Showing posts with label All Stars Project. Show all posts
Showing posts with label All Stars Project. Show all posts

Tuesday, August 9, 2011

Mayor Defends Financing for Fulani Group (2006)

By Jill Gardiner
The New York Sun, September 14, 2006

Mayor Bloomberg is defending the city's decision to approve more than $12 million in tax-free financing for a nonprofit group founded by a political leader who has been accused of making anti-Semitic comments.

Mr. Bloomberg said the approval of the tax-free financing for the All Stars Project, a performing arts group, was based solely on the substance of the group and had nothing to do with its founding member, Lenora Fulani, who is no longer affiliated with the group.

The city's Industrial Development Agency gave the green light to the arrangement earlier this week over objections from several leading elected officials, who said the organization's relationship with Ms. Fulani should disqualify it.

"We don't look at the politics or the personal philosophies or the first amendment rights of what people say who are not involved with a project," Mr. Bloomberg told reporters.

"If they have a problem with other people they should express it to other people, but we are not going to hurt the kids at the All Star Project," he added referring to the opponents.

Ms. Fulani, a former leader of the Independence Party, backed Mr. Bloomberg when he was running for mayor in 2001 and then again in 2005, giving him crucial support and an alternative party line for New Yorkers who wanted to vote for him but didn't want to pull the lever for the Republican Party. He has distanced himself from her positions, but they repeatedly come back to haunt him.

Ms. Fulani's most divisive words came in 1989, when she wrote: "Jews had to sell their souls to acquire Israel." This week, the state comptroller, Alan Hevesi, the City Council speaker, Christine Quinn, the public advocate, Betsy Gotbaum, and Rep. Jerrold Nadler wrote to the head of the IDA urging him to block the financing request. Others who hold power on the IDA board directed their proxies to reject it.

But Mr. Bloomberg contended that there was nothing wrong with the deal: "We're trying to do what's right for our children and we certainly do not want to run a city where everybody's got to pass a litmus test of agreeing with those people running for office," he said.

Bloomy's 'All Stars': City arranges new multi-million-dollar financing for Fulani's crew (2006)

By Tom Robbins
The Village Voice, August 22, 2006

City arranges new multi-million-dollar financing for Fulani's crew

Even though he was the odds-on favorite to win re-election last year, Mayor Mike Bloomberg took no chances. In addition to running as the Republican Party's nominee, the billionaire media mogul sought and accepted the nomination of the Independence Party, thus providing an alternative for those true-blue Democrats who could never pull the GOP lever, even while holding their noses in the privacy of the voting booth. It was the same strategy that had worked so well for him in 2001, when the 59,000 votes he polled as the Independence candidate put him over the top in that razor-close race.

But the second time around, Bloomberg took a fair amount of heat for the tactic: Reporters asked him why he was still associating with the zany crowd that controlled the city's Independence Party, which included Lenora Fulani, prone to tossing occasional anti-Semitic barbs, and her oddball therapy guru, Fred Newman, who openly approved of sex between shrinks and patients. Those questions increased in volume after Fulani publicly refused to disavow her own earlier comments, in a NY1 TV interview, that Jews are "mass murderers" and had "sold their souls to acquire Israel."

But Bloomberg's strategy was to be better safe than sorry, banking on the hope that most voters wouldn't notice and the rest wouldn't hold it against him. And he was right. The CEO-turned-politician scored an overwhelming 750,000-vote tally against Democrat Fernando Ferrer, with more than 74,000 cast for him on the Independence Party line.

Now, nine months after the little third party helped him achieve that crushing victory, Bloomberg's administration is poised to provide Fulani and Newman with new $12 million tax-free bond financing for a controversial nonprofit organization they have long controlled. The bond deal, due to be approved by the city's Industrial Development Agency next month, would allow a youth program called the All Stars Project to refinance $8.3 million in outstanding city bonds and add an additional $4.2 million to allow the group to make improvements at its headquarters on West 42nd Street—a space it acquired in 2002 with an earlier IDA bond deal from Bloomberg's administration.

Tax-free bonds for private businesses and nonprofit groups are awarded frequently by the city, but applicants have to show that the subsidies will benefit the public. All Stars has been the subject of repeated complaints and investigations concerning allegations that it is used to lure unwary people into Newman's so-called "social therapy" practice and into political activities like the Independence Party. The group has always denied it, and a probe last year by the office of state attorney general Eliot Spitzer did not result in charges of wrongdoing.

The financing deal is clearly attractive. The bonds would save All Stars several hundred thousand dollars in costs and mortgage-recording taxes, according to Good Jobs New York, which monitors city projects. So far, however, few specifics have been provided. The only information made public is a one-paragraph advertisement published in the New York Daily News on August 8. A spokesperson for the city's Economic Development Corporation, which oversees the IDA, confirmed the deal and said only that some of the new $4 million plus would go for new heating and ventilation systems for the All Stars headquarters, adding that more details will be available before a September 7 hearing on the matter.

Bloomberg spokesperson Stu Loeser said the mayor played "no role" in the bond deal, adding that Newman and Fulani have distanced themselves from the project. In February, Newman resigned from posts he held there, although he and Fulani remain leading figures in the group.

An All Stars spokesman confirmed the bonds will be used to "finance necessary renovations and improvements."

Whatever the details, the project appears to be a kind of consolation prize for the group, which had a decidedly unhappy experience in its most recent dealings with city government. In March, in a caustic letter, the group announced it was dropping its application for a $230,000 contract to provide after-school training to city schoolkids through the Department of Youth and Community Development. The move came after a 10-month-long inquiry that began shortly after a Voice story on the matter ("Fulani's City Hall Push," June 7, 2005). At the time, the Voice reported that Fulani and Newman had been invited into Bloomberg's inner sanctum at City Hall, where they had met with top city officials, including schools chancellor Joel Klein. Part of their pitch was to provide theater and music activities to schoolchildren. Bloomberg's aides were receptive to the idea. But All Stars officials confirmed that they were more interested in receiving the stamp of approval from City Hall than the cash. "It would be the city validating all of our work in this field," Gabrielle Kurlander, who lives with Newman and receives $200,000 as president of the group, told the Voice last year.

But the contract negotiations came just as the mayor was agreeing to take the Independence Party line, and the coincidence helped spark a spate of additional stories in the New York Post and on NY1. In the face of that publicity, the city's youth department announced that All Stars would get careful scrutiny before any contracts were awarded.

That investigation, along with a parallel one by Spitzer's office, put the after-school grant on hold. City officials never completed their probe, but on March 6, All Stars president Kurlander fired off an angry four-page letter to city youth department officials saying they'd had enough. The letter offered—in remarkably frank language—Kurlander's version of her group's dealings with the youth agency and City Hall.

According to Kurlander, the after-school activities application started with the suggestion of a Bloomberg policy aide, Ester Fuchs, who "urged us to apply for a grant." (Fuchs told the Voice last year that the idea was broached by an All Stars lobbyist.) Kurlander said she "expressed concern" that the application "might fall victim to various forms of political gamesmanship" given the media attention to the group.

Despite city assurances that wouldn't happen, Kurlander wrote, the youth department's general counsel began contacting All Stars board members and supporters as far away as California "to inquire about their political affiliations." After a protest to Fuchs, Kurlander said, those inquiries were halted. But as the mayoral race heated up, NY1 broadcast a multi-part series by reporter Rita Nissan, prompting a new series of inquiries.

The youth department's new questions, Kurlander wrote, "read like an inquisition from Senator Joseph McCarthy." She said the queries included questions about who on the board was "in therapy, about living and personal financial arrangements of principals associated with the program, and other intrusive and abusive lines of questioning."

All Stars again complained, Kurlander wrote, this time to both Fuchs and Bloomberg campaign director Kevin Sheekey (now a deputy mayor). Kurlander said City Hall aides "disingenuously" told her that it was out of their hands. She said that even after Spitzer dropped his own separate inquiry, the city's probe continued. The last straw apparently came when the Voice reported, several days before Kurlander's irate letter, that city sources were telling it the contract wouldn't be awarded.

The All Stars executive wrote that the city's inquiry had "degenerated into the worst form of 'policy by politics' " and a "corruption of governmental responsibility."

"Finally," Kurlander concluded, "while it is the case that some individuals in the All Stars community worked hard for Mayor Bloomberg's re-election, All Stars has always made it plain that it neither sought nor expected any special treatment or favors." At the bottom of the letter, Kurlander cc'd Fuchs, Sheekey, and Mayor Bloomberg.

"Psychopolitics": Inside The Independence Party Of Fred Newman, Part Three

By Rita Nissan
NY1 News, November 2, 2005

Fred Newman, the leader of the Manhattan Independence Party, wants to have a say in how your children are educated. But his views on sex and marriage may leave some parents wary. NY1’s Rita Nissan has more in part three of her special series, "Psychopolitics."

Fred Newman lives by his own rules. He says monogamy and marriage aren’t for him.
“I don't think it's any of the state's business who my dearest loves are and how I relate to another human being and give to them and receive from them,” he says.

Newman calls them his dearest loves, the women he lives with in his West Village
townhouse. He admits some of the women initially came to him for psychological help.

Newman treats patients in Social Therapy, his self-created field of psychology.

“Some of them were in therapy, yeah,” he says.

But mainstream psychologists say it's unethical for therapists to have sex with their patients because it violates personal boundaries and trust.

Newman is not held to any ethical codes. As a psychotherapist, he doesn’t need a license to practice in New York State, although the laws have changed and he’ll need one by the end of the year.

“I think that people’s sexual relationships should be something very personal between the people who are engaging in it, and I think if people love each other, care for each other, are attracted to each other and decide together that they want to have sex, they should,” he says. “[Does it matter that it's a patient and a therapist?] I think sexual relationships are between human beings, not human beings under certain descriptions or in certain categories. I believe that people should fall in love as they so desire, and if they want to include in that sexuality, they should include that.”

Newman controls several organizations that appear to be intertwined: Social Therapy clinics, the Manhattan Independence Party, and his youth charity the All Stars Project. All Stars introduces children and teens to Newman’s ideas.

At All Stars headquarters, Newman writes and directs plays at the Castillo Theatre. His books are everywhere, and volunteers have been invited to social therapy related events.

“It’s cool,” says Loretta Martin.

NY1 met Martin at a campaign rally for Mayor Michael Bloomberg. She works for Newman’s Independence Party and volunteers for All Stars.

“We hear it all over the place, Social Therapy,” Martin says.

A 2003 evaluation of All Stars shows some high school students read his book, "Let's
Develop." In it, Newman explains what he calls "friendosexuality." He writes that sex is best when "performed" the same way children play, with friends as equals.

Former patients say they were advised to have sex with their friends, without forming
emotional bonds. Mainstream psychologists say that leads to unhealthy relationships.

Here's how former patient M. Ortiz describes what happened when she went to Newman
for help with a relationship: “Fred Newman in therapy suggested that maybe I should go have a relationship with someone else and bring it back to the therapy group and see if there were any problems and then we could discuss it. That was his advice to me regarding a personal relationship. He said I should go sleep around.”

Ortiz says Newman’s views on sex were well known among his followers.

“It was a joke in the media and even in the community that Fred has four wives, Gabrielle [Kurlander], Hazel - the late Hazel Daren, who was his first cult relationship - and two other wives, Gail Elberg and Deborah Green,” she says.

Some of those women now have plush jobs with All Stars.

Gabrielle Kurlander earns $200,000 a year as its president. In the 1980’s she was a therapy patient. Newman fell in love with her. He once wrote, "Gabrielle Kurlander, my dearest love, made my life."

Gail Elberg is another All Stars official that Newman lives with. Elberg oversees the volunteer program. She’s been with Newman for more than 30 years.

Newman doesn't call these women his wives. He doesn’t think marriage is a good thing.

“I don't consider any woman my wife. I think that's a highly troublesome and complex
relationship,” he says. “I no longer participate in it. I have some very dear friends of mine, women friends of mine, who I relate to in all kinds of ways. But I don’t collect wives.”

