Showing posts with label Chip Berlet. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Chip Berlet. Show all posts

Tuesday, August 9, 2011

Guru Fred Newman Enchants Loyal Followers and Pat Buchanan (1999)

By George Gurley
The New York Observer, December 6, 1999

Right now, Fred Newman is best known as the man behind Lenora Fulani, an African-American psychologist and two-time Presidential candidate who is a major force in the Reform Party. Recently, Mr. Newman and Ms. Fulani had lunch at the Essex House with Pat Buchanan, who is hoping to be the Reform Party's candidate for President. Ms. Fulani ended up endorsing him and is now his campaign co-chair. All this resulted in jeers, derision, comparisons to the Hitler-Stalin pact, a lot of publicity for Ms. Fulani & and a few mentions in the press of that character in the shadows, Mr. Newman.

Mr. Newman, 64, is a psychotherapist, playwright and self-styled Marxist revolutionary whose organization has its headquarters at 500 Greenwich Street. Every few years, journalists take him apart and repeat accusations (he's an anti-Semite, he runs a cult, he brainwashes people, etc.), but somehow he survives and prospers.

He presides over what he calls "a development community." It's made up of a small clique of members who've been following Mr. Newman for decades and a couple hundred worker bees who have joined more recently. Together, Mr. Newman and his followers run therapy centers around the country, as well as a theater and a talent show network for inner-city kids.

As you get off the elevator at the Greenwich Street headquarters, to the left is the East Side Center for Short-Term Social Therapy, to the right is the Castillo Theater (most recent production: Mr. Newman's musical comedy, The Last Temptation of William Jefferson) and beyond that is a telemarketing room, where volunteers raise money every evening.

It doesn't feel like New York City in there, but more like a community arts center in the Midwest. You see beaming faces, normal faces and a few blank ones, too.

On a Friday afternoon, Gabrielle Kurlander, 36, was sitting on a couch in her office. She acts in and directs Mr. Newman's plays. Since 1990, she has run the All-Stars Talent Show Network.

Ms. Kurlander was wearing a Giorgio Armani pinstripe jacket, black sweater, black skirt. Behind her were some of Mr. Newman's books - among them, Let's Develop!, in which he lays out his philosophy and offers handy exercises like: "Do something wrong just for the sake of saying 'I was completely wrong!'"

Ms. Kurlander said she moved to Manhattan from Ithaca, N.Y., to be an actress. She soon found a place in the community and began pounding nails, sweeping floors, recruiting and attending group therapy sessions led by Mr. Newman, who became her boyfriend 11 years ago.

"He's somebody that I'm very, very close to and have tremendous respect for," Ms. Kurlander said. "I think he's very, very smart." She laughed. "He's not a guru, he's not a cult leader, he's just someone who people follow," Ms. Kurlander said. "There is a grouping of us who've given our lives to this. I get paid now. I didn't used to get paid, and probably if I wasn't paid tomorrow, I'd still be doing this."

Roger Grunwald, the publicist for the Newman group, was present for the interview with Ms. Kurlander, taking notes on a yellow pad.

Enter Mr. Newman, wearing a leather jacket over a button-down shirt, green slacks and New Balance running shoes. Early on, he talked about Pat Buchanan: "I hardly know him," Mr. Newman said. "He seems like a decent man. Pat, when he was a kid, he was a tough Irish working-class kid who beat everyone up."

Ms. Kurlander howled at the remark.

Mr. Newman said he likes Mr. Buchanan's "smarts" and doesn't think he's an anti-Semite: "I'm a Jew, a Jew all my life, and I can smell anti-Semites. He doesn't smell like an anti-Semite."

Mr. Newman, who has long supported the Palestine Liberation Organization and criticized the American Jewish establishment, has also been called an anti-Semite. In 1985, he told a convention that Jews "are the stormtroopers of decadent capitalism against people of color the world over."

"I'm hardly an anti-Semite, which is what I've been charged with," he said. "But it's been played up and it plays well for political purposes in some people's hands and people make use of it and I'm not complaining."

Mr. Newman then held forth on a number of subjects, including Donald Trump's "soak the rich" plan. (Doesn't go far enough, he said.) Ms. Kurlander laughed when appropriate; Mr. Grunwald was silent for the 45-minute session.

I suggested that Mr. Newman and I might be left alone, which Ms. Kurlander found very amusing: "Would you prefer that? Ha-ha-ha-ha! Have a private interview?"

Mr. Newman put Karl Marx at the top of his list of thinkers. "Marx's thought has so permeated all of sociology," he said. "And Bill Clinton is a Marxist. It's taught in all the schools, whether it's called that or not."

Will his own work survive?

"History will let us know whether it's worth anything or nothing, and we say that to each other constantly & Yes! I think it will survive."

Fred Newman, whatever he is, has had an amazing New York life. He was born in 1935. His father, a salesman, died when he was 9. His mother raised five kids on welfare and ran serious poker games and rented out rooms in their house a half-block from Yankee Stadium. Mr. Newman sold baseball stuff there and his mother would talk to players like Mickey Mantle and Yogi Berra as they walked by; the players called her Grandma Sadie.

He hated school, but tested well enough to get into Stuyvesant High School. At 19, he volunteered to serve in Korea, partly to escape a painful love affair. Back home, he attended City College of New York, majored in philosophy, married at 22, lost his virginity and got into Stanford University, where he earned a doctorate in philosophy.

