It really wouldn’t be too much to say that there are many people now living who would be dead without Ralph. It certainly wouldn’t be too much to say that successive generations of reforming lawyers and legislators got their start and their continuing encouragement from him.
In writing, about him, therefore, one need not declare an interest. “Sea-green incorruptible” was. Carlyle’s sardonic description of Robespierre, but it recurs to my mind as an almost frighteningly apt phrase, in this case.
Why frightening? Well, I first met Nader 22 years ago, when he took me to lunch on my arrival as a columnist in Washington. We had what I thought was a great time, and he later telephoned to say that he was worried, about my smoking. He would, he said with perfect gravity, pay me the oddly exact figure of four and a half thousand dollars, and cover any therapy bills I might incur, if I would quit the habit and thus save myself for the nation (or The Nation, as he may possibly have thought of it).
On every occasion that we have met since, he has renewed this offer, adjusted for inflation and other variables. I once really needed the money, and considered calling him up and claiming to have sworn off, before realizing that the very idea of exploiting his innocence and concern was profane. Of course, there is something paternalistic in such a gesture (if he could be the father I never had, I could be among the many, many children that he never had). Indeed, his whole crusade for greater “safety” and regulation could be described as paternal in character.
And a slight secret about Ralph Nader is the extent of his conservatism. The last time I saw him up close, he was the guest at Grover Norquist’s now famous “Wednesday Morning” gathering, where Washington’s disparate conservative groups meet—by invitation only, and off the record—under one ceiling. He gave them a sincere talking-to, pointing out that their favorite system—free market capitalism—was undermining their professedly favorite values. I remember particularly how he listed the businessmen who make money by piping cable porn into hotel rooms. (He rolled this out again on Meet the Press.)
Nader was the only serious candidate in the last presidential election who had favored the impeachment, on moral and ethical grounds, of Bill Clinton. When asked about his stand on gay and transgender rights and all that, he responds gruffly that he isn’t much interested in “gonadal politics.”
He has often made a united front with conservatives like Norquist, and even more right-wing individuals like Paul Weyrich, on matters such as term limits and congressional pay raises. When I asked Grover about Ralph’s prospects of attracting Republicans, incidentally, he told me that he thought a Nader campaign just might appeal to some of the former Buchanan wing—anti-trade and anti-interventionist (not to forget anti-immigrant). So Nader and Buchanan might as well run for each other’s votes, or skip all that and just take in each other’s washing.
Nader’s puritanism and austerity—he lives in a rooming house with a shared pay phone in the hall and doesn’t own a car—have been his shield since 1966, when the clever people at General Motors admitted to putting private dicks on their most scathing critic.
Nader was followed, and his friends were questioned, on the assumption that an unmarried guy of Lebanese parentage must be up to something. But no: no drinks and no drugs and no carnality and no terrorism. Nader testified, a congressional subcommittee saw Bobby Kennedy trashing G.M.’s president, and an all-American star was born, one who rejected the affluent part of the American Dream.
Ralph could have gone on being an uneasy conscience for Washington, as he was all through the Nixon and Carter and Reagan years (after all, you don’t need to campaign for office to do that), but he seems finally to have found a temptation he cannot resist.
By running for president in 2000 and accidentally changing history, he has at last imbibed a draft of something addictive. Someone should tell him that the next bender will bring diminishing returns. In 2000, no matter how much he claimed to be above such distinctions, Nader clearly ran from the left. He also repudiated one of the center left’s favorite mantras, concerning the “lesser evil,” scornfully pointing out that this meant giving in to evil without a fight.
In most of his speeches he maintained that he didn’t care which of the two main candidates won, because it made no difference. But when pressed, he would sometimes try to have this both ways, saying that his candidacy energized liberal Democrats and even helped get out their vote. His less conspicuously intellectual supporters, such as Michael Moore, assured the faithful crowds that Bush couldn’t get elected anyway, so there was no need to worry.
At that point, a certain intellectual corruption crept in. You must accept the logical and probable consequences of what you propose. Nader could not quite be honest and admit that, given the national arithmetic, he was very much more likely to help Bush than Gore. There are 10 toss-up states, with 106 electoral votes among them (and everybody now knows about the electoral college). They are Florida, Iowa, Minnesota, Missouri, Nevada, New Hampshire, Ohio, Oregon, New Mexico, and Wisconsin.
Once you understand the arithmetic, you cannot really claim that any consequences are unintended. For example, we have it on Gore’s own word that if he had been elected, Saddam Hussein would still be in power.
Nader is currently the only recognizable candidate who wants the United States to withdraw from Iraq. This discrepancy is not exactly a detail. It is, in fact, too big a contradiction to be explained away. But could it explain why Nader this time seems to be running from the right? He is spouting the rhetoric of social and fiscal conservatism, and pitching for allegedly disillusioned Republicans who would have nothing to be disillusioned about if he hadn’t helped squeak their man past the post in the first place.
The NAP could also probably be described as a right-wing force even if, as befitted a party run by a couple of shrinks, it suffered from chronic schizophrenia. It began as a Maoist splinter group and mutated through LaRoucheism to Buchananism. Guru Fred Newman characterizes Jews as “storm troopers,” and Fulani calls them “mass murderers of people of color,” positions which have a nice, demented ring to them.
Nader seems, to his credit, a touch sensitive on the point. When Doug Ireland, one of the country’s toughest and brightest radical columnists (and a two-time Nader endorser), called attention to the unholy alliance he got a call from Ralph, who shouted at him for being “a McCarthyite bully” and repeatedly asked, about Newman, “Has he committed any crime?”
I had better luck when Ralph called me back late one night and nearly persuaded me to argue against myself. It’s a pleasure to debate with him. But he told me, when I asked about the NAP, that “I never saw Fulani at the meeting,” which I suppose could be technically true as long as he was looking away. (She was a prominent member of the platform committee.)
He maintained that the Newmanites were no different, in principle, than, say, the Mountain Party in West Virginia: “They’re recognized as ‘on the ballot’ by the Federal Election Commission, so you can ‘jump on.’” He said that the Green Party wasn’t going to decide until its June convention, and that it still might vote not to campaign in swing states, so there was no purpose in delaying.
In the very rational and seductive tone of voice that he can bring to bear, Ralph insisted that there is no bad time at which to challenge the gerrymandering of one party districts, the fixing and front loading of primaries, the rigging of party conventions, and the exclusion of third-party candidates from the “presidential debates.” The liberal intellectuals who take these deformities for granted and then turn on him are, as he put it, “incarnate autocrats.”
And whose fault is Gore’s defeat? “He slipped on 18 banana peels, of which I was only one. Anyway, he won the election, didn’t he?” This is quite funny and also quite shrewd, as regards Democratic self pity, but it shows again that tendency to have everything both ways. “I’m going to take more votes from Bush this time—no doubt about it.” (By the way, at least one exit poll suggests that this was true in 2000, if only in New Hampshire.)
But on the other hand, and only moments later, he says, “I’ll show Kerry how to take Bush down; we’ll be a free consulting firm for the Democrats; be our guest—take our issues.”
Since one of the main “issues” is the pressing need to demolish the Democratic Party, my head began to swim a little, and I told him as much.
He made a friendly inquiry, renewing his smoke-ending offer. We chatted about a heroic Israeli dissident we had both known. He recommended a good comrade of his who was deeply involved in the rebuilding of Afghanistan. There are not enough people like Nader running for office, even at the local level, let alone the national one. I hung up with a truly bad case of the blues.
When Nader says “corporate” he really means corporate, and not just Halliburton. When he says that politics should not be a “zero-sum” game, he articulates a truth. When he says that Americans ought to be able to vote “No,” rather than being compelled to say “Yes,” he asserts something morally important.
But when he proposes to help elect a corporate Democrat by outbidding a conservative Republican, he is building a bridge from the middle of the river, and ends up not by combating the many absurdities of our electoral system but rather by illustrating them.
Showing posts with label Reform Party. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Reform Party. Show all posts
Tuesday, August 9, 2011
Speech to the Reform Party National Convention (2000)
By Dr. Lenora Fulani, August 11, 2000
It's great to be here. Thank you all for that beautiful welcome last night. It's great to have a credential you can count on. As you know, I've been a political independent for a long time. I first ran for office as an independent almost 20 years ago, in the days when, if you told people you were an independent, they looked at you as if you had just come from Mars.
Today, the American independent is the new force in national politics. We're the wild card. And it certainly has been wild. And it looks like that's going to continue. I like that feature of our movement.
Since the very start I've been something of a conatroversial figure myself. Some people have objected to me on the grounds that I am too radical that I am a left winger, a progressive, a revolutionary and that a storm of controversy follows my every move. I want to address that reputation today. I want to address it because I believe it is at the very heart of the issues and the choices that face us, the Reform Party and the entire independent movement.
Let me get right to the point. The issue that we face is whether or not we are a revolutionary movement. What does that mean? What does it mean to be a revolutionary movement in the year 2000? Here's what it means to me. It means being a movement dedicated to completing the first American Revolution by challenging the basic formula that is contemporary America a formula in which corporate interests rule and democracy takes a back seat. I believe we are a revolutionary movement. I believe we must be. American politics is too corrupt for us to be anything but. And let me tell you something more. If our Founding Fathers George Washington and Thomas Jefferson and John Adams and Benjamin Franklin and Tom Paine, and if you'll grant me historical license, Frederick Douglass and Susan B. Anthony were in this room with us today, they'd be standing up here with me. They'd be saying to all of you Fellow Citizens, aren't you ready to stand up to tyranny? Don't you love freedom and liberty sufficiently to challenge the old order? Do you not understand that to be a patriot is to be a revolutionary?
Fellow Reformers, George Washington and Thomas Jefferson would not be on the side of the nay sayers who counsel us to avoid controversy, to appear moderate and to walk the straight and narrow. George Washington and Thomas Jefferson would be on my side because I am like them. I am cut from the same cloth.
Some people like to call me names and believe me, I've been called plenty. There's nothing I haven't been called: Left wing, Right wing, Nigger, Jew lover, Jew hater, Pervert, Provocateur, Opportunist. I've heard it all. And then some. But General Washington and Mr. Jefferson slave owners though they might have been were also revolutionaries. And I am certain, if they could rise from the dead this morning, they'd join me at this podium and say, Lenora Fulani? We know her. She's with us. She's an American Revolutionary. Aren't you?
But what does it really mean to be a revolutionary in this new and high tech and frightening millennium? It means continuing the revolutionary process not violently but powerfully such that we can engage the fundamental contradiction of the American experience. What is that contradiction? It's that while we believe with all our heart in democracy, we have been willing to compromise it for the good of the economy.
The deepest conflict among the Founding Fathers let us not forget was the issue of slavery. While virtually everyone knew it to be morally wrong, the institution was allowed to exist because it made the economy thrive. And so the democratic rights of a whole race of people were abrogated because slavery enriched the U.S. economy.
It is not altogether different from the circumstances we face today. The globalists argue that NAFTA, the WTO and a general trade policy that unleashes multi-national corporations around the globe are good for the economy. The negative impact on Americans workers, on the environment and on long term economic development is supposed to be considered negligible. We don't believe it is negligible. But there is a far more profound problem at hand. For the globalist special interests have stolen our government so that they can prioritize their economic interests over all else. Some argue that the problem with the two parties is that they are captive to the special interests. I disagree. They are not captive to the special interests. They are the special interests. And they rule unequivocally on behalf of the globalists.
That's why Ross Perot told the American people, when he first ran for President, that we had to take our government back. That we, the people, had to set the terms on which business does business. We're not anti business. We're pro democracy and we believe this is our country and we have the right to run it.
Sometimes people will say to us, "Oh, that political reform stuff very interesting. But what do you stand for?" Here's our answer: We stand for the democratic right of the people of this country all the people of this country to collectively and democratically determine our economic, social, cultural, and policy priorities. The two parties have usurped that right. And we must re assert it.
The Reform Party has been through tremendous turmoil in the last year. I don't have to recapitulate it for all of you, because you lived it we lived it, together. Some people have said to me that they have been beaten down by it. They feel demoralized, angered, and despairing. I can understand those feelings. I have felt them myself. I was, after all, a supporter of Pat Buchanan, before he betrayed his commitment to build this party on a pro democracy, left/center/right foundation. But, I want to thank Pat Buchanan. Yes, I want to thank him. Here's why. I think Pat, by his presence and his neo reactionary takeover attempt of our party, has taught us a very important lesson. A lesson we needed to learn. He taught us that we you and I and millions of liberty loving Americans across the country, built something of extraordinary value, something he wanted so badly that he was willing to commit fraud to try to get.
We belittle ourselves if we think it's just the $13 million. Yes, Pat wants the money. And John Hagelin will hopefully prevent him from getting his hands on it. But this party, if it remains honest and uncorrupted, and this movement this revolutionary movement are things of extraordinary value to ordinary people. But there's another lesson to be learned here, too. It's a harder one to learn. It's a lesson about building building from the bottom up. A lot of people are angry at Pat Buchanan. They're angry because he came in and tried to take over our party. But if we're serious independents, and genuine revolutionaries, we have to ask ourselves how that happened. I think it happened because in many states, the party had simply not been built at the grassroots. When Pat Buchanan came in with 25 followers here and 70 followers.
There, he could make a power grab. How did that happen? How did a movement, which attracted 20 million Americans in 1992 and 8 1/2 million Americans in 1996, find itself with a political party in the year 2000 that was so vulnerable to being overrun by 300 Buchanan Brigadiers?
We find ourselves in this situation, fellow Reformers, because we failed to build the party from the bottom up. We remained too dependent on a top down model for party building, and that simply will not work. We were created by the 8/1/2 million votes cast for Ross Perot in 1996. We honor and respect Mr. Perot for that catalytic contribution. But we will not succeed in our historic mission if we rely on a model of party building that rests solely on big names and big money.
In New York, we have a state party that was created by a millionaire independent Tom Golisano, who spent $8 million on a run for governor in 1994 to poll 217,000 votes which won ballot status for the Independence Party. But in New York, hundreds of party activists believed that we had to take the gift we had been given and make it our own. And so we went out and built that party so that it now has 175,000 members and vibrant broad based democratic structures making it the largest and most significant state party organization in the Reform Party and an increasingly pivotal force in New York State politics.
In my view, we have paid too little attention to the New York model and too much attention to waiting for the next big name or big money to come along. That has hurt the party and hurt the movement. We have paid a price for that error. How big of a price we do not yet know.
But we must move on. And we will. And I must say that one of the things I like best about John Hagelin is that he is not a big name and he has no big money. But he's been out there building and organizing and getting on the ballot and bringing new blood into the Reform Party and into independent politics. That's who I think deserves the nomination of the Reform Party.
If you watched any of the Republican National Convention, as I did, you may have been astounded as I was, by the seeming transformation of that party. I was deeply touched by Colin Powell. I was thrilled to see John McCain. But if you look closely at that party, in spite of its new openness and inclusivity you can see that while Colin Powell and John McCain are permitted to speak, they will not be permitted to lead. It is not a revolutionary party. It's a special interest party. That's why, in my opinion, they both ultimately belong with us in the independent movement.
And we must carry on building our movement. The destructive divisions and unhealthy fractiousness in Reform did not begin on the day Pat Buchanan arrived. They will not be overcome merely by our shared opposition to his effort to transform us into a party of social conservatism. Nor will they be overcome by our trying to recreate ourselves as some bland and non controversial element hoping to survive the election and somehow, magically, get 5% of the vote.
Controversy is our business. We're the people who want to bring down the two party system. We're the people who want to open up the debates, close down the FEC and throw the corrupt politicians and their globalist benefactors out of office. If that ain't controversial, I don't know what is.
I am proud to be with all of you today. I fully expected that our New York delegation would be de credentialed by the Buchanan convention because democracy is out the window over there and so is election law and the constitution. I want to take a moment to acknowledge those delegates, our state chairman Frank MacKay, our most able delegation organizer Cathy Stewart, and our brilliant attorney Harry Kresky. They are some serious party builders and serious fighters. We're fighting hard for the heart and
soul of our movement. And we are proud to be fighting alongside John Hagelin, soon to be our Presidential nominee. John Hagelin is a good and decent and highly intelligent and articulate spokesman for our cause. You all know that.