All of this doesn’t sit well with the people who have spent decades tracking Newman. Critics say his unorthodox views make it questionable whether he should work with children, and they say Mayor Bloomberg should be held accountable for helping All Stars grow.

Since he took office, All Stars has moved into a massive new headquarters thanks to tax free bonds from the city, and its been awarded a three-year contract to operate after-school programs. But that contract is on hold because of various investigations.

We have spoken to some All Stars participants who say it's a wonderful program that gives underprivileged children and teens a place to go. They praise Fred Newman and the work that he is doing.

Bloomberg's Therapist (2005)

By Tom Robbins
The Village Voice, June 21, 2005

Mayor Mike's independence party friends can put him on the couch

There was a post-stadium dip in the polls for Michael Bloomberg last week. But the Republican mayor still has a potential job-saving ace in the hole, the same one he had in 2001: a jowly, white-bearded fellow named Fred Newman.

Fred who? That would be Dr. Fred Newman, of course, renowned founder of Social Therapy, the psychological practice dedicated to "a new science of human development," as he modestly proclaims it. Still lost? Well, you must have heard of Fred Newman, author of half a dozen books, and considered by many (OK, by many of his followers) to be the philosophical heir to Ludwig Wittgenstein and Lev Vygotsky (you know, Vygotsky, the great Soviet constructivist psychologist).

Utterly lost? What about Fred Newman the well-known playwright, whose works include Lenin's Breakdown, Risky Revolutionary, and the hilarious All My Cadre, not to mention The Therapy Plays: Newman's Postmodern Follies? That one just finished a successful month-long run at the Castillo Theatre (founded by Newman), which is partners with the All Stars Project (co-founded by Newman), which is the nonprofit youth performance organization housed in a glittering new West 42nd Street headquarters purchased and built with $8.35 million in tax-free bonds provided by the administration of, yes, Michael Bloomberg.

Which brings us to that other important hat worn by Dr. Newman, that of state committee member of the Independence Party, the political group that holds Row C on the ballot and which provided Bloomberg 59,000 votes and his 2001 margin of victory. This month, the party announced it would once again be proud to carry the mayor's name for re-election.

Lenora Fulani, whose past anti-Semitic comments got her in hot water this spring, gets most of the ink and the airtime where the Independence Party is concerned. But she is a longtime and loyal disciple of Fred Newman.

"She is one of my life's proudest accomplishments," Newman told an interviewer a few years ago. "This man is someone I love dearly," Fulani said in turn of her mentor.

After years spent on the political fringes, the two orchestrated a takeover of the Independence Party in the mid 1990s. They promptly found themselves courted by people like Bloomberg, George Pataki, and Charles Schumer in search of a second ballot line.

The party announced its latest Bloomberg endorsement at a reception held on June 5 at City Hall restaurant on Duane Street, attended by some 150 party faithful and a throng of media. Newman, 69, briefly addressed the troops, but his logic and sentence structure are sometimes hard to follow, and the press kept its focus on Fulani, asking her one more time if she regretted saying a few years back that Jews "function as mass murderers of people of color."

Fulani's comments were actually a slightly softer echo of Newman's own words, uttered in 1985, according to the Anti-Defamation League, which has long watchdogged his efforts: "The Jew, the dirty Jew . . . ," Newman said then, "a self-righteous dehumanizer and murderer of people of color."

Bloomberg has denounced Fulani's words as "despicable." But he's otherwise stuck by Fulani and Newman, appearing at their fundraising events and donating $250,000 of his own money last year to the Independence Party. The mayor has also had an open-door policy for Fulani et al. at City Hall, and the All Stars Project is now seeking a city contract to provide after-school care ("Fulani's City Hall Push," Voice, June 8).

The Anti-Defamation League thinks that's a bad idea, as do many others who have witnessed Newman's theories at work. They say that while his neo-Marxist philosophizing and zany plays appear comical from the outside, there's very little amusing about his rigid orthodoxy when viewed up close, with the occasional anti-Semitic outburst being only part of the problem.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

One of those who has recently made her complaints public is a Los Angeles-based theatrical producer named Molly Hardy, who was hired last year by a neighborhood clinic in L.A. run by a longtime Newman associate. Hardy thought she was being hired to produce neighborhood theater but soon discovered that her job was to produce youth talent shows on the West Coast like those currently promoted by Newman and Fulani's city-subsidized All Stars Project.

The talent shows date back to the early 1980s, when Newman's political organization, then called the International Workers Party, decided that providing venues for kids to sing and dance could aid its other organizing. The shows are not aimed at developing talent so much as getting kids to "perform"—an all-important buzzword in Newman's theories.

Last June, Hardy was flown to New York to receive training at the All Stars Project about how to put together a talent show. "It was more like controlling me than training me," said Hardy.

She received a 12-page "Licensing and Policy Manual." It spells out, in minute detail, how All Stars talent shows must be conducted. Each licensee must undergo two to three years of training by national All Stars staff, including trips to the New York headquarters. It also lists the minimum number of seats for each show (500), number of volunteers (45-50), clipboards (75), rubber gloves (two boxes), and tubes of Super Glue (two), along with a couple dozen other must-have items.

More troubling to Hardy were the provisions listed under "All Stars Talent Show Network Tenets" that said all participants and audience members were required to pay admission fees. That was Newman's Social Therapy peeping through—you gotta pay for what you want. Hardy was sent to observe a talent show on June 26, 2004, at Walton High School in the Bronx, where she saw the rules put into practice. There, a mother with three young girls in tow arrived at the school after taking the subway from their home in Queens, eager to participate. The All Stars organizers told the mother that she had to pay $22—a $5 fee for each of her daughters, and $7 for her to sit in the audience. "The mother didn't have the money, and they wouldn't let her in," Hardy told the Voice. She said she watched as an All Stars representative approached the woman and said, "What did you hear the person on the phone tell you to do?"

The mother answered that she heard the figure $5, but that she thought that was the price for the whole family. According to Hardy, the All Stars representative, a white woman with a lengthy association with Newman, responded, "You need to listen so you don't perform like a poor, uneducated black woman."

"The woman got real mad," Hardy said. "She said, 'I am going to report you.' The kids were crying. I turned to two of the volunteers with me and said, 'I could never do that.' One of the volunteers said, 'I know. It is really hard at first. You get used to it.' "

What made the scene more unreal, Hardy said, was that only 11 kids showed up for the show. "They had 50 volunteers, all with these red vests on, and only 11 kids in a theater that holds 500."

Back in Los Angeles, Hardy filed complaints with state officials and the FBI, charging that the clinic that employed her had improperly funneled money it received from the government to All Stars. She also relayed her criticisms to the office of New York State attorney general Eliot Spitzer. The office, which said it had reviewed past complaints about All Stars without finding violations, said it had yet to receive Hardy's information.

All Stars officials refused to discuss Hardy's allegations or any other matters. "We'll have no comment for your story," a spokesman for the group said late Friday. He gave his name as Bill O'Reilly. Wait a minute, he was asked, is that your real name? "Honest. We just don't talk to The Village Voice," he said.

Needed: A New Approach to U.S. Violence (1997)

By Gabrielle Kurlander
Christian Science Monitor, November 7, 1997

Violence in America is not new. Nor is it an aberration. From the revolution that founded our country to "Beavis and Butt-Head," violence is as American as apple pie.

Still, many Americans feel strongly that somehow violence is not the same thing it has always been. It has taken a new place in our daily lives. Some people point to the fact that children are bringing guns and and knives to school; others cite the proliferation of violence on television and in the movies.

There is, I think, another important difference in what violence is today and in how we are experiencing it.

Historically, violence arose in the context of an America that was growing, prospering, progressing, and developing - economically, politically, and culturally. Consequently, violence generally occurred in the context of an overall constructive thrust to American life.

We can't just 'stop the violence' by throwing more tax dollars into the pot. Similarly, harsh 'tough on crime' legislation has had little impact.

That is no longer the case. This is not to suggest that the violence of times gone by can be justified as having served a purpose. Violence was, and is, brutal and destructive. In a world that has in some respects all but stopped developing, however, violence takes on a different significance - in the lives of individuals and in the life of America itself.

This is particularly true of poor inner-city communities where, with economic and social development at a standstill, violence is often all that is happening.

Decades of liberal failure have shown us that you can't just "stop the violence" by throwing more tax dollars into the pot. Similarly, the evidence suggests that even the harshest "tough on crime" legislation has had little impact. According to "The Real War on Crime: The Report of the National Criminal Justice Commission," for example, "academic research has shown little or no correlation between rates of crime and the number of people in prison."

Traditional solutions to violence, whether liberal or conservative, have simply not been effective.

The Senate is scheduled to take action soon on The Violent and Repeat Juvenile Offender Act of 1997, part of a package of proposed juvenile justice legislation. The debate, which is taking place along the old political fault line, ignores the historical changes in American violence.

Violence is the bad news. The good news is a new kind of development. Innovative programs - independent of government funding and politicking - are making use of cutting-edge research in human development to reinitiate the constructive development of tens of thousands of inner-city youngsters in some of New York City's poorest neighborhoods. These same neighborhoods recently have witnessed an unprecedented downturn in crime and violence.

While the professional politicians continue to invoke traditional solutions to mobilize the shrinking pool of voters who keep them in office, these independent programs are developing the lives of young people and the future of America.

Gabrielle Kurlander is president of the nonprofit Community Literacy Research Project Inc., which sponsors the All-Stars Talent Show Network, a New York City anti-violence program for youth.

Business Unusual (1991)

NOTE: Interesting how Newman used to be more than willing to step up to the plate and take full responsibility for every single front group (and, more importantly, to openly acknowledge a connection among the IWP’s cultural, political, therapeutic and business ventures). In the article below, Newman is assigned full credit for a variety of artistic and financial schemes, and crows about having the support of prominent members of the black arts community—all this and corporate sponsorship, too! With the exception of the All Stars Talent Show and the Castillo Cultural Center, all of the projects mentioned in this article were either abandoned (by Newman) or were jointly disbanded after bitter contests for artistic and financial control. Guess who served as free labor in all of these businesses—social therapy patients and rank-n-file cadre.

By Michael Klein
National Alliance, August 8, 1991

When the Party Boat set sail for Bear Mountain up New York’s majestic Hudson River on a foggy May morning seven wars ago, Dr. Fred Newman didn't know at the time that the all day outing would lead, a few short years later, to a corporate sponsorship of an immensely popular summer entertainment extravaganza that has become the talk of the town. Not to mention finding himself neck deep in film, theater, video and cultural enterprises.

And much, much more: there’s the corporate sponsorship deals with Anheuser-Bush Companies, Inc, the giant brewer behind Budweiser beer, a feature film production, a hit off-off Broadway show, the largest and most successful talent show network for youth in the country, business ventures with a sparkling of some talented and creative people, all of them innovators, in their respective fields. People like the Reverend Sharpton, America’s premier civil rights leader, who is less widely known for his role in bringing millions of dollars from the billion dollar entertainment business back into the communities from which they come; multi-talented music producer and publicist Tony Rose; writer, actor and director James Chapman who leads the Living the Dream theater company; songwriter Annie Roboff and countess more performers, artists, DJs, promoters, recording engineers, investors, publicist, rapper, songwriters, roadies, writers, clowns and fire-jugglers.

Not to mention the hardest working man in show business, America’s most beloved contemporary artist, James Brown. This fall, one of the record companies Newman founded will release a fabulous lost masterpiece, a set of recordings by the Godfather featuring none other than Reverend Al Sharpton preaching alongside Brown singing a series of gospel classics, including “God Has Smiled on Me,” “Power in the Blood” and “Nearer My God to Thee.”

Welcome to Fred Newman Productions, Inc., the business empire built by America’s most controversial political figure, with a portfolio that includes some of the hottest acts and talents around.

