Showing posts with label Rainbow Lobby. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Rainbow Lobby. Show all posts

Tuesday, August 9, 2011

Rainbow Lobby Presentation (IWP Plenary, 1989)

The following is the 1989 Rainbow Lobby presentation to the IWP's plenary session-a biannual gathering of IWP leaders and cadre. Although the names of IWP leaders such as Fred Newman and Lenora Fulani have been maintained for the sake of clarity-as have the names of public figures and IWP front groups-all other personal names have been deleted for legal reasons.

Good afternoon. We're going to begin today's discussion by reviewing briefly a history of the Rainbow Lobby tactic since its humble beginnings in the final months of the Dennis Serrette campaign, in 1984. To prepare this history, I reread my notes from five years of meetings-CC meetings, Political Committee meetings, Monday morning staff meetings, Sunday evening regional meetings, and meetings of the various incarnations of the Business Project (OED, Finance Committee, We Mean Business). In the course of reading these notes I was struck by the enormous changes this tactic has gone through, the many uses we've put it to, and the importance that Fred has always attached to its growth and development. I was particularly impressed by the evolution of the Rainbow Lobby's organizational design. It seemed to me to be an exceptionally clear example of how classical Leninists build organizations.

The Rainbow Lobby, in its organizational development, has evolved what I understand to be three characteristic features of a Leninist organization. First, there has been a continuous dialectic between the activity of coalition-building and the activity of base building between the Rainbow Alliance model and the Rainbow Lobby organization. We have swung between these two modes in an extremely growthful way that I'd like to discuss more later.

Secondly, the Rainbow Lobby has, over the last five years, interacted with a constellation of other tactics created and directed by the pre-party-the New Alliance Party, the Fulani campaign, etc.-and has contributed significantly to advancing the political and material position of the working class and its allies in this national sector. And finally, the Rainbow Lobby has become a point of interface between the working class vanguard in this national sector and the international working class, through its lobbying on behalf of the independent working class forces in Zaire.

This Leninist organizational design is, of course, one of the things that distinguishes the Rainbow Lobby from all the other liberal-issue lobbies that come knocking on the doors of mainstream America. The other thing that distinguishes it is its issue: democracy. In our understanding of democracy we are far closer to the reactionary bourgeoisie than we are to our liberal colleagues sitting across the table from us in a turf meeting. These liberals understand democracy as an end in itself, an end, moreover, that has already been achieved, at least in this exceptional national sector. On the other hand, Communists and the reactionary bourgeoisie both agree that democracy is just a tactic.

The bourgeoisie has no strategic commitment to democracy, because they understand that democracy-the rule of the majority-is inconsistent with the bourgeoisie staying in power. The form of democratic institutions is tactically useful to them in preserving their class rule, although the content of democracy-the rule of the majority-is a source of dangerous contradictions.

The Rainbow Lobby is a tactic for advancing the antagonisms in society between the form of democratic institutions, instruments of class rule, and the content of democracy, its tendency, as Luxemburg calls it, to negate its class character and be transformed into an instrument of working class struggle.

The conquest of a parliamentary majority in favor of reforms such as civil rights, women's rights, abortion rights, is, again to quote Luxemburg, "a calculation which, entirely in the spirit of bourgeois liberalism, preoccupies itself only with one side-the formal side-of democracy, but does not take into account the other side, its real content." Our fight for fair elections and democracy, however, has a revolutionary cutting edge because it puts forward the content of democracy-the sovereign power of the people-and exposes the gap between this content and the institutional forms constraining it.

Let's move now to the brief history of the Rainbow Lobby. A clear understanding of this history would definitively answer many of the questions that have recently been coming up among Rainbow Lobby organizers questions such as "what is the relationship between NAP and the Rainbow Lobby, between Fulani and the Rainbow Lobby," and so forth. So let's examine this history.

When we say that the Rainbow Lobby is nonpartisan, we are not just articulating the correct line vis-à-vis the IRS. From its very beginnings the Rainbow Lobby was organized by our tendency to be a broad coalition-"confederation" as Thomas Todd called it-of the forces in the independent political movement. In the midst of our political campaign for president in 1984, comrade [Deleted], as head of National Ops, was busy trying to forge unity among any progressive independent force willing to put some distance, however short, between itself and the Democratic Party. The original coalition between NAP and the Consumer Party-"Independents for Dennis Serrette"-died shortly after we registered the political committee with the FEC.

But we continued to reach out to other parties-Labor Farm, Liberty Union, elements of Peace and Freedom, important leaders in the Nation of Islam like Thomas Todd, Minister Don Muhammed and Johnnie Walls, church leaders like Owen Brooks from Delta Ministries, and Herbert Hoover Wright. And we reached out to them on behalf of the independent working class movement, not on behalf of NAP or the Dennis Serrette campaign.

In October of 1984 we opened the Rainbow Alliance office in Washington DC for the purpose of coordinating a national campaign to educate people on independent politics: its history, the full range of independent parties in this country, how independent politics was being used to advantage by the right wing to leverage its power in the Republican Party.

In the Fall of that year, Jimmy Swaggart packed Madison Square Garden for 4 days, demonstrating the power of right-wing grassroots organizing. We recognized the importance of doing this from the left. We appealed to the left to join us in this nonsectarian, non-partisan coalition that would work for the unity of all progressive independent forces and put together a strategy that would get these forces some political clout in the 1988 election.

Far from conceiving the Rainbow Alliance as a NAP front, Fred told us in September of 1984 that it would be indicative of the Rainbow Alliance's great success if NAP had to fight for hegemony within the Alliance.

Throughout the following year, 1985, the Mass Organizing project gave enormous energies to bringing this Rainbow Alliance into existence. A new department within Mass Organizing was set up to direct this work: Coalition and Lobbying, under the leadership of [Deleted] and [Deleted].

[Deleted] took over from [Deleted] as the organizer or "convenor" of the Alliance, and [Deleted] concentrated on building our lobbying activities. Early in 1985, our first piece of legislation, the Fair Elections Bill-H.B. 2320 as it was known then-was introduced by Conyers. NAP was of course the most active and supportive member of the Alliance. Following a Rainbow Alliance meeting in March, NAP sent [Deleted] and [Deleted] to Greenville, MS to support a teachers' strike, at the request of Delta Ministries. In response to a demand by Liberty Union, we co-organized with them a press conference and demonstration in honor of the 100th anniversary of the Haymarket Riot. We tried our best to get paid speaking engagements for Thomas Todd.