Then he started teaching at City College. In 1966, one of his students asked for an A to avoid the draft. Professor Newman said O.K., started giving A's to everyone, and was eventually fired from six more schools around the country.

By this time, he and his wife had two kids. (His son was severely brain damaged at birth and has spent his life in an institution.) In 1967, Mr. Newman moved to Reno, Nev., for divorce purposes. He took long naps, watched the sun set, listened to the Beatles, drank a little bit, didn't smoke pot and tried to be a writer.

He would wake up at 5:30 A.M. to work on a novel based on his mother, In the Purple Roses of Her Dying Years. Somehow it got into the hands of family members and they hated it.

Back in New York, Mr. Newman went to protests, started a political collective called "If & Then." He read Karl Marx, Mao Zedong and Leon Trotsky, saw a therapist, became a drug rehabilitation counselor at a Queens clinic, which fired him after he organized a work stoppage. In 1970, he started up a therapy practice of his own. And that's when it all started really happening for him.

"Suddenly, I was making money again, more than I'd ever made in my life," he said. He and some comrades created a therapeutic community on the Upper West Side, Centers for Change. They put out two newspapers, Unite and Right on Time, and started a free school for kids and a dental clinic.

"It's probably fair to say I was the dominant leader," Mr. Newman said. "& It's probably fair to say it was my followingpeople were following me. I hope I wasn't an authoritarian oppressor, but I think that's probably accurate to say that."

He and his "following" joined up with Lyndon LaRouche, but pulled out in 1974 to form the International Workers Party, which aimed to organize welfare recipients. Party members raised money on the sidewalks of the Upper West Side.

In 1979, his group evolved into the New Alliance Party; in 1984, it ran a candidate for President. That was Dennis Serrette, a black activist and trade union leader from Harlem.

"Fred was introduced to me at a party," said Mr. Serrette, 59, from his Maryland home. "His persona is a warm, sensitive, sort of jolly, twinkly Santa Claus kind of guy, one that seems always to be a good listener. Then you start figuring out that this thing is not so loose as it looks, it's a lot tighter. Then, when you try to look under the skirt of what's happening, you begin to look a little sharper and you hear the name Fred Newman, Fred this and Fred that, and then you start to say, Well, is this guy the messiah or what?"

Mr. Serrette said he was badgered into Mr. Newman's brand of "social therapy."

"It was like a piranha attack and they all take a bite out of you," he said. "It's like a police interrogation but not with two - you got 10 bad guys biting at you, until they sort of break your spirit or break you down. The women around Newman who carry out his bidding are the ones that really are the lieutenants, they'll smile at you but they kick ass. But he never gets his hands dirty "he always manages to stay just beyond the fray of the fight. He will never engage you in hard discussions. The reality is he's a shrewd tactician who runs the cult through his mistresses."

According to Mr. Newman's spokesman, Roger Grunwald, "Dennis Serrette ended his association with Fred Newman and Lenora Fulani 15 years ago, after his personal relationship with Dr. Fulani broke up. Since then he periodically pops up to be interviewed and to grind a very old ax."

In 1988, Ms. Fulani ran for President and got on the ballot in all 50 states in the race. "I am your sexual preference," went one slogan. That got the Party some attention, as did its embrace of Louis Farrakhan.

On a Thursday evening, 30 or so people were gathered in the center's "telemarketing room" to call "old friends" for money. They were buzzing about over takeout dinners and bottled water. "Volunteer of the Month" plaques were up on a wall.

At 6:30, as the spokesman Mr. Grunwald looked on, three middle-aged women answered questions. They'd all been through Mr. Newman's brand of therapy and said they worked the phones four times a week. One of them, Phyllis Goldberg, said someone handed her a flier on the street and she'd been there for 21 years.

"He's hilariously funny," Ms. Goldberg said of Mr. Newman. "He's probably the kindest person I ever met. He's shy. He's very, very, very smart."

The telemarketers got into their "performance spaces" and got their three-page scripts ready.

Doug Balder, an architect, said he does four or five shifts a week and raises up to $100,000 a year for the Newman group. He has been there 16 years.

Mr. Grunwald said to me after a while: "George, ever done something like this?" he said, smiling, headset on. "You can come back another time, we'll train you." Soon, he led me to the elevator. "There are a lot of people around here who don't make phone calls," he said. "But for the people who do it, they've been organized in such a way that they relate to it in the way that a person would relate to theatrical activity as a member of an ensemble. They're all working collectively."

"They would embrace Adolf Hitler if it would give them credibility," said ex-Newman follower Judi Miller, a writer. Feeling "very lonely" and "isolated," she said she joined the community in 1984 at the suggestion of her dentist. She stuffed envelopes, attended therapy sessions, sold ad space for the New Alliance newspaper. She also agreed to pay a "tithe" and reduce her lithium dosage. Over all, she lasted four years.

"I was one of the only ones not to give up my apartment, and I didn't, because it's rent-controlled, so that would be stupid," she said.

(According to Mr. Grunwald, "These allegations are ridiculous, untrue and politically motivated.")

What did Ms. Miller think of Dr. Newman?