But back in May of 1984, Newman was concerned with managing the first presidential campaign of the then fledgling New Alliance Party, the independent party he had been instrumental in bringing into being five years earlier when he brought together progressive leaders of the welfare rights movement to form a people’s party in New York City. By ’84, NAP was ready to go national, and that was going to cost money. Newman opted for a cruise up the Hudson, which would give members of NAP’s New York community the opportunity to have some fun and sun on the Hudson and raise money for the campaign.

It was a hit—so much so that by August they were back on the boat, this time for a moonlight cruise named “Jumpin’ in ’84,” which was not only a fundraiser for the campaign but also a tribute to top African American artists starring alumni of the legendary Count Basie Band. It was fun, moonlight, and all-important dollars for an historic move onto the national arena, for progressive independent politics.

Newman was convinced that the key to successful fundraising was professionalization. For the two summer cruises, New Alliance Party activists and volunteers took on the job of planning and running the rides, the primary goal being that everyone who came on board would have a BLAST. The idea was doubly radical; it revolutionized not only how entertainment events were done, but gave a new and radical twist to how leftist politics was done as well.

“There has always been, tragically, a glorification of poverty in progressive politics,” Newman recalled, citing the instance of a progressive Southern state legislator who had complained about how the New Alliance Party violated the tenet that for a movement organization to be legit, it had to be poor. “We do not glorify poverty,”

And out of that simple dictum—that poverty is an evil which needs to be battled out of existence by any means necessary—Newman has fashioned an extraordinary, new way of doing business, a business as unusual as anything in these trying times that is committed to the needs of people and our communities above all else.

From the stage of the popular downtown club, Wetlands, Cantor Cohen Debo'rah Yahvah and company, dressed in biblical garb complete with swords, leads a crowd of hundred of mostly white young people in a chant/rally/sing-along, turning the trendy, alternative music club in to a rocking call and response happening.

“C'mon, ya'll, let me hear you!”

“No justice.”

“No peace.”

They chant for Tawana Brawley, and Phillip Pannnell, Jr., and other victims of racial violence, here in the middle of the New Music Seminar. The Castillo International recording artist was one of the featured performers during the annual showcase of the cutting edge of music and performance. Debo'rah has already sold over a thousand copies of her “Reggae Down Babylon” single, recently out on Castillo International, a record, tape, video and publications production and distribution company that is among the latest of Newman's enterprises, and which is in the midst of discussing licensing for the record, which has made a splash as far away as Japan.

Castillo International’s Gabrielle Kurlander, special assistant to Newman, built CI into a vital force in the publishing and recording business, developing a national sales team that pounded the pavements to build the grassroots network, and bringing on as national spokesperson, Moses Stewart, who rose to national prominence as a much-respected battler for social justice following the murder of his son, Yusuf Hawkins in Bensonhurst in 1989. The funky “Reggae Down Babylon” was the label’s first straight-ahead dance release.

A powerful vocalist and songwriter who refined her art in the churches and clubs of Florida (she was once dubbed “Jacksonville’s own Aretha Franklin”), Cantor Cohen Debo'rah Yahvah's music is an organic part of the new and righteous movement for social justice on the streets of African America whose call and response rallying cry: “No justice, No peace,” has shaken the forces of evil and injustice across this land. The regulars at Wetlands, where the radical alternative culture of the 60s has been revived, had just joined forces with a new movement—a social/cultural/political happening of the 90s based in the African American communities, new and unusual business. The performance/get together is rocking, passionate, historic and fun. Newman strikes again.

Back on the Hudson—around 1985.

Out of the success of the boatride/fundraisers, the idea for a concert series on the water—Musicruise—was born. Key to making it happen was the coming “on board” of respected concert producer Julie Lokin of New Audiences, Inc., one of the largest such enterprises in the New York area. Lokin had started out as a patient of Newman’s, whose burgeoning Social Therapy practice had grown over the past decade and a half to become a significant force in the mental health field. Newman established himself in the field of business counseling; among a group of business people who had sought out Newman’s much respected services was a young Jewish businessman Bob Levy of the advertising firm Levy, Sussman and Levine, who today serves as executive vice president of Fred Newman Productions, Inc.

Together Lokin and Newman, with Levy providing management support, have piloted Musicruise into what is now its eighth and most ambitious year, having established itself over that period with a roster of top acts and the Newman brand of fun. Before you even embark from Manhattans Pier 81 (every Friday night throughout the summer there are two sailings, and some nights three), you can spend (free) the early evening hours on land enjoying a unique “carnival of possibilities” with fire-jugglers, slack-rope walkers, belly dancers, stilt-walkers, clowns and wandering musicians, not to mention food, drink and crafts for sale. By the time you board the boat, ticket in hand, you are most definitely chillin’ and ready for some of the hottest acts around. The whole experience of mingling top talent and a delightful array of acts that would make Broadway Danny Rose green with envy has resulted in rave reviews across town from customers, weekend guides and trade magazines.

“Musicruise Mixes Music, Social Message,” says the headline in Amusements and Business, a respected industry journal. “Before the ship sets sail, guests are courted on the pier by an offbeat carnival of mimes, clowns and stilt walking poets, produced by New York’s Castillo Cultural Center,” AB notes in a flattering profile. “The venture is not operating without a social conscience: Mingled with the free entertainment are vocal representatives from the Community Literacy Research Project, a New York organization combating the city’s drug problem. The representatives speak to the public, call for donations and sell merchandise to support their causes.” Newman strikes again.

What’s a veteran political activist such as Newman doing, swimming in the mainstream of the billion dollar entertainment biz reading Variety, auditioning talent and sitting down to hammer out a string of deals with all sorts of people you might ask. Those who first saw him in the entertainment [magazines] or chatted with him after a theater performance of “Our Young Black Men Are Dying and Nobody Seems to Care,” James Chapman’s extraordinary and moving play that Newman is directing at the Castillo Cultural Center (where he is the executive director) may wonder how one of the keenest minds in show biz wound up as America’s most important and controversial political activist and organizer.

“Buy political,” says Newman. That was a slogan he coined in the early 80s, when the political community he was building was increasingly reaching out to and getting support from local businesses eager to be a part of a movement for political empowerment. Political community has distinguished the tendency Newman founded in the late 60s throughout its nearly 25-year existence. Newman was born in the Bronx to a poor Jewish family during the depths of the Depression, artistically and literarily-gifted, those talents were forced below the surface by the survival needs that followed the tragic death of his father when Newman was nine years old. The gifts came out instead in the machine shops of the Bronx and Manhattan, where he learned the craft of tool-making. After service in Korea, Newman took advantage of the GI Bill to earn a doctorate in philosophy at California’s prestigious Stanford University.

Following graduation there was a series of teaching posts at colleges coast to coast, but by the mid-60s Newman was being bounced out of school after school for giving all A’s to every one of his students so as to keep them from being drafted. His academic career finished after that rebellion, Newman—now quite radicalized by the turmoil of the times—turned to political organizing.

In contrast to the various leftist “party builders” who've come and gone, Newman’s burning concern was to sink roots into the heart of the community by building, from the bottom up, independent political, cultural, economic and therapeutic institutions.

“Buy political” grew from the success of that new kind of building: neighborhood businesses, mom and pop stores, the local dental clinic and scores of other establishments were happy to support the efforts, with advertising, contributions of goods, services and money; lots of other ways: Newman insisted that the support be mutual.

“It has been African American artists who have made the music business in this country.” says CI’s Kurlander. “But distribution is owned lock, stock and barrel by companies with no concern for the African American community. We've had the beginning, with CI of establishing a truly independent distribution network. All of the profits go back into the community. We’re here to make money and we know what we are going to do with it—reinvest it in the community.”

By the time of its first outing up the Hudson, Newman’s tendency was ready to branch out with the particular brand of professionalism that Newman had developed, moving ever more deeply into both the high-rolling entertainment business (although the base of community business support was always nurtured) as well as other arenas. The Rainbow Lobby was launched in Washington, DC to apply grassroots pressure on Capitol Hill that would force the powers-that-be to pay attention to the yearning for peace and decency that politicians generally ignored. Very rapidly, the Lobby became a million dollar operation, investing the funds contributed by tens of thousands of supporters back into legislative and lobbying efforts that have already won a number of significant victories for the national and international democracy movement.

And NAP was getting ready to launch its second national campaign, with Newman managing the 1988 Presidential run of Dr. Lenora Fulani, the dynamic national spokesperson for the party who made history by becoming the first African American and the first woman to get on the ballot in every state. The professionalism that had by now become the hallmark of the tendency not only pulled off the almost superhuman feat of gathering the necessary million and half signatures (striking down a number of anti-democratic state election laws in the process) but also qualifying for over a million dollars in federal primary matching funds. Between the Lobby, the national campaigns, Musicruise (and other entertainment ventures launched by New Alliance Productions), Newman’s Social Therapy practice and that of other therapists he trained at the Institute for Social Therapy, the tendency had become a “millionaire,” but with a twist: all of the money is reinvested back into the community, to fund local campaigns, develop young artists, build schools, expand health care and legal services, and much, much more.

Musicruise and the All Stars Talent Show Network in particular had sunk themselves deep into the cultural mainstream. The boat rides have had continuous corporate sponsorship and support, while the talent shows culminating in the twice yearly National Finals in New York’s Town Hall have become star-studded, gala affairs. Throughout the year, young people who join the talent show network not only get to display and develop the awesome creative talent they have honed in the ‘hood, but also run lights, stage manage, sell tickets and build audiences in their communities, creating the infrastructure necessary for the network to grow and thrive at the grassroots.

Because this isn't about simply dropping some dollars into a community, but actually creating what is needed for a whole new way of doing entertainment, and business, so as to grow and expand.

“This business enterprise is one which has been built to support our people and our community,” says Newman. “People like Cantor Cohen to Tony Rose to James Chapman are contributing to that.”

It’s quite dialectical really, the community contributing to an enterprise that makes it possible for the community to be given to, all in one business package. Most importantly, the model breaks out of the traditional scheme which has devastated under-served, and downright exploited, communities dependent often for their very lives on the uncertainties of corporate largesse. Even the most conscientious businessperson has to weigh a whole host of factors in giving back something to the folks who made success possible in the first place.

“Individuals and businesses have always given back to the community in some way or another, but now there is a business designed to do just that,” Newman explains. “Not just a portion of the money, but the bulk of it goes into the community, because that is how the business has been set up.”

Which has led to some extraordinary and important collaborations of late. In association with Carl Clay, the moving force behind Black Spectrum Theater in the African American community of Queens, Fred Newman Productions and the Community Entertainment Group is producing “Let’s Get Busy,” a powerful film starring rap idol Doug E. Fresh as a young artist who organizes young folks in his community to challenge the corrupt political machine that’s selling them and their families down the river. Doug E. is on of a crew of talented and socially concerned artists who have lent their support to the Talent Show Network, as have Regina Belle, Kool Moe Dee, MC Lyte, and actor Giancarlo Esposito.

Clay—who describes Black Spectrum as “dedicated to producing a theater of social relevancy”—first met Newman’s enterprise through the All Stars. “There was a very positive gravitation toward both entities we had developed mutual respect about programs that we were both doing with young people,” Clay recalled in an interview at the start of the project last year. “I had gone around trying to get the resources to do this film, and there was a great deal of interest—but a different type of interest. A lot of people didn't want to get involved in the politics, no matter how much I talked about this being the wave of the future, and that it’s the kind of thing we need to talk about with young people. A couple of foundations wanted to help out, but the bottom line was a lot of ‘interest.’”

Sated for release later this year, “Let’s Get Busy” will be the first full-length film Fred Newman Productions will have helped to make happen. A number of distributors are already looking with interest at the film, which is now getting the finishing touches put on its soundtrack.

I don’t want nobody to give me nothing. Open up the door, I’ll get it myself.”
James Brown, 1968

That’s the Godfather of Soul himself talking. And as everybody knows, there is probably no artist in America who ha been a more passionate advocate of folks and communities doing it for themselves with their own strength. “Just open up the door,” James has always demanded.