In tandem with pursuing this coalitional work, our tendency was deepening our understanding of the centrality of the fairness issue for organizing in this national sector, at this particular point in history. At the 1985 Marxism and Mental Illness Conference, Fred gave a talk entitled "Freedom, Fairness and Violence," which called for the hegemony of fairness over bourgeois freedom, and identified violence as the result of the hegemony of bourgeois freedom. A slide show produced for the event, 'Our Time Has Come," outlined the history of American bourgeois democracy, making the point that whatever fairness we have in this country was not by bourgeois design, but as a result of the struggles of the working class, organized independently, and more often than not, led by people of color.

Our efforts at building a broad, democratic coalition met up with the usual inertia of the US left. By August of that year, Fred had this to say about the Rainbow Alliance:

"There isn't much of a Rainbow Alliance it's a marginal social phenomenon. We create the illusion that they're a sitting body that reviews this stuff. In reality, we are still trying to bring this Alliance into existence. It has a slight history. We've begun to identify the kinds of issues that give it coherency-independent politics, H.R.2320, etc. Is there broad coalitional support for this single issue, which is actually so sweeping so as not to be a single issue at all? No one yet has got to go with it. You can go with 2320 and still keep your foot out the door. If these forces take the next step to the petitioning campaign and an independent effort in 1988, that's a big step."

In retrospect we can see that this was a step these forces were politically and most importantly, materially, incapable of even contemplating. By the 1988 election, these forces were completely irrelevant to the independent campaign for fair elections. If this future was not entirely visible to us in August of 1985, it became clearer after Lenora's smashing success in the November mayoral election. The enormous response of the Black working class to Lenora, as measured in votes, indicated the beginning of a fusion between our tendency and the class, and our hegemony over the Old Left. In a CC meeting after the election, Fred gave these instructions for our upcoming meeting of the Rainbow Alliance: "We have a new tactic for the Rainbow Alliance: we're bringing out Fulani. We don't care if Johnnie Walls, et al. come. Our message is: come if you desire. Stay away at your own risk. We are bringing out our tendency. Our concern is not about ballot status, etc. It's about fusion with the class."

The Rainbow Alliance continued an administrative existence into 1986. We had taken the coalition as far as it would go. Now it was time to go back to the base. Moreover, our growing fusion with the class was making possible a new coalition-the coalition between the left and right wings of the rainbow movement us and the Nation of Islam.

While the Rainbow Alliance was withering away, the Rainbow Lobby-a project supposedly supported by the Alliance but in reality funded entirely by NAP chapters around the country and various Institutes-was establishing itself on Capitol Hill. In late 1985 the Business Project had taken on trying to raise money for the Lobby by approaching organizations which had endorsed H.R. 2320, urging them to become members and contributors. This tactic met with complete and utter failure. Meanwhile, Business launched another project-the Community Social Workers: [Deleted], [Deleted] and [Deleted]. The job of these organizers was to go out to the community, taking with them a portfolio of our political products, and to figure out how to get the community to "buy political," to fuse with our independent working class institutions. One of the institutions in the community social workers' portfolio was the Rainbow Lobby. What this research and development team discovered was that the Rainbow Lobby was a hit with the progressive middle class. By April of 1986, [Deleted] was assigned to specialize in the Lobby, to fine-tune how to sell fair elections and democracy at the door. I remember our amazement when [Deleted] began bringing in $60 and $70 a night! This was unprecedented for a door-knocking tactic. In fact, no other mass organizing tactic in our history had ever enjoyed such a high rate of productivity.

The research and development carried out by the community social workers contributed immeasurably to placing our mass organizing on a more proletarianized and scientific basis, and what is an extension of this, on a firm financial basis. By the fall of 1986, the Business Project formed a sub-committee to manage a national canvass operation. Fred directed that NAP organizers deployed to the regions be trained to do the Rainbow Lobby canvass so that they could be as mobile and flexible as possible. The Rainbow Lobby canvass provided the material pre-conditions for building NAP operations all over the country. For the first time, our mass organizing could be self-financing. In addition, the Rainbow Lobby provided the subsidy needed to increase the National Alliance circulation to almost 50,000 copies, and to add another color.

In line with this spectacular entry into the world of middle-class mass organizing, the Rainbow Lobby constituted itself as a new organization, separate from the Rainbow Alliance, and in January 1987, incorporated as the Rainbow Lobby, Inc.

In a meeting in January 1987, Fred spoke about the dialectic between the Rainbow Lobby and the impending Campaign '88. He told us that the Lobby should resist being taken over by Campaign '88 for as long as possible. It's growth, financially and politically, was what would make it valuable to the '88 campaign-we didn't want to give it over prematurely.

Fred stressed that the Rainbow Lobby was strategically more important to us than Campaign '88. In a sense, it was a new "inside' tactic relative to the Democratic Party-and a far more potent tool than the Democratic Party club work. Instead of taking away members, we were taking away money. Our capacity to carry out our political plans is very tied to our ability to re-route money our way. Revolutions are very expensive!

In June of 1987 we finally had to stop resisting being taken over by Campaign '88. Following Lenora's declaration of her candidacy, we began the conversion of our Rainbow Lobby canvass to matching funds. The experience and expertise we had gained in building the Rainbow Lobby opened up extraordinary possibilities that had never existed before-the ability to go into 20 states, in many of which we had no infrastructure, and immediately begin to raise money in small, matchable donations. And the ability to qualify for matching funds was a precondition for accomplishing 51 in '88.

The Rainbow Lobby had built up sufficient surplus and was able to integrate volunteer organizers into the phone operation successfully enough so as to survive the permanent loss of its top organizers for the 18 months of the campaign, and the loss of all its organizers save one, for 6 months. It emerged from Campaign '88 in fair financial condition, but with only one-half the cadre it had had prior to conversion. In light of the significance that Fred had attached to the Rainbow Lobby tactic, namely, identifying its post-campaign expansion as the true measure of the success of the campaign. This reduction of cadre seemed a significant deviation, a deviation which, as you all know, we immediately set about to rectify, by recalling our Marxist-Leninists from the New Alliance Party, where they were not needed, and where they were, in a significant way, serving as a fetter to its development.