"Don't say doctor," Ms. Miller said. "It's just Fred Newman or Fred. He's not anything to be respected, he's a bullshit artist & You know how you realize things and you have little signals that something's wrong here? Like, well, he's not our lord and master. There's something wrong with this man. It was ridiculous. It was just so dumb. I'm ashamed that I belonged to that group and I was duped."

One of the people who helped in her two-year "detox" was Chip Berlet, of the Boston-based Political Research Associates. Mr. Berlet has studied and condemned Mr. Newman and his group: "He thinks of himself as being one of the great left thinkers of our age," he said. "He's actually kind of a pompous egomaniac. He's surrounded himself with people who constantly are telling him how smart he is, which is the classic aspect of a totalitarian organization."

Mr. Grunwald was ready for that charge: "Chip Berlet works for a left wing think tank that has received substantial funding from major Democratic Party donors," he said. "His charges have long been discredited as partisan `dirty tricks' directed against the independent political movement."

Fred Newman has been ill for the last five years, with diabetes, hypertension and kidney failure. Before undergoing three hours of dialysis, he met me for lunch at the Manatus Restaurant on Bleecker Street. His large blue eyes have a dizzying effect behind the wire-rimmed glasses. "Our work is, I don't want to misrepresent it, it's not Freud," he said. "But it's been accepted by a lot of very, very mainstream, good people."

He said he rejects the idea of the self, along with addiction, victimization and Freud's notion of the human being as fundamentally abnormal. He thinks people are "super-alienated" these days.

"Most of the people I see in therapy," he said, "they have good jobs, they're doing well, they're respectable people. They're the people who, you're walking down the street you're walking by. They're not weirdos, they're not in Bellevue, they're desperately unhappy."

When he's not working, Mr. Newman watches sports and political shows, PBS, and Charlie Rose and watches videos at home. His favorite movie ever is Marcel Carne's Les Enfants du Paradis.

"The character who plays the mime, I don't relate to it," he said. "Like I don't think it's me, but I feel an empathy for the tragedy of his life. By the fact that he's this brilliant, extraordinarily gifted performer but his life is so openly unfulfilling. He can't live in the real world. In some ways he can only fully live in his world of fantasy and I wouldn't say I see that as how I am, but I feel close to that."

Mr. Newman rents a place in the Hamptons every summer and writes out there. He has an assistant who drives him around in a rented Lincoln Town car. He said he once took Al Sharpton to the hospital after he was stabbed and met with Louis Farrakhan twice.

"I found him a very personable, decent man," he said. "I didn't have any sense at all of him being anti-Semitic."

Mr. Newman ordered a piece of rye toast and a mint tea with lemon. "I can't really eat anymore," he said. "I used to be bigger and much heavier. I barely eat now."

He never wears coats in the winter. He's social, likes people coming over, but doesn't like getting dressed up.

"Gabrielle wanted to put some gel in my hair, so I look better, and I still find that unpleasant," he said.

Mr. Newman likes bluegrass music, plays a little piano and guitar. Carousel may be his favorite musical. He doesn't like Mayor Giuliani.

"I think he's taken too much credit and he's been racially divisive," he said. "I don't think he's a particularly good man."

He wishes the Giants and Dodgers were still in New York. And he's always loved sex: "I've always enjoyed it and always had an appetite. I wouldn't describe it as in any way abnormal. I think I've had sex as often as the situation called for and the other person wanted it and I wanted it, ha-ha! I think of myself as a sexual person. I like to think I'm not as abusive as men [can be]. Maybe that's not true, not for me to say. I work hard not to be abusive toward women, I have a high regard for women. Women have played a really important role in my life. A lot of the good work in the creating of the community has been done by brilliant and powerful women."

In American history, he admires Eugene B. Debs and is "a little partial" to Thomas Paine. He hopes the American people pick up the issue of political reform.

"I live well," he said. But he claimed he wasn't even sure if he has a bank account, and said he doesn't know what an A.T.M. is. His assistant gives him money. He said he has made a fair amount from therapy, but put his personal net worth at less than a million. In fact, it's "nothing," he said.

He lives in an ivy-covered brownstone in Greenwich Village, which he co-purchased with a female friend for $920,000 in 1993. Mr. Newman lives in a unit with Ms. Kurlander. The rest of the place is occupied by two men and nine women, some of whom Mr. Newman has been involved with over the years.

"I feel very good and proud about it," he said. "I think it's disgraceful the way people who have intimate relationships break up and then hate each other for life. I find that very offensive."

I said his living arrangements sounded like every man's dream.

"These are my dearest, dearest friends and colleges, co-workers," he said, "who've invested millions of hours to build the All-Stars Talent Show Network. That's who we're talking about here, and many of these people are women, and in the case of some of them, but not all of them, we've been close in all kinds of ways, including physically, and I feel thrilled about that."

He continued: "It's not a harem of people, it's a collection of human beings, some of whom are brilliant psychologists, heads of medical services of Long Island community hospital, vice presidents of major companies. That's who they are, and they have an integrity as that. They're not just women to have sex with."

After we'd been talking about an hour, Mr. Newman told me he cries fairly often.

"I cry every time I see movies," he said. "I'm a movie crier, I cry all the time. I certainly cried during Gods and Monsters. I thought that was very touching, their relationship. I'm kind of a sucker for romantic kind of things. When movies get touching and romantic, I cry. There's a movie with Richard Gere and Julia Roberts, their comeback movie."