And there has probably been no more forceful door opener in the past 15 years than the Reverend Al Sharpton, currently president of the National Action Network. who in addition to being the most important civil rights activist in the nation today, has also specialized in putting heat on corporations to give back to the communities some of the money they take from it (fully 25% of all U.S. entertainment consumer dollars are generated from the African American community).

Forged in the crucible of Dr. King’s “Operation Breadbasket” by the Reverend Jesse Jackson, throughout the 1990s Sharpton led numerous campaigns that leaned on big entertainment to give something back, using community mobilization as muscle.

In 1980, while Sharpton was heading up the National Youth Movement, he went into a studio in Augusta, Georgia with Brown, who since the early 70s has been a surrogate father to the civil rights activist, to lay down the only gospel record that Brown has cut in his extraordinary 30-year recording career.

At the time of recording I had already been involved for years in the movement, and he had supported me, doing concerts with the Youth Movement,” Sharpton recalled. “He and I decided we wanted to do a record, and this was the only time that he wanted to do gospel. He wanted to record me preaching, so we decided to [combine] it as a rap/gospel record with me preaching and him singing.”

They put down the two main tracks with James’ powerhouse band, the JB’s: “God Has Smiled on Me” and “Power in the Blood,” a pair of powerful and inspirational rockers with Brown and “Rev” trading off on the vocals (“Preach. Rev” Brown exhorts his surrogate son in the course of the tracks). Three years later they were back in the studio to round out the collaboration, laying down more tracks, including a beautiful arrangement by Brown of the classic “Nearer My God to Thee.”

Recently, Brown decided that he was going to pull the lost masterpieces from the vault to lay on Sharpton as a gift.

“The ultimate gift that a musician can give is to do his music with somebody,” says Sharpton proudly. “To have James Brown record you—that’s like having Picasso do a portrait of you so this is an ultimate, personal gift he gave me, more as a result of our father and son relationship than anything else.”

Sharpton brought the tapes to Newman, whose Castillo International had already produced and marketed Reverend Al’s first release on tape, the remarkable “Sharpton and Fulani in Babylon.” Produced, mixed and mastered by the enormously gifted Tony Rose, “Babylon” was Castillo International’s first tape release. Rose took the documentary audio footage from the movement on the streets for justice that Sharpton and Fulani had been leading and transformed it in the studio into an extraordinary audio experience, mixing in raps, beats, samples and adding special effects that created a brand new genre altogether which grabs you, the listener, from your chair and gently but firmly thrusts you into history.

CI also produced and distributed “Independent Black Leadership in America,” the only collection of the writings of Sharpton, Fulani and Minister Louis Farrakhan of the Nation of Islam currently available under one cover. The book, released last year and now in its second printing, is carried by a number of national distributors, including Baker and Taylor, the nation’s largest. Building upon the support provided by community-based book and record stores, “Independent Black Leadership” has now landed on the shelves (and the best seller lists) of chain stores like B. Dalton’s and Tower Books, generating profits that can be sunk back into attracting and supporting more talented authors from the community. And this September, CI will publish “The Man Behind the Sound Bite: the Real Story of the Reverend Al Sharpton,” the first biography of the “people’s preacher.”

FN Productions’ executive [vice president] Bob Levy is thrilled with the forthcoming release of the Brown/Sharpton gospel collection on the CI label, and was equally thrilled with the opportunity to meet Brown in Augusta recently. “I had been directly responsible for the marketing and advertising for Polygram Records with Levy, Sussman and Levine in the 70s—when James Brown was on the label,” Levy recalled. “I hadn’t had an opportunity to meet him until now. 1 first saw him perform in 1963, and I wanted him to know that there were millions of young people like me who grew up on him. He was part of our lives how we dressed and how we danced. And he’s one of those legends who—when you meet them—lives up to the legend.”

What they were like as kids

“Nothing runs on air. WE MUST HAVE MONEY to do our dream.”

Tony Rose—musician, producer, engineer, publicist, a modern day Renaissance man—is a living, breathing example of the power, creativity and hope for a new life in our communities unleashed by the unusual business of Newman’s enterprises.

Brought up in the African American community of Roxbury in Boston, Rose, like Newman. hoisted himself to the pinnacle of excellence in his field, in this case, the recording business. As a manager and engineer (among Rose’s countless credits was the engineering of the New Kids on the Block “Merry, Merry Christmas” mega hit), Rose was at the height of his creative powers when he first met Newman at the Castillo Cultural Center. They have, in a short time, developed a strong and intimate relationship based on their shared commitment to give their all to the community, and to make all the money they need to make it happen.

Tony Rose does not glorify poverty either.

“Fred Newman appeals to every person on the planet,” says Rose. “He gives 100% and more to every thought and idea that comes in to him. I’ve seen and met a lot of people, but he is the first I have connected with. He can understand everybody who comes across his way. His love of people—of human beings—is enormous. And his business acumen; we’re talking about a Stanford graduate, that’s no joke. I’d love to know what he was like as a kid, you know, ages 5 to 15.”

Like Newman, Rose grew up in poverty, an experience which helped shape a powerful commitment not just to making it, but to do whatever was necessary to ensure that everyone makes it.

“Myself as a Black man in America—I’m a captive,” says Rose. “We’re all people, with our hopes and dreams, but someone like George Bush sees himself as a conqueror. And I’m the captive. So it’s my job to overthrow the conqueror. It’s a fight of good against evil, and at the end of the day, Fred Newman is a good man against evil. He’s in history.”

Rose, like Newman and all those involved in the enterprise, is confident that CI—including the profits—will continue to skyrocket. “The business success is naturally there, because I’ve never seen a person give people so much as much as Fred does, in so many ways, what they need,” says Rose. “And Bob Levy, that cat is something else.”

Rose described a typical evening hanging out with Newman. “First he would do business, business, business with me. And then business, business, business with Al Sharpton. And then do a newspaper meeting. And then, he put on a smock, and he started to paint. You know, we’re here for a short time, and he knows that.”

Newman and Rose have recently become partners in a new record label, Cold Sweat Records, which is about to rock the house and the clubs with its first release, “Debbie’s House Party.”

“Hey, ‘Debbie’s House Party’ is a great record. I’m proud to do this in partnership with this person. We’re on to the next level in business, we’re rocking and we’re rolling and we’re in business. It’s designed for a purpose. It’s our coming out.”

Barely a year old, Castillo International is indeed coming out, all over. The James Brown/Reverend Sharpton collaboration promises to thrill the millions of fans of both. “It’s going to be a classic, and ironically, he’s hotter now than he’s ever been commercially, and I definitely wasn’t the household name I’ve become when we recorded it,” says Sharpton. “James was a victim of police brutality as well as police misconduct, but because of the spiritual side of James Brown and his understanding of oppression, he came through without bitterness because he had a depth that was deeper than they thought, like a Mandela. He was able to turn a negative situation into a resurrection of his entire career.”

Is the entertainment world ready for Reverend Al Sharpton, rock star?

The Art Factory: What is a Revolutionary Workers' Collective (1989)

By Fred Newman
Stono, 1989

Castillo is a new collective of artists, journalists, technicians, intellectuals, formed by the coming together of two other collectives—the National Alliance (NA) newspaper collective (begun in 1979) and the Castillo Center for Working Class Culture (CCWCC) collective (begun in 1981). And the CCWCC was itself born of—what else?—still another collective, the New York institute for Social Therapy and Research (NYISTR—begun in 1978). So, it should be clear, Castillo is about collectivity. But what in the hell is collectivity anyway? The dictionary (with its usual pomposity) says that “collectivity” is “the quality or state of being collective.” And it defines “collective” as “formed by collecting; gathered into a whole” and “of, as, or characteristic of a group; of or by all or many of the individuals in a group acting together” (our italics). But Castillo is a certain kind of collective; it is a workers’ collective. As such it is a group working, not merely neutrally acting, together.

But what is work, in general, and what is cultural and intellectual work in particular? And what’s collective work? And what’s collective cultural and/or intellectual work? To get a handle on these matters we have to go beyond the “neutral” dictionary of Mr. Webster to the distinctly and admittedly class biased science of Mr. Marx. Work, or the activity of producing goods or services, is typically organized in our culture and/or society in a highly productive yet highly alienated way. Workers, cultural and otherwise, are “Strangers in an Estranged World,” making things not for their own or their families or even their communities’ use but rather for exchange, i.e., to be sold in the appropriate market place. Indeed, what is produced is ultimately (at least in most cases) used. But the criterion of production is whether it will sell; not whether it is socially needed. (The 493rd brand of striped toothpaste is obviously less needed than the as yet unbuilt housing for the homeless but there is more money to be made on 493.) The estrangement of labor, therefore, is the subtle transformation of one’s work activity into a product together with the transformation of labor itself into a product (paid for by a wage), thereby alienating or structurally separating one’s creativity and productivity from oneself, i.e., one’s human activity.

Now those who benefit most from this arrangement (this organization of work)—we’ll call them capitalists for the sake of our exposition—argue that this way of doing work has produced the most and the best products that humankind has ever had. Many seriously disagree with this claim of the capitalists. Others agree but raise the question of the price humankind has been forced to pay for the capitalist arrangement. Still others point out that times change and that what was best and most at an earlier moment in history might no longer be either relative to the current collective needs of the Earth’s total population. Castillo believes that work—cultural, intellectual or otherwise—done for exchange is destructive of both worker and product and points to the current level of decadence manifest in capitalist art, capitalist science, capitalist culture, capitalist toothpaste, capitalist politics and capitalist workers as clear evidence. The socialist countries, surely more committed to production for use rather than exchange, but vastly poorer than the capitalist countries and, moreover, functioning in a capitalist (exchange dominated) world environment, have not yet come close to exhibiting the social superiority of collective production for use. Furthermore, we believe that socialist, communist, revolutionary and progressive intellectuals and artists within capitalist countries, especially but not limited to the U.S., have failed to create the conditions necessary to carry out collective work for use. Castillo believes that we have a critical role to play in making plain both the possibility of and the superiority of workers’ collective production for use in intellectual, journalistic and cultural work.

What’s so different about us? Castillo is a critical component of a new political movement for radical independence. Here in the U.S. progressive working class politics, culture, journalism and intellectual work have historically been profoundly hindered by the absence of working class institutions useable both to produce and disseminate the politics, culture, journalism and intellectual products of our class. Working class newspapers, theatres, research centers, art centers, schools, political parties etc., while to some extent functional (albeit in extremely assimilated/revisionist fashion) in Western Europe and other still-capitalist sectors of the world, are conspicuously absent in the U.S. So-called progressive working class politics, art, etc., are inevitably both created and transmitted by petit bourgeois institutions and/or straight out bourgeois institutions and, therefore, employ the mode of production of the petit bourgeoisie and/or the capitalists. In order to break with this state of affairs radical independence is required, not as a state of consciousness or even a unique political programmatic, but as an activity. Radical independence is organizational self determination, only derivable from the activity of developing unmediated (direct) organizational relationships to the working class and enlightened middle class community. Radical independence means building actual working class institutions.

Perhaps this language is too fancy. The work involved, however, is hardly fancy. Castillo is a working collective of artists and intellectuals who every week, for many hours, fundraise door-to-door to support our radically independent mode of artistic and intellectual production. And the radically independent network of embryonic working class institutions of which Castillo is a component fundraise not only door-to-door but subway car to subway car and block to block in our working class and middle class neighborhoods to establish not merely a financial independence but a political independence unrealizable when Exxon or even a more humane philanthropist is the ultimate funding source of one’s creative activity. Castillo co-operatively, enthusiastically and successfully works to build new, radically independent working class-for-itself institutions here in the U.S.A. This radical independence both makes possible and demands a re-organization of creative and intellectual work.