The Rainbow Lobby, under our collective Marxist-Leninist leadership, is now beginning a new phase of its development. It has done its duty, served its purpose as a source of material support for other mass organizing tactics. It will now intensify its efforts in support of its own autonomous mass organizing goal: the organizing of the progressive middle class into an alliance with the working class. We have long ago identified the willingness of the progressive middle class to give money to an organization which they recognized, at some level, was doing something to fight encroaching fascism. We will now move explicitly to shape the social motion of the middle class, to do base-building, to build a class-wide organization.

We are very excited to have this opportunity today to meet as Marxist-Leninists with comrade Fred, and have him give us political guidance for this next stage of our development.

National Gay and Lesbian Task Force Memorandum (July 10, 1989)

Dear Friends and Colleagues,

The undersigned groups and individuals request in this letter that the membership application of the New Alliance Party (USA) be rejected by the International Gay and Lesbian Association (ILGA), or be postponed for consideration until the ILGA’s 1990 conference. In prior correspondence, we sent a packet of background materials, some of which are referenced in this letter. Please copy and distribute the background information as you see fit.

We take this unusual and somewhat extreme measure because in its dealings with U.S. gay and lesbian organizations and communities, the New Alliance Party has never demonstrated significant commitment to the aspirations of the U.S. gay and lesbian political movement. We recognize the great difficulty presented to activists when asked to evaluate working relationships of organizations in other countries. However, we ask that you carefully consider our point of view and bear us in mind when you cast your votes on the New Alliance Party’s membership application.

The New Alliance Party’s long and disturbing history is filled with stories of deception, infiltration, disruption, and attempted destruction of autonomous organizations working within larger political movements. Within the past year, no fewer than one dozen gay and lesbian newspapers within the U.S. have published articles documenting an uneasy and sometimes hostile relationship with gay and lesbian activists and organizations. (See background materials.) Time and again, gay and lesbian activists and activists in other progressive movements report feeling exploited and used by the New Alliance Party and its many organizational affiliates to further the Party’s own agenda, not the agenda of an autonomous, grassroots gay and lesbian political movement or a larger movement for progressive social change.

In particular, during the 198S U.S. presidential campaign, the New Alliance Party alienated many activists by its tactics of exploitation and disruption.

In San Diego, California, New Alliance Party Presidential candidate Lenora Fulani dominated a spring, 1988 AIDS candlelight vigil with a long speech about her campaign. Many were offended by her takeover of the event. (See: St. Louis Gay and Lesbian News Telegraph “Behind the Scenes at the New Alliance Party.”)

At the 1988 nominating convention of the California Peace and Freedom Party, Fulani led a walkout of her delegates from the convention and declared the opening of a new Peace and Freedom Party convention. Both the genuine P&F convention and the bogus convention called by Fulani nominated candidates. The California Secretary of State’s office could not determine who the duly elected nominee for P&F was and thus refused to accept either candidate, leaving the P&F without a presidential candidate on the ballot unless P&F could hold a second nominating convention. (See Next: “Opportunists of the World Unite!”)

At an October 25 rally in San Francisco which was intended to focus on defeat of two right-wing AIDS related initiatives, Fulani again staged a takeover of the event and attempted to give a campaign speech, but was forced by the crowd and event organizers to stop speaking. A few days prior to the rally, four major speakers from the gay and lesbian community cancelled plans to attend because they did not want to give credibility to Fulani or the New Alliance Party. None had been told that Fulani would speak at the rally. (See GCN: “Fulani Fracas at SF Rally.”)

In August 19S7, New Alliance Party announced that Vernon Bellecourt, leader of the American Indian Movement, had endorsed the Fulani presidential campaign. I: was later brought to light that Bellecourt was paid $1,000 a month as a campaign consultant, rendering his “endorsement” politically meaningless since he was employed by the Fulani campaign. (See GCN: “A Queer Alliance.”)

Our objections to the New Alliance Party’s membership in ILGA are not based solely on their behavior in the 1988 U.S. presidential campaign.

The New Alliance Party defines homosexuality as a political protest against a repressive society caused by the breakdown of the nuclear family. This definition of gayness and lesbianism ignores many people’s experience of homosexuality so deeply rooted in their childhood (nurture) or even having genetic origins (nature) that it scarcely seems a matter of choice. Further, what are we to assume about homosexuality in a post revolutionary society? That it will no longer be a necessary “protest against a repressive society” and therefore will disappear? No gay and lesbian political organization we know subscribes to this theory of homosexuality, nor would any wish to, since it runs counter to our argument for civil rights protections on the basis of an unchangeable sexual orientation.

The New Alliance Party’s theory of homosexuality strikes us as inherently homophobic and utterly counterproductive to a movement for lesbian and gay freedom and liberation. Our freedom should never be conditional based on the particular constructions of society, culture or politics, especially given that homosexuality is a universal and wholly human expression of sexual and affectional orientation which has existed in every historical and cultural context on the planet.

The New Alliance Party and its affiliate the Rainbow Lobby have intentionally conducted fundraising campaigns in which they call themselves the “Rainbow” in order to make their organization appear connected with Rev. Jesse Jackson’s Rainbow Coalition. Rev. Jackson was also a 1988 presidential candidate and received widespread support from lesbians and gay men across the country. The Rainbow Coalition has an excellent relationship with gay and lesbian communities and activists, having incorporated a “lavender stripe” during the ‘88 campaign for Jackson and hired a gay man to work with lesbians and gay men.

The New Jewish Agenda, a U.S. organization of progressive Jews based in New York City, reported an attempted takeover of their membership structure by the New Alliance Party in 1988 and 1989. NAP members joined New Jewish Agenda in large numbers and dominated meetings by attempting to steer NJA away from its own organizational agenda and toward a NAP agenda. After many frustrating months, NJA voted to expel from its membership all NAP members. (See: Correspondence from New Jewish Agenda to National Gay and Lesbian Task Force.)

In 1985, the Mississippi Welfare Rights Organization, a group of black women working for welfare reform in Mississippi, reported that New Alliance Party members proposed a merger of NAP and the Mississippi Welfare Rights Organization. After the merger was rejected by the welfare rights group, NAP begin scheduling meetings with key organizers from the welfare rights group to conflict with regular, monthly meetings of the Welfare Rights Organization. (See: “Clouds Blur the Rainbow.”)