It was time for a nap before dialysis.

"It's been a good life," he said. "I've been very fortunate and I don't mind talking about it."

Art Caper (1990)

Artists Defect From Castillo Center Auction When Links to Political Group Surface
By Alisa Solomon
Village Voice, November 1990

Artist Les Levine handed over a silk screen worth more than $2,000 to the Castillo Cultural Center for its auction November 1 to raise money for its “New Visions/New Voices” program. He didn't think twice when a group of young painters asked that he support the work of Latino, African-American, and women artists. Over the last year, he'd already donated prints to benefits for AIDS, homelessness, Franklin Furnace, and the War Resisters League, but, like more than 40 other established, well-known artists, when the group approached, he couldn't say no. “Artists from those communities are not shown enough,” he said.

But last week, Levine pulled his work out of the auction. “They didn't tell me the Castillo Center was connected to the New Alliance Party,” he said. “When I found out, I asked them questions about some of the things I heard they supported, which are repugnant to me, and they didn't give me satisfactory answers, I decided I couldn't be associated with them.”

By press time Monday, at least nine artists had withdrawn from the auction or had announced their intentions to do so. While more than 30 remain, including Richard Serra, Christo, and Robert Longo, the move has shaken the Soho art world and generated controversy again around NAP. “The art world is kind of dumb,” said artist Deborah Kass, who decided to withdraw from the benefit after reading some of Castillo's publications last summer and then was outraged to find her name listed among participants in an advertisement for the event. “We'll all do any vaguely liberal sounding sort of thing without looking into it because we're all too busy, or we're flattered to be asked, or because it just doesn't occur to us to be suspicious of something that sounds decent.”

It's a story familiar to critics of the New Alliance Party, the cult-like political organization headed by Fred Newman, whose rhetoric borrows from most progressive movements, and whose omnipresent candidate in every election year is Lenora Fulani. The Castillo Center is another NAP affiliate (like the Rainbow Lobby, named to evoke Jesse Jackson's Rainbow Coalition) that looks good on the surface but is, according to Chip Berlet, an analyst with Political Research Associates, “a recruitment mechanism for the party.” Berlet, who published a report on NAP in 1987 and continues to monitor the group, calls NAP a “proto-fascist” movement.

“They are divisive and destructive to the African-American community,” said Jitu Weusi, longtime black activist and a founder of the Unity Coalition. Just last month, NAP challenged the ballot petitions of the coalition and the United African Party. Weusi fears that NAP could attain permanent ballot status if it garners 50,000 votes on Tuesday. Last year, New Jewish Agenda took the unprecedented step of expelling NAPers from the organization because, as an NJA memo put it, “NJA was faced with what appeared to be a concentrated effort by NAP to infiltrate with the purpose of damaging our work.” And Queer Nation, the gay and lesbian direct action group has recently labeled NAP “a menace to our community.”

While NAP is targeting the gay and lesbian vote, its definition of gayness, Joyce Hunter of the Hetrick-Martin Institute has said, is “merely a political restatement of the pathology view of homosexuality.” Sue Hyde of the National Gay and Lesbian Task Force adds, “NAP does not limit itself to preying upon the gay and lesbian movement. It will prey upon any movement, use any issue, use any disguise to further the megalomania of Fred Newman. Their newest scheme and scam plays upon many people's interest in freedom of expression” and Hyde puts the Castillo Center's November 1 art auction at the focal point of that scheme.

The Castillo Center does produce plays, exhibit paintings, and develop a variety of artistic projects in its $2.7 million Soho loft. “Right,” said Berlet, “And Leni Riefensthal made films, too.” At the very least, one has to wonder about the idea of an upscale auction by a center that claims to be, in auction co-chair's Judy Penzer's words, “a place where art is no longer a commodity.” If Castillo sells all of the objects in the auction at their lowest prices, it will haul in close to $200,000. Meanwhile, one Castillo painting on a central wall of the gallery is a still life with the words “Fuck Bourgeois Art” scrawled across it.

Penzer and the other auction co-chair, S. K. Duff, both of whom have worked in the art world, got the event off the ground by approaching gallery owners, directors, and artists and asking for their support. Once they had some takers, they were also able to use their names to lure others. “1 heard Christie's was involved,” said one artist who is pulling out. “Leo Castelli was supporting it. Some friends were donating pieces. I figured, why not?”

Yet Christie's spokesperson Roberta Maneker said that the auction house never gave official permission for Castillo to use their name, much less their logo—which graces the auction invitation and catalogue. While Penzer asserts that such permission was granted, Maneker replies, “I'm the only one authorized to give permission and I did not give it.” She says a letter from Christie's lawyer has been sent to Castillo expressing their dismay at this “appropriation.” At the Castelli gallery, associate director Patty Brundage said, “I think we were misled. If we had it to do over again, knowing the facts, we wouldn't have participated.”

Meanwhile, some artists have complained that Castillo unfairly listed their names to promote the event. Penzer has said that some artists, like Kass, were listed in the ad before they had decided to pull out. But Tim Rollins and Altoon Sultan, among others, were listed as participating artists when, in fact, a collector had donated one of their pieces. Penzer says this was a mistake attributable to her inexperience.