And you know, of course, that when we turned to him to champion the fight to preserve democracy in our party, he responded with enthusiasm and wit and grace. But let me tell you something else about John Hagelin that you may not have fully grasped. He's got real guts. There were a lot of people out there in the media, in the two parties, on the right and on the left who couldn't wait to attack Pat Buchanan. It was sound bite heaven for every would be, has been, wannabee political type across the spectrum, including some people who like to think of themselves as independents. But you know something? None of them, not one, was willing to come out and get into the Reform Party primary to have the fight the fight for the heart and soul of not just the Reform Party but of our revolutionary independent movement. None, except John Hagelin.
Let me leave you with this. If George Washington and Thomas Jefferson and Frederick Douglass were here today, do you know what they'd be doing? They'd be standing up with the American Revolutionary, John Hagelin. And do you know who else would be up here? The great Revolutionary War naval commander and hero, John Paul Jones. In a critical naval battle in 1779, under constant fire from the better armed and better equipped British Navy, Jones rallied his forces with words that inspire us today. "We have not yet begun to fight," he cried. Several hours later, the British ship Serapis was forced to surrender to Jones and the revolutionary forces. And so, in the great tradition of our American Revolution which continues to this day I send this message to all who would try to denigrate or derail our independent populist revolution: We have not yet begun to fight!
It's great to be here. Thank you all for that beautiful welcome last night. It's great to have a credential you can count on. As you know, I've been a political independent for a long time. I first ran for office as an independent almost 20 years ago, in the days when, if you told people you were an independent, they looked at you as if you had just come from Mars.
Today, the American independent is the new force in national politics. We're the wild card. And it certainly has been wild. And it looks like that's going to continue. I like that feature of our movement.
Since the very start I've been something of a conatroversial figure myself. Some people have objected to me on the grounds that I am too radical that I am a left winger, a progressive, a revolutionary and that a storm of controversy follows my every move. I want to address that reputation today. I want to address it because I believe it is at the very heart of the issues and the choices that face us, the Reform Party and the entire independent movement.
Let me get right to the point. The issue that we face is whether or not we are a revolutionary movement. What does that mean? What does it mean to be a revolutionary movement in the year 2000? Here's what it means to me. It means being a movement dedicated to completing the first American Revolution by challenging the basic formula that is contemporary America a formula in which corporate interests rule and democracy takes a back seat. I believe we are a revolutionary movement. I believe we must be. American politics is too corrupt for us to be anything but. And let me tell you something more. If our Founding Fathers George Washington and Thomas Jefferson and John Adams and Benjamin Franklin and Tom Paine, and if you'll grant me historical license, Frederick Douglass and Susan B. Anthony were in this room with us today, they'd be standing up here with me. They'd be saying to all of you Fellow Citizens, aren't you ready to stand up to tyranny? Don't you love freedom and liberty sufficiently to challenge the old order? Do you not understand that to be a patriot is to be a revolutionary?
Fellow Reformers, George Washington and Thomas Jefferson would not be on the side of the nay sayers who counsel us to avoid controversy, to appear moderate and to walk the straight and narrow. George Washington and Thomas Jefferson would be on my side because I am like them. I am cut from the same cloth.
Some people like to call me names and believe me, I've been called plenty. There's nothing I haven't been called: Left wing, Right wing, Nigger, Jew lover, Jew hater, Pervert, Provocateur, Opportunist. I've heard it all. And then some. But General Washington and Mr. Jefferson slave owners though they might have been were also revolutionaries. And I am certain, if they could rise from the dead this morning, they'd join me at this podium and say, Lenora Fulani? We know her. She's with us. She's an American Revolutionary. Aren't you?
But what does it really mean to be a revolutionary in this new and high tech and frightening millennium? It means continuing the revolutionary process not violently but powerfully such that we can engage the fundamental contradiction of the American experience. What is that contradiction? It's that while we believe with all our heart in democracy, we have been willing to compromise it for the good of the economy.
The deepest conflict among the Founding Fathers let us not forget was the issue of slavery. While virtually everyone knew it to be morally wrong, the institution was allowed to exist because it made the economy thrive. And so the democratic rights of a whole race of people were abrogated because slavery enriched the U.S. economy.
It is not altogether different from the circumstances we face today. The globalists argue that NAFTA, the WTO and a general trade policy that unleashes multi-national corporations around the globe are good for the economy. The negative impact on Americans workers, on the environment and on long term economic development is supposed to be considered negligible. We don't believe it is negligible. But there is a far more profound problem at hand. For the globalist special interests have stolen our government so that they can prioritize their economic interests over all else. Some argue that the problem with the two parties is that they are captive to the special interests. I disagree. They are not captive to the special interests. They are the special interests. And they rule unequivocally on behalf of the globalists.
That's why Ross Perot told the American people, when he first ran for President, that we had to take our government back. That we, the people, had to set the terms on which business does business. We're not anti business. We're pro democracy and we believe this is our country and we have the right to run it.
Sometimes people will say to us, "Oh, that political reform stuff very interesting. But what do you stand for?" Here's our answer: We stand for the democratic right of the people of this country all the people of this country to collectively and democratically determine our economic, social, cultural, and policy priorities. The two parties have usurped that right. And we must re assert it.
The Reform Party has been through tremendous turmoil in the last year. I don't have to recapitulate it for all of you, because you lived it we lived it, together. Some people have said to me that they have been beaten down by it. They feel demoralized, angered, and despairing. I can understand those feelings. I have felt them myself. I was, after all, a supporter of Pat Buchanan, before he betrayed his commitment to build this party on a pro democracy, left/center/right foundation. But, I want to thank Pat Buchanan. Yes, I want to thank him. Here's why. I think Pat, by his presence and his neo reactionary takeover attempt of our party, has taught us a very important lesson. A lesson we needed to learn. He taught us that we you and I and millions of liberty loving Americans across the country, built something of extraordinary value, something he wanted so badly that he was willing to commit fraud to try to get.
We belittle ourselves if we think it's just the $13 million. Yes, Pat wants the money. And John Hagelin will hopefully prevent him from getting his hands on it. But this party, if it remains honest and uncorrupted, and this movement this revolutionary movement are things of extraordinary value to ordinary people. But there's another lesson to be learned here, too. It's a harder one to learn. It's a lesson about building building from the bottom up. A lot of people are angry at Pat Buchanan. They're angry because he came in and tried to take over our party. But if we're serious independents, and genuine revolutionaries, we have to ask ourselves how that happened. I think it happened because in many states, the party had simply not been built at the grassroots. When Pat Buchanan came in with 25 followers here and 70 followers.
There, he could make a power grab. How did that happen? How did a movement, which attracted 20 million Americans in 1992 and 8 1/2 million Americans in 1996, find itself with a political party in the year 2000 that was so vulnerable to being overrun by 300 Buchanan Brigadiers?
We find ourselves in this situation, fellow Reformers, because we failed to build the party from the bottom up. We remained too dependent on a top down model for party building, and that simply will not work. We were created by the 8/1/2 million votes cast for Ross Perot in 1996. We honor and respect Mr. Perot for that catalytic contribution. But we will not succeed in our historic mission if we rely on a model of party building that rests solely on big names and big money.
In New York, we have a state party that was created by a millionaire independent Tom Golisano, who spent $8 million on a run for governor in 1994 to poll 217,000 votes which won ballot status for the Independence Party. But in New York, hundreds of party activists believed that we had to take the gift we had been given and make it our own. And so we went out and built that party so that it now has 175,000 members and vibrant broad based democratic structures making it the largest and most significant state party organization in the Reform Party and an increasingly pivotal force in New York State politics.
In my view, we have paid too little attention to the New York model and too much attention to waiting for the next big name or big money to come along. That has hurt the party and hurt the movement. We have paid a price for that error. How big of a price we do not yet know.
But we must move on. And we will. And I must say that one of the things I like best about John Hagelin is that he is not a big name and he has no big money. But he's been out there building and organizing and getting on the ballot and bringing new blood into the Reform Party and into independent politics. That's who I think deserves the nomination of the Reform Party.
If you watched any of the Republican National Convention, as I did, you may have been astounded as I was, by the seeming transformation of that party. I was deeply touched by Colin Powell. I was thrilled to see John McCain. But if you look closely at that party, in spite of its new openness and inclusivity you can see that while Colin Powell and John McCain are permitted to speak, they will not be permitted to lead. It is not a revolutionary party. It's a special interest party. That's why, in my opinion, they both ultimately belong with us in the independent movement.
And we must carry on building our movement. The destructive divisions and unhealthy fractiousness in Reform did not begin on the day Pat Buchanan arrived. They will not be overcome merely by our shared opposition to his effort to transform us into a party of social conservatism. Nor will they be overcome by our trying to recreate ourselves as some bland and non controversial element hoping to survive the election and somehow, magically, get 5% of the vote.
Controversy is our business. We're the people who want to bring down the two party system. We're the people who want to open up the debates, close down the FEC and throw the corrupt politicians and their globalist benefactors out of office. If that ain't controversial, I don't know what is.
I am proud to be with all of you today. I fully expected that our New York delegation would be de credentialed by the Buchanan convention because democracy is out the window over there and so is election law and the constitution. I want to take a moment to acknowledge those delegates, our state chairman Frank MacKay, our most able delegation organizer Cathy Stewart, and our brilliant attorney Harry Kresky. They are some serious party builders and serious fighters. We're fighting hard for the heart and
soul of our movement. And we are proud to be fighting alongside John Hagelin, soon to be our Presidential nominee. John Hagelin is a good and decent and highly intelligent and articulate spokesman for our cause. You all know that.
And you know, of course, that when we turned to him to champion the fight to preserve democracy in our party, he responded with enthusiasm and wit and grace. But let me tell you something else about John Hagelin that you may not have fully grasped. He's got real guts. There were a lot of people out there in the media, in the two parties, on the right and on the left who couldn't wait to attack Pat Buchanan. It was sound bite heaven for every would be, has been, wannabee political type across the spectrum, including some people who like to think of themselves as independents. But you know something? None of them, not one, was willing to come out and get into the Reform Party primary to have the fight the fight for the heart and soul of not just the Reform Party but of our revolutionary independent movement. None, except John Hagelin.
Let me leave you with this. If George Washington and Thomas Jefferson and Frederick Douglass were here today, do you know what they'd be doing? They'd be standing up with the American Revolutionary, John Hagelin. And do you know who else would be up here? The great Revolutionary War naval commander and hero, John Paul Jones. In a critical naval battle in 1779, under constant fire from the better armed and better equipped British Navy, Jones rallied his forces with words that inspire us today. "We have not yet begun to fight," he cried. Several hours later, the British ship Serapis was forced to surrender to Jones and the revolutionary forces. And so, in the great tradition of our American Revolution which continues to this day I send this message to all who would try to denigrate or derail our independent populist revolution: We have not yet begun to fight!
Black Folk, Reject Fulani and Buchanan! (1999)
By Charles Barron
Black Radical Congress News, November 15, 1999
They say politics makes strange bedfellows, but this is getting ridiculous. Where ever you find rich white males in the political mix, you'll find Dr. Lenora Fulani. It doesn't matter if they are left, right, wrong or racist. She has pushed Fred Newman, Tom Galisano, Abe Herschfield, Ross Perot, and now arch racist conservative Pat Buchanan for President. I guess it's pragmatism over principles for Dr. Fulani. It matters not that these men have done nothing for the Black community and as for Buchanan, his repugnant, vile views are diametrically opposed to any radical, progressive or civil rights agenda we've ever had. Buchanan, a defender of the pre-civil war south, the good ol' days for racist white folk, a staunch supporter of Reaganomics, a supporter of closing borders and stopping immigrants of color from reuniting with their families, is considered by many a racist, fascist bigot.
Dr. Fulani, who has considered herself a progressive independent, has spent years criticizing Rev. Jesse Jackson and Rev. Al Sharpton for delivering the Black vote to the Democratic Party, and now she has the nerve to try to deliver Black folk to a racist backward thinking political misfit like Pat Buchanan. This is madness!
Buchanan Coming to Harlem
According to an article in the Friday, November 12, 1999 edition of the New York Daily News, Dr. Fulani, in her endorsement of Buchanan's attempt to win the Reform Party nomination for the White House, stated that, "I'm going to take Pat Buchanan to 125th Street in Harlem. We're going to have lunch at Sylvia's, I'm going to take him to speak at the Rev. Al Sharpton's National Action Network." She further stated that, "he is not a racist or a fascist or a bigot. He is not a hater." Nothing can be further from the truth.
Beware of Wolves in Sheep's Clothing
Black Folk! Harlem! Beware of wolves in sheep's clothing!! "Everything Black ain't really Black!" We must not allow Black leaders to peddle political views to us that will turn back the hands of time. I'll be the first to agree with Dr. Fulani that we need an alternative to the two party system of Democrats and Republicans, however, we don't want to go from the frying pan into the fire. Pat Buchanan and the Reform Party is not the answer. As Chairperson of the newly formed Black led multi-racial Unity Party, I firmly believe in independent radical politics. But how could you call yourself a progressive and support a regressive like Buchanan? Fortunately, I don't believe Black Folks are going to believe Fulani's hype on Buchanan. And fortunately, Dr. Fulani does not have much influence in the Black community. Lets stay politically vigilant and be critical analytical thinkers. When Buchanan comes to Harlem, lets hope he leaves with Dr. Fulani all by her lonesome and is not welcomed at the National Action Network's House of Justice. The House of Justice should not be contaminated with the stench of Buchanan. We should not give a platform to a man like Buchanan. Lest we forget, Buchanan was a columnist for Rupert Murdock's racist rage sheet called the New York Post. Anybody that Murdock gives a column to can't be for us. Buchanan regularly castigated Blacks and Latinos in his column. From affirmative action to welfare reform to supporting the Confederate flag, he has dissed us badly. This is war. We need not provide a forum for a man whose views are well known and clearly anti-Black and anti-Latino.
Support Reparations
The new millennium will usher in election years 2000 and 20001. Black leaders will be cutting all kinds of deals with white led parties and their white candidates. Unfortunately, these deals will gain only them access and favor with these parties and candidates. Nothing will trickle down to the "hood" and make life better for us folk on a grassroots level. Let's not give them our votes so easily. Let's be intelligent voters. Political candidates should be given a Black political litmus test. That test should start with this question. Will you support Reparations for people of African ancestry in America and the worldwide African diaspora? We certainly deserve it. Everybody else is getting paid for America's and Europe's "Crimes Against Humanity." Why not us!
In 1990, the USA paid Japanese Americans 1.2 billion dollars or $20,000 each for their containment in concentration camps during the WWII years, and the Congressional Black Caucus supported the Japanese. In 1952, Germany paid $822 million to Jewish holocaust survivors. America is paying the indigenous people, whose land they stole, millions in Reparations. No one deserves it more than they do. But why not us? We were enslaved from 1619 to 1863, the date of the so-called Emancipation Proclamation. That's 244 years of free labor for them and "pure-de-hell" for us. Then from 1863 to 1965, the date of Civil Rights legislation, represents 102 years of legal Jim Crow apartheid like racism. From 1965 to the present we still suffer from economic, political and social oppression. They owe us big time. Here's how they can pay us. How about no taxes for us to pay for the next 20 years? How about free education for our people from kindergarten to graduated school? How some land? How about a $50 billion down payment? That's for starters. They can take the $50 billion from the $260 billion bloated military budget, during this time of so-called peace. Where there's a will, there's a way. We certainly deserve it. No support for Reparations, no Black vote! Wouldn't it be great if we all united around that proposition? Congressman John Conyers and the Congressional Black Caucus has had a bill, HR40, stuck in Committee since 1989, on Reparations. Let's force Congress to deal with it. This is a serious "doable" issue.
We Need New Leadership
We should choose candidates based upon their positions on issues, not because a self-proclaimed Black leader is promoting and parading them among us. From supporting the KKK's right to march, to supporting Pat Buchanan for President and providing a forum for him in Harlem, Black leaders mut not be allowed to continue to confuse the masses.
We need new leadership, principled-centered, visionary, radical progressive leadership that supports the people over the party, principles over opportunistic egocentric pragmatism, that is honest, trustworthy and does not compromise the integrity and intelligence of the Black community. Let's bring back "Power to the People." Black folk, in the name of Fannie Lou Hamer, Malcolm X and Martin Luther King, Jr., reject Pat Buchanan and Dr. Lenora Fulani for her political hypocrisy. Let's keep it real, and remember, "the struggle may be long, but our victory is certain."