The New Alliance Party is currently promoting its “AIDS Bill of Rights,” a copy of a California law that critics say is poorly conceived, poorly drafted and redundant of already existing legislation which protects people with AIDS as people with disabilities. Additionally, some activists believe that to promote apiece of legislation which is focused on people with AIDS and HIV infection only would be disruptive to a new and fragile alliance with disability rights groups. The Party has received no support for its “AIDS Bill of Rights” from any of the consistent and credible federal lobbying organizations, such as the AIDS Action Council, the Human Rights Campaign Fund, the National Gay and Lesbian Task Force, the American Civil Liberties Union, or the National Organizations Responding to AIDS.

The New Alliance Party was denied a seat on the 1987 March on Washington for Lesbian and Gay Rights Steering Committee. The decision was unanimous based upon the deceptive and disruptive tactics of the New Alliance Party.

The New Alliance Party claims affinity with and supports Minister Louis Farrakhan, a notoriously anti Semitic and anti gay leader of the Nation of Islam. Their alignment with Farrakhan is completely inconsistent with their claims of support for the gay and lesbian political agenda.

For all the reasons stated in this letter and for all the reasons contained in the background material we have sent you, the organizations and individuals signing this letter urge the International Lesbian and Gay Association to reject New Alliance Party’s membership application. The New Alliance Party speaks only for itself and does not represent the U.S. gay and lesbian community and organizations. Further, we urge that they not be given any sanctioned forum or time on your conference agenda.

If you have questions or need further information, please feel free to contact the National Gay and Lesbian Task Force, or any group co signing this letter. Thank you for your attention to this very important matter.

[signatures redacted]

Inside the New Alliance Party (1988)

aka Rainbow Alliance aka Rainbow Lobby aka the Organization a/k/a
By Dennis L. Serrette
Radical America, 1988

I write after much thought and some distance from the New Alliance Party (NAP). When I broke ties with NAP after my 1984 presidential race, I felt I needed some time to evaluate the hodgepodge of contradictions, racism, sexism, and cultism that so revealed itself during the course of my campaign.

I knew when I joined NAP that it was not black-led, and I knew when I left it was not black-led. It took longer to understand that NAP was not even a progressive organization as it also pretends.

Be that as it may, I probably still would not take the time to write about the organization. However, as a long-time activist who made the mistake of joining NAP, and who served on the organization's “Central Committee,” I believe I have a responsibility to reveal the intense psychological control and millions of dollars Fred Newman employs to get well-meaning in­dividuals in our communities (they target the black community), to viciously attack black leaders, black institutions, and progressive organizations for purposes of building Newman's power base.

What follows is a relatively brief narrative on Fred Newman's operations, NAP being but one front.' I have interchangeably used the names NAP, the organization, the International Workers Party (IWP), etc., for they are all run by, and consist of the same people. NAP is Newman's public electoral tactic, so it has many “members” (mostly people who have been stopped on the street who paid a dollar for a paper, or some other come-on, who rarely actively participate, and often don't even know they joined (who are not a part of “the organization/IWP,” i.e., Newman's followers.

At the outset, I want to answer the frequently asked question: “Is Newman associated with LaRouche?” I simply do not know. I understand that Newman originally completely denied hav­ing joined with LaRouche, claiming, instead, that it was his followers who had, but that he was forced to retract the denial in the face of overwhelming evidence. The story told to all organization members who were not with Newman at the time was that Newman and his followers were with LaRouche when he was “a leftist.” ‘‘a split from SDS,'' pre-Operation Mop-up. I have since learned that this was a lie, that they joined after LaRouche had made a decisive right shift, and participated in the cam­paign to destroy the Left. I did not see any direct evidence of a LaRouche connection while I was in NAP. But, I was never privy to what was go­ing on at the top—Newman's household. Newman often bragged about how much he learned from LaRouche, and, as noted below, the reported organizational operations of LaRouche's group are frighteningly similar to those of Newman's group.

Like LaRouche's National Caucus of Labor Committees, Newman runs a very tightly con­trolled organization. Like LaRouche, Newman has created numerous organizations (most only paper) with divergent names; some to attract particular individuals, some solely to make money, many with names so similar to true left organizations that unknowing individuals are often fooled (e.g., Rainbow Alliance and Rain­bow Lobby, which have no connection to Jesse Jackson's Rainbow Coalition; the Unemployed and Welfare Council, which attacked the Na­tional Welfare Rights Organization, etc.).

Newman controlled all the resources, person­nel, and policies of the organizations. When I left in 1984, he was living with three “wives.” One was in charge of all the organization's finances, which Newman boasted well-surpassed $1 million; another controlled all personnel/members; and the third was in charge of all “national operations.”

The organization has set up its own internal caste system. Rank and file members worked 14-plus hours a day, often out on street corners, raising money. Newman, on the other hand, spent most mornings reading in his large upper Westside apartment and jogging in Riverside Park. His workday began with his afternoon therapy sessions in his luxury Westside offices.

Newman and his chosen lieutenants often met and relaxed at his seaside mansion. The mansion was supported by a mandatory tax placed on members of the organization. Rank and file members were always taken along on trips to the mansion for the “honor” of cooking for and cleaning up after Newman and his chosen ones.

Newman's/NAP's political positions vary according to what he believes he can best capitalize on at the time. I personally witnessed this opportunism on a number of occasions. Quite notably, before it became obvious that Jesse Jackson's campaign would move grass­roots folks nationwide, Newman harshly at­tacked Jackson. When it seemed as though Newman could exploit Jackson's movement, he used Jesse's name endlessly, in literature and elsewhere, and created the “Rainbow Alliance” and “Rainbow Lobby.” Similarly, Newman strongly maintained that Louis Farrakhan was an insignificant right-winger. When it looked as though he could opportunize from Minister Farrakhan's popularity in the black community, Newman's line took a 180-degree turn.