Now the artist or intellectual—radical or not so radical—might insist (many do) that they do not create for exchange. Indeed they might claim that they create neither for exchange nor for use. The petit bourgeois artist with the very best of intentions may say that she or he creates out of a deeper psychological or spiritual or creative drive. Perhaps so, but psychological, spiritual and creative states of mind do not determine social reality; social reality determines them. No doubt these complex mental states, in their turn, profoundly influence social reality. But it is illusion to suppose that the inner drives of our species can transform the oppressiveness of our exploitatively organized society and culture. Rather it is the collective reorganization of the mode of creating and producing art and analysis which will yield profoundly new and sublime inner states now unimaginable.

But we must push even deeper. Production for use? For whose use and for what use? Is our production for the use of the working class? This might seem the apparent answer. But it is, of course, wrong. Our creative production is for the use of all those who support the total reorganization of all work so as to eliminate ultimately the exploitation of human by human. The working classness of Castillo’s politic is not a petty sectarian bias but a world historic recognition that the reorganization of work is a necessary pre condition for the elimination of all forms of exploitation, racism, sexism, homophobia, etc. The reorganization of work and the political organization of the working class are dialectically interdependent. For the bourgeois economically defined working class in itself is in no way the revolutionary class for itself that will usher in (by including all of humankind within its domain) a development of productivity and creativity heretofore unknown, indeed, unimagined by our species. If the working class is not a politically revolutionary activity (practical critical in Marx’s words) then it is not truly a class at all. It is not an historical class: it is merely a societal category.

Revolutionary Culture or "Marxist Aesthetics"

The Marxist aestheticians (not surprisingly!) work feverishly to justify their claims that there is such a thing as “Marxist aesthetics.” To achieve this impossible justification (for there is no such thing as Marxist aesthetics, still less a justification of it) they re write and de revolutionize Marx by explicitly eliminating revolutionary activity.

In his general introduction to the widely respected Marxism and Art, Maynard Solomon articulates the classic version of the “justification.” We quote extensively in the interests of fairness:

Marxism, however, has had its greatest successes precisely in the realm of heightening and transforming consciousness as a prelude to the intended transformation of society. At the very tune that Engels was composing his last works. Marxism had become the accepted philosophy of a party representing large segments of the German working class, and was making inroads in other countries as well, including Russia, the United States, England and France . Its theories were gripping the masses. To the extent that its exponents emphasized the derivative aspect of the various modes of consciousness they appeared to negate the means of explaining Marxism’s influence. Marxism could only account for its revolutionary power (and prevent itself from being transformed into a doctrine of evolutionary parliamentary passivity) by “correcting” the economic determinist emphasis, by explaining how men are able to “make their own history” even though they do not do so “out of whole cloth.” This posed an apparently insuperable difficulty for those who regarded Marxism as an unalloyed “science of society”: if ideas can transform society, how can it be asserted that economic forces are in the last analysis decisive? [Footnote 19: Lenin was to introduce an even greater difficulty. He asserted that the working class could, by itself, only achieve trade union consciousness, thereby suggesting that the automatic processes of history could not produce socialism.] If super-structural categories are contingent upon the material base, how can it be said that such categories are in turn decisive in the transformation of the material base? If Marxism posits the dependency of superstructure upon material social historical developments, how can Marxism itself be explained except as a premature expression of a working class which has not yet asserted itself in a decisive economic sense? Further, if the ruling ideas “are the ideas of the ruling class” how can the anti-capitalist power of the Marxist theories themselves be explained? Is Marxism exempt from its own laws?

As has been indicated, the issue turns on dialectics. Marx had laid the groundwork for the solution to these difficulties as early as 1843, in the Introduction to A Contribution to the Critique of Hegel’s Philosophy of Right (see below pages 52 53), where he described the philosophical artistic “dream history” in which Germany had avoided the necessity of present political action but in which it had anticipated its revolutionary future. [Footnote 20: The separation of Marx from Feuerbach hinged on precisely this question of the dynamic subject: “The chief defect of all hitherto existing materialism … is that the thing, reality, sensuousness, is conceived only in the form of the object or of contemplation, but not as human sensuous activity.” (Theses on Feuerbach.)] Engels patiently took up this thread m his later writings. In Ludwig Feuerbach, he wrote: “Just as in France in the eighteenth century, so in Germany in the nineteenth, a philosophical revolution ushered in the political collapse.” Super-structural events—ideas, philosophy, art, etc.—prefigure changes in the mode of production. Marxism not only allows for, but demands the heightening of consciousness as a necessary pre condition for historical progress.

The stress in Engels’ later works upon the active and revolutionary side of super-structural processes reconfirmed the presuppositions from which Marxism originated. The ruling ideas of each age are the ideas of the ruling class (see below, pages 49 50). These include an anticipatory element which comes into being not primarily as the emerging consciousness of a rising class but as the highest level of consciousness of the most advanced members of the ruling class itself who seek thereby to avoid the painful realities of social existence as well as to transcend their awareness of impending extinction as a class. [Footnote 21: “The bourgeoisie itself … supplies the proletariat with its own elements of political and general education; in other words, it furnishes the proletariat with weapons for fighting the bourgeoisie,” write Marx and Engels in a different context (The Communist Manifesto, chap: one, p. 117).

They continue: “Just as, therefore, at an earlier period, a section of the nobility went over to the bourgeoisie, so now a portion of the bourgeoisie goes over to the proletariat, and in particular, a portion of the bourgeois ideologists, who have raised themselves to the level of comprehending theoretically the historical movement as a whole.” (loc cit.).] These ideas penetrate various strata of society through the mediation of the art forms and theoretical writings in which they are expressed, becoming part of the consciousness of oppressed classes, crystallizing into the Utopian, revolutionary, system shattering goals of ascending groups—the imaginative models by which the mode of production is ultimately transformed.

No revolution can take place without the work of ideological preparation, without the transformation of consciousness. History is an extension of the labor process, in which, writes Marx in Capital, “we get a result that already existed in the imagination of the labourer at its commencement” (see below, page 23). [Footnote 22: Marx’s discovery ‘that the labor process consists of the materialization of goal projections (concretizations of the imagination) not only resolves the philosophical problems of causality and teleology (origins and goals, means and ends are inseparably linked) but also constitutes the basis for the formulation of all applications of Marxist theory—whether of politics, philosophy, or aesthetics. For in Marxism the labor process is the model of all social activity, and the teleological element in the labor process demarcates human labor from instinctive animal labor.

Engels writes: “The animal merely uses external nature, and brings about changes in it simply by his presence; man by his changes makes it serve his ends, masters it. This is the final, essential distinction between man and other animals.” (Dialectics of Nature, p. 291). Lukacs explores this subject in a brilliant essay of his final years, “The Dialectics of Labor: Beyond Causality and Teleology,” (Telos, no. 6 (Fall 1970), pp. 162 74). See also Lucio Colletti, “The Marxism of the Second International” (Telos, no. 8 (Summer 1971), pp. 84ff).) And this brings us back into the aesthetic dimension: it is mankind’s dream work play, poetry, theoretical science, philosophy its mock world into which the imagination withdraws for sustenance and rejuvenation, which is a necessary motor of the labor process and of history itself.

If this analysis were even halfway correct it would justify the comfortable inactivity of the Marxist aesthete as an independent “consciousness raiser,” an expert on contemplation and imagination who hobnobs with the literati and culturati of the bourgeoisie not because of his or her liking for the dry martini. No. According to Solomon the Marxist aesthete, ever self-sacrificing, bears the horror of the Hamptons and elsewhere to serve the proletariat by discovering those necessary ideas,” … mankind’s dream work—play, poetry, theoretical science, philosophy its mock world into which the imagination withdraws for sustenance and rejuvenation [does he mean booze and hor d’oeuvres?], which is a necessary motor of the labor process and of history itself.” (Our italics)

But the creative contemplations and imaginings of an alien class could not be and need not be the necessary motor of history. The real resolution, i.e., the Marxist resolution, of the problematic laid out by the not so wise Solomon is, of course, revolutionary activity, not “Marxist aesthetics” or bourgeois creativity. The “dynamic subject” spoken of as a necessity by Solomon in his footnote 20 is nothing more and nothing less than the revolutionary activist. Indeed, the extent to which the Marxist aesthete seeks to eliminate revolutionary activity is never more apparent than in Solomon’s clever albeit disingenuous de-contextualization of Marx’s first thesis on Feuerbach. Here is the whole thesis, the full quote:

The chief defect of all hitherto existing materialism (that of Feuerbach included) is that the thing, reality, sensuousness, is conceived only in the form of the object or of contemplation, but not as sensuous human activity, practice, not subjectively. Hence, in contradistinction to materialism, the active side was developed abstractly by idealism which, of course, does not know real, sensuous activity as such. Feuerbach wants sensuous objects, really distinct from the thought objects, but he does not conceive human activity itself as objective activity. Hence, in Das Wesen Des Christenthums, he regards the theoretical attitude as the only genuinely human attitude, while practice is conceived and fixed only in its dirty-judaical manifestation. Hence he does not grasp the significance of “revolutionary,” of “practical critical,” activity.

Solomon, like Feuerbach, does not “grasp the significance of ‘revolutionary,’ of ‘practical critical’ activity.”

“Marxism … demands the heightening of conscious’ ness as a necessary pre condition for historical progress” asserts Solomon. But what is the activity of “heightening consciousness”? Not, mind you, what activities heighten consciousness (for such a formulation idealistically reifies “heightened consciousness”) but what is heightening consciousness qua activity? Marx, the revolutionary, insists that it is only heightening consciousness as revolutionary activity which allows women and men to “make their own history.” The resolution of Solomon’s pseudo problem (i.e., how can there be new and revolutionary ideas if the ideas are themselves totally determined products of an economically over-determined base) is organized revolutionary activity. For it is only in, with and by such collective activity an activity which explicitly is not “an extension of the labor process” and therefore not historical in the bourgeois or societal or class in itself sense but historical in a class for itself or revolutionary sense, that the subjective objective (and the superstructure base) dichotomy is practically and totally smashed.

Solomon’s distortions know no bounds. In footnote 19 he actually invokes V.I. Lenin to justify his cultured analytical life style. But when Lenin “asserted that the working class could, by itself only achieve trade union consciousness, thereby suggesting that the automatic processes of history could not produce socialism,” he was hardly advocating a year’s vacation for himself to be spent playing chess with Maxim Gorky. He was, and Solomon surely knows this, insisting that economism was a deadly deviation from Bolshevism, whose centerpiece is its insistence on the fundamental role of organized revolutionary activity (the Leninist party) as a pre-condition for social revolutionary change.

Does the issue “turn on dialectics,” as Solomon glibly indicates? Indeed, when the “Marxist Aesthetician” starts talking about dialectics (not to mention “turning on”), hold on to your money. To be sure, the dialectical method is critical to Marxist science. But dialectics, for Marx, is not reducible to a bourgeois model of feed back or American style pragmatic interactionism. Dialectics is the methodology of revolutionary activity. Here, in all fairness, we must point out that Solomon has been mis-educated by no less an authority than Engels. For it was Engels, caught up in the paradigm of 19th century bourgeois science, who over-identified dialectics (and dialectical materialism) as a universal rather than as a revolutionary science. It was Lenin, not Engels, who translated Marx’s (and Hegel’s) dialectical method into revolutionary activity. And while Lenin understood this well the critical role of the petit bourgeoisie and of intellectual and creative work in the revolutionary process, he never regarded “consciousness raising” as in any manner an alternative to organized revolutionary activity (i.e., the democratic centralist revolutionary party).

In sharp contrast to both Marx and Lenin Solomon says, “No revolution can take place without the work of ideological preparation, without the transformation of consciousness. History is an extension of the labor process, in which, writes Marx in Capital ‘we get a result that already existed in the imagination of the labourer at its commencement.’ And in footnote 22 he adds, “For in Marxism the labor process is the model of all social activity...”