Contributors began to have second thoughts after receiving one or more of several mailings. Queer Nation sent out a flier to the advertised list of participating artists, with quotes from Voice articles, Chip Berlet, gay newspapers, and former NAP presidential candidate Dennis Serrette, all warning of NAP's questionable practices. For some the flier motivated withdrawal from the auction. For others, it seemed unsubstantiated. “It was anonymous and all the quotes were taken out of context,” said Vered Lied, whose husband, Thorton Willis, will participate. Lucio Pozzi questioned auction organizers about various charges, and came away satisfied that the money from the sale of his artwork “will be used for charitable purposes.” And Cary Leibowitz, a/k/a Candyass, says, “1 don't have time to think about it. It would seem a little fascist to rule them out right away.”

Attorney Jerry Ordover, who represents a number of artists, saw the ad for the auction and “felt alarmed because of the things I've read about NAP over the years.” He sent a letter expressing his “healthy skepticism about a group that takes positions which I find weird and which allies itself with individuals who are antithetical to pro-humanity positions.” He enclosed a copy of a Voice article published last year about Castillo's opening.

That article, and a Voice review of a Castillo production of a Heiner Muller play, were the subjects of a front page article in the National Alliance, NAP's weekly organ, which called the Voice “the party line-ish voice of the New York City arts establishment.” The article quoted Newman labeling the Voice a “Stalinist operation” trying “to drive an ice pick into the head of a significant and independent rival.”

According to some artists, Penzer tried to convince them to stay in the auction by discrediting the Voice, and calling the mailings part of a “witch hunt” against Castillo. “When she used that word,” said Melissa Meyer, “that's when I was convinced to pull out.” Penzer told the Voice that there was a “McCarthyite attack” going on, “insinuating that Castillo is not really Castillo and that we don't really do culture.” She denied that Castillo is part of the New Alliance Party but said that it “is part of a network of progressive organizations. NAP is one. Castillo is another.” She added, “We're supportive of the work they [NAP] do. We think it's good.” She did not deny that Fred Newman heads NAP, the “social therapy movement” and the Castillo Center. “He's lots of things.” she said. “He's a painter and a playwright, too.”

Penzer said that artists who pulled out are responding to pressure, insinuation, and a “censorship attack on their support of this organization,” adding, “I don't have a sense from the artists who pulled out of any substantive disagreement about Castillo.” But for Dotty Attie, there were serious problems. “They have ties to political groups that support Al Sharpton and Louis Farrakhan,” she said. “I don't feel sympathetic with that.” And Gary Stephan, who let his answering machine pick up his phone for a week even when he was home “because Castillo was calling me six times a day,” was put off by their “left and right analysis mixed in some sort of paranoid soup.”

One artist who chose to withdraw from the auction after reading up on NAP puts it, “When groups as diverse as the Anti-Defamation League of B'nai B'rith, the National Gay and Lesbian Task Force, and Jackson, Mississippi's progressive black newspaper [The Jackson Advocate] all conclude that NAP is seriously bad news, you can't exactly call it a conspiracy.”

In the end, some artists say, the experience has been sobering, and might, Gretchen Bender suggests, “get us to do our homework in the future.” But, says one artist who requested anonymity because he feared for his family's safety, “This has left such a bad taste, it's almost shut me off to the whole idea of donating work. It's really sad, but next time a group comes to me, I'm going to be really hesitant.”

“Opportunists of the World, Unite!” (Next, 1988)

he Many Faces of NAP
By Nina Reyes
Next Magazine, August 31-September 6, 1988

“For the past year … we have been asked by progressive activists to provide information on the New Alliance Party because of concern over its past ties to Lyndon LaRouche and because of the appearance of an internal authoritarian structure within the organization. [Our report] is a response to those concerns—concerns which we feel are justified and which have obliged us to depart from our usual pattern of researching only explicitly right wing organizations.”
Chip Berlet
Author of “Clouds Blur the Rainbow
The Other Side of the New Alliance Party”
Political Research Associates
Cambridge, MA

The New Alliance Party (NAP), established in New York City in 1979, describes itself as a “Black-led, woman-led, multiracial, pro-gay independent political party,” that is posing a substantial threat to the traditional course of politics in the United States. Its candidate for President, Dr. Lenora B. Fulani, has attracted media attention nationwide. Its political rhetoric apparently appeals to enough voters to put Fulani on the ballot in all 50 states.

But serious questions have been raised by researchers and activists about the history, ideology and methodology of the party, and investigations into the operations of NAP have revealed compelling reasons to view the party with caution and suspicion. To date, awareness of the party's tactics seems to be the best defense against its unsettling incursions into various communities. The following is an abbreviated history of the party, and a brief overview of criticisms that have been brought against it.

The Chronology

The New Alliance Party was established ten years after Dr. Fred Newman's Maoist oriented Centers for Change (CFC) had been incorporated. Newman, a 53-year-old political theorist with a Ph.D. in the philosophy of science from Stanford, had been at the center or at the head of NAP's predecessor organizations, and is currently acting as Fulani's campaign manager.

Newman and his associates from the CFC merged their organization briefly with Lyndon LaRouche and his National Caucus of Labor Committees (NCLC) in 1974, precisely the time at which LaRouche's political ideology was moving to the far right. Although NAP consistently disputes critical assessments of the nature and depth of Newman and his followers' involvement with LaRouche and NCLC the affiliation has haunted Newman and, consequently, NAP.