When progressive newspapers and in­dividuals fail to support Newman, they become legitimate targets for destruction, even those he previously acclaimed. In my particular case, when I was promoting NAP, both the public and internal presentation of me was that of the leading black progressive. When I raised issues of Newman's racism and exploitation of blacks, I was labeled a nationalist (i.e., not a leftist). When I spoke honestly about NAP to persons outside the organization, articles began to appear in the National Alliance that would have made J. Edgar Hoover proud. I even received calls from friends that NAP was call­ing up women friends of mine from years past to see if they could contribute “sexual” dirt to a paper about me. When they couldn't find the dirt, Lenora Fulani authored the article under the auspices of the ‘‘Women's Caucus, another paper committee. Theodore (Ted) Taylor, who NAP vociferously praised as a leading black trade unionist when he associated with NAP, was attacked as a rank opportunist when he joined with SEIU. Gerena Valentine was lauded as New York's premier progressive elected official when he ran with a NAP affilia­tion, and harshly criticized when he broke with NAP.

Newman has brought a million-dollar-plus lawsuit against The Jackson Advocate, Jackson, Mississippi's only black newspaper, and its black activist editor, Charles Tisdale. Why? When Newman saw the broad support Jesse Jackson received in the South, he decided to target some resources there. He assigned several New Yorkers to Mississippi. Tisdale, having knowledge about the Alliance, did not support NAP's claim on his community. Know­ing the time and resources required to publish a newspaper, and the time and resources required to defend a law suit, Newman had his lawyer slap a major law suit on Tisdale. It does not matter if NAP loses the case. NAP almost always loses. The suit serves its purpose of inflicting injury.

NAP had the audacity to ask me to testify against Tisdale. I told them that their request was outrageous. Next thing I knew, I too was in court, and receiving calls threatening to have the Sheriff come to my home at night to arrest me. (The Court dismissed their action against me.)

The Main Enemy

In short, Newman operates in total Opposi­tion to the movement. Both “the Left” and “the movement” are considered enemies by Newman. Newman has labeled his suit against Tisdale a suit against the Left, as though attacks on progressive institutions are a good thing. In fact, a review of the National ~4Iliance will reveal far more venomous assaults on pro­gressives than on reactionaries.

Newman uses left rhetoric well, and organizes with a left front. He appeals to what is good and progressive in people, and uses that to build his base. He will as quickly embrace as he will attack a movement, a progressive, an organization, a principle – based on how he can best opportunize from it. His [members], almost all of whom have absolutely no history in the movement, have few other ways to see the issues.

Most members join “the organization via politics or therapy. Once an individual has been drawn close, s/he is met by two lieutenants and told that there is a secret underground organization, the International Working Party (IWP), allegedly a left party organization. Membership in the organization requires that you reveal all your resources, and that you turn over everything to the organization. (Even personal relationships are said to belong to the organization, so it is common for a member to report on his/her partner.) Mandatory bi­monthly dues are assessed, and anything may be demanded at any time.

The IWP has been chaired by Newman since its inception. As far as I know, no one else has ever been considered as an alternative. The Central Committee members are all chosen by Newman. During the entire 2½ years I sat on the Central Committee, there was never a single policy debate by the CC once Newman made his position known.

There is an enormous amount of secret ritual surrounding the IWP which, like most rituals, entices the members. Unlike most left organizations where the party is public and the membership is underground, Newman has created the reverse, and has used it as one of many isolating factors that maintain the membership.

Social therapy, Newman's creation, is con­sidered the “backbone of the tendency.” Every member is required to attend at least one social therapy (i.e., psychotherapy) session weekly, led by Newman's hand-picked, hand-trained therapists. (In most cases, Newman's top therapists are also his top spokespersons.) Although the therapy is mandatory, members must still pay for the sessions.

What is Therapy

Therapy, NAP style, is a method for recruiting innocent, vulnerable people, ex­ploiting their vulnerabilities, and controlling their behavior.

As noted earlier, all members were required to attend therapy at least once a week. Some at­tend twice a week or, at times, even daily. Par­ticular ‘patients” were targeted in sessions. The entire group then generally converged on the victim who generally broke down in tears. They are then forgiven, accepted, and praised. Topics range from the most personal aspects of one's life to the failure to give enough of one­self to the organization.

According to the tenets of ‘‘social therapy,~~ private time, private thoughts, “critical faculties” are all bourgeois. One can only be cured of their bourgeois ideology in social therapy. If you disagree at all with one of Newman's black lieutenants, the entire therapy group attacks you for being racist. If you dis­agree with a woman therapist, the entire group attacks you for being sexist, If you question the opinions of the therapist, you are resorting to your bourgeois critical faculties.

Members are kept busy from sun-up, way past sun-down. Members no longer have time to call family, to visit, even to attend funerals, holidays, or other special events. When members do visit their families, more often than not another IWP member accompanies them. (Generally, members have alienated themselves from all their other friends and all their close relationships are with fellow lWPers.) Members generally share apartments, living communally, and often invite new recruits to move in with them. Members and potential members were often encouraged to quit their pre-IWP job, unless their job position could be exploited.

Any problems that arose from this extreme regimentation were dealt with in therapy. Bourgeois thinking, problems with “giving it all for the revolution” were dealt with by the group that had become the member's entire world; that knew their every vulnerability; that shaped their thinking and understanding of people, events, history.

Conclusion

These few pages offer but an overview of a complex, and, in my opinion, dangerous organization. Dangerous, not only to the inno­cent, well-intentioned people who are caught in its grasp, but to the many it will try to exploit. Dangerous, because it uses a very progressive line, and untold millions of dollars, to prey on black communities, to attack black leaders and institutions, and to assault progressive organizations at whim. Dangerous because it can lie outright—lie about being black-led when blacks do not sit on the top, do not control the resources, do not control personnel; lie to its members about its participation with LaRouche; lie about Charles Tisdale; lie about me; lie about whatever serves Newman's in­terests, and put forth spokespersons who come to believe these lies. Dangerous because many members will do whatever they are told to do without ever evaluating what they have been told.

In conclusion, while I believe it is important that NAP be exposed for what it truly is, it is our job not to dwell on the organization, which craves controversy, but to concentrate our energies in our communities and organize, organize, organize. It is a vacuum that has been left open that allows NAP and other oppressive organizations to abuse our communities. We must fill that vacuum with genuinely pro­gressive, community-controlled organizations.