But whether the labor process includes producing something that was or wasn’t “in the imagination” of the laborer hardly matters. Contemporary computerized and automated production more and more suggests that this statement is, even on its own terms, false. But to use this empirically questionable feature of the labor process to justify the motor force role of imaginings (and, in Solomon’s argument, bourgeois imaginings at that!) in the revolutionary process is utterly ludicrous. For to claim that “in Marxism the labor process is the model of all social activity” is to relegate Marxism to a passive science of societal assimilation as opposed to an active science of revolution. For, you see, the revolutionary activity is not modeled after the labor process. The revolutionary activity is, in fact, the self conscious reorganization of the labor process; it is only by virtue of this reorganizing activity that relevant imaginings (whatever their origins) transform into significant social and cultural tools (and results). It is the revolutionary activity (the reorganization of the labor and production process) which challenges the minant epistemology ontology and methodology which in turn makes consciousness raising (using culture and knowledge created by the bourgeoisie and even its precursors) meaningful in a revolutionary sense.

CONCLUSION

Castillo is, as we have said, reorganizing the process of producing art and analysis. Castillo is reorganizing the production of culture; reorganizing the production of how we see and hear and feel and touch and imagine and dream and think and love and learn and…. We are reorganizing the production of culture, to the extent possible, for the use of the revolution for the benefit of all humankind.

The significant feature of revolutionary work and production, cultural or otherwise, is not the dominance of theory over practice, thought over action, or even a “dialectical unity” between theory and practice, thought and action. The plan, the idea, the conception, in revolutionary production do not precede the action or the activity, in any sense, dialectical or otherwise. Indeed the “teleological element” is absent in revolutionary work precisely because such work completely challenges the linear, cause-effect organization of work (and everything else) in bourgeois society; in its place is a historical relationship to production which treats the totality of human history and development, to be sure in antagonistic relationship to its current societal organization but not determined by that societal organization. Thus the reorganization of cultural production in a revolutionary manner yields art which at once challenges the totality of the societal organization of culture and contributes to nothing less than the totality of human history. It is production which in both form and content will not be circumscribed by any societal assumptions and pre-conditions. To be sure it will be determined by them. Forces of production cannot be idealized away. But Castillo will not be organized by the societal organization of the production of culture. All of this, of course, if we succeed. If we fail we will … well, who cares and who knows?

The Castillo production process is dialectical in practice, not in theory. Lev Vygotsky, the Soviet psychologist, has taught us about tool and result.

The search for method becomes one of the most important problems of the entire enterprise of understanding the uniquely human forms of psychological activity. In this case, the method is simultaneously prerequisite and product, the tool and the result of study.

(Vygotsky, 1978, p. 65)

All our products are results and tools, revolutionary tools. Yet these are not the tools of the local hardware store. They are far more like the tools of the tool and dye maker—tools specifically shaped to be results capable of advancing the further production—of tools! Revolution, we were once told, is not an afternoon tea party. But what if it is? What, after all, is an afternoon tea party? Well, it depends on how you produce it for whom and for what use. Tools, tools, tools. We are not simply making toots (and results); we are reorganizing the production of art and analysis so as to yield tools and more tools (and results). Our art is never commodified because it is simply the tool for the next result—and tool and result and tool and result and tool…

U.S. Left Opens $2.7 Million Psychology & Cultural Center (1989)

By Jacqueline Salit
National Alliance Newspaper, 1989

The New York Times’ real estate section described it as a “hands off condo conversion” in a front page story last April. The property is 500 Greenwich Street in the far west section of fashionable Soho. The newly renovated second floor of the imposing old brick building—it was once a U.S. post office—is now the headquarters of a stunningly beautiful therapy and arts complex

Located in one quarter of the floor’s 9,000 square feet is the East Side Center for Short Term Psychotherapy. A series of richly designed, jewel-like rooms—each one a different size and a different shape, walls hung with the paintings and photographs of the artists across, the way—is where the therapy gets done.

The East Side Center (it used to be located on Manhattan’s Upper East side and kept the name when it moved) is a partnership of psychiatrists, psychologists and psychotherapists trained in the radical discipline known as Social Therapy. In the early 70s Dr. Fred Newman, the founder of Social Therapy, applied a series of theoretical breakthroughs he made in the nature of human emotionality to the development of a progressive clinical approach now practiced at the ESC. The effectiveness of Social Therapy in treating the emotional problems of patients from all class, racial and ethnic backgrounds and the business acumen of its practitioners has turned the social therapeutic movement from a mental health alternative on the outskirts of the psychotherapeutic mainstream to an operation which grosses nearly $45,000 a month, $35,000 of which is income directly from the practice of Social Therapy. The additional $10,000 derives from educational and training activities designed to reach both the public at large and mental health professorial with aspects of the social therapeutic approach. An evening seminar on “Friendosexuality,” conducted by Newman in New York this month, drew an audience of 200 and grossed $3,500.

The lion’s share of the second floor—about 6,000 square feet—belongs to the Castillo Cultural Center, a multi-disciplinary collective of radical artists.

Castillo is a color-lavished, high-spirited and totally serious work-place reminiscent of a giant Tinker Toy constructed to reveal, rather than disguise, the process of production that is Castillo’s cultural work. It was designed and produced by architects Wilton Duckworth and Doug Balder and a team of highly skilled crafts who—as members of the independent political community to which Castillo belongs—were in love with their task and, working in close collaboration with Newman, built accordingly. It expresses at every moment, in every joining of wood and iron, space and light, the passion and playfulness, the seriousness and joy, the ongoing working class love affair that gave rise to it. The formal opening of Castillo in October (the East Side Center held its own opening March) will unveil this extraordinary revolutionary architectural achievement, whose price tag came to nearly $1 million.

Under the direction of Newman (he is a playwright, director, actor and painter in addition to being a psychotherapist), these actors, directors, painters, journalists, photographers, graphic designers, researchers, comedians and architects operate an art factory, a workshop, a theater, a darkroom, and a publishing house that produces two bi-monthly magazines—Stono, An International Journal of Culture and Politics; and Probe, The Intelligence Magazine of the Working Left—and a weekly newspaper, the National Alliance.

Through its range of activities—including a nightly door-to-door canvassing and street fundraising operation, the sale of advertising space in its publications and a telemarketing system which sells subscriptions to both performances and publications—Castillo grosses in the neighborhood of $55,000 a month, or nearly three quarters of a million dollars annually. It expects to raise, an additional $40,000 in contributions and revenues for its premiere season—A Festival of Revolution—a theatrical, artistic and political statement on the viability of American revolution in the face of the stalemate between international capital and the socialist bloc and the continuing struggle for revolution in the underdeveloped world. The centerpiece of the festival is a tetralogy of theatre pieces: the American premiere of The Task, by East German avant-gardist Heiner Müller; Müllerschmerz, by Castillo Collective member and African American dramatist William Pleasant; Carmen’s Community, based on the opera Carmen by Bizet; and No Room for Zion, by Fred Newman.

The dazzling complex at 500 Greenwich—which combines the highly profitable social therapeutic center servicing a surprisingly multi-racial, multi-class, gay and straight clientele with a controversial cultural collective that has flourished without benefit of government, corporate or foundation funding—has already established itself as a unique and provocative location on the art and psychology scene.

But even more unusual than the combining of the two, and even more controversial than either Newman’s social therapeutic discoveries or Castillo’s cultural statement, is the fact that, this highly visible and profitable enterprise is a project of the major left tendency in the United States of America.

There’s an old Left joke that goes, “What do you call three Trotskyists in a phone booth?—a left political convention.” This is one of those jokes that is more tragic than funny in that it offers a remarkably apt description of the vision of the American Left: ultra small and ultra irrelevant.

But to the traditional U.S. Left—the Communist Party USA, the Democratic Socialists of America and the various sects and sectlets that periodically pop up across the political landscape—marginality is a virtue and poverty is next to godliness. For the U.S. Left, being poor means you’re down with the masses and that you haven’t been bought.

But even a child knows that in the U.S. of A. things cost money. Big things cost big money. And you don’t have to be Ché Guevara or V.I. Lenin to know that if you’re making something as big as a revolution, you’re gonna run up some pretty big bills.

In 1983, with the first four successful years of the New Alliance Party behind him, Fred Newman turned his attention to making money. NAP, on whose executive board he served, had gone heavily into debt off its first attempt to win permanent ballot status the year before. It was clear from NAP’s 1979 Bronx run, the 1980 and 1981 Dump Koch campaigns, and from the 1982 ballot status race that there was a palpable responsiveness from both working class and middle class communities to independent politics and to a grassroots challenge to the monopolization of the political process by the Democratic and Republican parties. The problem was money. Reaching masses of people with both message and organization was expensive.

To begin, Newman turned to the Social Therapy centers—then called the Institute for Social Therapy and Research—which he had helped to launch in 1977. Therapy was the one activity of the political network of which he was the architect that generated a financial surplus.

Through an extensive financial reorganization including the closing down of several centers that dramatically reduced the Institute’s overhead—Newman and a business consultant, Deborah Green, upgraded training and supervision of the therapists, standardized and professionalized fee collection and produced a dramatic upturn in the profitability of each practice. In turn, the social therapists, all political activists as well, contributed a large portion of their enriched partnership draws to fund a long term research and development project directed by Newman. He assembled a team of grassroots organizers—he called them Community Social Workers—who began going door-to-door with a portfolio of community-based service organizations, soliciting members and contributors. The experiment was oriented towards creating a mass-production, mass-organizing model that could turn the practice of political organizing into a money-making activity which could in turn fund the expansion of the mass organizing. This was the key to building a mass-based, large-scale, independent political movement in the United States.

“There was a great deal of resistance to this expanded reproduction model,” recalls Deborah Green, MBA. “The mass organizers were impatient, they didn’t want to give the model any time. They kept falling back on personality organizing or subjective explanations for what was—or wasn’t—going well. The challenge was to objectify the whole process and thereby discern how we could move many people to do just a little bit financially and politically, rather than focusing on getting a few people to do something big by way of participation.” The work proceeded slowly.

When the Rainbow Lobby—the independent, pro-democracy Capitol Hill lobbying office—was opened by one of Newman’s colleagues in 1985, the door-to-door canvassing operation began to experiment with reaching into middle-income communities with the Lobby’s message. The results were startling. Within weeks the canvassers were raising between $50 and $100 in one evening shift. That money went to the Lobby to support the expansion of its activities on the Hill and its capacity to educate greater and greater numbers of people about the erosion of American democracy. Canvassers collected consistently large amounts of money while explaining that legislative, political and legal initiatives have to be supported at the grassroots in order to combat the overriding and anti-democratic influence of the Far Right. Nearly 35,000 people have joined the Lobby in the last four years and an additional 90,000 have contributed to its cause.

By 1988, the Lobby had dozens of canvassers in the field, was running a telemarketing operation to reach contributors for follow up donations and grossed $548,000. In 1989 the Lobby has put 60 canvassers in the field and projects that it will gross $1.2 million.

The success of the Lobby canvass had far reaching implications. The scientifically proven responsiveness of broad, cross-sections of the population to a door-to-door appeal for more democracy gave Newman the data he needed to design the groundbreaking matching-funds drive for African American independent Presidential candidate Dr. Lenora Fulani—whose cornerstone campaign issue was the need for more democracy. In 1988 Fulani became the first African American woman in history to qualify for federal primary matching funds. Over 66,000 people contributed to the drive. Her campaign raised a total of $2,757,548—$938,798 of which was the matching grant from the federal government.

A large portion of that money was used to finance the ballot access drive that placed her and the New Alliance Party on the ballot in all 50 states and the District of Columbia—the first time in American history that a Black and woman appeared on every presidential ballot in the country. The media coverage of Fulani’s fight to get on the ballot—while by no means comparable to the billions of dollars’ worth of free advertising afforded George Bush and Michael Dukakis—was nonetheless substantial. Millions of Americans heard her demand that the inequalities in the presidential electoral process—which effectively disenfranchise the vast majority of the American people—be rectified. A quarter of a million people voted for her, and the New Alliance Party emerged from the election as the fourth largest electoral party and the largest progressive party in America.