The “LaRouche connection” is the most commonly cited example of NAP's peculiar political evolution, although Mary Fridley, NAP's candidate for the U.S. Senate seat held by Edward Kennedy, defended the association with the statement that “there were some things to gain” from the close association with LaRouche back in 1974, “especially their economic analysis.” The reason that questions regarding Newman and other founders' association with LaRouche still dog NAP is that there are lingering operative similarities between the two organizations.

Berlet cites nine instances of congruence between NAP and the LaRouchites, and concludes that “these similarities do not change the fact that LaRouchite philosophy is apparently neo-fascist while Newmanite philosophy is apparently left-progressive, but it does mean that internally both groups have an authoritarian hierarchy whose existence is denied, and both groups rely on psychologically manipulative theories to control core members.”

In the interim between the disbanding of the various centers associated with CFC and the foundation of NAP, it seems clear that the structural vision of CFC remained basically intact. Like NAP and its affiliated organizations, the CFC operation consisted of a mixture of community organizing and community-based service centers, and, according to Village Voice reporter Joe Conason, CFC emphasized the need for therapy and mental health services within a community as NAP does currently. However, using their experiences during the remainder of the 1970s, Newman and his colleagues were able to create in NAP a far more sophisticated implementation of the ideas and community organization tactics than the CFC had generated.

Following their withdrawal from NCLC in 1974, Newman and his group formed the International Workers Party (IWP), which one NAP researcher has called “a splinter group modeled in spirit and practice on the National Caucus of Labor Committees.” Other sources say that the IWP was a “proletarian vanguard” party that focused its actions primarily on running candidates for president and publishing a newspaper entitled the International Worker. In his Voice article, Conason cites passages from documents published by IWP which stated that in 1975, when Boston's dramatic and violent resistance to busing was garnering national attention, the party was “opposed to busing because it divides the classes.”

Ken Lawrence, writing for the Jackson Advocate, revealed that the IWP party line of the time, as it appeared in the International Worker, termed community movements, including Black nationalism, feminism, gay pride and the struggles for affirmative action, “fascist.”

The IWP was eventually disbanded. In 1976, following the dissolution of IWP, Newman and his colleagues began to organize welfare recipients into the New York City Unemployed and Welfare Council (NYCUWC). Fridley, who became active with the group of people who ultimately founded NAP when she got involved with NYCUWC through the Coalition of Grass Roots Women, stated that the NYCUWC was “a union of about 10,000 welfare recipients, mostly women of color.” Furthermore, Fridley added, this loose organization of people used the candidacy of Joseph Galiber, who was running for Bronx borough president to “test the waters” for the formation of a viable third party in the bipartisan electoral field.

“We got about 25,000 votes, which said to us, although the media did not cover it at all, that there was sentiment for third-party politics. It wasn't crazy, that we had ultimately put out a pro-gay, Black-led, multi-racial, people-instead-of-profits politic, which was a very radical campaign in the Bronx, which is certainly not someplace that is historically known for its militant and radical politics.” These organizations, according to Fridley, under the umbrella group, the Labor Community Alliance for Change, became the New Alliance Party.

The results of Conason's investigation into the origins of NAP conflict with Fridley's account of the NAP's formalization. His research shows that NYCUWC was embroiled in a struggle “with another, more-legitimate welfare rights organization,” while the Coalition of Grass Roots Women, which he calls “yet another Newmanite front” was accused by a feminist paper of “attempting to ‘trash' an international women's conference.” A number of papers and journals came out, “most or all under the rubric of United Struggle Press,” the Institute for Social Therapy and Research opened, and “the Labor Community Alliance for Change announced that it had become the New Alliance Party.” It was after these occurrences, Conason wrote, that “NAP as NAP became involved with the Galiber, whose record as a Bronx state senator was undistinguished to say the least; he was and is the most conservative member of the Black Caucus, and had always been a regular [Democratic] party hack … Even worse, perhaps, were his business connections with organized crime figures and poverty program exploiters.”

The Politics

Since its foundation as a “Black-led, woman-led, multi-racial, pro-gay independent political party,” NAP has grown dramatically in terms of membership, financial stability, and especially in terms of its ability to affect the political landscape of the United States. In 1988, NAP's Presidential candidate, 38-year-old Lenora Fulani, has qualified for federal matching funds and will probably be on the ballot in all 50 states. The two goals of her campaign—the formation of a viable third party in the U.S., and ensuring that the Democrats will not be elected to the White House—seem within NAP's grasp.

Although Fulani's campaign is not the first indication that NAP may well be reaching for and attaining its goal of capturing national attention, it is the most powerful. A mere four years ago, in 1984, NAP ran Dennis Serrette, a Black trade unionist, as its Presidential candidate on the ballots of 33 states. Even if he had been phenomenally successful, which he was not, retrospective wisdom suggests that votes for his candidacy could not have been billed as a way to teach the Democrats a lesson, nor would the relative scale of his success have treated his supporters to the opportunity to declare a “mandate from the people.”