Footnotes

1. Others include New York Institute of Social Therapy and Research, Rainbow Alliance, East Side Center for Short Term Therapy, the Harlem Institute, Association of Better Communities, the New York City Unemployed and Welfare Council, George Jackson-Rosa Luxemberg Cultural Center, the National Alliance Newspaper, the New Black Alliance, Coalition of Grass Roots Women, the In­ternational Workers Party, and more. All are created and put to rest by Newman, according to the group or person he is targeting (e.g., when they decide to go after me, they created the New Black Alliance (NBA)). Once I agreed to be the presidential candidate, the NBA was disbanded. Similarly, Newman created the New York City Unemployed and Welfare Council to pull in some welfare activists and attack the National Welfare Rights Organization. When Newman decided to switch the focus to elec­toral politics, he disbanded the New York City Unemployed and Welfare Council, deeply disappointing many of the “leaders who had no say in the matter. James Scott, Alma Brooks, and Neter Brooks, whose names Newman continues to use, all left the organization. Newman creates the organization, chooses who among the inner circle will ‘‘lead'' it, how it will run, what it will do, and when it is no longer needed.

2. It is relatively common for Newman's people to attack black newspapers wherever they go if NAP isn't given ex­tensive coverage.

Dennis Serrette is an ex-member of NAP and, in 1984, was their presidential candidate.
He is now a black activist working and writing in Maryland.

(This Article Was Originally Published in Radical America, Vol. 21, No. 5)

“Opportunists of the World, Unite!” (Next, 1988)

he Many Faces of NAP
By Nina Reyes
Next Magazine, August 31-September 6, 1988

“For the past year … we have been asked by progressive activists to provide information on the New Alliance Party because of concern over its past ties to Lyndon LaRouche and because of the appearance of an internal authoritarian structure within the organization. [Our report] is a response to those concerns—concerns which we feel are justified and which have obliged us to depart from our usual pattern of researching only explicitly right wing organizations.”
Chip Berlet
Author of “Clouds Blur the Rainbow
The Other Side of the New Alliance Party”
Political Research Associates
Cambridge, MA

The New Alliance Party (NAP), established in New York City in 1979, describes itself as a “Black-led, woman-led, multiracial, pro-gay independent political party,” that is posing a substantial threat to the traditional course of politics in the United States. Its candidate for President, Dr. Lenora B. Fulani, has attracted media attention nationwide. Its political rhetoric apparently appeals to enough voters to put Fulani on the ballot in all 50 states.

But serious questions have been raised by researchers and activists about the history, ideology and methodology of the party, and investigations into the operations of NAP have revealed compelling reasons to view the party with caution and suspicion. To date, awareness of the party's tactics seems to be the best defense against its unsettling incursions into various communities. The following is an abbreviated history of the party, and a brief overview of criticisms that have been brought against it.

The Chronology

The New Alliance Party was established ten years after Dr. Fred Newman's Maoist oriented Centers for Change (CFC) had been incorporated. Newman, a 53-year-old political theorist with a Ph.D. in the philosophy of science from Stanford, had been at the center or at the head of NAP's predecessor organizations, and is currently acting as Fulani's campaign manager.

Newman and his associates from the CFC merged their organization briefly with Lyndon LaRouche and his National Caucus of Labor Committees (NCLC) in 1974, precisely the time at which LaRouche's political ideology was moving to the far right. Although NAP consistently disputes critical assessments of the nature and depth of Newman and his followers' involvement with LaRouche and NCLC the affiliation has haunted Newman and, consequently, NAP.

The “LaRouche connection” is the most commonly cited example of NAP's peculiar political evolution, although Mary Fridley, NAP's candidate for the U.S. Senate seat held by Edward Kennedy, defended the association with the statement that “there were some things to gain” from the close association with LaRouche back in 1974, “especially their economic analysis.” The reason that questions regarding Newman and other founders' association with LaRouche still dog NAP is that there are lingering operative similarities between the two organizations.

Berlet cites nine instances of congruence between NAP and the LaRouchites, and concludes that “these similarities do not change the fact that LaRouchite philosophy is apparently neo-fascist while Newmanite philosophy is apparently left-progressive, but it does mean that internally both groups have an authoritarian hierarchy whose existence is denied, and both groups rely on psychologically manipulative theories to control core members.”

In the interim between the disbanding of the various centers associated with CFC and the foundation of NAP, it seems clear that the structural vision of CFC remained basically intact. Like NAP and its affiliated organizations, the CFC operation consisted of a mixture of community organizing and community-based service centers, and, according to Village Voice reporter Joe Conason, CFC emphasized the need for therapy and mental health services within a community as NAP does currently. However, using their experiences during the remainder of the 1970s, Newman and his colleagues were able to create in NAP a far more sophisticated implementation of the ideas and community organization tactics than the CFC had generated.

Following their withdrawal from NCLC in 1974, Newman and his group formed the International Workers Party (IWP), which one NAP researcher has called “a splinter group modeled in spirit and practice on the National Caucus of Labor Committees.” Other sources say that the IWP was a “proletarian vanguard” party that focused its actions primarily on running candidates for president and publishing a newspaper entitled the International Worker. In his Voice article, Conason cites passages from documents published by IWP which stated that in 1975, when Boston's dramatic and violent resistance to busing was garnering national attention, the party was “opposed to busing because it divides the classes.”

Ken Lawrence, writing for the Jackson Advocate, revealed that the IWP party line of the time, as it appeared in the International Worker, termed community movements, including Black nationalism, feminism, gay pride and the struggles for affirmative action, “fascist.”

The IWP was eventually disbanded. In 1976, following the dissolution of IWP, Newman and his colleagues began to organize welfare recipients into the New York City Unemployed and Welfare Council (NYCUWC). Fridley, who became active with the group of people who ultimately founded NAP when she got involved with NYCUWC through the Coalition of Grass Roots Women, stated that the NYCUWC was “a union of about 10,000 welfare recipients, mostly women of color.” Furthermore, Fridley added, this loose organization of people used the candidacy of Joseph Galiber, who was running for Bronx borough president to “test the waters” for the formation of a viable third party in the bipartisan electoral field.

“We got about 25,000 votes, which said to us, although the media did not cover it at all, that there was sentiment for third-party politics. It wasn't crazy, that we had ultimately put out a pro-gay, Black-led, multi-racial, people-instead-of-profits politic, which was a very radical campaign in the Bronx, which is certainly not someplace that is historically known for its militant and radical politics.” These organizations, according to Fridley, under the umbrella group, the Labor Community Alliance for Change, became the New Alliance Party.