Charles Barron is the President and CEO of Dynamics of Leadership, Inc., a national leadership training firm and Chairperson of the Unity Party.
Black Radical Congress News, November 15, 1999
They say politics makes strange bedfellows, but this is getting ridiculous. Where ever you find rich white males in the political mix, you'll find Dr. Lenora Fulani. It doesn't matter if they are left, right, wrong or racist. She has pushed Fred Newman, Tom Galisano, Abe Herschfield, Ross Perot, and now arch racist conservative Pat Buchanan for President. I guess it's pragmatism over principles for Dr. Fulani. It matters not that these men have done nothing for the Black community and as for Buchanan, his repugnant, vile views are diametrically opposed to any radical, progressive or civil rights agenda we've ever had. Buchanan, a defender of the pre-civil war south, the good ol' days for racist white folk, a staunch supporter of Reaganomics, a supporter of closing borders and stopping immigrants of color from reuniting with their families, is considered by many a racist, fascist bigot.
Dr. Fulani, who has considered herself a progressive independent, has spent years criticizing Rev. Jesse Jackson and Rev. Al Sharpton for delivering the Black vote to the Democratic Party, and now she has the nerve to try to deliver Black folk to a racist backward thinking political misfit like Pat Buchanan. This is madness!
Buchanan Coming to Harlem
According to an article in the Friday, November 12, 1999 edition of the New York Daily News, Dr. Fulani, in her endorsement of Buchanan's attempt to win the Reform Party nomination for the White House, stated that, "I'm going to take Pat Buchanan to 125th Street in Harlem. We're going to have lunch at Sylvia's, I'm going to take him to speak at the Rev. Al Sharpton's National Action Network." She further stated that, "he is not a racist or a fascist or a bigot. He is not a hater." Nothing can be further from the truth.
Beware of Wolves in Sheep's Clothing
Black Folk! Harlem! Beware of wolves in sheep's clothing!! "Everything Black ain't really Black!" We must not allow Black leaders to peddle political views to us that will turn back the hands of time. I'll be the first to agree with Dr. Fulani that we need an alternative to the two party system of Democrats and Republicans, however, we don't want to go from the frying pan into the fire. Pat Buchanan and the Reform Party is not the answer. As Chairperson of the newly formed Black led multi-racial Unity Party, I firmly believe in independent radical politics. But how could you call yourself a progressive and support a regressive like Buchanan? Fortunately, I don't believe Black Folks are going to believe Fulani's hype on Buchanan. And fortunately, Dr. Fulani does not have much influence in the Black community. Lets stay politically vigilant and be critical analytical thinkers. When Buchanan comes to Harlem, lets hope he leaves with Dr. Fulani all by her lonesome and is not welcomed at the National Action Network's House of Justice. The House of Justice should not be contaminated with the stench of Buchanan. We should not give a platform to a man like Buchanan. Lest we forget, Buchanan was a columnist for Rupert Murdock's racist rage sheet called the New York Post. Anybody that Murdock gives a column to can't be for us. Buchanan regularly castigated Blacks and Latinos in his column. From affirmative action to welfare reform to supporting the Confederate flag, he has dissed us badly. This is war. We need not provide a forum for a man whose views are well known and clearly anti-Black and anti-Latino.
Support Reparations
The new millennium will usher in election years 2000 and 20001. Black leaders will be cutting all kinds of deals with white led parties and their white candidates. Unfortunately, these deals will gain only them access and favor with these parties and candidates. Nothing will trickle down to the "hood" and make life better for us folk on a grassroots level. Let's not give them our votes so easily. Let's be intelligent voters. Political candidates should be given a Black political litmus test. That test should start with this question. Will you support Reparations for people of African ancestry in America and the worldwide African diaspora? We certainly deserve it. Everybody else is getting paid for America's and Europe's "Crimes Against Humanity." Why not us!
In 1990, the USA paid Japanese Americans 1.2 billion dollars or $20,000 each for their containment in concentration camps during the WWII years, and the Congressional Black Caucus supported the Japanese. In 1952, Germany paid $822 million to Jewish holocaust survivors. America is paying the indigenous people, whose land they stole, millions in Reparations. No one deserves it more than they do. But why not us? We were enslaved from 1619 to 1863, the date of the so-called Emancipation Proclamation. That's 244 years of free labor for them and "pure-de-hell" for us. Then from 1863 to 1965, the date of Civil Rights legislation, represents 102 years of legal Jim Crow apartheid like racism. From 1965 to the present we still suffer from economic, political and social oppression. They owe us big time. Here's how they can pay us. How about no taxes for us to pay for the next 20 years? How about free education for our people from kindergarten to graduated school? How some land? How about a $50 billion down payment? That's for starters. They can take the $50 billion from the $260 billion bloated military budget, during this time of so-called peace. Where there's a will, there's a way. We certainly deserve it. No support for Reparations, no Black vote! Wouldn't it be great if we all united around that proposition? Congressman John Conyers and the Congressional Black Caucus has had a bill, HR40, stuck in Committee since 1989, on Reparations. Let's force Congress to deal with it. This is a serious "doable" issue.
We Need New Leadership
We should choose candidates based upon their positions on issues, not because a self-proclaimed Black leader is promoting and parading them among us. From supporting the KKK's right to march, to supporting Pat Buchanan for President and providing a forum for him in Harlem, Black leaders mut not be allowed to continue to confuse the masses.
We need new leadership, principled-centered, visionary, radical progressive leadership that supports the people over the party, principles over opportunistic egocentric pragmatism, that is honest, trustworthy and does not compromise the integrity and intelligence of the Black community. Let's bring back "Power to the People." Black folk, in the name of Fannie Lou Hamer, Malcolm X and Martin Luther King, Jr., reject Pat Buchanan and Dr. Lenora Fulani for her political hypocrisy. Let's keep it real, and remember, "the struggle may be long, but our victory is certain."
Charles Barron is the President and CEO of Dynamics of Leadership, Inc., a national leadership training firm and Chairperson of the Unity Party.
Why I'm Backing Patrick Buchanan (1999)
By Lenora Fulani
WorldNetDaily.com (1999)
My endorsement last week of Pat Buchanan for the Reform Party presidential nomination set up a news cycle of incredulity over our political alliance. In some cases, the disbelief was so extreme as to make it appear that Buchanan and I are from different planets, rather than different ideological backgrounds. We are not, however, from different planets. We're from the same one, and it's facing a set of economic problems and challenges so great that the left/right differential can seem like a hill of beans in comparison.
"Aha!" you say. Just as I thought! She's an economic determinist. A classic socialist! In some respects I suppose I am. But Pat Buchanan? Hardly. Yet, he pointed out at our joint press conference, "The great goal of social justice is not being served in America today by this economy and the way it is functioning. I don't believe we ought to take away the money or the wealth of those who have earned it legitimately. But I do believe the disparities in income in this country are becoming too great. They're becoming outrageous, and that is not healthy. They are far greater in this society than any other democracy or democratic republic on earth. That is not healthy."
Those disparities are unhealthy. Ten percent of America's households own 80 percent of the country's private wealth, leaving 20 percent of the nation's wealth distributed among the bottom 90 percent of the population. But worse than unhealthy, they are intrinsic to the current course of globalization and financialization of the world economy as long as special interests control U.S. economic and trade policy. Pat Buchanan and I are not the only right/left partners to observe this.
The anti-NAFTA movement was propelled by a "strange bedfellows" coalition of conservative, centrist, and progressive economic populists. So was the anti-Fast Track movement which muscled Congress into rejecting the process (authorizing the president to negotiate trade deals with only an up or down vote by Congress) along with its predatory product (trade deals that boosted the profiteering of multinational corporations at the expense of American jobs and international labor and environmental standards).
But what exactly is the solution? Conservative economic nationalists like Buchanan believe we need "tax and trade policies that put America before the global economy." On the other end of the political spectrum progressive economists, who see the corrosive effects of globalism much in the way conservatives do, argue for a different approach. William Greider wrote in The Nation that globalization "has to be slowed down, not stopped, and redirected on a new course of development that is more moderate and progressive, that promises broader benefits to almost everyone." Greider comments on the wide disparity in wealth adding, "When rising incomes are broadly distributed, it creates mass purchasing power -- fueling a virtuous cycle of growth, savings and new investment. When incomes are narrowly distributed, as they are now, the economic system feeds upon itself, eroding its own energies for expansion, burying consumers and business, even governments, in impossible accumulations of debt."
How to address what Greider calls this "pathological" state of the U.S. economy and what Buchanan calls the "betrayal" of the American worker? Progressives argue for shifting the tax burden from labor to capital, restructuring trade terms to balance the flow of commerce, raising wages at the low end of the pay scale, forgiving the bad debts of poorer nations, reforming the mission of central banks to support growth rather than "thwarting" it and refocusing national priorities on creating jobs and improving wages -- rather than on multi-national competitiveness as the key to prosperity. Greider, in particular, appeals to the liberal notion that government must act responsibly to cure the pathology.
Buchanan's view of the issues are not altogether different, though he does not concede the inevitability of globalization. He favors a fairer tax code that relies on a national sales tax rather than income tax, a 15 percent tariff on foreign products that compete with U.S. goods and a "wage equalization tariff on manufactures from low wage countries." He supports an increase in the minimum wage and his goals include "full employment, with our working people as well compensated and rewarded as any on earth," and "a wider, deeper distribution of property and prosperity."
Buchanan does not, however, appeal directly to a notion of the innate responsibility of government. He projects that he wants to play hardball with our trading partners to eliminate the burgeoning U.S. trade deficit. He often uses China, or as Pat likes to emphasize, "Communist China," as an example. Beijing imposes on average a 22 percent tariff on U.S. imports (just reduced to 17 percent by the new trade pact) while Washington imposes none in return. But the problem isn't what China is up to. They're doing what any nation -- communist or capitalist -- must do to gain advantage in the highly competitive global marketplace. The problem for the American people is that U.S. Big Business wants access to a billion Chinese consumers whose spending power is being enhanced by China's trade surplus. And business is willing to have us endure the downsides of a trade deficit in order to get it.
The American people currently have no way to bring the U.S.-based transnationals to heel. Right now these special interests control the two parties that control our government. Labor pipes up every now and then -- usually at election time -- to demand things like restrictions on the import of foreign steel. But the AFL-CIO hooked its wagon to capital over 50 years ago, and consequently will not buck its two-party duopoly.
The rank and file, the unorganized (85 percent of the workforce) and the unemployed are not automatically so inclined. This is Buchanan's and my constituency. It is multi-racial, male and female, urban and rural, and it is significantly disempowered under the current political arrangement. Buchanan hopes to sell them on the need to play hardball. I do, too. My difference with Buchanan, however, is that I think they need to play hardball -- not with China, per se -- but with the two parties and with special interest politics. How? By insisting on participating more directly in the policy-making and governmental process. How do we accomplish that? By a surgical reform of America's electoral and political process that brings voter participation up, incumbency advantage down, and shifts decision making to the grassroots through the use of democratic forms like initiative and referendum and national town hall meetings.
The American people need more political capital. They should have the power to more directly set the terms for trade, taxes, and national economic priorities.
Buchanan's decision to leave the Republican Party and join up with the Reform Party and me is one indicator that he is now willing to turn the tables on the special interests.
Turning the decision-making over to the American people is the next step. If we do something about the democracy disparity between the elites and ordinary citizens, the country will be on its way to effecting policies which close the gap between rich and poor as well.
WorldNetDaily.com (1999)
My endorsement last week of Pat Buchanan for the Reform Party presidential nomination set up a news cycle of incredulity over our political alliance. In some cases, the disbelief was so extreme as to make it appear that Buchanan and I are from different planets, rather than different ideological backgrounds. We are not, however, from different planets. We're from the same one, and it's facing a set of economic problems and challenges so great that the left/right differential can seem like a hill of beans in comparison.
"Aha!" you say. Just as I thought! She's an economic determinist. A classic socialist! In some respects I suppose I am. But Pat Buchanan? Hardly. Yet, he pointed out at our joint press conference, "The great goal of social justice is not being served in America today by this economy and the way it is functioning. I don't believe we ought to take away the money or the wealth of those who have earned it legitimately. But I do believe the disparities in income in this country are becoming too great. They're becoming outrageous, and that is not healthy. They are far greater in this society than any other democracy or democratic republic on earth. That is not healthy."
Those disparities are unhealthy. Ten percent of America's households own 80 percent of the country's private wealth, leaving 20 percent of the nation's wealth distributed among the bottom 90 percent of the population. But worse than unhealthy, they are intrinsic to the current course of globalization and financialization of the world economy as long as special interests control U.S. economic and trade policy. Pat Buchanan and I are not the only right/left partners to observe this.
The anti-NAFTA movement was propelled by a "strange bedfellows" coalition of conservative, centrist, and progressive economic populists. So was the anti-Fast Track movement which muscled Congress into rejecting the process (authorizing the president to negotiate trade deals with only an up or down vote by Congress) along with its predatory product (trade deals that boosted the profiteering of multinational corporations at the expense of American jobs and international labor and environmental standards).
But what exactly is the solution? Conservative economic nationalists like Buchanan believe we need "tax and trade policies that put America before the global economy." On the other end of the political spectrum progressive economists, who see the corrosive effects of globalism much in the way conservatives do, argue for a different approach. William Greider wrote in The Nation that globalization "has to be slowed down, not stopped, and redirected on a new course of development that is more moderate and progressive, that promises broader benefits to almost everyone." Greider comments on the wide disparity in wealth adding, "When rising incomes are broadly distributed, it creates mass purchasing power -- fueling a virtuous cycle of growth, savings and new investment. When incomes are narrowly distributed, as they are now, the economic system feeds upon itself, eroding its own energies for expansion, burying consumers and business, even governments, in impossible accumulations of debt."
How to address what Greider calls this "pathological" state of the U.S. economy and what Buchanan calls the "betrayal" of the American worker? Progressives argue for shifting the tax burden from labor to capital, restructuring trade terms to balance the flow of commerce, raising wages at the low end of the pay scale, forgiving the bad debts of poorer nations, reforming the mission of central banks to support growth rather than "thwarting" it and refocusing national priorities on creating jobs and improving wages -- rather than on multi-national competitiveness as the key to prosperity. Greider, in particular, appeals to the liberal notion that government must act responsibly to cure the pathology.
Buchanan's view of the issues are not altogether different, though he does not concede the inevitability of globalization. He favors a fairer tax code that relies on a national sales tax rather than income tax, a 15 percent tariff on foreign products that compete with U.S. goods and a "wage equalization tariff on manufactures from low wage countries." He supports an increase in the minimum wage and his goals include "full employment, with our working people as well compensated and rewarded as any on earth," and "a wider, deeper distribution of property and prosperity."
Buchanan does not, however, appeal directly to a notion of the innate responsibility of government. He projects that he wants to play hardball with our trading partners to eliminate the burgeoning U.S. trade deficit. He often uses China, or as Pat likes to emphasize, "Communist China," as an example. Beijing imposes on average a 22 percent tariff on U.S. imports (just reduced to 17 percent by the new trade pact) while Washington imposes none in return. But the problem isn't what China is up to. They're doing what any nation -- communist or capitalist -- must do to gain advantage in the highly competitive global marketplace. The problem for the American people is that U.S. Big Business wants access to a billion Chinese consumers whose spending power is being enhanced by China's trade surplus. And business is willing to have us endure the downsides of a trade deficit in order to get it.
The American people currently have no way to bring the U.S.-based transnationals to heel. Right now these special interests control the two parties that control our government. Labor pipes up every now and then -- usually at election time -- to demand things like restrictions on the import of foreign steel. But the AFL-CIO hooked its wagon to capital over 50 years ago, and consequently will not buck its two-party duopoly.
The rank and file, the unorganized (85 percent of the workforce) and the unemployed are not automatically so inclined. This is Buchanan's and my constituency. It is multi-racial, male and female, urban and rural, and it is significantly disempowered under the current political arrangement. Buchanan hopes to sell them on the need to play hardball. I do, too. My difference with Buchanan, however, is that I think they need to play hardball -- not with China, per se -- but with the two parties and with special interest politics. How? By insisting on participating more directly in the policy-making and governmental process. How do we accomplish that? By a surgical reform of America's electoral and political process that brings voter participation up, incumbency advantage down, and shifts decision making to the grassroots through the use of democratic forms like initiative and referendum and national town hall meetings.