In fact, Serrette left NAP in late 1984, and has since become one of its most vocal critics. Called as a witness in a lawsuit NAP filed against the Jackson Advocate, Berlet reports, Serrette accused NAP of using Blacks within the party to strengthen its credibility with minority communities by putting Blacks in visible positions within the party while failing to give them substantive influence over policy or resources within the organization. “I don't understand [Black control] as just having a Black face in a high place,” Serrette stated in the Advocate case. “That's nothing more than racism and nothing more than window dressing.”

In 1984, NAP attempted to win California's socialist Peace and Freedom Party's Presidential nomination in a way that Emma Mar, the convention organizer and the departing state chair of the party, termed “disruptive.”

“They brought 50 people in buses,” who demanded to be seated as delegates, Mar recalled, “and proceeded to wreck our convention.” In support of their bid for the nomination, Mar related, the NAP people “were shouting and stomping and they had a bullhorn. They turned out many of them to be registered Democrats,” which disqualified them from delegate status.

In 1986, the Boston branch of NAP ran a well-funded campaign against progressive State Representative John McDonough. In a letter to Bay Windows, John Kyper, who worked as a precinct captain for McDonough, wrote that the NAP candidate, Cathy Stewart, distributed campaign literature entitled “A Woman and the Rainbow.”

“I spoke to some voters who had thusly come to the erroneous conclusion that the Rainbow Coalition had endorsed her,” Kyper related, and “a Stewart campaign worker at Green Street station was heard to accuse [McDonough] of being ‘bad on women's issues'—a charge that his record clearly demonstrates is false.”

In 1988, NAP again attempted to win the Presidential nomination of the Peace and Freedom Party by disrupting the proceedings of the party's convention. This time the NAP candidate, Fulani, walked out of the convention with approximately one third of the party's delegates, and declared the opening of a new Peace and Freedom Party convention. Both the original convention and the NAP/Peace and Freedom Party convention filed the names of their nominees with California's secretary of state. After conducting an investigation into the matter, the secretary of state “was unable to ascertain who the duly elected party officials and nominee were,” which means that the Peace and Freedom Party's ballot space will be blank in November unless the party holds “a new state-wide convention before September 5, with only properly selected delegates seated.”

NAP's stated objective in the 1988 Presidential contest is to cost the Democrats the election. Fulani estimates that a million votes for her will in fact keep Michael Dukakis from reaching the White House. NAP representatives state that the Democrats have taken the votes of politically disempowered communities—Blacks, Hispanics, American Indians, gays and lesbians—for granted, that Dukakis' choice of a running mate slaps his progressive constituency in the face, and that the majority of Democrats, while dissatisfied with Dukakis, feels that it has no means of holding the “Democratic machine” accountable. To these disenchanted voters, Fulani offers her candidacy as a way “to send the Democrats a message.”

Sue Hyde of the National Gay and Lesbian Task Force sent copies of Berlet's report on NAP with a cover letter detailing her own experiences with NAP to a number of gay and lesbian publications. Her letter warned that although “NAP's platform, insofar as it is articulated on paper, is very appealing to me and not antithetical to many of our own movement's goals … I do not believe that the party's methodology or structure make it an appropriate or trustworthy organization for achieving these goals.” Her experience of being misled into participating in one of the NAP forums, which was in fact a thinly veiled recruitment meeting, has been echoed again and again in various forms by activists.

Certainly many gay and lesbian voters across the nation are torn by the choice between what the Gay and Lesbian Defense Committee and Mass ACT OUT have termed “the evil of two lessers.” At the same time, NAP offers gay and lesbian voters the option of helping to ensure that the Republicans keep control of the executive office, which is hardly a desirable political consequence for the vengeful pleasure of giving Dukakis back what he has given to our community.

In addition, there is a side to the New Alliance Party that voters should examine thoroughly before casting ballots in support of the “Rainbow Slate.”

The Practice

Numerous investigators, and, in fact, many community activists and organizers who have not conducted extensive research, have independently concluded that NAP and its therapeutic branch, the Institutes for Social Therapy and Research, show the classic hallmarks of a cult.

The Institutes for Social Therapy—founded in 1978—pre-date the formalization of NAP as it exists now. “Unlike what many people say, NAP did not start the Institute,” said Fridley. “There was a request from the community to figure out how to address the mental health crisis in New York at the time,” which convinced Newman and his colleagues, who were attempting to organize communities in New York City, to resuscitate some of their old ideas from the days of CFC.

Conason's research into CFC shows that “internal CFC documents from November 1972 through February 1973 show that ‘therapy' sometimes in week-long marathon sessions, was the top priority of the group,” although CFC also operated a dental and therapeutic clinic in the Bronx and a school for young children.

But over the course of the 1970s, Newman's interest in social therapy, coupled with the metamorphosis of his political ideology, qualitatively changed his implementation of the therapy model for mobilization of a community.

For example, in a paper entitled Homophobia and the Rise of Neo-Fascism in the United States, Fridley explains the rationale behind social therapy, and attempts to demonstrate its efficacy in regards to the politicization of the gay community. The main thrust of social therapy is to teach the individual that a sense of being “maladjusted” in society is actually evidence of mental fitness, because the society itself is unsound, corrupt and morally bankrupt. Referring to NAP's historical roots in CFC, Fridley remarked, “You can't just provide services for people if you're interested in bringing the community into a power relationship with the powers-that-be.” The way to bring about the change, according to Fridley, is to empower communities in areas where they have previously been disempowered—by providing, for example, therapy in poor, working class, and minority communities, where traditional therapies have historically been either withheld from the people, or used to keep them in place.