“And now there is a national election with the NAP candidate, Lenora Fulani, on the ballot in all 50 states, with federal matching money and national media coverage, a feat not achieved by the Communist Party or other left, third-party challenges. We keep asking, where does the money come from, and how does it affect other leftists’ struggle to operate in some connection to the electoral process?”

Radical America, September/October 1987
From an introduction to a
series of four articles attacking
the New Alliance Party,
Lenora Fulani and Fred Newman

The tired and cynical remnants of the establishment U.S. Left, like the editorial board of the magazine Radical America, keep asking: “Where does the money come from?” Interestingly, the right wing is provoked by this matter too. An article in the July 17 edition of the Belgian newspaper, La Libre Belgique, stated that Mobutu Sese Seko—the fascist dictator of Zaire—claims that the Rainbow Lobby is financed by diamond merchants from Antwerp. Mobutu has been a prime target of the Lobby’s international legislative and educational campaign for democracy and human rights, and his reputation was badly damaged by a hugely successful national media blitz spurred by the Lobby during his recent visit to the United States. After the trip, his backers in Washington, DC told La Libre Belgique that “they doubted that contributions from American citizens could cover the expenditures of the Rainbow Lobby.” In the Belgian newspaper Le Soir an anti-Mobutu journalist who has exchanged information with the Rainbow Lobby was accused by the Mobutu government of being “funded by Jewish diamond merchants.”

Both the Right and the Left disingenuously insist that they can’t figure out how the network of political, psychological and cultural organizations engineered by Newman is funded. How do they get their money? They do it the revolutionary way. They organize committed people to ask people for it. And the political, or cultural, or psychological statement that is intrinsic to the organized activity of asking is so relevant that people—hundreds of thousands of them—give.

Communists in the Mainstream (1987)

An IWP Plenary Presentation

The accomplishment of our tendency is the development of a non-revisionist new left in this national sector. We have successfully built a tendency which is bringing communism into the mainstream of the body politic in the United States of America. For a particularly exemplary instance of communist leadership in the mainstream, think back to the last weekend of June 1986.

On Friday night, we produced a Musicruise featuring Jorma Kaukonen. While some of our organizers were keeping the peace among the white working class of New Jersey, others were presenting at a gay leadership conference downtown. This conference continued the next day. That night, the New York Institute for Social Therapy & Research presented at its 10th Annual Marxism and Mental Illness Conference a theatre piece, "After the Revolution," which showed not only that it could happen here, but graphic details about just how it might happen-complete with hints at contemporary activities (such as infiltrating the Sixth Fleet and having NAP stockpile weapons in the community).

The next day, we marched 200 strong down Fifth Avenue in the Gay Pride March. In the scornful words of one Democratic Party hack, "NAP put on a show again." The March was followed by a meeting of some of the leading theoreticians and organizers of our tendency in which they planned a conference on the issue of communists in the mainstream, and that was followed by a week-long program to train newly developing communists who had come in from all over the country. This exhausting weekend was a particularly striking display of our capacity to be, and our location as, communist leaders in the mainstream.

Self-conscious Bolsheviks were on the Hudson, marching down Fifth Avenue, in a West Village church, a Social-Democratic controlled community theatre, and in our own independent Castillo Center-hard at work shaping whatever social motion could be discerned, exploiting opportunities that came our way while the bourgeoisie was on vacation, imparting a certain social stamp even to a rock concert. It has always been our contention that we don't have to water down our communism in order to be in the mainstream. On the contrary, we believe that it is impossible to be a communist without being in the mainstream, and whatever mainstream successes we have had are wholly due not to our business acumen, but to our cadre, as Bette the Bronx Bomber would say: "that tightly knit, well-disciplined leadership body of crazy motherfuckers."

Not since the successful organizing of the Communist Party USA in the 1930s has the U.S. had communist leadership. And never before has it had non-revisionist leadership. How did the CP sell out? How do we avoid the pulls of revisionism? What are revisionism's historic roots, and the current manifestations in the left, the working class movement, the mainstream body politic?

We are communists in the mainstream, the non-revisionist left in the United States of Amerikka. Therefore, because we have a fused, if modest (or "small," to quote the New York Times, the official newspaper of record) relation to the class and because of that, a fused, if modest, toehold in the American body politic, we are confronting mainstream revisionism every single day in a hundred ways. Revisionism is no less than the character of progressive politics in the United States. As Marxist-Leninists, we must know its character and history intimately in order to purge all remnants of it from our tendency and to further expose it in the mainstream-distinguishing it from our politic and organizing the class to support a genuine communist politic.

We are not the first communist attempt to move into the mainstream. The Communist Party USA was a significant force in the mainstream during the 1930s and the first part of the 1940s. This was the period of their greatest success as a mass-based leadership force of the U.S. working class and, in the later part of this period, their greatest failure, as the popular front was transformed from a correct tactic for fighting fascism to a revisionist strategy for socialism.

From the end of the Civil War through the post-World War II period, U.S. capital consolidated its political control, rapidly built its industrial plant, and emerged as the leadership of the international bourgeois class. This relatively rapid ascendancy of the U.S. bourgeoisie also meant a rapid proletarianization of the U.S. working class-one of the historic conditions for mass working class ferment. During this approximately 80-year period-in particular from the 1880s on through the late 1940s-the U.S. working class waged a bitter and ruthless struggle (not infrequently an armed struggle), against the U.S. bourgeoisie. In its struggle for economic rights the U.S. working class expressed unadulterated, pure class rage.

During the organizing of the copper and coal miners, lumber jacks, longshoremen and other industrial workers, pitched battles occurred frequently between armed workers and armed thugs, the Pinkertons-a private army hired by the Rockefellers and other robber barons and industrialists. A not uncommon scenario was the Pinkertons murdering the women and children at a strike camp and the strikers attacking the Pinkertons, culminating in the public hanging of leadership of the strike. In the organizing of the United Mine workers, if a worker didn't sign a union card his arms were broken in half. If a miner wanted to live, he signed. International Women's Day and May Day-both international working class holidays-have their origins in this country. The U.S. working class was out for blood. That is our heritage-which the CPUSA sold out.

The 1930s-the Great Depression-was a period of massive working class ferment: in the urban neighborhoods, on the farm and on the job, in the factories and coal mines, amongst the southern Black sharecroppers, middle-class progressives and the intelligentsia. The CPUSA played a leading role in organizing all of these sectors. The two most tactically significant were the organizing of the industrial working class through the eventual building of the CIO (Congress of Industrial Organizations), and the southern Black working class.

The CPUSA owed its capacity to organize Blacks to the leadership it got from the Third International, the Comintern. For the CPUSA's position was that Blacks were simply another section of the working class that had to be united and gain equality with the white working class in order to achieve greater class strength. Under the leadership of the Comintern, the CPUSA changed its position to one of identifying Blacks as a separate nation with the right to self-determination. The Sharecroppers Union-a predominantly Black organization of sharecroppers and laborers who were arming themselves and demanding land-expressed this strategy.

By the mid-1930s, the CPUSA's base in this most militant working class in the leading capitalist country of the world made the CPUSA a shining star, the jewel of the Third International-of all the CP's internationally. The political challenge which the CPUSA faced was how to provide political leadership to the class-conscious militancy of the U.S. working class. It did not rise to this challenge; it failed utterly-such that this most militant and rageful working class was sold out and destroyed as a class, and the CP-style revisionism spread like a cancer and became incorporated fully into mainstream American progressivism.

The CPUSA was formed shortly after the Russian Revolution by trade union leaders and militants and, as they were called, foreign born Marxists from Eastern Europe and Russia-all of whom supported the Principles namely Leninism-that guided the Russian Revolution. There were many fundamental problems in the formation of the CPUSA. One (which we have discussed and written about extensively) is that while the CPUSA was formed out of the correct recognition that a vanguard party was needed to make the revolution, the tactical question of what needed to be done to form a vanguard was not engaged.

Historical, tactical, dialectical, scientific questions like: what kind of relationship could be organized between a vanguard and the working class; what was the state of the working class at that time; was there a basis for a vanguard party; what political issues would be raised for the class in following the leadership of the vanguard; what mass organizations were needed as a basis for the development of the vanguard; were not raised. Though there was a programmatic agreement with Leninism, Leninism was never practiced. Political differences which were worthy of principled political struggle in order to advance the Party's organizing rapidly polarized into factional fights. A factional struggle broke out between the trade unionists and foreign-born Marxist elements over whether the party should be legal and above ground (the position of the trade unionists) or illegal and underground (the position of the foreign-born Marxists).

The decision of the Comintern was in support of the organic U.S. trade union based leadership. The party, it was stated, should be legal because, since the U.S. was a bourgeois democracy, the party could function legally. This was seen as an advantageous position from which to recruit the working class into a communist party. Indeed, the position of the trade union faction was that the militancy of the U.S. working class would make it receptive to communist organizing-a very dangerous position if it's oversimplified, which it was. The Comintern's support of the trade-union wing coupled with the upsurge in trade-union organizing in the 1930s de facto made the trade-union faction's politic dominant in the CPUSA. It's important to examine this politic and its historic origins.

The trade union movement in this country did not grow from a party as in Europe, but rather the parties-most importantly the CPUSA-grew from the trade union movement. This has had a two-fold effect on the development of the U.S. working class. On the one hand, it allowed for the development of a working class that was not conservatized by a social democratic politic as in Western Europe but rather expressed pure class rage. On the other hand, the U.S. working-class movement developed separately from a strategy for socialism and historically has been politically backward. The specific politically backward perspective of the class in this national sector has been syndicalism-a politic which holds that the working class struggle is fundamentally economic, not political, and needs to be fought in the economic arena. Working class rage and militancy is thought to be sufficient to achieve socialism-a vanguard party is not needed.

The International Workers of the World (IWW), a most militant working class organization seeking to organize One Big Union in the late 1800s and early 1900s, was anarcho-syndicalist. They rejected participation in the electoral arena and any form of organizational structure that would curb spontaneous class struggle, e.g., dues check-off, union contracts, etc. They were for all-out continuous class struggle. Ironically, the CPUSA was formed in part as an alternative to anarcho-syndicalism, as well as to the social democracy which engaged in the political arena through elections but didn't recognize the need to smash the state. The CPUSA, while recognizing that a revolutionary political party was necessary, retained a syndicalist deviation. This deviation was the source of their sellout.

William Z. Foster was the leading trade unionist who formed the Communist Party in 1919 and was General Secretary of the Party in the 1940s, following Earl Browder. In some of his writings, Foster located the U.S. working class' vulnerability to syndicalism in its being seduced by bourgeois democracy and thereby thinking there isn't a struggle to be waged on the political front. He bemoaned the fact that the U.S. working class suffers from a low class consciousness. This is an interesting analysis, for in claiming that syndicalism demonstrates a lack of class consciousness Foster is confusing a rejection of the political struggle with a low class consciousness.

The Wobblies, for example, were scornful of bourgeois democracy, not seduced by it. Their lack of political activity didn't grow from a lack of class consciousness or vulnerability to belief in the bourgeois state. Rather, they were ultra-left politically. Class consciousness was not the problem with the U.S. working class prior to WWII. The issue was how to shape that class consciousness, that rage, into a political consciousness or, more to the point, revolutionary activity. This was the very question that needed to be dealt with in deciding what kind of communist organization to form after the Bolshevik revolution in Russia in 1917.

Though militant class consciousness may be a necessary condition for the development of a mass-based revolutionary vanguard organization, it's not simply more class consciousness that is needed to form this vanguard organization. Foster's analysis holds on to the primacy of class militancy and confuses that with political development. The perspective the CPUSA ultimately employed was to "lend the economic struggle a political character," Lenin's characterization (in What Is To Be Done?) of economism-making the economic trade union struggle primary or placing the economic struggle before the political struggle.

The vulnerability of the U.S. working class and its leadership to syndicalism is not simply that it's enamored of bourgeois democracy. The vulnerability is historical, not psychological, and has much to do with the specific manner in which capitalism and bourgeois democracy developed in the U.S. As articulated in Green and Newman's article "The Divine Right of White America: Euro-Centrist Ideology in the U.S." (Practice, 1986), it is the white skin privilege of the U.S. working class that is the basis for its political backwardness which, among other things, takes the form of glorifying the struggle and capacity of the working class to achieve economic power-a kind of syndicalist "manifest destiny" (Practice, pp. 22-23).