The American people need more political capital. They should have the power to more directly set the terms for trade, taxes, and national economic priorities.
Buchanan's decision to leave the Republican Party and join up with the Reform Party and me is one indicator that he is now willing to turn the tables on the special interests.
Turning the decision-making over to the American people is the next step. If we do something about the democracy disparity between the elites and ordinary citizens, the country will be on its way to effecting policies which close the gap between rich and poor as well.
The Strange Career of Dr. Lenora Fulani (1999)
By Ron Daniels
Black Radical Congress News, 23 December 1999
Dr. Lenora Fulani, former presidential candidate of the now defunct New Alliance Party, and "critic" of the two party monopoly on politics in this country, recently stunned many observers by endorsing Pat Buchanan's campaign to become the Reform Party's candidate for President in the 2000 election. In rationalizing her decision to endorse one of the most rabid, racist, sexist, homophobic, right wing political figures on the political scene today, Dr. Fulani suggested that Buchanan's candidacy would be good for "independent" politics and the political fortunes of Black people.
Indeed, Dr. Fulani promised to bring Pat Buchanan to the heart of Harlem, the Capital of Black America, to dine at Sylvia's restaurant and speak at the House of Justice, the headquarter of the Rev. Al Sharpton's National Action Network. How could Dr. Fulani who claims to be a Marxist and a champion of Black causes endorse an arch adversary of Black people? From my vantage point no one should be surprised that Dr. Fulani could commit such a deplorable act. For some time, at the direction of her mentor and master Dr. Fred Newman, it appears that Dr. Fulani's services as a political operative have been for sale to the highest bidder.
As a veteran of the progressive independent political movement, when I ran for President in 1992, 1 did so in part to protect the Black community against political interlopers and pretenders like Dr. Lenora Fulani. A cursory examination of the principal Black independent political movements in the last quarter century reveal that Dr. Lenora Fulani was nowhere to be found in any of them. From the National Black Political Assembly, the National Black Independent Political Party to the National Black United Fund, there is no evidence that Dr. Fulani played any significant role in the independent Black political movement. So how did Dr. Lenora Fulani become a "prominent" Black political leader purporting to represent the interests of Black people? The Fulani phenomenon is but the latest example of a predominantly White organization utilizing a Black face, and in this instance a Black female face, to establish a base in the Black community to carry out its own political agenda.
This scheme has been aided and abetted by well meaning but gullible Black people who arc understandably so fed up with many of the current crowd of Black "leaders" and the two establishment parties that they will give an audience to anyone who offers the appearance of an alternative. Many Black women are also understandably eager to see Black women break out of the mold of simply being followers in male dominated organizations and movements to becoming leaders in political organizations and movements. Dr. Fred Newman has cleverly attempted to exploit these legitimate aspirations within the Black community.
Most knowledgeable activists have always known that Dr. Fulani's claim that the New Alliance Party (the political formation Newman created to carry out his machinations) was a Black led party was a fraudulent assertion. Fred Newman, a one-time associate of Lyndon LaRouche, has always been the headmaster of a predominantly White cult like operation, which included the New Alliance Party (NAP). Using a concept called "social therapy," which essentially proclaims that people with mental disorders can be cured through service to the movement," many of the patients of Newman's social therapy clinics became the foot soldiers of NAP. It was these foot soldiers who largely comprised the army of volunteers who successfully labored to get NAP on the ballot in all fifty states during Fulani's presidential campaigns; campaigns which may have been calculated to raise money for Newman's operations by exploiting the matching fund provisions of the federal election laws more than to promote the interests of Black people and the oppressed.
Through it all, Fulani has never been the leader of anything. She has functioned as a devout servant of Fred Newman, who once said something to the effect that, "I made her, she is my proudest accomplishment." For her part, Fulani is so mesmerized by Newman that she has praised him as a leader "who has done more for Black people than any Black leader alive." Together this odd couple has been pimping and prostituting Black folks to promote their own agenda, which mostly appears to be enriching Newman and his associates. A few years ago, Newman abruptly declared that NAP had outlived its usefulness and disbanded it. If NAP was so successful then why did Newman shut it down? Shortly after the demise NAP Fulani popped up in the camp of the billionaire right wing populist Ross Perot. Apparently Perot was eager to use Newman's foot soldiers to secure ballot status for his presidential campaign. Since that time Fulani has been deployed to mind the right wing independent movement founded by Perot. It was out of this movement and Perot's presidential campaigns that the Reform Party was founded.
Noticeably quiet for the past few years, now Newman and Fulani have resurfaced as allies and co-partners of the right wing demagogue Patrick Buchanan, political bounty hunters whose only leverage is their purported ability to field an army of foot soldiers and the claim that they can deliver Black folks to the Reform Party and Buchanan. Such is the strange career of one Lenora Fulani. Now that we know the real deal, the sham, there is no reason for Black folks to be duped by Fred Newman and his "proudest accomplishment."
Black Radical Congress News, 23 December 1999
Dr. Lenora Fulani, former presidential candidate of the now defunct New Alliance Party, and "critic" of the two party monopoly on politics in this country, recently stunned many observers by endorsing Pat Buchanan's campaign to become the Reform Party's candidate for President in the 2000 election. In rationalizing her decision to endorse one of the most rabid, racist, sexist, homophobic, right wing political figures on the political scene today, Dr. Fulani suggested that Buchanan's candidacy would be good for "independent" politics and the political fortunes of Black people.
Indeed, Dr. Fulani promised to bring Pat Buchanan to the heart of Harlem, the Capital of Black America, to dine at Sylvia's restaurant and speak at the House of Justice, the headquarter of the Rev. Al Sharpton's National Action Network. How could Dr. Fulani who claims to be a Marxist and a champion of Black causes endorse an arch adversary of Black people? From my vantage point no one should be surprised that Dr. Fulani could commit such a deplorable act. For some time, at the direction of her mentor and master Dr. Fred Newman, it appears that Dr. Fulani's services as a political operative have been for sale to the highest bidder.
As a veteran of the progressive independent political movement, when I ran for President in 1992, 1 did so in part to protect the Black community against political interlopers and pretenders like Dr. Lenora Fulani. A cursory examination of the principal Black independent political movements in the last quarter century reveal that Dr. Lenora Fulani was nowhere to be found in any of them. From the National Black Political Assembly, the National Black Independent Political Party to the National Black United Fund, there is no evidence that Dr. Fulani played any significant role in the independent Black political movement. So how did Dr. Lenora Fulani become a "prominent" Black political leader purporting to represent the interests of Black people? The Fulani phenomenon is but the latest example of a predominantly White organization utilizing a Black face, and in this instance a Black female face, to establish a base in the Black community to carry out its own political agenda.
This scheme has been aided and abetted by well meaning but gullible Black people who arc understandably so fed up with many of the current crowd of Black "leaders" and the two establishment parties that they will give an audience to anyone who offers the appearance of an alternative. Many Black women are also understandably eager to see Black women break out of the mold of simply being followers in male dominated organizations and movements to becoming leaders in political organizations and movements. Dr. Fred Newman has cleverly attempted to exploit these legitimate aspirations within the Black community.
Most knowledgeable activists have always known that Dr. Fulani's claim that the New Alliance Party (the political formation Newman created to carry out his machinations) was a Black led party was a fraudulent assertion. Fred Newman, a one-time associate of Lyndon LaRouche, has always been the headmaster of a predominantly White cult like operation, which included the New Alliance Party (NAP). Using a concept called "social therapy," which essentially proclaims that people with mental disorders can be cured through service to the movement," many of the patients of Newman's social therapy clinics became the foot soldiers of NAP. It was these foot soldiers who largely comprised the army of volunteers who successfully labored to get NAP on the ballot in all fifty states during Fulani's presidential campaigns; campaigns which may have been calculated to raise money for Newman's operations by exploiting the matching fund provisions of the federal election laws more than to promote the interests of Black people and the oppressed.
Through it all, Fulani has never been the leader of anything. She has functioned as a devout servant of Fred Newman, who once said something to the effect that, "I made her, she is my proudest accomplishment." For her part, Fulani is so mesmerized by Newman that she has praised him as a leader "who has done more for Black people than any Black leader alive." Together this odd couple has been pimping and prostituting Black folks to promote their own agenda, which mostly appears to be enriching Newman and his associates. A few years ago, Newman abruptly declared that NAP had outlived its usefulness and disbanded it. If NAP was so successful then why did Newman shut it down? Shortly after the demise NAP Fulani popped up in the camp of the billionaire right wing populist Ross Perot. Apparently Perot was eager to use Newman's foot soldiers to secure ballot status for his presidential campaign. Since that time Fulani has been deployed to mind the right wing independent movement founded by Perot. It was out of this movement and Perot's presidential campaigns that the Reform Party was founded.
Noticeably quiet for the past few years, now Newman and Fulani have resurfaced as allies and co-partners of the right wing demagogue Patrick Buchanan, political bounty hunters whose only leverage is their purported ability to field an army of foot soldiers and the claim that they can deliver Black folks to the Reform Party and Buchanan. Such is the strange career of one Lenora Fulani. Now that we know the real deal, the sham, there is no reason for Black folks to be duped by Fred Newman and his "proudest accomplishment."
Invasion of the body snatchers (1999)
By Joe Conason
Salon Magazine, November 16, 1999
When Pat Buchanan made his unholy alliance with Lenora Fulani, it wasn't the "left" he embraced but a strange, secretive group of disrupters known as the "Newmanites."
The oddest political story of the past week -- "Lenora Fulani endorses Patrick Buchanan" -- fit quite neatly into that venerable old news category known as man-bites-dog. But it was better than a mere news story, because this Reform Party love fest was so far out, so high-concept that it sounds like the synopsis for a sitcom: She's a black leftist, he's a white rightist, and now they're taking on the Establishment -- together. Fabulous!
This story line has a promising subplot, too. Dr. Fulani, as she prefers to be called, is a psychologist and one of the foremost practitioners of a controversial discipline known as "social therapy." Pat Buchanan, with his blustering manner and tendency toward bigoted wisecracks, is clearly deeply in need of counseling. Every week, the show could open in Lenora's office, with Pat stretched out on the couch, muttering about his uptight boyhood and his nostalgia for Joe McCarthy and General Franco.
Working through his hang-ups about gays, Jews, immigrants and other minorities is truly liberating for him, while his black female therapist strips away his benighted prejudices to reveal the core of humanity within him. It's sort of a '90s update of "All in the Family." Beautiful!
Yeah, the "Lenora and Pat Show" has just the right combination of humor and pathos to make wonderful American entertainment. Best of all, it's pure fantasy.
The truth about Fulani and her faction within the Reform Party is actually far more interesting than the version served up by the national media last week. The sharp-tongued therapist and her sheeplike followers have come a long way from their weird origins on Manhattan's Upper West Side, but some things haven't changed. They are as opportunistic and unprincipled as ever, and they have no real connection with "the left."
However disorganized, disunited and difficult-to-define the American left may be, virtually all of its constituencies have had at least one thing in common during the past two decades: an unfortunate encounter with the Fulani faction, which has traveled under a variety of names and disguises since it first appeared in New York during the 1970s.
Liberal and left-wing Democratic clubs, gay rights groups, black community organizations and many others have been infiltrated, disrupted and denounced by the "social therapists," who have then moved on to their next project.
Before Fulani's outfit merged themselves into the Reform Party several years ago, they were known as the New Alliance Party, but their murky origins stretch all the way back to the early '70s. That was when a philosophy teacher at City College named Fred Newman, who at age 64 is still believed to control the group, began to formulate his own theory of politically-tinged psychotherapy.
Among his small group of acolytes, Newman developed a guru status that apparently permitted him to build what is now a substantial network therapy centers and related cultural and political institutions. Therapy patients were encouraged, and some say coerced, into giving time and money to whatever political formation Newman and his fellow "therapists" were operating at the time.
Lenora Fulani joined up in the late '70s and was soon elevated to a leadership position. Given the quasi-Marxist and feminist pretensions of Newman and his colleagues, a black female like Fulani provided the perfect public face. But the secret inner leadership of the organization remained wholly under Newman's control, with many of its members taking their mandated "therapy" directly from him. Because they have changed their organizational moniker so many times, those who follow their antics refer to them as "the Newmanites."
From the beginning, the nominally left-wing Newmanites had an antagonistic relationship with their comrades in other groups. For a tumultuous period in the early '70s, Newman brought his followers into the even more cult-like National Caucus of Labor Committees, where Lyndon LaRouche was engaged in his own peculiar exercises in therapy and thought control.
At the time, LaRouche's NCLC was notorious for attacking left groups not only with propaganda but physical violence. After a few months, Newman grew tired of taking orders from LaRouche and withdrew to create his own organization again. And ever since, in New York and elsewhere, the Newmanites have clashed with various leftists and liberals, usually over charges that they had attempted to take over some organization or campaign for their own purposes.
During the late '70s and early '80s, they pursued a strategy of simultaneously joining and attacking Democratic clubs in New York City. They were subsequently expelled from a short-lived New York leftist effort called the Unity Party. Then for a time they sought a coalition with the Nation of Islam, defending Louis Farrakhan against charges of homophobia and anti-Semitism (with Newman giving one speech in which he denounced Jews as "the storm troopers of decadent capitalism").
After the 1988 presidential campaign, the Newmanites had a tense relationship with Jesse Jackson's Rainbow Coalition, which they first infiltrated and then mimicked by setting up a front called the "Rainbow Lobby." The resulting confusion led Jackson to publicly dissociate himself from them on more than one occasion, while they repudiated him as a "sellout."
And then in 1992, when they perceived a potential for new mischief in the Reform Party, they disbanded the New Alliance Party altogether and allied themselves with conservative billionaire Ross Perot.
Throughout these permutations, Fulani has always articulated a leftish perspective on such topics as gay rights, affirmative action and economic justice. Her high-minded rhetoric, combined with a corps of dedicated activists, lawyers and writers drawn from the "social therapy" clientele, has afforded her group significant leverage within the Reform Party, particularly in New York, where Perot's supporters are known as the Independence Party.
In a fledgling party that attracts thousands of inexperienced newcomers, the organizing muscle and political skill of the Newmanites provides them with influence disproportionate to their actual size. Moderate and conservative activists in the Reform Party have, not surprisingly, viewed the rise of this internal faction with undisguised dismay. Buchanan's embrace of Fulani won't endear him to them. And it is probably safe to predict that before the campaign is over, or soon afterward, the Newmanites will be denouncing Buchanan as a fascist, a racist and an enemy of independent politics.
Despite the media spin, nobody who has observed the Newmanites during their long and tortured history was shocked when they joined forces with the hero of the ultra-right. Repeatedly rejected by every element of the left, they finally took their tactics and therapy to another venue. Their quest for power has taken them from LaRouche to Farrakhan to Buchanan -- a long, strange trip into the wilderness, with no left turns anywhere along the way.
Salon Magazine, November 16, 1999
When Pat Buchanan made his unholy alliance with Lenora Fulani, it wasn't the "left" he embraced but a strange, secretive group of disrupters known as the "Newmanites."
The oddest political story of the past week -- "Lenora Fulani endorses Patrick Buchanan" -- fit quite neatly into that venerable old news category known as man-bites-dog. But it was better than a mere news story, because this Reform Party love fest was so far out, so high-concept that it sounds like the synopsis for a sitcom: She's a black leftist, he's a white rightist, and now they're taking on the Establishment -- together. Fabulous!
This story line has a promising subplot, too. Dr. Fulani, as she prefers to be called, is a psychologist and one of the foremost practitioners of a controversial discipline known as "social therapy." Pat Buchanan, with his blustering manner and tendency toward bigoted wisecracks, is clearly deeply in need of counseling. Every week, the show could open in Lenora's office, with Pat stretched out on the couch, muttering about his uptight boyhood and his nostalgia for Joe McCarthy and General Franco.
Working through his hang-ups about gays, Jews, immigrants and other minorities is truly liberating for him, while his black female therapist strips away his benighted prejudices to reveal the core of humanity within him. It's sort of a '90s update of "All in the Family." Beautiful!