Because social therapy contains within its prescription for healing the necessity of empowerment through action, patients of social therapy are urged to become politically involved. At this point, NAP, with whom the Institutes' therapists are closely allied, stands ready to receive contributions of time, solicitation and action to “assist” the patients in their “healing process.”

Not coincidentally, NAP's political platform appeals specifically to “Afro-American, Latino, Native American, Asian, Women, Lesbian and Gay, poor and working people … oppressed nationalities, farmers, trade unionists and the unemployed.” The tenets of the party offer a political balm to these and other communities, whose political self image have been “injured” by the inattention of the Democratic and Republican parties.

Additionally, according to Serrette, being involved with therapy is a prerequisite for involvement, in any significant sense, with NAP. “If you want to be part of this organization, you will have to take therapy because it is the backbone of our tendency,” Serrette reports he was told.

Dennis King, who has studied the evolution of NAP from its earliest incarnation as the Centers for Change, through its affiliation with LaRouche and NCLC, and the formation and dissolution of IWP, said “The New Alliance Party is a therapy cult and a political cult.” Its ideological leadership is all former patients of Newman and two other members of the organization, Hazel Daren and Gail Elberg. However, King warned, “You can't dismiss them as a pure and simple cult,” because the term is used too frequently in reference to small and relatively harmless religious fanatical organizations that have become fixtures in many urban centers and rural areas. “That [kind of a label] discounts the fact that they're having a political effect on the world,” considering that Fulani's campaign may in fact keep the Republicans in the Oval Office, King added.

Of note, also, is that the Cult Awareness Network keeps information on NAP with its extensive files on LaRouche.


Playing it Straight?


Even if it weren't for the strange and apparently coercive connection between therapy and politics, NAP is still an extremely difficult organization to deal with on a political level. Its members' tactics are abrasive and disruptive in group settings, even when the NAP people claim that their agenda coincides with that of the meeting. On occasions when NAP is criticized for its methodology or questioned closely about its history, NAP respondents verge into hysterical personal attacks that distort and over-blow the impact of the critique in an attempt to undercut the credibility or expose hidden motivations of the critic.

For example, responding to Sue Hyde's memorandum to the gay press, National Alliance editors Dan Friedman and Freda Rosen stated that Sue Hyde's letter “white-baits, straight-baits and cult-baits the New Alliance Party.” Following a bizarre line of reasoning to refute Hyde's comments, they remarked that “Fulani believes that the circulation of the [NGLTF] letter is an attempt by the establishment leadership of the gay movement to subvert the independence of the rank and file.”

Upon publication and dissemination of Berlet's report, NAP called the results of Berlet's research “a diatribe of racist disinformation,” categorically dismissing, with insults and denunciations, his extensive research and the questions it posed. Berlet emerged unscathed, although NAP previously has attempted to punish, harass and annoy their detractors publicly. For example, a gay newspaper was recently unable to find a reporter willing to cover NAP because the party has a reputation for suing journalists who say things it does not like.

Furthermore, NAP continually misrepresents itself and its history, committing errors of omission or creating an atmosphere of innuendo in lieu of fact. In other cases, NAP lies outright.

Occasionally canvassers in Boston introduce their organization as the “Alliance.” At other times, referring to NAP's Rainbow Alliance or Rainbow Lobby, NAP workers solicit donations by identifying themselves as the “Rainbow,” which many people automatically associate with Jesse Jackson's Rainbow Coalition. They refer to their field of 24 candidates nationwide as “the Rainbow Slate,” and the prevalence of Fulani's picture spliced with photos of Reverend Jackson insinuate a connection that the Rainbow Coalition says does not exist. One Rainbow Coalition member recalls with anger that NAP went about publicly announcing that Jackson was urging his supporters to switch their allegiance to the NAP candidate, Serrette, after Jackson himself dropped out of the race. “That's just wrong,” says Pat Cusick, the Rainbow Coalition's media secretary in Boston. “Jesse backed the Democratic ticket after he left the race through to November.”

Lawrence's research shows that Serrette, in a report entitled “Inside the New Alliance Party,” wrote “Like LaRouche, Newman has created numerous organizations (most only on paper) with divergent names; some to attract particular individuals, some solely to make money, many with names so similar to true left organizations that unknowing individuals are often fooled.”

In their earlier years, the confusing similarity of names among NAP predecessor the New York City Unemployed and Welfare Council, the NCLC's National Unemployed and Welfare Rights Organization, and the legitimate National Welfare Rights Organization served to give the impression of credibility to the two organizations that were badly in need of both money and members if they were to achieve their ambitious goals. Because the tactic seemed to be so effective, NAP apparently has not given it up, although it dismisses questions regarding the purposefulness of some similarities in name.

Given the unexplained and unexplorable vagrancies of NAP's political past, its inextricable connection to the Institutes for Social Therapy and Research, and its history of harassing and disrupting other progressive organizations in the effort to assert it own organizational and political hegemony on the Left, NAP as an organization is not what its literature makes it out to be. While NAP professes support for and willingness to work with a number of progressive movements according to Paul Sprecher, a member of People Against Cult Therapy, “cult-like organizations' ability to cooperate with other political groups is practically nil, except in the most opportunistic fashion.”