The results of Conason's investigation into the origins of NAP conflict with Fridley's account of the NAP's formalization. His research shows that NYCUWC was embroiled in a struggle “with another, more-legitimate welfare rights organization,” while the Coalition of Grass Roots Women, which he calls “yet another Newmanite front” was accused by a feminist paper of “attempting to ‘trash' an international women's conference.” A number of papers and journals came out, “most or all under the rubric of United Struggle Press,” the Institute for Social Therapy and Research opened, and “the Labor Community Alliance for Change announced that it had become the New Alliance Party.” It was after these occurrences, Conason wrote, that “NAP as NAP became involved with the Galiber, whose record as a Bronx state senator was undistinguished to say the least; he was and is the most conservative member of the Black Caucus, and had always been a regular [Democratic] party hack … Even worse, perhaps, were his business connections with organized crime figures and poverty program exploiters.”

The Politics

Since its foundation as a “Black-led, woman-led, multi-racial, pro-gay independent political party,” NAP has grown dramatically in terms of membership, financial stability, and especially in terms of its ability to affect the political landscape of the United States. In 1988, NAP's Presidential candidate, 38-year-old Lenora Fulani, has qualified for federal matching funds and will probably be on the ballot in all 50 states. The two goals of her campaign—the formation of a viable third party in the U.S., and ensuring that the Democrats will not be elected to the White House—seem within NAP's grasp.

Although Fulani's campaign is not the first indication that NAP may well be reaching for and attaining its goal of capturing national attention, it is the most powerful. A mere four years ago, in 1984, NAP ran Dennis Serrette, a Black trade unionist, as its Presidential candidate on the ballots of 33 states. Even if he had been phenomenally successful, which he was not, retrospective wisdom suggests that votes for his candidacy could not have been billed as a way to teach the Democrats a lesson, nor would the relative scale of his success have treated his supporters to the opportunity to declare a “mandate from the people.”

In fact, Serrette left NAP in late 1984, and has since become one of its most vocal critics. Called as a witness in a lawsuit NAP filed against the Jackson Advocate, Berlet reports, Serrette accused NAP of using Blacks within the party to strengthen its credibility with minority communities by putting Blacks in visible positions within the party while failing to give them substantive influence over policy or resources within the organization. “I don't understand [Black control] as just having a Black face in a high place,” Serrette stated in the Advocate case. “That's nothing more than racism and nothing more than window dressing.”

In 1984, NAP attempted to win California's socialist Peace and Freedom Party's Presidential nomination in a way that Emma Mar, the convention organizer and the departing state chair of the party, termed “disruptive.”

“They brought 50 people in buses,” who demanded to be seated as delegates, Mar recalled, “and proceeded to wreck our convention.” In support of their bid for the nomination, Mar related, the NAP people “were shouting and stomping and they had a bullhorn. They turned out many of them to be registered Democrats,” which disqualified them from delegate status.

In 1986, the Boston branch of NAP ran a well-funded campaign against progressive State Representative John McDonough. In a letter to Bay Windows, John Kyper, who worked as a precinct captain for McDonough, wrote that the NAP candidate, Cathy Stewart, distributed campaign literature entitled “A Woman and the Rainbow.”

“I spoke to some voters who had thusly come to the erroneous conclusion that the Rainbow Coalition had endorsed her,” Kyper related, and “a Stewart campaign worker at Green Street station was heard to accuse [McDonough] of being ‘bad on women's issues'—a charge that his record clearly demonstrates is false.”

In 1988, NAP again attempted to win the Presidential nomination of the Peace and Freedom Party by disrupting the proceedings of the party's convention. This time the NAP candidate, Fulani, walked out of the convention with approximately one third of the party's delegates, and declared the opening of a new Peace and Freedom Party convention. Both the original convention and the NAP/Peace and Freedom Party convention filed the names of their nominees with California's secretary of state. After conducting an investigation into the matter, the secretary of state “was unable to ascertain who the duly elected party officials and nominee were,” which means that the Peace and Freedom Party's ballot space will be blank in November unless the party holds “a new state-wide convention before September 5, with only properly selected delegates seated.”

NAP's stated objective in the 1988 Presidential contest is to cost the Democrats the election. Fulani estimates that a million votes for her will in fact keep Michael Dukakis from reaching the White House. NAP representatives state that the Democrats have taken the votes of politically disempowered communities—Blacks, Hispanics, American Indians, gays and lesbians—for granted, that Dukakis' choice of a running mate slaps his progressive constituency in the face, and that the majority of Democrats, while dissatisfied with Dukakis, feels that it has no means of holding the “Democratic machine” accountable. To these disenchanted voters, Fulani offers her candidacy as a way “to send the Democrats a message.”

Sue Hyde of the National Gay and Lesbian Task Force sent copies of Berlet's report on NAP with a cover letter detailing her own experiences with NAP to a number of gay and lesbian publications. Her letter warned that although “NAP's platform, insofar as it is articulated on paper, is very appealing to me and not antithetical to many of our own movement's goals … I do not believe that the party's methodology or structure make it an appropriate or trustworthy organization for achieving these goals.” Her experience of being misled into participating in one of the NAP forums, which was in fact a thinly veiled recruitment meeting, has been echoed again and again in various forms by activists.

Certainly many gay and lesbian voters across the nation are torn by the choice between what the Gay and Lesbian Defense Committee and Mass ACT OUT have termed “the evil of two lessers.” At the same time, NAP offers gay and lesbian voters the option of helping to ensure that the Republicans keep control of the executive office, which is hardly a desirable political consequence for the vengeful pleasure of giving Dukakis back what he has given to our community.

In addition, there is a side to the New Alliance Party that voters should examine thoroughly before casting ballots in support of the “Rainbow Slate.”

The Practice

Numerous investigators, and, in fact, many community activists and organizers who have not conducted extensive research, have independently concluded that NAP and its therapeutic branch, the Institutes for Social Therapy and Research, show the classic hallmarks of a cult.

The Institutes for Social Therapy—founded in 1978—pre-date the formalization of NAP as it exists now. “Unlike what many people say, NAP did not start the Institute,” said Fridley. “There was a request from the community to figure out how to address the mental health crisis in New York at the time,” which convinced Newman and his colleagues, who were attempting to organize communities in New York City, to resuscitate some of their old ideas from the days of CFC.