Yeah, the "Lenora and Pat Show" has just the right combination of humor and pathos to make wonderful American entertainment. Best of all, it's pure fantasy.
The truth about Fulani and her faction within the Reform Party is actually far more interesting than the version served up by the national media last week. The sharp-tongued therapist and her sheeplike followers have come a long way from their weird origins on Manhattan's Upper West Side, but some things haven't changed. They are as opportunistic and unprincipled as ever, and they have no real connection with "the left."
However disorganized, disunited and difficult-to-define the American left may be, virtually all of its constituencies have had at least one thing in common during the past two decades: an unfortunate encounter with the Fulani faction, which has traveled under a variety of names and disguises since it first appeared in New York during the 1970s.
Liberal and left-wing Democratic clubs, gay rights groups, black community organizations and many others have been infiltrated, disrupted and denounced by the "social therapists," who have then moved on to their next project.
Before Fulani's outfit merged themselves into the Reform Party several years ago, they were known as the New Alliance Party, but their murky origins stretch all the way back to the early '70s. That was when a philosophy teacher at City College named Fred Newman, who at age 64 is still believed to control the group, began to formulate his own theory of politically-tinged psychotherapy.
Among his small group of acolytes, Newman developed a guru status that apparently permitted him to build what is now a substantial network therapy centers and related cultural and political institutions. Therapy patients were encouraged, and some say coerced, into giving time and money to whatever political formation Newman and his fellow "therapists" were operating at the time.
Lenora Fulani joined up in the late '70s and was soon elevated to a leadership position. Given the quasi-Marxist and feminist pretensions of Newman and his colleagues, a black female like Fulani provided the perfect public face. But the secret inner leadership of the organization remained wholly under Newman's control, with many of its members taking their mandated "therapy" directly from him. Because they have changed their organizational moniker so many times, those who follow their antics refer to them as "the Newmanites."
From the beginning, the nominally left-wing Newmanites had an antagonistic relationship with their comrades in other groups. For a tumultuous period in the early '70s, Newman brought his followers into the even more cult-like National Caucus of Labor Committees, where Lyndon LaRouche was engaged in his own peculiar exercises in therapy and thought control.
At the time, LaRouche's NCLC was notorious for attacking left groups not only with propaganda but physical violence. After a few months, Newman grew tired of taking orders from LaRouche and withdrew to create his own organization again. And ever since, in New York and elsewhere, the Newmanites have clashed with various leftists and liberals, usually over charges that they had attempted to take over some organization or campaign for their own purposes.
During the late '70s and early '80s, they pursued a strategy of simultaneously joining and attacking Democratic clubs in New York City. They were subsequently expelled from a short-lived New York leftist effort called the Unity Party. Then for a time they sought a coalition with the Nation of Islam, defending Louis Farrakhan against charges of homophobia and anti-Semitism (with Newman giving one speech in which he denounced Jews as "the storm troopers of decadent capitalism").
After the 1988 presidential campaign, the Newmanites had a tense relationship with Jesse Jackson's Rainbow Coalition, which they first infiltrated and then mimicked by setting up a front called the "Rainbow Lobby." The resulting confusion led Jackson to publicly dissociate himself from them on more than one occasion, while they repudiated him as a "sellout."
And then in 1992, when they perceived a potential for new mischief in the Reform Party, they disbanded the New Alliance Party altogether and allied themselves with conservative billionaire Ross Perot.
Throughout these permutations, Fulani has always articulated a leftish perspective on such topics as gay rights, affirmative action and economic justice. Her high-minded rhetoric, combined with a corps of dedicated activists, lawyers and writers drawn from the "social therapy" clientele, has afforded her group significant leverage within the Reform Party, particularly in New York, where Perot's supporters are known as the Independence Party.
In a fledgling party that attracts thousands of inexperienced newcomers, the organizing muscle and political skill of the Newmanites provides them with influence disproportionate to their actual size. Moderate and conservative activists in the Reform Party have, not surprisingly, viewed the rise of this internal faction with undisguised dismay. Buchanan's embrace of Fulani won't endear him to them. And it is probably safe to predict that before the campaign is over, or soon afterward, the Newmanites will be denouncing Buchanan as a fascist, a racist and an enemy of independent politics.
Despite the media spin, nobody who has observed the Newmanites during their long and tortured history was shocked when they joined forces with the hero of the ultra-right. Repeatedly rejected by every element of the left, they finally took their tactics and therapy to another venue. Their quest for power has taken them from LaRouche to Farrakhan to Buchanan -- a long, strange trip into the wilderness, with no left turns anywhere along the way.
Guru Fred Newman Enchants Loyal Followers and Pat Buchanan (1999)
By George Gurley
The New York Observer, December 6, 1999
Right now, Fred Newman is best known as the man behind Lenora Fulani, an African-American psychologist and two-time Presidential candidate who is a major force in the Reform Party. Recently, Mr. Newman and Ms. Fulani had lunch at the Essex House with Pat Buchanan, who is hoping to be the Reform Party's candidate for President. Ms. Fulani ended up endorsing him and is now his campaign co-chair. All this resulted in jeers, derision, comparisons to the Hitler-Stalin pact, a lot of publicity for Ms. Fulani & and a few mentions in the press of that character in the shadows, Mr. Newman.
Mr. Newman, 64, is a psychotherapist, playwright and self-styled Marxist revolutionary whose organization has its headquarters at 500 Greenwich Street. Every few years, journalists take him apart and repeat accusations (he's an anti-Semite, he runs a cult, he brainwashes people, etc.), but somehow he survives and prospers.
He presides over what he calls "a development community." It's made up of a small clique of members who've been following Mr. Newman for decades and a couple hundred worker bees who have joined more recently. Together, Mr. Newman and his followers run therapy centers around the country, as well as a theater and a talent show network for inner-city kids.
As you get off the elevator at the Greenwich Street headquarters, to the left is the East Side Center for Short-Term Social Therapy, to the right is the Castillo Theater (most recent production: Mr. Newman's musical comedy, The Last Temptation of William Jefferson) and beyond that is a telemarketing room, where volunteers raise money every evening.
It doesn't feel like New York City in there, but more like a community arts center in the Midwest. You see beaming faces, normal faces and a few blank ones, too.
On a Friday afternoon, Gabrielle Kurlander, 36, was sitting on a couch in her office. She acts in and directs Mr. Newman's plays. Since 1990, she has run the All-Stars Talent Show Network.
Ms. Kurlander was wearing a Giorgio Armani pinstripe jacket, black sweater, black skirt. Behind her were some of Mr. Newman's books - among them, Let's Develop!, in which he lays out his philosophy and offers handy exercises like: "Do something wrong just for the sake of saying 'I was completely wrong!'"
Ms. Kurlander said she moved to Manhattan from Ithaca, N.Y., to be an actress. She soon found a place in the community and began pounding nails, sweeping floors, recruiting and attending group therapy sessions led by Mr. Newman, who became her boyfriend 11 years ago.
"He's somebody that I'm very, very close to and have tremendous respect for," Ms. Kurlander said. "I think he's very, very smart." She laughed. "He's not a guru, he's not a cult leader, he's just someone who people follow," Ms. Kurlander said. "There is a grouping of us who've given our lives to this. I get paid now. I didn't used to get paid, and probably if I wasn't paid tomorrow, I'd still be doing this."
Roger Grunwald, the publicist for the Newman group, was present for the interview with Ms. Kurlander, taking notes on a yellow pad.
Enter Mr. Newman, wearing a leather jacket over a button-down shirt, green slacks and New Balance running shoes. Early on, he talked about Pat Buchanan: "I hardly know him," Mr. Newman said. "He seems like a decent man. Pat, when he was a kid, he was a tough Irish working-class kid who beat everyone up."
Ms. Kurlander howled at the remark.
Mr. Newman said he likes Mr. Buchanan's "smarts" and doesn't think he's an anti-Semite: "I'm a Jew, a Jew all my life, and I can smell anti-Semites. He doesn't smell like an anti-Semite."
Mr. Newman, who has long supported the Palestine Liberation Organization and criticized the American Jewish establishment, has also been called an anti-Semite. In 1985, he told a convention that Jews "are the stormtroopers of decadent capitalism against people of color the world over."
"I'm hardly an anti-Semite, which is what I've been charged with," he said. "But it's been played up and it plays well for political purposes in some people's hands and people make use of it and I'm not complaining."
Mr. Newman then held forth on a number of subjects, including Donald Trump's "soak the rich" plan. (Doesn't go far enough, he said.) Ms. Kurlander laughed when appropriate; Mr. Grunwald was silent for the 45-minute session.
I suggested that Mr. Newman and I might be left alone, which Ms. Kurlander found very amusing: "Would you prefer that? Ha-ha-ha-ha! Have a private interview?"
Mr. Newman put Karl Marx at the top of his list of thinkers. "Marx's thought has so permeated all of sociology," he said. "And Bill Clinton is a Marxist. It's taught in all the schools, whether it's called that or not."
Will his own work survive?
"History will let us know whether it's worth anything or nothing, and we say that to each other constantly & Yes! I think it will survive."
Fred Newman, whatever he is, has had an amazing New York life. He was born in 1935. His father, a salesman, died when he was 9. His mother raised five kids on welfare and ran serious poker games and rented out rooms in their house a half-block from Yankee Stadium. Mr. Newman sold baseball stuff there and his mother would talk to players like Mickey Mantle and Yogi Berra as they walked by; the players called her Grandma Sadie.
He hated school, but tested well enough to get into Stuyvesant High School. At 19, he volunteered to serve in Korea, partly to escape a painful love affair. Back home, he attended City College of New York, majored in philosophy, married at 22, lost his virginity and got into Stanford University, where he earned a doctorate in philosophy.
Then he started teaching at City College. In 1966, one of his students asked for an A to avoid the draft. Professor Newman said O.K., started giving A's to everyone, and was eventually fired from six more schools around the country.
By this time, he and his wife had two kids. (His son was severely brain damaged at birth and has spent his life in an institution.) In 1967, Mr. Newman moved to Reno, Nev., for divorce purposes. He took long naps, watched the sun set, listened to the Beatles, drank a little bit, didn't smoke pot and tried to be a writer.
He would wake up at 5:30 A.M. to work on a novel based on his mother, In the Purple Roses of Her Dying Years. Somehow it got into the hands of family members and they hated it.
Back in New York, Mr. Newman went to protests, started a political collective called "If & Then." He read Karl Marx, Mao Zedong and Leon Trotsky, saw a therapist, became a drug rehabilitation counselor at a Queens clinic, which fired him after he organized a work stoppage. In 1970, he started up a therapy practice of his own. And that's when it all started really happening for him.
"Suddenly, I was making money again, more than I'd ever made in my life," he said. He and some comrades created a therapeutic community on the Upper West Side, Centers for Change. They put out two newspapers, Unite and Right on Time, and started a free school for kids and a dental clinic.
"It's probably fair to say I was the dominant leader," Mr. Newman said. "& It's probably fair to say it was my followingpeople were following me. I hope I wasn't an authoritarian oppressor, but I think that's probably accurate to say that."
He and his "following" joined up with Lyndon LaRouche, but pulled out in 1974 to form the International Workers Party, which aimed to organize welfare recipients. Party members raised money on the sidewalks of the Upper West Side.
In 1979, his group evolved into the New Alliance Party; in 1984, it ran a candidate for President. That was Dennis Serrette, a black activist and trade union leader from Harlem.
"Fred was introduced to me at a party," said Mr. Serrette, 59, from his Maryland home. "His persona is a warm, sensitive, sort of jolly, twinkly Santa Claus kind of guy, one that seems always to be a good listener. Then you start figuring out that this thing is not so loose as it looks, it's a lot tighter. Then, when you try to look under the skirt of what's happening, you begin to look a little sharper and you hear the name Fred Newman, Fred this and Fred that, and then you start to say, Well, is this guy the messiah or what?"
Mr. Serrette said he was badgered into Mr. Newman's brand of "social therapy."
"It was like a piranha attack and they all take a bite out of you," he said. "It's like a police interrogation but not with two - you got 10 bad guys biting at you, until they sort of break your spirit or break you down. The women around Newman who carry out his bidding are the ones that really are the lieutenants, they'll smile at you but they kick ass. But he never gets his hands dirty "he always manages to stay just beyond the fray of the fight. He will never engage you in hard discussions. The reality is he's a shrewd tactician who runs the cult through his mistresses."
According to Mr. Newman's spokesman, Roger Grunwald, "Dennis Serrette ended his association with Fred Newman and Lenora Fulani 15 years ago, after his personal relationship with Dr. Fulani broke up. Since then he periodically pops up to be interviewed and to grind a very old ax."
In 1988, Ms. Fulani ran for President and got on the ballot in all 50 states in the race. "I am your sexual preference," went one slogan. That got the Party some attention, as did its embrace of Louis Farrakhan.
On a Thursday evening, 30 or so people were gathered in the center's "telemarketing room" to call "old friends" for money. They were buzzing about over takeout dinners and bottled water. "Volunteer of the Month" plaques were up on a wall.
At 6:30, as the spokesman Mr. Grunwald looked on, three middle-aged women answered questions. They'd all been through Mr. Newman's brand of therapy and said they worked the phones four times a week. One of them, Phyllis Goldberg, said someone handed her a flier on the street and she'd been there for 21 years.
"He's hilariously funny," Ms. Goldberg said of Mr. Newman. "He's probably the kindest person I ever met. He's shy. He's very, very, very smart."
The telemarketers got into their "performance spaces" and got their three-page scripts ready.
Doug Balder, an architect, said he does four or five shifts a week and raises up to $100,000 a year for the Newman group. He has been there 16 years.
Mr. Grunwald said to me after a while: "George, ever done something like this?" he said, smiling, headset on. "You can come back another time, we'll train you." Soon, he led me to the elevator. "There are a lot of people around here who don't make phone calls," he said. "But for the people who do it, they've been organized in such a way that they relate to it in the way that a person would relate to theatrical activity as a member of an ensemble. They're all working collectively."
"They would embrace Adolf Hitler if it would give them credibility," said ex-Newman follower Judi Miller, a writer. Feeling "very lonely" and "isolated," she said she joined the community in 1984 at the suggestion of her dentist. She stuffed envelopes, attended therapy sessions, sold ad space for the New Alliance newspaper. She also agreed to pay a "tithe" and reduce her lithium dosage. Over all, she lasted four years.
"I was one of the only ones not to give up my apartment, and I didn't, because it's rent-controlled, so that would be stupid," she said.
(According to Mr. Grunwald, "These allegations are ridiculous, untrue and politically motivated.")
What did Ms. Miller think of Dr. Newman?
"Don't say doctor," Ms. Miller said. "It's just Fred Newman or Fred. He's not anything to be respected, he's a bullshit artist & You know how you realize things and you have little signals that something's wrong here? Like, well, he's not our lord and master. There's something wrong with this man. It was ridiculous. It was just so dumb. I'm ashamed that I belonged to that group and I was duped."
One of the people who helped in her two-year "detox" was Chip Berlet, of the Boston-based Political Research Associates. Mr. Berlet has studied and condemned Mr. Newman and his group: "He thinks of himself as being one of the great left thinkers of our age," he said. "He's actually kind of a pompous egomaniac. He's surrounded himself with people who constantly are telling him how smart he is, which is the classic aspect of a totalitarian organization."
Mr. Grunwald was ready for that charge: "Chip Berlet works for a left wing think tank that has received substantial funding from major Democratic Party donors," he said. "His charges have long been discredited as partisan `dirty tricks' directed against the independent political movement."
Fred Newman has been ill for the last five years, with diabetes, hypertension and kidney failure. Before undergoing three hours of dialysis, he met me for lunch at the Manatus Restaurant on Bleecker Street. His large blue eyes have a dizzying effect behind the wire-rimmed glasses. "Our work is, I don't want to misrepresent it, it's not Freud," he said. "But it's been accepted by a lot of very, very mainstream, good people."
He said he rejects the idea of the self, along with addiction, victimization and Freud's notion of the human being as fundamentally abnormal. He thinks people are "super-alienated" these days.
"Most of the people I see in therapy," he said, "they have good jobs, they're doing well, they're respectable people. They're the people who, you're walking down the street you're walking by. They're not weirdos, they're not in Bellevue, they're desperately unhappy."