For the working class to function as a political leadership force and not merely fight for its own immediate economic interests (i.e., syndicalism), it must provide leadership in the political struggle against all oppression. Making the political struggle primary in the U.S. means making the fundamental struggle the struggle against racism. A communist leadership force in the U.S., then, must provide revolutionary leadership to the struggle of Black people.

Though for a brief period in the early 1930s the CPUSA moved beyond organizing Blacks simply for equality to organizing for revolutionary control, this was only a temporary programmatic change, which, at the risk of sounding anti-communist, was imported from Moscow under the leadership of Stalin. The fact that it was imported is not the problem, but rather the problem is that the correct identification of the revolutionary potential of the Black population did not result in the purging of the CPUSA's syndicalism. The change in perspective didn't come complete with a thorough reappraisal of the CPUSA's tactic and analysis nor was it a self-conscious challenge to the racist ideology of the white working class.

The CPUSA, never employing Leninist method, never capable of principled political struggle, overwhelmed by the militancy of the trade union struggle, was incapable of reversing the racism of its analysis and misidentified the source, character, and what is to be done about the political backwardness of the U.S. working class. The response of the CPUSA to the challenge to develop the politic of the class was to call for more militancy (which meant joining the CPUSA) instead of engaging head on structural racism.

By the mid 1930s, with syndicalism in hand, the CPUSA had become a militant left political force to be reckoned with in U.S. politics. Its popularity was growing. Roosevelt recognized the Soviet Union in 1933. This helped lay the basis for the Third International in 1935 to organize a popular front with all anti-fascist forces against the rise of fascism in Europe, which was posing a threat to the existence of the Soviet Union and the future of International Communism. The objective need for a limited unity of anti-fascist forces was a valuable opportunity for the CPUSA to thrust further into the mainstream, which it did. Furthermore, the CPUSA was moving into the mainstream with something the bourgeoisie, in particular the Roosevelt wing, needed to control, namely, a militant labor base with popular support.

Roosevelt, a bourgeois revisionist, was revising the structure of the bourgeois state in the form of the New Deal. He was attempting to bring labor into a new political coalition which would reorder economic policies by bringing the economy under more direct state control. By doing so, labor's effectiveness and revolutionary potential as an independent force would be blunted. Just as the bourgeoisie needed something from the CPUSA, the CPUSA needed something from the bourgeoisie, namely, for it to fight fascism. In addition, the bourgeoisie had something the CP wanted, as opposed to needed-the capacity to help it become a legitimized social force. Both sides had strong bargaining positions and a deal was struck.

In its first decade of existence (the 1920s), the CPUSA was a marginal political force. Within the space of a few years in the early 1930s, the CPUSA built a mass base in the labor movement and within a few more years it had direct lines to the White House-a very rapid move into the mainstream. During the popular front period, 1935-45, with a brief interruption during the Hitler-Stalin pact (a tactical move by Stalin to delay Hitler's attack on the Soviet Union), the Party was at the height of its popularity and growing rapidly. Its influence also extended to the intelligentsia and middle class. Its syndicalist deviation was particularly evident here in its perspective on culture-which was to build and support working class culture. The syndicalism lies in the belief that you can have working class culture under capitalism without making the revolution, another example of the divine capacity-stemming from the divine right-of the white working class.

The specific major reforms from the New Deal were the unions winning minimum wages, maximum hours, restrictions on child labor and the right to organize and to strike. The cost of the deal for the bourgeoisie was making the trade union movement a permanent fixture, a state-endorsed element of U.S. society. Elements of the bourgeoisie were dead set against Roosevelt's concessions to labor; they were considering assassinating him and had plans to seize state power. But, in fact, legitimizing labor was a small price to pay for retaining economic and political control. The cost of the deal for the CPUSA and the U.S. working class was, of course, much greater in fact, too great.

In exchange for winning economic reforms and the possibilities of consolidating the popular front and remaining in mainstream locations where it could best influence the U.S. entry into the war against Germany, the CPUSA dropped its independent organizing. The Sharecroppers Union, an organization that was beginning to arm the southern Black and some elements of the white working class, was disbanded and full support was thrown behind the NAACP. Within the unions, patriotism superseded all else. By 1940, CPUSA members were introducing resolutions in the trade unions denouncing the adoption of communist, fascist or other "extremist" foreign policies-justified as an attempt to prevent an anti-communist purge.

Though during World War I the international capitalist class was disunified and at war with one another, the capitalists emerged from this war as a unified international class under the leadership of the U.S. bourgeoisie, with a right split (fascism) emerging. The international working class, on the other hand, emerged from the war split by the sellout of the social democracy, but having made a monumental historic gain in Russia, the establishment of the first socialist state. What was needed internationally was much party building, but it wasn't being done. Instead, a non-Leninist method of party building was used, leaving the strategic needs of the working class in other national sectors vulnerable to being subsumed by the tactical needs of the Soviet Union. Thus, by the 1930s the international communist movement made the same deadly political sacrifice to the bourgeoisie as did the CPUSA. In exchange for the popular front, revolution was abandoned as the means for achieving socialism. In Spain, the Civil War of the 1930s was fought solely in defense of the bourgeoisie state against fascism with no independent tactic for making a socialist revolution. The critical task of figuring out how to employ the necessary popular front tactic without subsuming strategic goals for socialism was not accomplished by either the Comintern or the CPUSA.

The CPUSA mistook the concessions Roosevelt made to labor in the New Deal for socialism. It thought they had achieved their goal without making the revolution. They were full partners; Roosevelt like Stalin; Uncle Joe was a kind of popular hero. The unions had state sanction. Socialism was underway and would continue to develop under the benevolent protection of the popular front. The Marxist-Leninist cover of the CPUSA's syndicalism was blown. The syndicalist deviation and practice of the CPUSA made the Party vulnerable to total cooptation when it entered the mainstream. The winning of the trade union demands was equivalent in their eyes to winning the revolution. Communism was equated not only with unionism but patriotism as in the remarkable slogan "Communism is 20th century Americanism."

In 1940, Earl Browder, then General Secretary of the Party, was jailed on trumped up charges of passport forgery. This signaled FDR's support for purging the Communists from the unions. Shortly after his release from jail three years later, he made the following statement in a piece called, "Victory and After," which became the Party's ideological guide:

The prevailing "American way of life," which is dominated by its capitalist foundation in many and most decisive ways, determines that our national unity cannot find expression in the forms and modes followed by the Soviet peoples . In the United States, national unity can be achieved only through compromise between the conflicting interests, demands, and aspirations of various class grouping (primarily between those usually spoken of as "capital and labor"), a compromise which agrees to reach at least a provisional settlement of all disputes through arbitration. The motive power behind such a compromise can only be something which all parties hold in common-that is, patriotism, the common determination to win the war .

The Communist Party of the United States has completely subordinated its own ideas as to the best possible social and economic system for our country . to the necessity of uniting the entire nation, including the biggest capitalists . The Communist Party of the United States foresees that out of victory for the United Nations will come a peace which will be guaranteed by the cooperation of the United States, the Soviet Union, Britain and China . This will make possible the solution of reconstruction problems with a minimum of social disorder and civil violence . We offer our cooperation to all like-minded persons and groups.

In 1944, under Browder's leadership, the Party was disbanded and reorganized into the Communist Political Association (CPA) and though Stalin ordered the Party reinstated in 1945, it continues to this day to function along the lines of Browder's Political Association: "A non-partisan association of Americans" that "adheres to the principles of scientific socialism, Marxism," and "looks to the family of free nations, led by the great coalition of democratic capitalist and socialist states, to inaugurate an era of world peace, expanding production and economic well-being."

The CPUSA had the bourgeoisie on its knees and it let them up. It had significant mainstream location and substantial leverage given its mass, militant base. It needed the popular front, but couldn't handle the tactical intricacies of building the popular front without giving up its independent organizing of the working class. In fact, the harder the bourgeoisie kicked the communists in the head, the more they capitulated. By 1953 the Rosenbergs were executed, McCarthyism was in full swing and the CPUSA was completely on the defensive. At the height of its strength and ferment of the working class and its middle-class supporters the CPUSA never even attempted to seize state power. Indeed, if there were elements of the CP leadership or rank and file that wanted to, there was no possibility of struggle over this most important of issues because a factional split would have ensued.

This most militant of international working classes that picked up arms again and again in hatred of the capitalists was destroyed-totally wiped out as an independent political force. So much so that our class heritage, even to us as communists, is barely recognizable. The social impact on the U.S. working class of its total destruction has been profound. The proletariat exists only as a political class, not an economic class. Without its own political organization and means of expression, it ceases to exist as a class. The complete loss of identity of the U.S. working class is one of the factors that makes psychology the dominant ideological mode of late U.S. capitalism and Social Therapy such a viable tactic.

Since the 1930s, progressive politics has come to be the politic which emerged from the CPUSA's deal with the liberal wing of the bourgeoisie under Roosevelt. But CP revisionism goes beyond the colossal sellout of the New Deal era which destroyed the U.S. working class movement. The CP as an organization makes reconstruction-the rebuilding of the U.S. working class movement-enormously difficult and painstakingly slow by boldly and explicitly thwarting progressive and revolutionary efforts that spring up (e.g. the Black Panthers, the New Left, us). And, further, revisionism has come to be what progressive politics is in the U.S. Its dominant paradigm is the capitulation to reform as the evolutionary means of achieving socialism which requires the abandonment of independent working class organizations. When the progressive movement reacts to the building of an independent left-of-center party as fringy and crazy, this is revisionism.

How else can we make sense of the ludicrous charge against [Liz] Munoz' Peace and Freedom Party run for Governor of California-that an independent party will take votes away from a party of the bourgeoisie (the Democratic Party)-than revisionist capitulation to the bourgeoisie. Isn't a working class party supposed to take votes away from the capitalists? Don't we want to defeat the capitalists, with whom we are in a class war? The brainwashing of revisionism is so great that this argument actually holds significant weight in progressive circles. It is important to see that the revisionism of the CPUSA per se is not the problem. Daily we see them becoming more and more irrelevant as an organization as they tail the Democratic Party and fail to organize any direct relationship to the class. It is, rather, the legacy of their deal with the liberal state-a left-of-center progressive politic that is thoroughly revisionist and corrupted by liberalism-that we must expose and reorganize. The tactical expression of anti-revisionism in this national sector is independent politics. We are thus in the best position to raise constantly the difference between revisionism and communism, while the CPUSA has no historic relevancy.

The failure of progressive politics in this country has made the working class cynical and as a result open to right-wing organizing. The cynicism of the class about the capacity of a progressive movement to bring about social change has its counterpart in the cynicism of the left about the capacity of the working class to carry out revolutionary activity. The failure of progressive politics is not the failure of the U.S. working class but the failure of its leadership. Our commitment as communists in the mainstream is to reorganize this relationship between the class and its leadership.

We must do this by exposing to the class how revisionist progressive politics is a distortion-not an expression-of communism. We do not reinforce anti-communism by blaming communism; we will never do anything that supports anti-communism. Thus, our efforts to stamp out revisionism cannot be a vindictive attack on the CPUSA. Rather, we face the class, continue to build from the bottom up, so that when the class asks what is communism, we are there to answer. Our mainstream location allows us to become that force which the class looks to to learn what communism is. The New York State 1986 gubernatorial campaign is an example of how our location in the mainstream allows us to function in this role.

Our task is to rebuild the American working class from scratch. We must be bold enough to move into the mainstream, ruthless enough to use our mainstream success to keep building our party organizations and our independent relationship to the class, politically principled enough to expose mainstream revisionism without ever being anti-communist, and scientific enough to attack the ideology and political backwardness of the U.S. working class at its source-structural racism.