Conason's research into CFC shows that “internal CFC documents from November 1972 through February 1973 show that ‘therapy' sometimes in week-long marathon sessions, was the top priority of the group,” although CFC also operated a dental and therapeutic clinic in the Bronx and a school for young children.

But over the course of the 1970s, Newman's interest in social therapy, coupled with the metamorphosis of his political ideology, qualitatively changed his implementation of the therapy model for mobilization of a community.

For example, in a paper entitled Homophobia and the Rise of Neo-Fascism in the United States, Fridley explains the rationale behind social therapy, and attempts to demonstrate its efficacy in regards to the politicization of the gay community. The main thrust of social therapy is to teach the individual that a sense of being “maladjusted” in society is actually evidence of mental fitness, because the society itself is unsound, corrupt and morally bankrupt. Referring to NAP's historical roots in CFC, Fridley remarked, “You can't just provide services for people if you're interested in bringing the community into a power relationship with the powers-that-be.” The way to bring about the change, according to Fridley, is to empower communities in areas where they have previously been disempowered—by providing, for example, therapy in poor, working class, and minority communities, where traditional therapies have historically been either withheld from the people, or used to keep them in place.

Because social therapy contains within its prescription for healing the necessity of empowerment through action, patients of social therapy are urged to become politically involved. At this point, NAP, with whom the Institutes' therapists are closely allied, stands ready to receive contributions of time, solicitation and action to “assist” the patients in their “healing process.”

Not coincidentally, NAP's political platform appeals specifically to “Afro-American, Latino, Native American, Asian, Women, Lesbian and Gay, poor and working people … oppressed nationalities, farmers, trade unionists and the unemployed.” The tenets of the party offer a political balm to these and other communities, whose political self image have been “injured” by the inattention of the Democratic and Republican parties.

Additionally, according to Serrette, being involved with therapy is a prerequisite for involvement, in any significant sense, with NAP. “If you want to be part of this organization, you will have to take therapy because it is the backbone of our tendency,” Serrette reports he was told.

Dennis King, who has studied the evolution of NAP from its earliest incarnation as the Centers for Change, through its affiliation with LaRouche and NCLC, and the formation and dissolution of IWP, said “The New Alliance Party is a therapy cult and a political cult.” Its ideological leadership is all former patients of Newman and two other members of the organization, Hazel Daren and Gail Elberg. However, King warned, “You can't dismiss them as a pure and simple cult,” because the term is used too frequently in reference to small and relatively harmless religious fanatical organizations that have become fixtures in many urban centers and rural areas. “That [kind of a label] discounts the fact that they're having a political effect on the world,” considering that Fulani's campaign may in fact keep the Republicans in the Oval Office, King added.

Of note, also, is that the Cult Awareness Network keeps information on NAP with its extensive files on LaRouche.


Playing it Straight?


Even if it weren't for the strange and apparently coercive connection between therapy and politics, NAP is still an extremely difficult organization to deal with on a political level. Its members' tactics are abrasive and disruptive in group settings, even when the NAP people claim that their agenda coincides with that of the meeting. On occasions when NAP is criticized for its methodology or questioned closely about its history, NAP respondents verge into hysterical personal attacks that distort and over-blow the impact of the critique in an attempt to undercut the credibility or expose hidden motivations of the critic.

For example, responding to Sue Hyde's memorandum to the gay press, National Alliance editors Dan Friedman and Freda Rosen stated that Sue Hyde's letter “white-baits, straight-baits and cult-baits the New Alliance Party.” Following a bizarre line of reasoning to refute Hyde's comments, they remarked that “Fulani believes that the circulation of the [NGLTF] letter is an attempt by the establishment leadership of the gay movement to subvert the independence of the rank and file.”

Upon publication and dissemination of Berlet's report, NAP called the results of Berlet's research “a diatribe of racist disinformation,” categorically dismissing, with insults and denunciations, his extensive research and the questions it posed. Berlet emerged unscathed, although NAP previously has attempted to punish, harass and annoy their detractors publicly. For example, a gay newspaper was recently unable to find a reporter willing to cover NAP because the party has a reputation for suing journalists who say things it does not like.

Furthermore, NAP continually misrepresents itself and its history, committing errors of omission or creating an atmosphere of innuendo in lieu of fact. In other cases, NAP lies outright.

Occasionally canvassers in Boston introduce their organization as the “Alliance.” At other times, referring to NAP's Rainbow Alliance or Rainbow Lobby, NAP workers solicit donations by identifying themselves as the “Rainbow,” which many people automatically associate with Jesse Jackson's Rainbow Coalition. They refer to their field of 24 candidates nationwide as “the Rainbow Slate,” and the prevalence of Fulani's picture spliced with photos of Reverend Jackson insinuate a connection that the Rainbow Coalition says does not exist. One Rainbow Coalition member recalls with anger that NAP went about publicly announcing that Jackson was urging his supporters to switch their allegiance to the NAP candidate, Serrette, after Jackson himself dropped out of the race. “That's just wrong,” says Pat Cusick, the Rainbow Coalition's media secretary in Boston. “Jesse backed the Democratic ticket after he left the race through to November.”

Lawrence's research shows that Serrette, in a report entitled “Inside the New Alliance Party,” wrote “Like LaRouche, Newman has created numerous organizations (most only on paper) with divergent names; some to attract particular individuals, some solely to make money, many with names so similar to true left organizations that unknowing individuals are often fooled.”

In their earlier years, the confusing similarity of names among NAP predecessor the New York City Unemployed and Welfare Council, the NCLC's National Unemployed and Welfare Rights Organization, and the legitimate National Welfare Rights Organization served to give the impression of credibility to the two organizations that were badly in need of both money and members if they were to achieve their ambitious goals. Because the tactic seemed to be so effective, NAP apparently has not given it up, although it dismisses questions regarding the purposefulness of some similarities in name.

Given the unexplained and unexplorable vagrancies of NAP's political past, its inextricable connection to the Institutes for Social Therapy and Research, and its history of harassing and disrupting other progressive organizations in the effort to assert it own organizational and political hegemony on the Left, NAP as an organization is not what its literature makes it out to be. While NAP professes support for and willingness to work with a number of progressive movements according to Paul Sprecher, a member of People Against Cult Therapy, “cult-like organizations' ability to cooperate with other political groups is practically nil, except in the most opportunistic fashion.”