When he's not working, Mr. Newman watches sports and political shows, PBS, and Charlie Rose and watches videos at home. His favorite movie ever is Marcel Carne's Les Enfants du Paradis.
"The character who plays the mime, I don't relate to it," he said. "Like I don't think it's me, but I feel an empathy for the tragedy of his life. By the fact that he's this brilliant, extraordinarily gifted performer but his life is so openly unfulfilling. He can't live in the real world. In some ways he can only fully live in his world of fantasy and I wouldn't say I see that as how I am, but I feel close to that."
Mr. Newman rents a place in the Hamptons every summer and writes out there. He has an assistant who drives him around in a rented Lincoln Town car. He said he once took Al Sharpton to the hospital after he was stabbed and met with Louis Farrakhan twice.
"I found him a very personable, decent man," he said. "I didn't have any sense at all of him being anti-Semitic."
Mr. Newman ordered a piece of rye toast and a mint tea with lemon. "I can't really eat anymore," he said. "I used to be bigger and much heavier. I barely eat now."
He never wears coats in the winter. He's social, likes people coming over, but doesn't like getting dressed up.
"Gabrielle wanted to put some gel in my hair, so I look better, and I still find that unpleasant," he said.
Mr. Newman likes bluegrass music, plays a little piano and guitar. Carousel may be his favorite musical. He doesn't like Mayor Giuliani.
"I think he's taken too much credit and he's been racially divisive," he said. "I don't think he's a particularly good man."
He wishes the Giants and Dodgers were still in New York. And he's always loved sex: "I've always enjoyed it and always had an appetite. I wouldn't describe it as in any way abnormal. I think I've had sex as often as the situation called for and the other person wanted it and I wanted it, ha-ha! I think of myself as a sexual person. I like to think I'm not as abusive as men [can be]. Maybe that's not true, not for me to say. I work hard not to be abusive toward women, I have a high regard for women. Women have played a really important role in my life. A lot of the good work in the creating of the community has been done by brilliant and powerful women."
In American history, he admires Eugene B. Debs and is "a little partial" to Thomas Paine. He hopes the American people pick up the issue of political reform.
"I live well," he said. But he claimed he wasn't even sure if he has a bank account, and said he doesn't know what an A.T.M. is. His assistant gives him money. He said he has made a fair amount from therapy, but put his personal net worth at less than a million. In fact, it's "nothing," he said.
He lives in an ivy-covered brownstone in Greenwich Village, which he co-purchased with a female friend for $920,000 in 1993. Mr. Newman lives in a unit with Ms. Kurlander. The rest of the place is occupied by two men and nine women, some of whom Mr. Newman has been involved with over the years.
"I feel very good and proud about it," he said. "I think it's disgraceful the way people who have intimate relationships break up and then hate each other for life. I find that very offensive."
I said his living arrangements sounded like every man's dream.
"These are my dearest, dearest friends and colleges, co-workers," he said, "who've invested millions of hours to build the All-Stars Talent Show Network. That's who we're talking about here, and many of these people are women, and in the case of some of them, but not all of them, we've been close in all kinds of ways, including physically, and I feel thrilled about that."
He continued: "It's not a harem of people, it's a collection of human beings, some of whom are brilliant psychologists, heads of medical services of Long Island community hospital, vice presidents of major companies. That's who they are, and they have an integrity as that. They're not just women to have sex with."
After we'd been talking about an hour, Mr. Newman told me he cries fairly often.
"I cry every time I see movies," he said. "I'm a movie crier, I cry all the time. I certainly cried during Gods and Monsters. I thought that was very touching, their relationship. I'm kind of a sucker for romantic kind of things. When movies get touching and romantic, I cry. There's a movie with Richard Gere and Julia Roberts, their comeback movie."
It was time for a nap before dialysis.
"It's been a good life," he said. "I've been very fortunate and I don't mind talking about it."
The New York Observer, December 6, 1999
Right now, Fred Newman is best known as the man behind Lenora Fulani, an African-American psychologist and two-time Presidential candidate who is a major force in the Reform Party. Recently, Mr. Newman and Ms. Fulani had lunch at the Essex House with Pat Buchanan, who is hoping to be the Reform Party's candidate for President. Ms. Fulani ended up endorsing him and is now his campaign co-chair. All this resulted in jeers, derision, comparisons to the Hitler-Stalin pact, a lot of publicity for Ms. Fulani & and a few mentions in the press of that character in the shadows, Mr. Newman.
Mr. Newman, 64, is a psychotherapist, playwright and self-styled Marxist revolutionary whose organization has its headquarters at 500 Greenwich Street. Every few years, journalists take him apart and repeat accusations (he's an anti-Semite, he runs a cult, he brainwashes people, etc.), but somehow he survives and prospers.
He presides over what he calls "a development community." It's made up of a small clique of members who've been following Mr. Newman for decades and a couple hundred worker bees who have joined more recently. Together, Mr. Newman and his followers run therapy centers around the country, as well as a theater and a talent show network for inner-city kids.
As you get off the elevator at the Greenwich Street headquarters, to the left is the East Side Center for Short-Term Social Therapy, to the right is the Castillo Theater (most recent production: Mr. Newman's musical comedy, The Last Temptation of William Jefferson) and beyond that is a telemarketing room, where volunteers raise money every evening.
It doesn't feel like New York City in there, but more like a community arts center in the Midwest. You see beaming faces, normal faces and a few blank ones, too.
On a Friday afternoon, Gabrielle Kurlander, 36, was sitting on a couch in her office. She acts in and directs Mr. Newman's plays. Since 1990, she has run the All-Stars Talent Show Network.
Ms. Kurlander was wearing a Giorgio Armani pinstripe jacket, black sweater, black skirt. Behind her were some of Mr. Newman's books - among them, Let's Develop!, in which he lays out his philosophy and offers handy exercises like: "Do something wrong just for the sake of saying 'I was completely wrong!'"
Ms. Kurlander said she moved to Manhattan from Ithaca, N.Y., to be an actress. She soon found a place in the community and began pounding nails, sweeping floors, recruiting and attending group therapy sessions led by Mr. Newman, who became her boyfriend 11 years ago.
"He's somebody that I'm very, very close to and have tremendous respect for," Ms. Kurlander said. "I think he's very, very smart." She laughed. "He's not a guru, he's not a cult leader, he's just someone who people follow," Ms. Kurlander said. "There is a grouping of us who've given our lives to this. I get paid now. I didn't used to get paid, and probably if I wasn't paid tomorrow, I'd still be doing this."
Roger Grunwald, the publicist for the Newman group, was present for the interview with Ms. Kurlander, taking notes on a yellow pad.
Enter Mr. Newman, wearing a leather jacket over a button-down shirt, green slacks and New Balance running shoes. Early on, he talked about Pat Buchanan: "I hardly know him," Mr. Newman said. "He seems like a decent man. Pat, when he was a kid, he was a tough Irish working-class kid who beat everyone up."
Ms. Kurlander howled at the remark.
Mr. Newman said he likes Mr. Buchanan's "smarts" and doesn't think he's an anti-Semite: "I'm a Jew, a Jew all my life, and I can smell anti-Semites. He doesn't smell like an anti-Semite."
Mr. Newman, who has long supported the Palestine Liberation Organization and criticized the American Jewish establishment, has also been called an anti-Semite. In 1985, he told a convention that Jews "are the stormtroopers of decadent capitalism against people of color the world over."
"I'm hardly an anti-Semite, which is what I've been charged with," he said. "But it's been played up and it plays well for political purposes in some people's hands and people make use of it and I'm not complaining."
Mr. Newman then held forth on a number of subjects, including Donald Trump's "soak the rich" plan. (Doesn't go far enough, he said.) Ms. Kurlander laughed when appropriate; Mr. Grunwald was silent for the 45-minute session.
I suggested that Mr. Newman and I might be left alone, which Ms. Kurlander found very amusing: "Would you prefer that? Ha-ha-ha-ha! Have a private interview?"
Mr. Newman put Karl Marx at the top of his list of thinkers. "Marx's thought has so permeated all of sociology," he said. "And Bill Clinton is a Marxist. It's taught in all the schools, whether it's called that or not."
Will his own work survive?
"History will let us know whether it's worth anything or nothing, and we say that to each other constantly & Yes! I think it will survive."
Fred Newman, whatever he is, has had an amazing New York life. He was born in 1935. His father, a salesman, died when he was 9. His mother raised five kids on welfare and ran serious poker games and rented out rooms in their house a half-block from Yankee Stadium. Mr. Newman sold baseball stuff there and his mother would talk to players like Mickey Mantle and Yogi Berra as they walked by; the players called her Grandma Sadie.
He hated school, but tested well enough to get into Stuyvesant High School. At 19, he volunteered to serve in Korea, partly to escape a painful love affair. Back home, he attended City College of New York, majored in philosophy, married at 22, lost his virginity and got into Stanford University, where he earned a doctorate in philosophy.
Then he started teaching at City College. In 1966, one of his students asked for an A to avoid the draft. Professor Newman said O.K., started giving A's to everyone, and was eventually fired from six more schools around the country.
By this time, he and his wife had two kids. (His son was severely brain damaged at birth and has spent his life in an institution.) In 1967, Mr. Newman moved to Reno, Nev., for divorce purposes. He took long naps, watched the sun set, listened to the Beatles, drank a little bit, didn't smoke pot and tried to be a writer.
He would wake up at 5:30 A.M. to work on a novel based on his mother, In the Purple Roses of Her Dying Years. Somehow it got into the hands of family members and they hated it.
Back in New York, Mr. Newman went to protests, started a political collective called "If & Then." He read Karl Marx, Mao Zedong and Leon Trotsky, saw a therapist, became a drug rehabilitation counselor at a Queens clinic, which fired him after he organized a work stoppage. In 1970, he started up a therapy practice of his own. And that's when it all started really happening for him.
"Suddenly, I was making money again, more than I'd ever made in my life," he said. He and some comrades created a therapeutic community on the Upper West Side, Centers for Change. They put out two newspapers, Unite and Right on Time, and started a free school for kids and a dental clinic.
"It's probably fair to say I was the dominant leader," Mr. Newman said. "& It's probably fair to say it was my followingpeople were following me. I hope I wasn't an authoritarian oppressor, but I think that's probably accurate to say that."
He and his "following" joined up with Lyndon LaRouche, but pulled out in 1974 to form the International Workers Party, which aimed to organize welfare recipients. Party members raised money on the sidewalks of the Upper West Side.
In 1979, his group evolved into the New Alliance Party; in 1984, it ran a candidate for President. That was Dennis Serrette, a black activist and trade union leader from Harlem.
"Fred was introduced to me at a party," said Mr. Serrette, 59, from his Maryland home. "His persona is a warm, sensitive, sort of jolly, twinkly Santa Claus kind of guy, one that seems always to be a good listener. Then you start figuring out that this thing is not so loose as it looks, it's a lot tighter. Then, when you try to look under the skirt of what's happening, you begin to look a little sharper and you hear the name Fred Newman, Fred this and Fred that, and then you start to say, Well, is this guy the messiah or what?"
Mr. Serrette said he was badgered into Mr. Newman's brand of "social therapy."
"It was like a piranha attack and they all take a bite out of you," he said. "It's like a police interrogation but not with two - you got 10 bad guys biting at you, until they sort of break your spirit or break you down. The women around Newman who carry out his bidding are the ones that really are the lieutenants, they'll smile at you but they kick ass. But he never gets his hands dirty "he always manages to stay just beyond the fray of the fight. He will never engage you in hard discussions. The reality is he's a shrewd tactician who runs the cult through his mistresses."
According to Mr. Newman's spokesman, Roger Grunwald, "Dennis Serrette ended his association with Fred Newman and Lenora Fulani 15 years ago, after his personal relationship with Dr. Fulani broke up. Since then he periodically pops up to be interviewed and to grind a very old ax."
In 1988, Ms. Fulani ran for President and got on the ballot in all 50 states in the race. "I am your sexual preference," went one slogan. That got the Party some attention, as did its embrace of Louis Farrakhan.
On a Thursday evening, 30 or so people were gathered in the center's "telemarketing room" to call "old friends" for money. They were buzzing about over takeout dinners and bottled water. "Volunteer of the Month" plaques were up on a wall.
At 6:30, as the spokesman Mr. Grunwald looked on, three middle-aged women answered questions. They'd all been through Mr. Newman's brand of therapy and said they worked the phones four times a week. One of them, Phyllis Goldberg, said someone handed her a flier on the street and she'd been there for 21 years.
"He's hilariously funny," Ms. Goldberg said of Mr. Newman. "He's probably the kindest person I ever met. He's shy. He's very, very, very smart."
The telemarketers got into their "performance spaces" and got their three-page scripts ready.
Doug Balder, an architect, said he does four or five shifts a week and raises up to $100,000 a year for the Newman group. He has been there 16 years.
Mr. Grunwald said to me after a while: "George, ever done something like this?" he said, smiling, headset on. "You can come back another time, we'll train you." Soon, he led me to the elevator. "There are a lot of people around here who don't make phone calls," he said. "But for the people who do it, they've been organized in such a way that they relate to it in the way that a person would relate to theatrical activity as a member of an ensemble. They're all working collectively."
"They would embrace Adolf Hitler if it would give them credibility," said ex-Newman follower Judi Miller, a writer. Feeling "very lonely" and "isolated," she said she joined the community in 1984 at the suggestion of her dentist. She stuffed envelopes, attended therapy sessions, sold ad space for the New Alliance newspaper. She also agreed to pay a "tithe" and reduce her lithium dosage. Over all, she lasted four years.
"I was one of the only ones not to give up my apartment, and I didn't, because it's rent-controlled, so that would be stupid," she said.
(According to Mr. Grunwald, "These allegations are ridiculous, untrue and politically motivated.")
What did Ms. Miller think of Dr. Newman?
"Don't say doctor," Ms. Miller said. "It's just Fred Newman or Fred. He's not anything to be respected, he's a bullshit artist & You know how you realize things and you have little signals that something's wrong here? Like, well, he's not our lord and master. There's something wrong with this man. It was ridiculous. It was just so dumb. I'm ashamed that I belonged to that group and I was duped."
One of the people who helped in her two-year "detox" was Chip Berlet, of the Boston-based Political Research Associates. Mr. Berlet has studied and condemned Mr. Newman and his group: "He thinks of himself as being one of the great left thinkers of our age," he said. "He's actually kind of a pompous egomaniac. He's surrounded himself with people who constantly are telling him how smart he is, which is the classic aspect of a totalitarian organization."
Mr. Grunwald was ready for that charge: "Chip Berlet works for a left wing think tank that has received substantial funding from major Democratic Party donors," he said. "His charges have long been discredited as partisan `dirty tricks' directed against the independent political movement."
Fred Newman has been ill for the last five years, with diabetes, hypertension and kidney failure. Before undergoing three hours of dialysis, he met me for lunch at the Manatus Restaurant on Bleecker Street. His large blue eyes have a dizzying effect behind the wire-rimmed glasses. "Our work is, I don't want to misrepresent it, it's not Freud," he said. "But it's been accepted by a lot of very, very mainstream, good people."
He said he rejects the idea of the self, along with addiction, victimization and Freud's notion of the human being as fundamentally abnormal. He thinks people are "super-alienated" these days.
"Most of the people I see in therapy," he said, "they have good jobs, they're doing well, they're respectable people. They're the people who, you're walking down the street you're walking by. They're not weirdos, they're not in Bellevue, they're desperately unhappy."
When he's not working, Mr. Newman watches sports and political shows, PBS, and Charlie Rose and watches videos at home. His favorite movie ever is Marcel Carne's Les Enfants du Paradis.
"The character who plays the mime, I don't relate to it," he said. "Like I don't think it's me, but I feel an empathy for the tragedy of his life. By the fact that he's this brilliant, extraordinarily gifted performer but his life is so openly unfulfilling. He can't live in the real world. In some ways he can only fully live in his world of fantasy and I wouldn't say I see that as how I am, but I feel close to that."
Mr. Newman rents a place in the Hamptons every summer and writes out there. He has an assistant who drives him around in a rented Lincoln Town car. He said he once took Al Sharpton to the hospital after he was stabbed and met with Louis Farrakhan twice.
"I found him a very personable, decent man," he said. "I didn't have any sense at all of him being anti-Semitic."
Mr. Newman ordered a piece of rye toast and a mint tea with lemon. "I can't really eat anymore," he said. "I used to be bigger and much heavier. I barely eat now."
He never wears coats in the winter. He's social, likes people coming over, but doesn't like getting dressed up.
"Gabrielle wanted to put some gel in my hair, so I look better, and I still find that unpleasant," he said.
Mr. Newman likes bluegrass music, plays a little piano and guitar. Carousel may be his favorite musical. He doesn't like Mayor Giuliani.
"I think he's taken too much credit and he's been racially divisive," he said. "I don't think he's a particularly good man."
He wishes the Giants and Dodgers were still in New York. And he's always loved sex: "I've always enjoyed it and always had an appetite. I wouldn't describe it as in any way abnormal. I think I've had sex as often as the situation called for and the other person wanted it and I wanted it, ha-ha! I think of myself as a sexual person. I like to think I'm not as abusive as men [can be]. Maybe that's not true, not for me to say. I work hard not to be abusive toward women, I have a high regard for women. Women have played a really important role in my life. A lot of the good work in the creating of the community has been done by brilliant and powerful women."
In American history, he admires Eugene B. Debs and is "a little partial" to Thomas Paine. He hopes the American people pick up the issue of political reform.
"I live well," he said. But he claimed he wasn't even sure if he has a bank account, and said he doesn't know what an A.T.M. is. His assistant gives him money. He said he has made a fair amount from therapy, but put his personal net worth at less than a million. In fact, it's "nothing," he said.
He lives in an ivy-covered brownstone in Greenwich Village, which he co-purchased with a female friend for $920,000 in 1993. Mr. Newman lives in a unit with Ms. Kurlander. The rest of the place is occupied by two men and nine women, some of whom Mr. Newman has been involved with over the years.
"I feel very good and proud about it," he said. "I think it's disgraceful the way people who have intimate relationships break up and then hate each other for life. I find that very offensive."
I said his living arrangements sounded like every man's dream.
"These are my dearest, dearest friends and colleges, co-workers," he said, "who've invested millions of hours to build the All-Stars Talent Show Network. That's who we're talking about here, and many of these people are women, and in the case of some of them, but not all of them, we've been close in all kinds of ways, including physically, and I feel thrilled about that."
He continued: "It's not a harem of people, it's a collection of human beings, some of whom are brilliant psychologists, heads of medical services of Long Island community hospital, vice presidents of major companies. That's who they are, and they have an integrity as that. They're not just women to have sex with."
After we'd been talking about an hour, Mr. Newman told me he cries fairly often.
"I cry every time I see movies," he said. "I'm a movie crier, I cry all the time. I certainly cried during Gods and Monsters. I thought that was very touching, their relationship. I'm kind of a sucker for romantic kind of things. When movies get touching and romantic, I cry. There's a movie with Richard Gere and Julia Roberts, their comeback movie."
It was time for a nap before dialysis.
"It's been a good life," he said. "I've been very fortunate and I don't mind talking about it."
The American People Want Reform. How Are We Going To Get It For Them? (1997)
by Jacqueline Salit (1997)
On March 15, 1997 the National Committee of the Patriot Party met in Washington, DC. We had several hours of discussion on a range of issues having to do with the building of the Reform Party that I wanted to communicate to all of you. These discussions were about the vision and design of Reform and how to make it most relevant and useful to the American people. We discussed the issue of whether the party would be developed as a populist and inclusionary party or whether it would be built along centrist and/or ideological lines.
Some in the Reform movement have mistakenly identified the Patriot Party with the so-called Schaumburg group. This is ironic, since some in the Schaumburg group identify the Patriot Party as under the control of "Dallas." Neither is accurate. The true story is important, however, as it has very direct bearing on some of the circumstances inside the Reform Party now, and on the emerging debate on the political choice between populism and centrism.
Some Working Definitions
Different people have different definitions. Here are some of ours. Centrism, or the model of building a party "at the center" is basically a term that reflects a particular political strategy. Sometimes it is confused with "moderation" or being a moderate on particular issues. But centrism is not so much an ideology as a "real-politic" approach. Centrists (in the current moment) see the Democratic and Republican parties as so distinct and far apart from one another, that there exists the opportunity to create a new party in between them. Its a way of positioning and making an appeal to voters on the basis of that positioning.
Populists, on the other hand, see the Democratic and Republican parties as pretty much the same and, in order to win elections, at the center. Consequently, there is not enough "space" between them to build a winning party there. Populism is a model of party-building that is more vertical, more bottom (the American people) versus top (the two parties and the government) than a horizontal model based on the left/center/right paradigm of centrism. Many populists (like most Americans) are moderates who don't agree with the extreme positions taken by either the ideological right-wing of the Republican Party or the ideological left-wing of the Democratic Party. At the same time, populism is an inclusive grassroots approach that is tolerant of divergent views, which often differs from centrism which tends to want to include only those ideologically "at the center." But centrism is not an ideological position. Its more of a political compass than an ideology. Hence, the equation between "centrist" and "moderate" is a confusion. After all, most who vote for the Democrats and Republicans are also moderate. Yet many are dissatisfied with the ineffectiveness of the two parties which has to do, not with the failure to be moderate but, with their fixation on winning even at the cost of their effectiveness to govern, i.e., their centrism.
The Truth About the Patriot Party
More on this debate later. Now for the true story of the Patriot Party. The Patriot Party, founded in April 1994, was, in essence, an experiment. Pro-third partyists who had become politically active through the Perot â92 campaign and independents based among what have been traditionally Democratic Party and liberal constituencies -- African Americans, Hispanics, gays and progressives -- came together in hopes of creating a new party. We set out to create something unique and specifically suited to this moment in American political life -- a moment in which the vast majority of Americans, from different walks of life, are deeply alienated from and distrustful of our government and its two party rule. Ross Perot's 1992 campaign had thoroughly exposed this. And the Patriot Party wanted to create a political instrument that was responsive. The Patriot Party was a party that was not based on any ideology -- not conservative, not moderate, not liberal-- but had a vision of including all Americans, regardless of ideology, in a new kind of party oriented toward political and fiscal reform and government accountability.
This unique Patriot format, governed by democratic and inclusionary rules and a set of ten principles -- rather than a "social issues" platform -- was not established without a protracted fight. One entire wing -- led by Lenora Fulani -- of what would ultimately become the Patriot Party was barred from attending the Kansas City meeting in the fall of 1993 that laid the groundwork for the founding of Patriot. Significantly, that meeting was convened and shaped by several people who are now significant influences on the so-called Schaumburg group including pollster and author Gordon Black, former Governor Lowell Weicker and Dick Lamm's 1996 campaign manager Tom D'Amore. In spite of the fact that this process got off on a very exclusionary foot, the group adopted rules for a founding convention that were open, grassroots-oriented and which, through its Congressional District representation structure, allowed for the inclusion and participation of all Americans who wanted to be a part of this fledgling effort. Much of the work to create, adopt and apply these rules was led by Nicholas Sabatine, who went on to become Patriot Party National Chair and Tom McLaughlin, a Patriot Party leader who is now the chairman of the Reform Party Rules Committee.
At Patriot's April 1994 founding convention, where 110 delegates from more than 20 states were credentialed, a fierce floor fight broke out over whether the term "centrist" should be incorporated into the party's principles. Among those advocating that it should were Gordon Black, who believed strongly in the concept of a party that was "centrist" (and "moderate," confusing the two in our opinion) and Laureen Oliver, a New York delegate. When the majority of delegates opposed the use of the term on the grounds that it was exclusionary to define the party along such lines, because it meant that people who did not define themselves as such were unwelcome, Oliver, Black and several others stormed out of the convention and immediately undertook to find ways to try to either destroy or take over the Patriot Party. (One of their methods, by the way, was to circulate false charges of anti-Semitism and extremism against Lenora Fulani and Fred Newman, taken from materials prepared by the Anti-Defamation League. Oliver herself was interviewed by the ADL for an anti-Fulani pamphlet released the following year which is now being aggressively distributed throughout Reform by Schaumburg activists and other Lamm supporters.)
Does any of this sound familiar? It should. The process that the Reform Party is now going through has some very similar characteristics. It even has some of the same characters!
The "Democracy" Gambit
It was for this reason that the Patriot Party, which had aggressively lobbied Ross Perot and the members of United We Stand, America to make the move to initiate the Reform Party and then actively supported and participated in the building process that began on September 25, 1995 in California, convened a meeting of its own National Committee on March 15 in Washington, DC. We had invested substantial political and human resources in the building of Reform; been a part of the magnificent results produced on election day in which the national infrastructure of a new, independent party was cemented; worked coalitionally to build numerous state party organizations; participated through various individuals in the 50 state conference call and the Nashville meeting, and were proud to have Patriot founders James Mangia elected to serve as national secretary of the Reform Party and Tom McLaughlin appointed by the partyâs officers to serve as chair of the Rules Committee. We felt throughout and feel now extremely positive about the growth and development of Reform, and about the many working relationships that have emerged between Patriots and many UWSAers, the Dallas staff and the many independents in activist and leadership roles in state parties.
Like others in Reform, we have also been concerned about the ongoing fixation by a vocal few on the so-called issue of "internal democracy" that permeated Nashville and has flooded the Internet since. The Patriot Party meeting was convened to discuss this state of affairs. It appears to us that the effort to focus the Reform Party on a fight over "internal democracy" -- whether Ross Perot does or should "control" Reform; whether Russ Verney does or should "control" Reform; whether the Schaumburg group does or should "control" Reform and the various state level permutations of this in Illinois, California, Virginia and elsewhere -- obscures an underlying and more significant issue for the Reform Party: namely, the issue of what kind of party we are building. Of course, everyone pays lip service to democracy and democratic rules. No one says they think things should be undemocratic. But an obsession with rules, however democratic those rules might be, means little in the absence of using them to guarantee inclusion and open debate and means nothing at all if they are used, as a cover for exclusion and stifling dialogue on key issues facing the party. Moreover, while rules are important to the process, democracy is not simply a structural or administrative matter, Mr. Roberts' rules not withstanding! It is also a posture, a spirit, a commitment to the open and free exchange of strategies and approaches. It is as much about the culture of a new kind of party as it is about the written rules of the party.
Centrist or Populist?
How do we answer the question of what kind of party we are building? One Patriot leader, Fred Newman, puts it this way: There is currently a disagreement in the Reform movement over whether the party should be a centrist party or a populist party. The centrists view the political situation in the country like this: The two parties are at the "extremes" -- the Democrats being on the "left" and the Republicans being on the "right." As referenced earlier, the centrists believe there is such a great space between these two parties that a new party -- a party of the center -- can be created and win elections there. This party would, in effect, try to get into the game now being played by the Republicans and Democrats, the game of winning elections by creating an electoral majority at the center. Those who believe in a more populist model have a different view of the political situation in the country. They -- the Patriot Party is among them, and so, we believe, is Ross Perot -- think there isn't a dime's worth of difference between the Democrats and Republicans; that both parties have taken control of the government and are running it on behalf of themselves and the mega-interests which fund them. Consequently, for the populists, ideology -- right (conservative), center (moderate), or left (liberal) -- is not fundamental. The real issue is creating a bottom-up, inclusive party that can unite all Americans regardless of their ideology, their background, their race, religion, ethnicity or lifestyle, who are excluded from ownership of a government and a country which, as Ross Perot has said, belongs to us. The populists aren't interested in creating a new party to get into the bipartisan game. Populism is about changing the rules of the game so that the American people can take back our government.
Win, Lose or Build
In response to this characterization of these two distinct positions, some Reform activists have said that while they strongly support the concept of a bottom-up, inclusionary, tolerant party, they like the characterization of Reform as "moderate" because the majority of the American people favor positions on social issues that are not at the extremes, but closer to the center. We agree. However, the point of creating a new reform-oriented party is to break the deadlock of the two party system. Defining a party in terms of positions on social issues, even moderate ones, does not promote that kind of reform. Everyone in two-party politics today calls themselves a moderate. Bill Clinton is for "responsibility" and "opportunity." Newt Gingrich is for bipartisan cooperation. Why? Because most voters consider themselves moderates, and the Democrats and Republicans want their votes. If a new third party simply defines itself as moderate, then it is trying to appeal to voters on the same basis as the two parties. But in addition to being moderate, the American people are rejecting the "win at all costs" game. The highly partisan and very corrupt system of American politics must be taken apart and reconstructed to be democratic, inclusive and a proper tool for governing by and for the American people.
Some in the Reform Party have a different take on this issue of the party's focus. They see the critical and immediate objective for Reform being that of winning elections in the short term. With that as your objective, it makes sense that projecting the party as "moderate" would seem important, since that's how you win elections in America these days (that, plus millions of dollars from special interests). Some have argued against this strategy because it is too ambitious and "bigger" than we are. My problem with the strategy of "winning elections" is that it isn't ambitious or big enough! Reform is out to reform the political system; to change the way our government is elected and run. The more Reform wants to project itself as the new political party that can accomplish that, the more we will grow. In my opinion, in the not-too-distant future, we will attract support from millions and millions of Americans because our message is their message. Then, winning elections will be a snap.
The American people are fed up with politicians whose idea of governing is figuring out how to take positions in order to raise the most money for their reelection campaigns. This system of political compromise has compromised our political system. We don't want compromise. We, the American people, want solutions. In order to get to those solutions, Reform is going to have to be more than "moderate." It's going to have to lead the fight to de-politicize our government and policy-making and revitalize our democracy through structural political reform. It is the focus on political reform -- which in Patriot has meant the focus on principles rather than social issue programmatics -- that makes the Reform Party uniquely relevant.
It goes without saying that everyone in the Reform movement -- not to mention everyone in the country -- has the right to choose whatever position on this matter they like. While the Patriot Party does not agree with the premise of a centrist party, we respect the right of those who hold to this position to do so. We'd love to see the populist vs. centrist debate put right out on the table. That's why we're distributing this paper. However, rather than have an open and democratic dialogue on this issue, some of the pro-centrist elements of our party have attempted to drive what they would characterize as the party's "conservative/right" and "liberal/left" out of the party in order to create a pure party of the (moderate) center -- before anyone even gets a chance to consider whether they think those ideological labels are useful and whether they want that kind of party or not.
Ideological Cleansing
What is the value of doing this, from their perspective? Presumably, if you have a new party that is "centrist" in its approach, it will be able to compete with the Democrats and Republicans for that "space" at the "center." After all, while the centrists believe the two parties are at the extremes, presumably they also recognize that the Democrats and Republicans are both clutching for a "center," too. That's why the two parties are so into "bipartisan cooperation." However, "bipartisanism" is easier said than done. The Democrats have a "left" and the Republicans have a "right" -- both of which are balking at their respective parties' attempt to muzzle them as the two parties seek compromise and accommodation with one another. Perhaps, the independent centrists believe that if they can chop off Reform's "left" and "right" from the start, it could give the party a significant advantage in the competition with the two major parties.
Presented in that framework, there may be some truth to the "centrists'" argument. The problem is that the framework is only useful if you're looking to create a third party that is just like the Republicans and the Democrats. Why would we want to do that? The American people are tired of politics as usual. We want to break out of the existing two-party mold, not simply by adding another clone to the picture, but by creating a party that is different in its approach to governing and spending, different in its ethics and accountability and different in its ability to unite the majority of Americans who currently have no place in the political system. That is the populist view.
The efforts at "ideological cleansing" inside the Reform Party have been ongoing and insidious. Some months ago, under the guise of a fight to "democratize" the Illinois Reform Party, accusations were made against Dawn Larson that she was a supporter of David Duke. Recently Jim Mangia was verbally attacked at a meeting of the West Los Angeles chapter in California Reform for his relationship to Lenora Fulani, who in turn was vilified for being a leftist. The discredited and politically (Democratic Party) motivated ADL report on Fulani and Newman has been widely circulated inside the party, most recently by members of the Board of the Colorado Reform Party who are aligned with Dick Lamm. These divisive efforts and others too numerous to mention emanate from the same circle which asserts the need for "internal democracy" and ideological purity. Obviously, the party is free to democratically decide that it wants to choose this ideological path. But no such decision has been made.
To the Convention
So far, the major decision that has been made with respect to this critical and self-defining issue, is to hold a national founding convention with hundreds of delegates, representing Congressional Districts and, thereby, diverse populations of Americans from across the country. This convention will democratically determine the character of the Reform Party. This convention will decide what kind of party we want our party to be. And it is a great strength of Reform and a tribute to all who are playing a role in building it that we have placed the future of the party in the hands of all those who are and will soon come to be building it.
And so, what is the Patriot Party's role in this process? Some have asked (more or less provocatively) why we still exist? Why haven't we simply "merged" into Reform?
In some respects, of course, we have. Patriot leaders hold varied posts in the Reform infrastructure. In states where election law provides for registering voters into a party, Patriot activists register voters into Reform affiliates. Patriot News reports on and analyzes developments in Reform and the broader independent movement.
At the same time, the Patriot Party believes in and is a particular model of a new political party. It is the populist model, the non-ideological approach, the inclusionary, bottom-up approach. Some call it Patriot populism. Some call it Perot populism ö in recognition of the populist and non-ideological voice that Ross Perot has contributed to the party-building effort.
The success of Reform has brought it to the point where it is in a position to deal with these very fundamental party "engineering" issues. Given the road Patriot has traveled, given our experiences and all that we have learned from our "experiment" to date, we hope that we have something very particular to contribute to the process, not the least of which is our ability to bring different kinds of Americans together for constructive dialogue on our shared future.
New York City
March 24, 1997
JACQUELINE SALIT is the editor of Patriot News, a National Committee member of the National Patriot Party and a State Committee member of the Independence Party of New York.
On March 15, 1997 the National Committee of the Patriot Party met in Washington, DC. We had several hours of discussion on a range of issues having to do with the building of the Reform Party that I wanted to communicate to all of you. These discussions were about the vision and design of Reform and how to make it most relevant and useful to the American people. We discussed the issue of whether the party would be developed as a populist and inclusionary party or whether it would be built along centrist and/or ideological lines.
Some in the Reform movement have mistakenly identified the Patriot Party with the so-called Schaumburg group. This is ironic, since some in the Schaumburg group identify the Patriot Party as under the control of "Dallas." Neither is accurate. The true story is important, however, as it has very direct bearing on some of the circumstances inside the Reform Party now, and on the emerging debate on the political choice between populism and centrism.
Some Working Definitions
Different people have different definitions. Here are some of ours. Centrism, or the model of building a party "at the center" is basically a term that reflects a particular political strategy. Sometimes it is confused with "moderation" or being a moderate on particular issues. But centrism is not so much an ideology as a "real-politic" approach. Centrists (in the current moment) see the Democratic and Republican parties as so distinct and far apart from one another, that there exists the opportunity to create a new party in between them. Its a way of positioning and making an appeal to voters on the basis of that positioning.
Populists, on the other hand, see the Democratic and Republican parties as pretty much the same and, in order to win elections, at the center. Consequently, there is not enough "space" between them to build a winning party there. Populism is a model of party-building that is more vertical, more bottom (the American people) versus top (the two parties and the government) than a horizontal model based on the left/center/right paradigm of centrism. Many populists (like most Americans) are moderates who don't agree with the extreme positions taken by either the ideological right-wing of the Republican Party or the ideological left-wing of the Democratic Party. At the same time, populism is an inclusive grassroots approach that is tolerant of divergent views, which often differs from centrism which tends to want to include only those ideologically "at the center." But centrism is not an ideological position. Its more of a political compass than an ideology. Hence, the equation between "centrist" and "moderate" is a confusion. After all, most who vote for the Democrats and Republicans are also moderate. Yet many are dissatisfied with the ineffectiveness of the two parties which has to do, not with the failure to be moderate but, with their fixation on winning even at the cost of their effectiveness to govern, i.e., their centrism.
The Truth About the Patriot Party
More on this debate later. Now for the true story of the Patriot Party. The Patriot Party, founded in April 1994, was, in essence, an experiment. Pro-third partyists who had become politically active through the Perot â92 campaign and independents based among what have been traditionally Democratic Party and liberal constituencies -- African Americans, Hispanics, gays and progressives -- came together in hopes of creating a new party. We set out to create something unique and specifically suited to this moment in American political life -- a moment in which the vast majority of Americans, from different walks of life, are deeply alienated from and distrustful of our government and its two party rule. Ross Perot's 1992 campaign had thoroughly exposed this. And the Patriot Party wanted to create a political instrument that was responsive. The Patriot Party was a party that was not based on any ideology -- not conservative, not moderate, not liberal-- but had a vision of including all Americans, regardless of ideology, in a new kind of party oriented toward political and fiscal reform and government accountability.
This unique Patriot format, governed by democratic and inclusionary rules and a set of ten principles -- rather than a "social issues" platform -- was not established without a protracted fight. One entire wing -- led by Lenora Fulani -- of what would ultimately become the Patriot Party was barred from attending the Kansas City meeting in the fall of 1993 that laid the groundwork for the founding of Patriot. Significantly, that meeting was convened and shaped by several people who are now significant influences on the so-called Schaumburg group including pollster and author Gordon Black, former Governor Lowell Weicker and Dick Lamm's 1996 campaign manager Tom D'Amore. In spite of the fact that this process got off on a very exclusionary foot, the group adopted rules for a founding convention that were open, grassroots-oriented and which, through its Congressional District representation structure, allowed for the inclusion and participation of all Americans who wanted to be a part of this fledgling effort. Much of the work to create, adopt and apply these rules was led by Nicholas Sabatine, who went on to become Patriot Party National Chair and Tom McLaughlin, a Patriot Party leader who is now the chairman of the Reform Party Rules Committee.
At Patriot's April 1994 founding convention, where 110 delegates from more than 20 states were credentialed, a fierce floor fight broke out over whether the term "centrist" should be incorporated into the party's principles. Among those advocating that it should were Gordon Black, who believed strongly in the concept of a party that was "centrist" (and "moderate," confusing the two in our opinion) and Laureen Oliver, a New York delegate. When the majority of delegates opposed the use of the term on the grounds that it was exclusionary to define the party along such lines, because it meant that people who did not define themselves as such were unwelcome, Oliver, Black and several others stormed out of the convention and immediately undertook to find ways to try to either destroy or take over the Patriot Party. (One of their methods, by the way, was to circulate false charges of anti-Semitism and extremism against Lenora Fulani and Fred Newman, taken from materials prepared by the Anti-Defamation League. Oliver herself was interviewed by the ADL for an anti-Fulani pamphlet released the following year which is now being aggressively distributed throughout Reform by Schaumburg activists and other Lamm supporters.)
Does any of this sound familiar? It should. The process that the Reform Party is now going through has some very similar characteristics. It even has some of the same characters!
The "Democracy" Gambit
It was for this reason that the Patriot Party, which had aggressively lobbied Ross Perot and the members of United We Stand, America to make the move to initiate the Reform Party and then actively supported and participated in the building process that began on September 25, 1995 in California, convened a meeting of its own National Committee on March 15 in Washington, DC. We had invested substantial political and human resources in the building of Reform; been a part of the magnificent results produced on election day in which the national infrastructure of a new, independent party was cemented; worked coalitionally to build numerous state party organizations; participated through various individuals in the 50 state conference call and the Nashville meeting, and were proud to have Patriot founders James Mangia elected to serve as national secretary of the Reform Party and Tom McLaughlin appointed by the partyâs officers to serve as chair of the Rules Committee. We felt throughout and feel now extremely positive about the growth and development of Reform, and about the many working relationships that have emerged between Patriots and many UWSAers, the Dallas staff and the many independents in activist and leadership roles in state parties.
Like others in Reform, we have also been concerned about the ongoing fixation by a vocal few on the so-called issue of "internal democracy" that permeated Nashville and has flooded the Internet since. The Patriot Party meeting was convened to discuss this state of affairs. It appears to us that the effort to focus the Reform Party on a fight over "internal democracy" -- whether Ross Perot does or should "control" Reform; whether Russ Verney does or should "control" Reform; whether the Schaumburg group does or should "control" Reform and the various state level permutations of this in Illinois, California, Virginia and elsewhere -- obscures an underlying and more significant issue for the Reform Party: namely, the issue of what kind of party we are building. Of course, everyone pays lip service to democracy and democratic rules. No one says they think things should be undemocratic. But an obsession with rules, however democratic those rules might be, means little in the absence of using them to guarantee inclusion and open debate and means nothing at all if they are used, as a cover for exclusion and stifling dialogue on key issues facing the party. Moreover, while rules are important to the process, democracy is not simply a structural or administrative matter, Mr. Roberts' rules not withstanding! It is also a posture, a spirit, a commitment to the open and free exchange of strategies and approaches. It is as much about the culture of a new kind of party as it is about the written rules of the party.
Centrist or Populist?
How do we answer the question of what kind of party we are building? One Patriot leader, Fred Newman, puts it this way: There is currently a disagreement in the Reform movement over whether the party should be a centrist party or a populist party. The centrists view the political situation in the country like this: The two parties are at the "extremes" -- the Democrats being on the "left" and the Republicans being on the "right." As referenced earlier, the centrists believe there is such a great space between these two parties that a new party -- a party of the center -- can be created and win elections there. This party would, in effect, try to get into the game now being played by the Republicans and Democrats, the game of winning elections by creating an electoral majority at the center. Those who believe in a more populist model have a different view of the political situation in the country. They -- the Patriot Party is among them, and so, we believe, is Ross Perot -- think there isn't a dime's worth of difference between the Democrats and Republicans; that both parties have taken control of the government and are running it on behalf of themselves and the mega-interests which fund them. Consequently, for the populists, ideology -- right (conservative), center (moderate), or left (liberal) -- is not fundamental. The real issue is creating a bottom-up, inclusive party that can unite all Americans regardless of their ideology, their background, their race, religion, ethnicity or lifestyle, who are excluded from ownership of a government and a country which, as Ross Perot has said, belongs to us. The populists aren't interested in creating a new party to get into the bipartisan game. Populism is about changing the rules of the game so that the American people can take back our government.
Win, Lose or Build
In response to this characterization of these two distinct positions, some Reform activists have said that while they strongly support the concept of a bottom-up, inclusionary, tolerant party, they like the characterization of Reform as "moderate" because the majority of the American people favor positions on social issues that are not at the extremes, but closer to the center. We agree. However, the point of creating a new reform-oriented party is to break the deadlock of the two party system. Defining a party in terms of positions on social issues, even moderate ones, does not promote that kind of reform. Everyone in two-party politics today calls themselves a moderate. Bill Clinton is for "responsibility" and "opportunity." Newt Gingrich is for bipartisan cooperation. Why? Because most voters consider themselves moderates, and the Democrats and Republicans want their votes. If a new third party simply defines itself as moderate, then it is trying to appeal to voters on the same basis as the two parties. But in addition to being moderate, the American people are rejecting the "win at all costs" game. The highly partisan and very corrupt system of American politics must be taken apart and reconstructed to be democratic, inclusive and a proper tool for governing by and for the American people.
Some in the Reform Party have a different take on this issue of the party's focus. They see the critical and immediate objective for Reform being that of winning elections in the short term. With that as your objective, it makes sense that projecting the party as "moderate" would seem important, since that's how you win elections in America these days (that, plus millions of dollars from special interests). Some have argued against this strategy because it is too ambitious and "bigger" than we are. My problem with the strategy of "winning elections" is that it isn't ambitious or big enough! Reform is out to reform the political system; to change the way our government is elected and run. The more Reform wants to project itself as the new political party that can accomplish that, the more we will grow. In my opinion, in the not-too-distant future, we will attract support from millions and millions of Americans because our message is their message. Then, winning elections will be a snap.
The American people are fed up with politicians whose idea of governing is figuring out how to take positions in order to raise the most money for their reelection campaigns. This system of political compromise has compromised our political system. We don't want compromise. We, the American people, want solutions. In order to get to those solutions, Reform is going to have to be more than "moderate." It's going to have to lead the fight to de-politicize our government and policy-making and revitalize our democracy through structural political reform. It is the focus on political reform -- which in Patriot has meant the focus on principles rather than social issue programmatics -- that makes the Reform Party uniquely relevant.
It goes without saying that everyone in the Reform movement -- not to mention everyone in the country -- has the right to choose whatever position on this matter they like. While the Patriot Party does not agree with the premise of a centrist party, we respect the right of those who hold to this position to do so. We'd love to see the populist vs. centrist debate put right out on the table. That's why we're distributing this paper. However, rather than have an open and democratic dialogue on this issue, some of the pro-centrist elements of our party have attempted to drive what they would characterize as the party's "conservative/right" and "liberal/left" out of the party in order to create a pure party of the (moderate) center -- before anyone even gets a chance to consider whether they think those ideological labels are useful and whether they want that kind of party or not.
Ideological Cleansing
What is the value of doing this, from their perspective? Presumably, if you have a new party that is "centrist" in its approach, it will be able to compete with the Democrats and Republicans for that "space" at the "center." After all, while the centrists believe the two parties are at the extremes, presumably they also recognize that the Democrats and Republicans are both clutching for a "center," too. That's why the two parties are so into "bipartisan cooperation." However, "bipartisanism" is easier said than done. The Democrats have a "left" and the Republicans have a "right" -- both of which are balking at their respective parties' attempt to muzzle them as the two parties seek compromise and accommodation with one another. Perhaps, the independent centrists believe that if they can chop off Reform's "left" and "right" from the start, it could give the party a significant advantage in the competition with the two major parties.
Presented in that framework, there may be some truth to the "centrists'" argument. The problem is that the framework is only useful if you're looking to create a third party that is just like the Republicans and the Democrats. Why would we want to do that? The American people are tired of politics as usual. We want to break out of the existing two-party mold, not simply by adding another clone to the picture, but by creating a party that is different in its approach to governing and spending, different in its ethics and accountability and different in its ability to unite the majority of Americans who currently have no place in the political system. That is the populist view.
The efforts at "ideological cleansing" inside the Reform Party have been ongoing and insidious. Some months ago, under the guise of a fight to "democratize" the Illinois Reform Party, accusations were made against Dawn Larson that she was a supporter of David Duke. Recently Jim Mangia was verbally attacked at a meeting of the West Los Angeles chapter in California Reform for his relationship to Lenora Fulani, who in turn was vilified for being a leftist. The discredited and politically (Democratic Party) motivated ADL report on Fulani and Newman has been widely circulated inside the party, most recently by members of the Board of the Colorado Reform Party who are aligned with Dick Lamm. These divisive efforts and others too numerous to mention emanate from the same circle which asserts the need for "internal democracy" and ideological purity. Obviously, the party is free to democratically decide that it wants to choose this ideological path. But no such decision has been made.
To the Convention
So far, the major decision that has been made with respect to this critical and self-defining issue, is to hold a national founding convention with hundreds of delegates, representing Congressional Districts and, thereby, diverse populations of Americans from across the country. This convention will democratically determine the character of the Reform Party. This convention will decide what kind of party we want our party to be. And it is a great strength of Reform and a tribute to all who are playing a role in building it that we have placed the future of the party in the hands of all those who are and will soon come to be building it.
And so, what is the Patriot Party's role in this process? Some have asked (more or less provocatively) why we still exist? Why haven't we simply "merged" into Reform?
In some respects, of course, we have. Patriot leaders hold varied posts in the Reform infrastructure. In states where election law provides for registering voters into a party, Patriot activists register voters into Reform affiliates. Patriot News reports on and analyzes developments in Reform and the broader independent movement.
At the same time, the Patriot Party believes in and is a particular model of a new political party. It is the populist model, the non-ideological approach, the inclusionary, bottom-up approach. Some call it Patriot populism. Some call it Perot populism ö in recognition of the populist and non-ideological voice that Ross Perot has contributed to the party-building effort.
The success of Reform has brought it to the point where it is in a position to deal with these very fundamental party "engineering" issues. Given the road Patriot has traveled, given our experiences and all that we have learned from our "experiment" to date, we hope that we have something very particular to contribute to the process, not the least of which is our ability to bring different kinds of Americans together for constructive dialogue on our shared future.
New York City
March 24, 1997
JACQUELINE SALIT is the editor of Patriot News, a National Committee member of the National Patriot Party and a State Committee member of the Independence Party of New York.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)